[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 63 KB, 412x462, plato.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7106735 No.7106735[DELETED]  [Reply] [Original]

Philosophy won't make god real.

>> No.7106762

I don't care. I just want to know how to become a philosopher king.

>> No.7106770

I know fedora et cetera, but seriously, how can you honestly believe that the allpowerful and conveniently benevolent creator
of this infinite universe personally cares about you or even this planet?

>> No.7106963

>>7106735

THAT IS BECAUSE IT CANNOT, AND IT IS NOT ITS PURPOSE; GOD ALREADY IS REAL; WITHOUT GOD, PHILOSOPHY WOULD NOT EVEN EXIST IN THE FIRST PLACE.

DID YOU EVEN THINK BEFORE TYPING, AND POSTING? I DO NOT THINK SO, NOR DO I THINK THAT YOU EVEN KNOW WHAT GOD IS.

>> No.7106969

Science won't make the natural laws real

>> No.7106977

>>7106770
Cuz he created it?

>> No.7106985

Religious community makes God real, not philosophy.

>> No.7106988

>mfw Kant btfo religious belief for all time but couldn't admit it so he stayed a Christian because of "muh faith"

>> No.7106989

>>7106735
Yes and no.
Philosophy is what defines "God" in the first place, so it depends on us to really give a solid definition.

>> No.7107000

Can someone seriously answer why philosophy isn't obsolete nowadays? I've seen a lot of guys here defend philosophy in this case and I'd genuinely like to hear why philosophy isn't obsolete.

>> No.7107002

Philosophy is pretty much responsible for making him not real.

>> No.7107118

>>7106989
>Philosophy is what defines "God" in the first place
Ehhhhhh, not really. The problem of god is related to the problem of philosophy's relationship to the city. The city defines the gods before the philosopher ever touches them, which is precisely the problem (and it's how you end up with a figure like Spinoza who defines god as nature, doing away with the personal god of the city that needs worshipped).

>>7107000
Philosophy's not a method or a subject matter, for one.

>> No.7107139

>>7106977
I create my feces. Caring about something because you created it is not necessary.

>> No.7107165

>>7107000
Philosophy isn't really useful nowadays. At least not in a super pragmatic sense. It's not like you can build a house with it or whatever. The main appeal in philosophy, like art, is that it's what you live for. Examining life helps you grow as a person, introduces you to new ideas, etc, etc. I mean, you don't really have to eat food that tastes good. You'd arguably get a better deal out of eating soylent. Who wants to live off of bland cardboard-esque vitamin mixes though?

Shit, asking why philosophy isn't obsolete *is* arguably philosophy.

>> No.7107217
File: 27 KB, 452x572, 1436959813591.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7107217

Yes it will, faggot

>> No.7107298

"God" is a very old word and it's only within abrahamic religions it's considered "everything" and other gods can't exist besides it/him.

*I* happen to prefer the Old signification of the term; which basically means something like Übermensch and don't support this "modern" re-definition of the term.

*I* find Nature is a better description than "God" for this signification of "everything" and think we should throw childish images away so we can go back to venerating Real Gods instead of some infantile Improbable. Nature should be worshipped more than some desert-god anyway.

>> No.7107308
File: 21 KB, 238x240, Whatwhat.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7107308

>>7106735

It really depends on your definition of "god", "make" and "real".

>> No.7107324
File: 69 KB, 1000x1000, Hegelllll.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7107324

>>7106735
God is the most immediate thing in human culture, the prove itself is that religion has been a part of the Spirit since the beginning of civilization.

>> No.7107332

>>7107324

Define "human culture" and then explain where it came from.

>> No.7107359

>>7107000
reddit
>>7106735
reddit

>> No.7107397
File: 241 KB, 380x389, IdolsongR-4.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7107397

>>7106735
Philosophy will make anime real.

>> No.7107422

>>7107397
I'll make YOU real as an ass-slave to my cock. It will be the realest you have ever experienced.

>> No.7107455
File: 10 KB, 200x200, 1440347417253.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7107455

God is real, and philosophy was made to cope with it.

>> No.7107476

>>7107455
We should really make it a meme to demand everyone to presignify their "God's" with which god they are referring to.

Do you really think the cargocults in the Amazon or any of the myriad primitive societies to-day or yesterday have or have had a need for your Abrahamic god?

>> No.7107480

>>7107476
you know, to cut down on the "god" threads where everyone is actually discussing one specific god that happen to be big in the modern era.

>> No.7107869
File: 64 KB, 578x800, image.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7107869

>>7106988

> mfw I'd be impressed if you could describe in any detail what Kant actually meant by "faith."

>> No.7107884

>>7107869
Oh shit's Kant deathmask guy.
This gun b gud.

>> No.7108451

>>7106770
Haha because he cares about reality and YOURE IN REALITY

>> No.7108455

>>7107000
Bcuz ur a faget and we want to know why!!!!!