/lit/ - Literature

File: 593 KB, 1185x1029, 1432677937125.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Tue May 26 19:47:17 2015 No.6595393 [Reply] [Original]

Is there any rigorous definition of heresy?

John Milbank said:
>I regard Catholic Christianity as fulfilling the best pagan impulses, heresy as exaggeration or thinning-down of the truth, and nihilism as a parody both of the Christian view that we are created from nothing and that therefore all that is finite is indeterminate, and equally of the likewise Christian view that ordered beauty is paradoxically in-finite.

I've looked over people who were tried for heresy and the reasons invoked, such as with Meister Eckhart, but is there an actual codification of heresies? It seems like there should be, or at least there should be a list of things that are heretical if violated. I see the term getting tossed around a lot where "heterodoxy" would seem to suffice.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 19:48:20 2015 No.6595396 Getting real tired real fast of the Milbank spam.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 19:50:45 2015 No.6595401 >>6595396 This is about heresy, not Milbank, m80. I only used his definition as an example.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 19:52:07 2015 No.6595409 File: 153 KB, 334x436, 1421209376683.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>6595401 >tfw it I just realized m80 means matey and isn't a typo I'm not gonna make it lads

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:06:51 2015 No.6595460 File: 2.17 MB, 1024x574, 1415366000394.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>6595409 It will be alright

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:17:12 2015 No.6595518 >>6595393 Christfaggotry is already heretical so who cares.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:18:47 2015 No.6595522 >>6595518 tips fedora

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:19:06 2015 No.6595524 File: 26 KB, 367x500, legenteman.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>6595518

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:22:19 2015 No.6595539 >>6595396 Same. It was cute until it became obvious that it's one guy.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:23:12 2015 No.6595545 >>6595539 I'm not the guy who posted the other Milbank threads, though

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:28:59 2015 No.6595580 >>6595545 It's still samefagging

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:30:53 2015 No.6595590 >>6595580 Maybe so, but that doesn't really concern this thread, which isn't about JM

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:31:03 2015 No.6595591 >>6595393 If you google "Muh religion" the first result is a definition of Islam, I just thought everyone should be aware of this.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:33:09 2015 No.6595599 >>6595409 Better late than never

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:33:19 2015 No.6595600 >>6595522 >>6595524 I'm not anti-religion. I'm anti-Christfaggotry specifically. Any other religion I'm fine with. So no.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:34:10 2015 No.6595603 >>6595524 >>6595522 >I bet no one realizes I'm samefagging.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:34:48 2015 No.6595604 >>6595600 Why do you hate Christianity more than Islam and Scientology?

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:36:26 2015 No.6595609 >>6595590 JM is the OP quote. You can't separate the thread from him.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:37:27 2015 No.6595612 >>6595603 >>6595600 >I bet no one realizes I'm samefagging.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:39:34 2015 No.6595619 >>6595604 Because it's shitting up my board. REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!

Anonymous Tue May 26 20:40:02 2015 No.6595623

>>6595604
Islam is going through that same phase Christfaggotry went through hundreds of years ago with the Inquisition and the Crusades. If anything, it's just following the precedent Christfaggotry set for that sort of twattery.

As for Scientology, it's literally a sci-fi author's get rich quick scam so I don't consider it a religion.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:40:27 2015 No.6595625 >>6595609 A OP quote, but the thread is not about his quote, his quote is just an example. I'm looking for a more rigorous definition.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:41:05 2015 No.6595629 >>6595603 >being this new

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:42:23 2015 No.6595637 >>6595623 What was wrong with the Crusades, apart from number four? And I don't think you can compare the Inquisitions to things like 9/11

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:44:33 2015 No.6595646 >>6595623 >Islam is going through that same phase Christfaggotry went through hundreds of years ago That's patently wrong. The current Islamic radicalism is nothing new. It flares even few decades since the beginning of Islam.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 20:47:59 2015 No.6595666 >>6595623 >Islam is going through that same phase Christfaggotry This is such a cop out, though I agree with its logical conclusion, which is that Islam should suffer the fate of Christianity and meet its death.

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 21:06:23 2015 No.6595746 >>6595623 >I hate Christianity more than Islam because Islam is basically a more backward version of Christianity

>>	Anonymous Tue May 26 21:21:28 2015 No.6595825 >>6595623 is this b8? God, you must struggle to walk and talk at the same time you poor thing.

Advanced search
Text to find
Subject [?]Search by post subject. Leave empty for any.
Username [?]Search for user name. Leave empty for any user name.
Tripcode [?]Search for tripcode. Leave empty for any.
Email [?]Search by email. Leave empty for any.
Filename [?]Search by image filename. Leave empty for any.
From Date [?]Enter what date to start searching from. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
To Date [?]Enter what date to start searching until. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
Image hash
Search in	All Posts OPs Only
Deleted posts	Show all posts Show only deleted posts Only show non-deleted posts
Internal posts	Show all posts Show only internal posts Show only archived posts
Order	New posts first Old posts first
Capcode	All Posts Only by Users Only by Mods Only by Admins Only by Developers
Results	Posts Threads
Action	[ Simple ]