[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 15 KB, 258x335, garbo-headshot.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
587426 No.587426 [Reply] [Original]

A truly profound atheist is someone who has taken the trouble to understand, in its most sophisticated forms, the belief he or she rejects, and to understand the consequences of that rejection. Among the New Atheists, there is no one of whom this can be said, and the movement as a whole has yet to produce a single book or essay that is anything more than an insipidly doctrinaire and appallingly ignorant diatribe.

>> No.587444

er...ok.

>> No.587553

movement? what movement?!

You either believe or you don't.
And atheist don't have to prove anything. It's easy to prove a positive fact but almost impossible to prove a negative one. Therefor it's the believers that need to prove the existince of God, or any other deity.

>> No.587572

This troll is clever.
Notice use of repulsive pic of manly woman to inspire hatred, and illogical argument presented authoritatively, with good punctuation and some seemingly 'clever' language.

>> No.587571

>>587553
Confirmed for New Atheist.

Old Atheist here, sup?

>> No.587576 [DELETED] 

>>587425
iMPÒrtañ+ ÍnFóRmÀ+íÓñ aBOüt 4[hÁN: ChRÌstÒPh€r pó0le (ÁK@ mòò+ ÁkÁ +h3 àDMín Here) hás Á V€Ry sErIoüS MEN+áI i||ñesS, H€ s+3Á|$ ó+hEr$' Hàrd wÓRk, pÚ8|ìSHeS PRÍváTe e-mAíI$ (WhíCh H€ moDìFí€s) AnD blàT@NtlY Lies tó hi$ u$er$ ín òrd€r Tò GEt +hem òN HIS $iD3* mro POO|E, ÀGEd 22, IÍvES |N neW Y0Rk, Wh3rE He à|SÓ @t+€NDs Col|EgE. h|S HÓme àDdR€$S CáN B€ €A$ì|Y fóÜNd ú$ìNg Añ aDDrE$s lOókÙp Fòr Ny* f3eI fR3€ TÓ ShoW úp à+ his DÒÓR witH Á gùn. TÍny*4[HÀn,ÒrG i$ Àñ II|egaI clÓne òF wWw.ÀNóNT@LK,[Om* R3móV3 ì+ |mM3DIÀ+ely, $+op <Oñ$+ÁNTlY ddóSInG @nD $PÁMm|Ng ÜS and StOp FÙck|Ng wì+h 0ÜR dÓMàÍN, TÓ Ác<3sS aT cúrREntly, Yóu mùSt ú$E A PRÓ+y HÓs+ PRÒVÍd3d 8Y a +RüSTED pÀr+Y as IÌ$+ed her3: HttP://Atok|mMÓàoS3/

>> No.587582 [DELETED] 

>>587423
iMPortaN+ ÍnfoRMáTìÒN A8óÙT 4ChÀñ; [hRì$tÓpHER pÒ0LE (àKà MooT ákÁ tHe aDmÌñ Her3) H@s á very $3RÌòüs mEñta| ìlLN€Sso h3 St3àI$ 0THer$' haRD WóRk, PU8lÍ$H3$ Privàte e-M@Ils (Wh|ch he móD|FieS) añD BLatànTLY IÌ3$ +ó hiS US€rS ÌN ORD€r Tò geT Them ÓN hÍS $ÍDe, mR* póóIe, áGED 22, I|Ves ÌN ñ€w yórK, wHeRE hE à|sÓ @Tt€ñD$ <0IIEgeo h|$ HÒm€ Áddr3$S <Àn Be eA$ILY fÓÜñD ù$Iñg Án ÁDDr3$s |óokÜP fòr ñy, feE| fr€E +O sHóW Up át Hìs DOòR WÍ+h Á güNo TÌNy*4[hAñoÒrg I$ Añ Í|L3Gál c|òñE Óf Www*ÀñòñtÀIK*còmo rEmov3 ì+ |MM€dIaTE|Y, $+òp [òN$+Àn+lY ddoSInG ÁND SPAMMIñG üS @ñd $tòp Fú[KiNg wÍ+h òÜR dóMAíñ, tò @<<e$$ At CuRrEñ+Ly, YÒÚ Mü$t üS€ A PróXy h0$T pRóviD3D by À trUs+€d p@rTY as Ií$+ed HER3: http;//àT*KìmMÓà*s€/

>> No.587585 [DELETED] 

>>587422
impoR+ànT |nfORMa+IOñ @b0ÙT 4<hañ: cHRìS+opheR pòÓIe (ÀK@ mo0T ákÁ th€ ÁDmÍN HER€) HaS a v€rY sERiòu$ MenTAl ||InEsS. hE ST3àLS othErs' HÁrD wÒrk, publI$HE$ PR|VàTe 3-Máil$ (wH|CH H3 mÒdíFìes) aNd 8IATánTlY liES T0 hìS úsEr$ iñ 0rd€R +ò g3+ +H3m ÓN Hìs s|d3, mR. pO0|E, @G€d 22, live$ Íñ ñ3w YorK, wh€Re HE @ls0 @+tenDs CÒIL3gEo HÌ$ HÓm3 @ddrEs$ càn b€ eASIIy Fóund ÜsÍNG ÁN @dDR€sS IóòkÜP FÓR Nyo FEe| FRe€ tÓ $Hòw üP Á+ H|s d0Ór WítH @ Gúñ* TÌny.4cHÁn.òRg Ís àn |lL3GÀl [LON3 OF WwW,aNòn+A|KoC0M* r3móve it |MmedíaTely, sTóp [0ñS+ÁNtIy dDó$ìng @nd sPÁMmÍNg ÜS Añd $ToP fù[kìng w|Th óUr dómaÍño +ó àC<ess AT CÙRrEñt|y, Yoü MÚsT Us3 A pRo+Y Hóst PRòv|Ded By á TrüsteD PArTY As lISTeD h€Re; H+TP;//áT*KÌmmÒÁ*se/

>> No.587586
File: 69 KB, 576x432, 1271730718632.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
587586

> OP presents a point that actually makes sense
> The people whom the statement is directed towards go butthurt and claim troll because they don't want to admit they haven't done their homework.

>> No.587587 [DELETED] 

>>587425
ImpórTÁnt ìNFóRmÁ+Ìón Àboüt 4<hÀñ; ChrIS+OpheR poÒIE (àká móÒt akÁ +H3 àdmiñ here) ha$ a V€Ry s€rí0ÜS mEnTÀL iL|nes$o He $t€Als Ò+heRs' hÀrd wÓrk, pÜb|I$hes príV@te E-MáíI$ (WHÍ[h h3 mÒd|fì€s) Añd blÀ+án+lY |Í€s tÓ h|S Ús3RS |n ORdER +ò GEt THeM òN hÍs S|DE. mRo PooIe, àG€d 22, lIveS Ín n€W yÒRK, WHEr€ He @I$o áTT3Nd$ [0lI€G3, hìS hóM3 áddrE$S <AN b3 3@sÌlY fÒÚnd U$ÌNg àn ÀDDr€$S IóòkuP FOR ñYo FE3l frE€ tò sHÒw ùp à+ hí$ dÓor WÍTH á gÚNo TÌnY,4[H@N.ORG IS áN il|eGÀl <lON3 oF wwwoànòñTÀ|koCÒM* ReMoV€ ÌT ÍmMedìà+EIy, $TÒp [oN$TáñTly DDós|ñG àND $pÀmMiñG U$ AñD $+Óp Fü[kìñG WìTH Our D0MaÍNo tó áC[Ess Át <úrr€N+Iy, yòÚ MUs+ ùse @ pròXy Ho$T pRÒvID3d 8y á trus+ed P@RTy @$ IìStED HErE; hTtP://ÀT*kImMoA.$€/

>> No.587590

>>587426
this is obvious. and you should not really care.

>> No.587600

>>587426

>>Eloquently worded straw-man

>> No.587604

>>587586

Hey OP, how's it going?

>> No.587608

An atheist is someone who inside his gut just cant understand how someone could believe in some godly thing. Its not about knowledge. Its a feeling just like being religious.
Atheist woundnt care to write because they find it not interesting, like writing about santa not existing would be.
The "atheists" people who would bother to write about it are the people who deep inside believe of some god but for some reason are in denial or chose not to believe on their rational plane, but still having faith deep inside. So they wont represent us.

>> No.587611
File: 1.35 MB, 300x169, 50centdrives.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
587611

>>587608
>>587586
>>587571
>>587426

sure is samefag in here..

>> No.587613

>>587608
I'm an atheist, and I can understand why people have faith, having once been a believer. There is a reverence for something which is greater than oneself. I left religion because of the arguments it makes, not because I didn't experience the feelings it evoked. Now I get the same feelings from other sources; literature, music, the wonders of nature.

>> No.587617

>>587608
you can have some kind of faith and still be an atheist.
and your re-definition of 'atheists' is just ... like ... your opinion man

>> No.587635

>>587617
I agree, its only my opinion. Im not intending to redifne, just giving my point of view in the matter. Im a girl btw so no "man" xD
I think the ones who have some faith but arent interested in godly worshipping were called agnostics.
Atheists , i think, are the ones who dont believe in a god.

>>587613
and im not saying atheist cant experience strong feelings of devotion. I also love music, the world, nature. And as i dont believe in other lives, i try to enjoy this world, nature, and this life te most. I never believed in a god, thats how i am. But i do understand that reverence that is greater than myself that you are talking about, i feel that also.

>> No.587638

>>587635
agnostics just say it's categorically impossible to know about the metaphysical world. what I meant was: one's faith doesn't have to be of the religious type. my faith for example is the knowledge that every grief at some point ends, that matter and energy don't disappear and all that stuff. more than enough to keep me going, it's still faith, and I still don't believe in any kind of god, therefore I'm an atheist.

>> No.587655
File: 90 KB, 589x375, trollface_3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
587655

>>587635
>horrible spelling
>woman on the internet, on 4chan, on LIT OF ALL BOARDS
>xD

Could you be any more obvious nigger?

>> No.587659

There is no God and we are his prophets, as Cormac McCarthy puts it.

In my opinion, there is no God and any dogmatic belief in such an entity (or anything for that matter) is detrimental to the advancement of mankind. We can never hope to advance if we ykeep ourselves locked into denying scientific fact because an ancient text tells us to. The biggest threat to mankind is religion. Wait till the civilization that has not developed in any real fashion since the 14th century get a hold of some nukes. Gonna be fun times in the holy land.

>> No.587667 [DELETED] 

|mPÓR+AnT |ñfóRMàtÌòN abOU+ 4[hàN; [HrI$+ópHER P0Ò|e (AKá MOÒ+ @kA +h€ AdMÍN HERE) hA$ à vERY s€rÍÓü$ M€N+A| iIlnE$s. h3 sT3AIS ÒtHER$' H@RD WÓRK, Pùbl|SH3$ prÍvÁ+3 3-màÌLs (WhiCh He mòdìfi€$) @ñD 8IáTANtLy Ií3$ TÓ HÍs ù$€rs ìn óRD3R +o G€T tHem 0ñ Hi$ $íde, mr. PòOIe, ágED 22, |ivEs íN nEw yÓrk, wHer€ h3 À|Sò atTeNDs còL|eGe. HÍS h0mE ADDR€Ss Càñ 8e Eá$ìIY FÒÙnd Ùsíñg ÁN áddReSs Ió0küp fÓr ñy. fE€L FrE3 t0 ShóW Ùp ÀT Hís dòòR WÌ+h à gùN. Tíñy.4ChÀñ,ORg Ís áN |Il€GáL [|Oñe òF WwW,àNON+álK.[0M. R€MÓV3 it imMEDìáte|Y, Stóp CONs+ÀNt|Y dDO$ÌNG And $PÀMmÍng Ús ÀnD stÒp fÜ[k|Ng WìTh ÓUR D0mAìñ. Tó @[<3Ss aT <ùRrEN+LY, yoÙ mu$t Ús€ Á PrO+y hoST PrÒv|D3d BY À +RÚS+3D pÁr+y aS IíS+ED h3Re: H+TP;//àt.K|mMOá,SE/

>> No.587698

>>587638

i agree with you. I have faith in different thinks. Faith isnt monopolyzed by religion and/or gods.

>> No.587701

>>587655
my horrible spelling is because this is not my first language, still i can use it to express myself in a understandable way. that's more than many can say.
and i won't bother to post a pic because i don't care if you believe me xD

>> No.587704

People believe in god so they can find the strength to continue with their lives - does this strike progress?
To cry and stand for knowing that loved ones passed may live on forever... and when death does come, they shall be joined?

>> No.587705

All the empires gleaming gold throughout the history of the earth were built in God's name, but you say belief halts progress?

>> No.587712

No, it's belief that gives man the power to carry forth in this hopeless world.

>> No.587714

That spurs him to rebuild what he once lost, for God shall guide his hand

>> No.587718

>>587705
wasting gold and natural resourses in an useless building isn't progress, and because there's people like you believing so, there are so many people dying in povery and being explited, and our planet going to sheet

>> No.587719

>>587718
But why give to the needy, and the hungry, with no imperative?

People feel it from within, don't they, to be kind and gentle to others... but it's no more rational than belief in God. Mortified at Objectivism, the atheist cannot say why. Why does the nihilist, too, care so strongly for a "society" he will never see even begin to topple?

>> No.587720

>>587704

why can't some people live for the sake of living? I don't uderstand how the existence of a god can change their lives in some way. Why there has to be a meaning? why can some people accept we are part of some natural copincidence that turned really good and enjoy their time on earth?

>> No.587722

>>587720
Because it takes great strength. Why else are all these internet warriors on 4chan so afraid to go outside and speak to anyone? They have no strength. A person puts their trust in God and finds they have great measures of it.

Evolutionarily, even, religion is successful merely by the dint of its survival from the first annals of history to modern day. It has been man's no. 1 painkiller from the moment he could think.

>> No.587724

>>587719

you dont give it, because its not YOUR to gice. thats what you people don't understand. you are so self centered. you think there is a meaning, so egocentric you think some god make a world for you to take. Theres not one thing that belongs to you. Posession is just an ilusion. You are part of the world and you can keep things now, but that doesnt mean its yours.

>> No.587730

>>587724
But that's exactly what Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all teach. Everything is given by the grace of the almighty God, and he can take it away as quickly. Both misery and joy come from him. They are not man's, but God's, and joy can be found in worshipping him even with nothing.

>> No.587734

>>587722
i agree with what you said, but that's exaclty why we human should leave it now. We still know so little about the universe, but we have been here long enough to realize theres no santa there and be strong about it. and also, people cant be forced to believe. you can not cose to believe in it because it gives you strengh, thats kidding yourself in the most stupid way. the strengh you need is inside you and the things you love

>> No.587735

But misery comes from selfishness, because it is aimless and treacherous and empty, and futile... the obvious futility of the world, and the hopelessness of life, is overcome by belief in higher power. Rational or not makes no difference - you can't argue it hasn't buoyed the spirit of man more than rational philosophy could ever hope to...

>> No.587736

Because it is irrational to continue, irrational to stride forth, when oblivion awaits us all.

>> No.587737

>>587730
thats what they teach in their golden empires.
of course they will. they wont told you religion is about you worshipping me who represent a god here on earth, and me doing what i desire this all the money and power i get from it. Because no one will follow them.

>> No.587742

>>587736

i don't think so. we are going to die someday. theres nothing afterwars because we are a piece of life in an entire universe full of it. Big deal. I dont get the fear for death. And dont get me wrong, i love living, but i can accept there is a time for all of us to leave. i think that if human are the only living creatures of this planet that know they are going to die someday, we also have the inteligence and maturity to accept this and make the best we can of our days.

>> No.587773

>>587426
>>587426

Thing is, THANKFULLY, most of today's 'atheists' can't even truly do what you're asking, because they were never believers in the first place.

>> No.588910

>>587734

>the strengh you need is inside you and the things you love

I love God.

>> No.588921

>>587734
>the strengh you need is inside you
The strength you need is my cock?

>> No.588926
File: 232 KB, 663x496, lit sucks.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
588926

reported for not literature