[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 217 KB, 1200x1529, 1718369164136783.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23504802 No.23504802 [Reply] [Original]

>Yeah so house Stark has been ruling the North for 8000 years!
Unironically what the fuck did he mean by this?
He goes on about taxes and the world needing to make sense and then he randomly drops this shit in.

>> No.23504940

>>23504802
Makes sense to me, House Yamato ruled Japan for just as long. Plus minus.

>> No.23504954

>>23504940
No they haven't. That's a myth.
Not even the concept of a Japan existed 8000 years ago.

>> No.23504982

>>23504954
It is all true, Emperor Jimmu descendant of Amaterasu and Izanagi has founded Japan. You are clearly a Mongolian dog.

>> No.23505368

The entire point is that that shit isn't reliable.

>> No.23506493

>>23504940
more like 2600, and as little more than figureheads that were emperors in name only for significant periods

>> No.23506528
File: 76 KB, 452x379, 1718816037810522.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23506528

>>23504802
>Sit on Uncle's lap, children. Oh! Don't mind that heh. Just uncle's wallet

>> No.23506652

History being unreliable is a major plot point. Just like with distant lands being unreliable.
I like it though. It gives a meaningful sense of weight to the houses.

>> No.23506672

>>23504802
>medieval societies don't keep the best records
>the ruling elite promotes narratives which are favorable to them and lend them legitimacy
Why is this so incomprehensible to /lit/? I thought this was supposed to be the smart board

>> No.23506678

>>23506672
Never happened in real life.

>> No.23506679

>>23504954
And the veracity of the Stark claim is put into question in the same way in the lore.
The truth is no one really knows since knowledge gets more murky as you go further back, basically before the Andal invasion it was mostly an oral tradition so shit gets very mythical past that point(insert Norse equivalency).
What they do know is they're the only one of the ruling houses still descended from the first men, IE the Andals didn't take over by force or integration there because of "the king who knelt". Thus the bloodline remained.

captcha: ARHHH

>> No.23506870

>>23506678
The catholic church promoted forgeries as canonical literature for centuries

>> No.23506969

>>23506678
I'm just going to interpret that as sarcasm lol

>> No.23506997

>>23504802
JUST FINISH THE BOOKS YOU MOTHERFUCKER SON OF A WHORE FAT FUCK AUSSIE CUNT

Just give us whatever you have written or scribbled man idc how good or bad it will be. It cannot be as bad as Dan Brown. Who cares man just give it. No one is gonna remember you for your last 2 books being terrible. Why the fuck are not you giving them

>> No.23507001

>>23506997
He'll give them to the other guy along with notes and he'll finish them.

>> No.23507008

>>23506870
ok prottie

>> No.23507044

It's almost like Game of Thrones sucks and is massively overrated, huh? GRRM is a terrible writer, and bites off way more than he can chew in terms of characters, plots, worldbuilding, etc. Then eventually it all comes back to bite him in the ass, and that is why he hasn't published a sequel since 2011 and had to write new shit to end the show (poorly)

>> No.23507062
File: 468 KB, 1065x648, 18.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23507062

It's ok, it's ok, his son will finish the project.

>> No.23507090

Couldn't he just say like Fuck you people I ain't writing shit about GoT anymore and let this be a lesson to you all that you seldom get what you want in life ha ha ha I am burning my manuscript and legally preventing anyone from completing the series after my death. Here's another Wild Cards

>> No.23508071
File: 317 KB, 898x678, IMG_4420.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23508071

>>23507062
M-mein Führer… George… George has no children.

>> No.23508157

>>23504802
>>Yeah so house Stark has been ruling the North for 8000 years!
>Unironically what the fuck did he mean by this?
Always two, there are. No more. No less. A Master and an apprentice.

>> No.23509129

>>23506672
Are they also exaggerating about their 700ft ice wall?

>> No.23509136

>>23508071
>>23507062
lmao

>> No.23509138

>>23504802
>Fat fucks tries to discredit his betters