[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 222 KB, 390x258, 6457678745786976896545.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
22934710 No.22934710 [Reply] [Original]

Why are modern female authors such garbage? In the past, there were great female authors and even recently J. K. Rowling was amazing. Go and find an audiobook on youtube right now by a female author and listen to the first ten minutes.They all follow a similar pattern no matter the genre.
>Main character is either a Mary Sue or has one minor flaw that "isn't her fault"
>Action sequences are so poorly written that you can't even picture them happening in your head
>Men bad
>Main character is "quirky" and "cool" but really just comes off as annoying
And other things along a similar theme. The tone always feels the same as well, written like Twilight (except Twilight was actually pretty okay). I realize that I'm discussing sub par authors here but I am comparing them to other sub par authors who are actually good, there are plenty of great zombie books available as audiobooks on youtube for example. Do they just get a woman pass to write absolute dog shit or am I imagining things?

>> No.22934720

>>22934710
Kys coomer trash.

>> No.22934751

Poo in the loo.
Do the needful sirs.

>> No.22934830

>>22934710
They definitely get a pass.

>> No.22934847

>>22934720
>feral retard appears
I listen to random audiobooks on youtube to fall asleep to. I'm not really picky about what they are but I just happened to notice a pattern.
>>22934751
>projecting mystery meat person
Post nose

>> No.22934875

>>22934710
Simple, they don't have to be good to sell books.

>> No.22934980

https://www.amazon.ca/Glass-Hotel-Emily-John-Mandel/dp/144345575X

This was the last book I read by a female Canadian author, was the most boring piece of shit. I could not make it through more than 1/2 through because it was just incredibly boring.

>> No.22935027

>>22934980
>boring
Weirdly enough that isn't even my main complaint here. Yes, a lot of them are just boring as well but remember that I am listening to audiobooks to try to fall asleep to so I am fine with them being boring. It's more that they are just badly written and the main character always feels like some kind of weird self-insert. There is nothing wrong with a character being written as a self-insert inherently I don't think but there is a right way to handle it and a wrong way.

>> No.22935060

>>22934710
>even recently J. K. Rowling was amazing
Ok man

>> No.22935125

>>22935060
You didn't think those were well-written? I know they had a ton of plotholes but that aside, you didn't think those stories were entertaining? When I was a teenager I loved those books.

>> No.22935128

>and even recently J. K. Rowling was amazing
I hate nu-/lit/

>> No.22935141
File: 204 KB, 930x1500, Circe_madeline_miller.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
22935141

>>22934710
Check pic related out if you want a white pill on the state of modern female authors.

>> No.22935154
File: 234 KB, 300x698, 1653952491958.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
22935154

>>22935141

>> No.22935161

>>22935154
You didn't even read it, did you anon?

>> No.22935163

>>22934710
i liked piranesi

>> No.22935189

>>22935161
You are obviously biased. Any retelling is obviously creatively bankrupt. As if Circe needed to be adapted for modern audiences.

>> No.22935203

>>22935163
Some would tell you Clarke is a legacy author signed before fantasy went all ABSOLUTE STATE but she meets the criteria.

>> No.22935306

>>22935189
>Any retelling is obviously creatively bankrupt.
That's not true anon. Some of the best stories out there are retellings, at least in part. We re-use stories all the time. Take a look at all the great fantasy books with Elves in them.

And sometimes its fun to read stories about ancient Greeks from modern authors.

>> No.22935355

I don't read books written by female authors. Simple as.

That lesson was learned a long time ago.

>> No.22935374

>>22934710
>modern books
I can only satisfy my escapist tendencies by reading books written by dead authors, whose works are so far removed from cultural relevancy that they may as well only exist for me.

>> No.22935926

>>22935355
frankenstein is pretty based desu

>> No.22935932

rijneveld is kino, though she calls herself a man.

>> No.22936310

>>22934710
No need to be sexist. Modern atuhors are garbage.

>> No.22936320
File: 481 KB, 472x500, 1681201046284315.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
22936320

>>22934710
>and even recently J. K. Rowling was amazing

>> No.22936447

>>22935125
>When I was a teenager I loved those books.
I don't think you ever stopped being one.

>> No.22936530

>>22936320
I'm aware that Nazi wizards are a retarded concept and I wasn't referring to her new books but rather the first 7
>>22936447
I'm in my 30's faggot. I WISH I was a teenager again, how is that even an insult?

>> No.22936656

>>22934710
There’s a tendency in the current zeitgeist for people to overly praise just-ok or shit works as groundbreaking as long as they’re written by women and “subversive”. There’s undoubtedly good stuff written by women out there but they’re hard to find when so many books written by women that people say are good are actually shit.

>> No.22936662
File: 35 KB, 352x500, MiguelSerrano.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
22936662

>>22936530
>I'm aware that Nazi wizards are a retarded concept
YOU are a retarded concept

>> No.22938334

>>22935355
I found Frankenstein to be pretty good, bit otherwise I'm afraid you're right

>> No.22938340

>>22936656
>so many books written by women that people say are good are actually shit.
That's nonsense. Do you actually believe people are putting women and minorities ahead just because of their identity? That's crazy talk!

>> No.22939419

>>22934710
>J. K. Rowling was amazing
I mean, if you are five... I guess.

>> No.22939549

>>22938340
These people are chuds. They actually believe that women and minorities have some advantage when books are getting selected to be published. They're totally crazy and need medication.

>> No.22939732

>>22939419
That's how old I was when my parents read it to me for the first time, yes. It's for children, it delivered on its intended purpose.
>>22939549
>Words words
Shut the fuck up you retarded little faggot. Go bitch and moan somewhere else.