[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 475 KB, 1195x1879, peterson.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20944801 No.20944801 [Reply] [Original]

>"So there's this idea. It's very old -I don't know old exactly maybe a few trillion years old... it certainly predates oral history which is only like a few hundred billion years old, and we shared a common ancestor with sedimentary rocks until a few million years ago- anyways there's this idea that the causal structure of the universe is isomorphic to the mind of God. And you can see this fundamental narrative playing out all in of our religious texts too. The same archetype pops up over and over again across language and cultural barriers. And if you look at the CT scans of rats, it's like a low resolution approximation of the Milky Way galaxy. *tears up*. And you know rats are considered sacred in many cultures. They're eukaryotic organisms just like us and their central nervous system is so similar to ours that if you hook a button up to its brain's reward system it'll orgasm itself to death, the way porn addicts do. And if you read the relevant literature on evolutionary astronomy and computational theology they can't explain it, and so you have to ask yourself why is that exactly eh? Like that's not a bloody COINCIDENCE man!"

Holy shit I'm fucking sold. Why didn't you guys recommend me this professor earlier?

>> No.20944807
File: 59 KB, 1024x545, 1661628814534326m.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20944807

>>20944801
>inb4 bump limit

>> No.20944814

>>20944801
fried his brain on benzos
hoe daughter fucks e-celebs
utter humiliation

>> No.20944829
File: 57 KB, 976x850, _91408619_55df76d5-2245-41c1-8031-07a4da3f313f.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20944829

>yfw when you realize a language agnostic version of the Old Testament is encoded in our reptilian brain and this was the universal grammar Chomsky was searching for all alone and this is why Christianity has been rediscovered independently across different cultures time and time again

>> No.20944838

>Guys this SIMULATED image of what we think the universe is like looks exactly like (rat) neurons
The human brain trying to perpetuate itself once again

>> No.20944844

I hope this isnt real.

>> No.20944851

>>20944844
listen to the first 10 min or so. He invited Dawkins on to sell his theory that the image of the Perfect Man is encoded in female brains and that it drives their mate selection strategy and that it'll periodically culminate in messianic ubermenschs.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbGoUwmqIEQ

>> No.20944860

>>20944801
This is what sold you? It sounds like the ranting of a teen stoner. "Woah this thing looks like the other thing"

>> No.20944869

>>20944801
I'm willing to believe this is real because he rambles this long and doesn't fucking state his point or what you're supposed to derive from it.

>> No.20944885

>>20944869
It's like he's entirely right brained.

>> No.20944893

you know you could just read spinoza instead

>> No.20944894
File: 137 KB, 1262x634, jp.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20944894

lmao

>> No.20944904

What do you call this type of person? Those that try to re-construct religion based on rationalism? Or who think religion has real value because of the social effects it might cause? These people have always seemed retarded to me

>> No.20944909

>>20944904
He's a very spiritual person and the scientist part of him is always trying to reconcile that by finding some biological basis for Universalism

>> No.20944920

>>20944801
>computational theology
Funnily enough this is an actual field, but it only has a single topic so far

>> No.20944922

>>20944904
>what do you call this person
hylic

>> No.20944930

>we shared a common ancestor with sedimentary rocks until a few million years ago
this pseud fuck can really get you clowns to believe anything, can't he

>> No.20944931

>>20944904
>Those that try to re-construct religion based on rationalism?
God=/=religion

>> No.20944934

>>20944904
>Or who think religion has real value because of the social effects it might cause?

This is by far the only real value religions has.

>> No.20944943

>>20944909
>spiritual person
>finding some biological basis
These people have know that grounding a spiritual doctrine in something like evolutionary biology is ridiculous right? That would just mean that spirit is a reproductively beneficial psychological mechanism, meaning spirit doesn't even exist. This is why full-blown theologians or esotericists are infinitely better to listen to, they actually make internally coherent systems

>> No.20944951

>>20944801
>And if you look at the CT scans of rats, it's like a low resolution approximation of the Milky Way galaxy. *tears up*.
I'm the one tearing up

>> No.20944989

>>20944904
A closet atheist with Dunning-Kruger

>> No.20944999
File: 685 KB, 1293x818, comment_Ggb5tdzlDKQiJ1LLsauceoqVRHHXsDMq.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20944999

>. And if you look at the CT scans of rats, it's like a low resolution approximation of the Milky Way galaxy. *tears up*. And you know rats are considered sacred in many cultures
It has taken man-thing this long to find-discover this? The Great Horned One has promised-pledged us your world. You will be our servants-slaves yes-yes!

>> No.20945002

>>20944930
he certainly made you believe it. LOOSER.

>> No.20945013

Another autumn, another JBP seethe thread, formerly cope

>> No.20945017 [DELETED] 

>>20945002
>>20944999
>>20944989
>>20944951
>>20944943
>>20944934
>>20944931
>>20944930
>>20944922
>>20944920
>>20944909
>>20944904
>>20944894
>>20944893
>>20944885
>>20944869
>>20944860
>>20944851
>>20944844
>>20944838
>>20944829
>>20944814
>>20944807
>>20944801
>>20945013
Trans women are women

>> No.20945024

>>20945017
mbappe is dating trans woman
it's over for chuds

>> No.20945030

>>20945024
>n*ggers are gay
whoa what a surprise

>> No.20945067
File: 1.56 MB, 2560x1600, poisson-a-tete-transparente-barreleye-2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20945067

>>20944801
When even someone as stupid, sociopathic and psychotic as Peterson understands this you know the idea is universal and true. Even if it gets muddied in his rat-worship (seriously; why is this man such a fuck-up?).

All mass is divine. The chaotic system fractally expanding and experiencing itself through itself is the true face of God.

>> No.20945073

>>20944801
Ah, the man who thinks Pinocchio was written by Dante. What a great mind.

>> No.20945076

>>20945030
>gay
she's a woman tho

>> No.20945110 [DELETED] 

>>20944930
Rocks are consideriacross geological timescales. They reproduce through crystallization and process information and react to stimuli the way any organism does if you zoom out far enough.

>> No.20945126

>>20944930
Rocks are considered sentient across geological timescales. They reproduce through crystallization and process information and react to stimuli the way any organism does if you zoom out far enough. The fact that you don't realize this is why the new atheist movement failed.

>> No.20945153

Noooo I don't want to be a sedimentary rock.

>> No.20945172

Whoah duuude, deep
Pass the bong

>> No.20945189

>>20945126
Source?

>The fact that you don't realize this is why the new atheist movement failed.

Failed at what?

>> No.20945200

>>20945189
>Taking the bait
ngmi

>> No.20945204
File: 103 KB, 676x1121, 1634579054712.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20945204

should i spend my paycheck on asian anya's set?

>> No.20945212

>>20945204
I hope no one seriously does things like this

I pirated some ASMR whore's porn the other day just to see what it was like and it's literally just a 6/10 bitch moving around mostly clothed on a bed. People are paying $20 a month for that.

>> No.20945219

>>20945212
I'm doing my penance for patriarchy

>> No.20945233
File: 332 KB, 1024x681, 8407784802_12a4f83273_b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20945233

This isn't "mind-blowing" or anything new. Watch "Hunting the Hidden Dimension." Its self-similarity and nature loves it. That's why you can look at tree branches in the fall and see the circulatory structure of the kidney. Its one of the clever ways that nature saves time. Instead of coding for each little iteration, just repeat the same one over and over at different scales.

Mandlebrot figured this out analyzing interference in telephone lines and realizing that smaller points of the wave resembled the larger waves when zoomed in. You see the same thing in electrocardiograms.

https://youtu.be/d0Exnv8Ym7s

>> No.20945242

>>20945067
oh shit ok you right you right

>> No.20945247

>>20945233
I know, we should all know but unfortunately 4chan is full of niggers and pseuds

>> No.20945280

>>20944829
No, I'm afraid it's really Mormonism that gets constantly rediscovered.

Too bad, enjoy hell

>> No.20945307

>>20944860
>>20944869
>>20944930

You people are retarded. Like absolutely fucking retarded if you think he actually said this.

>It's very old -I don't know old exactly maybe a few trillion years old... it certainly predates oral history which is only like a few hundred billion years old, and we shared a common ancestor with sedimentary rocks until a few million years ago

Have you got no concept of time and history of the universe or evolution?

>> No.20945321

>>20945204
just remember to upload it to e-hentai if you do

>> No.20945344

>>20944894
what the fuck is this lol

>> No.20945375

>>20944904
>Or who think religion has real value because of the social effects it might cause? These people have always seemed retarded to me

Are you fucking kidding me lmao

Islamic Caliphate and Iran 1979
>exists

Christianity and the fall of the Roman Empire
>exists

The Vatican
>exists


4,000+ years of human history
>exists

>> No.20945419

>>20945375
This.
>>20944904
Sorry but you're retarded

>> No.20945438
File: 320 KB, 480x480, 1655844003057.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20945438

>> No.20945442

>>20944814
Nothing wrong with having a hoe daughter

>> No.20945446

>>20945017
Based and true

>> No.20945453

>>20945375
Religion is retard, you literally have lower IQ

>> No.20945467

>>20945307
Hope he sees this bro

>> No.20945487

>>20945467
Im not defending JBP, but these are obvioulsy not his words and it's actually funny that some people see this as real and don't see a problem in him saying that oral history is a few hundred billion years old.

>> No.20945519

UP YOURS

>> No.20945525

>>20945487
Dude lobsters

>> No.20945614

>>20945344
it's gravity's rainbow. no idea why this dumbfuck anon keeps trying to pass it off as peterson in various threads

>> No.20945627

>>20945614
i don't have a dog in this race but probably because credulous chapo retards are putting the cart before the horse and looking for reasons to mock petersneed so they'd probably do something foolish like mock pynchon thinking it's him

>> No.20945659

>>20945627
I'm just laughing

>> No.20945670

>>20945627
what happened to your dog? is it too old?

>> No.20945688
File: 1.36 MB, 947x950, jp.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20945688

>And that's the thing. The devil is in the details. Are they white? No. The literature on that is quite clear. And you might say: "Are they circumcised?" Well, yes, by and large, most of the time, quite robustly. But then again, so are Muslims. And so are white Americans. Does that mean we discount circumcision as an indicator of tribe status? Well, maybe. But that's not the point. The point--and Carl Jung wrote about this--the point is that by the time you realize the importance of always checking the 'early life' section, you won't need to. This was the realization Jung made and it is a staggeringly brilliant observation. What he said was: once you understand the early life, you are beyond needing to know the early life. And that may sound like a paradox, and fair enough, but...

>> No.20945758

>>20945688
>The devil is in the details
I don't know dr peterson, that sounds suspiciously postmodern.

>> No.20945767

>>20945453
That may be true, but saying that religion has no effect on culture or people is the absolutely willfully braindead.

>> No.20945891

>>20945153
You WILL be a rock
You WILL slowly erode
But you will be happy

>> No.20945940

>>20944904
Intelligent lovers of wisdom.

>> No.20945941

>>20944801
very good impression, OP!

>> No.20945943

>>20945940
That is just...whoah...

>> No.20945949

>>20944801
Simulated universe? We can see it faggot, it doesn't look like that.

>> No.20946074

>>20944801
>clinical psychologist who spent decades personally helping hundreds of people severely afflicted by mental illness
>academic who published dozens of widely cited papers ranging in subjects varying from practical counseling, historical/philosophical roots of psychology, research paradigms in neurology...
>research scientist working on the operationalization of personality constructs as well as the neurobiological basis of addiction
>university professor who mentored dozens of grad students into academic, research, and counseling careers
>assisted in the development of software that increases the likelihood of at-risk students reaching graduation as a side project
>accidentally became internationally famous and ended up publishing 2 best selling books (so far) as well as organizing lectures in various countries throughout the world
inb4
>he's a drug addict tho!
>his office was messy once!
>er...you don't have a dad!
>er...wash your dick!
>his daughter is a slut!
>he likes the Jews!
>he's controlled opposition!
Still triggering trannies who don't like the truth, libtards who propaganize, racists he won't associate with, and pseuds who can't tell the difference between a media personality and real life.
>/thread

>> No.20946096 [DELETED] 
File: 2.96 MB, 360x640, aa.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20946096

>>20946074
trans women are cute and valid

>> No.20946098

>>20946096
sauce?

>> No.20946117
File: 91 KB, 1024x1019, fatpepe.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20946117

>>20946096
but what about the chocolate

>> No.20946131

>>20946117
you can lick the slightly melted chocolate out of the grooves made from her cutting her thighs.

>> No.20946133 [SPOILER] 
File: 1.58 MB, 1280x720, 1660018548579983.web.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20946133

>>20946098
First you must apologize for defending peterson and then you must admit that gender is a social construct and is nonbinary in nature

>> No.20946137
File: 22 KB, 576x432, 1657793648843.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20946137

>>20946133
man hands. i dont want it anymore.

>> No.20946185
File: 37 KB, 900x651, 13677428.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20946185

>>20946137
>those are man hands
maybe if you have chudcel twink hands

>> No.20946192

>>20944807
I'm so happy Mr Hyde won that fight. What an emotional rollercoaster.

>> No.20946203

>>20944801
This parody reveals a lot about whoever wrote it.

>> No.20946259
File: 822 KB, 1080x2020, Screenshot_20220905-154640_Chrome.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20946259

>>20946203
Yes it certainly does.

>> No.20946372

>>20946185
they're long, bony, and veiny. its unsettling.

>> No.20946450

>>20946259
This reply reveals a lot about you.

>> No.20946456

and thats the bloody thing with bloody marxist dragons in the cave eating your bloody father

>> No.20946954

>>20945487
If you werent reading super carefully, it's easy to miss that one error.
Otherwise whoever wrote this copypasta did a really good job of capturing Peterson's diction. And it's not like Peterson hasn't said equally retarded things.

>> No.20946974

>>20945487
Yeah sometimes you realize how fucking moronic the people on here are

>> No.20947024
File: 1.68 MB, 2552x2592, fag.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20947024

>>20945614
He's been doing it for over a year too. Pic-related doesn't even go back all the way.

>> No.20947150

>>20944801
Why are atheists so against these kind of ideas, when we know for a fact that the same principle applies to things like the petal distribution of a flower?

>> No.20948298

>>20944844
Sadly it is.

>> No.20948318

>>20945688
From the thumbnail I thought he had the Joker scare

>> No.20948320

>>20944801
>one thing looks similar to another thing
Whoa what a great argument, truly a genius

>> No.20948323

>>20944801
You niggers critique him all day meanwhile the floor of your room is probably littered with cumrags and mcdonalds bags and empty cans.

>> No.20948330

>>20948323
Doesn’t surprise me that a JP fanboy has never heard of ad hominem

>> No.20948346

>>20945438
based. wish it was longer and showed the tranny afterwards

>> No.20948350

>>20948346
>rooting for apelike, criminal behavior

>> No.20948352
File: 153 KB, 1001x823, 1655603321351.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20948352

>>20944829

>> No.20948358

>>20948330
Wrong. I'm indifferent to him, I just see a bunch of losers trying to refute him meanwhile if they listened to his meme advice they'd be better off.

>> No.20948364

>>20945438
It is not without reason that the Wise hath proclaimed that niggas have no impulse control.

>> No.20948377
File: 732 KB, 1600x1131, 70A71D74-DFFD-49FD-A399-878B14C2135C.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20948377

>>20948358
Truly shows indifference when you go out of your way to defend him in a thread. Either way, at least you acknowledge that you don’t even know basic logic, but it’s ok, take this picture as a starting point

>> No.20948398

>>20944801
>it's all isomorphism MAAAAN
Shared in equal measure by neoplatonists, LSD-maniacs and Swedenborgians (i.e., literal clinically verified schizophrenics). I those thoughts myself for quite a while after a much too high dose of LSD got me hospitalized with a brief psychotic episode.

As for Jordan Peterson, I just opened youtube - it has now been months, and he just posted ANOTHER 30 minutes cope and seethe video framing his twitter ban as some sort of apocalyptic and satanic rape of God himself. He is such a giant faggot, perhaps the greatest faggot of all e-celebs, and that is saying quite a lot.

>> No.20948409

>>20948377
How am I defending him? I'm merely making an observation, which is accurate. Hence you are at odds with reality, your room probably is messy and you probably are a loser. If not you, than many itt. His advice for young men is sound, why would you attack it? Maybe you don't want young white men to succeed, like a j*w?

Also, I said I am indifferent to the man, not to ideas which I can view separately. Why would anyone listen to your advice on logic and fallacies when you can't get basic stuff like this straight?

>> No.20948410

>>20948398
JP is just dude weed philosophy for people that larp as trad

>> No.20948415

>>20948398
>listen to me, i'm schizo and abuse drugs!
LMAO

>> No.20948417

>>20948410
>thinks trads listen to jbp
Do you have a mental disability?

>> No.20948431

>>20948409
> How am I defending him?
Ad hominem attacks at people criticizing him.
> Hence you are at odds with reality, your room probably is messy and you probably are a loser. If not you, than many itt.
Disagreeing with his retarded reading of jung is the only critique towards him itt. Nobody has ever said anything about clean rooms, nor has that been ever a central point of critique, if anything people make fun of trying to sell „cleaning your room“ as a profound philosophical insight. Again, nothing but ad hominems, as well as really poorly constructed strawmen
> Maybe you don't want young white men to succeed
Young white man certainly don’t succeed by developing a a victim complex over the imaginary academic pomo Marxist sjw
> like a j*w?
Seems my last point is already lost to you though
> Also, I said I am indifferent to the man
When your self perception is at such odds with your expressed behavior, I have all the right in the world to comment on this. I know you don’t realize, but you just wrote an entire paragraph defending him.

>> No.20948434

>>20944801
I had a peterson phase in 2016-2018. he was kinda entertaining at first but by the end got bored long winded platitutdes and some of his premises. he rly fkin lost it recently tho, what the fuck happened

>> No.20948437

>>20948415
Yet you just did anyway lmao gottem well played in playing yourself

>> No.20948447

>>20944999
Fascinating

>> No.20948456
File: 16 KB, 954x152, HITLERSON.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20948456

>>20944801
How is his new self help book about following Hitler's personal habits is going on?

>> No.20948457

>>20948437
From a certain perspective, yes, since I read your idiot post and keked. I would "listen" to jbp nefore you though, although I don't watch his youtube.

>> No.20948463

>>20948431
I'm just defending some of his ideas, and pointing out that most of his critics itt would be better off following his meme advice of cleaning their rooms. I'm indifferent to the man himself, because he is boring to me. But keep going.

>> No.20948466

>>20948456
Go back

>> No.20948469

>>20948457
>I would "listen" to jbp nefore you though, although I don't watch his youtube.
YOU JUST DID IT AGAIN LMAO, immediately proving yourself wrong.
Just stop bro

>> No.20948472

>>20948463
Why would I? You keep spouting the same nonsense without being able to address a single point I made

>> No.20948478

>>20948469
LMAO really?? you're not my bro, shitskin. Keep going.

>> No.20948481

>>20948472
I don't care about your points. You probably have cumrags and monster bottles all over your room.

>> No.20948484

>>20948478
>literally keeps listening to me instead of listening to JBP who he has said he would rather listen to but is admitting he does not listen to
You've been bested in this bout of wits mon ami, best retreat from the duelling grounds and tend to your wounds.

>> No.20948497

>>20944829
>Christianity has been rediscovered independently across different cultures time and time again
lmao

>> No.20948511

>>20944801
>computational theology
What??

>> No.20948522

>>20948484
>shitskin thinks he has "wit"
Lmao keep going retard

>> No.20948523

>>20944844
if you'd ever studied evolutionary astronomy and computational theology, especially where the two disciplines overlap, you'd realise it wasn't all that crazy what he's saying

>> No.20948527

>>20944851
>oxford campus
is this nutter at my uni AGAIN?
somehow i never see him around

>> No.20948532

>>20944829
>Christianity has been rediscovered independently across different cultures time and time again

>> No.20948541

>>20944920
take a discipline and put "computational" in front of it, and you have a new discipline
the new thing is putting quantum in front of everything, so its only a matter of time before we have quantum computational theology

>> No.20948543

>>20948527
How much is your tuition?

>> No.20948546

>>20948543
all paid for by student loans m8, plus i get an extra 2k busary because i come from a "low-income" family

>> No.20948558

>>20948546
You realize you have to pay those back for the rest of your life, you dumb 3rd worlder? Now tell me how much it is. 2k won't make a dent in it.

>> No.20949003

Utterly disgusting matter (not life: matter) worship ITT. Molecules of fesces aren't bits of God.

>> No.20949037

>>20944807
CANDYMAN

>> No.20949048
File: 27 KB, 568x305, 1654866598968.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20949048

>>20944801
Slay the dragon, clean your room, save your father. A little bit of disorder is a good thing, but you have to control it. Society is a male dominant construct. It's a hierarchy - control. If society goes too far you get tyranny. Tyranny, chaos: man and woman. Mother nature - chaos. You see?

>> No.20949088

The same reasons that cause you all to sperg about this kind Canadian centrist are also the reasons you're all miserable failures incapable of even putting together a single interesting shitpost. You ruin everything you touch. You're the single dominant reason for the downtrend in meaningful discussions across the internet and the world.

>> No.20949130
File: 77 KB, 645x770, 5c5.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20949130

>>20949088
>STOP LAUGHING AT MY EDADDY!!!

>> No.20949195

>>20949048
"Slay the dragon" means "kill jews". "Clean your room" means "force matter into its ideal shape". "Save your father" is about getting him to stop watching TV series.

>> No.20949227
File: 54 KB, 434x327, 015.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20949227

>>20949195
>OH GOD NCIS AGAIN?

>> No.20949238
File: 41 KB, 700x544, clarke.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20949238

>>20944801
>It's very old -I don't know old exactly maybe a few trillion years old
The universe is less than 14 billion years old.

>> No.20949566

>>20949130
Have you ever noticed how you hordes of retards with the same precooked opinions always show up in large numbers during wagie hours?

>> No.20949677
File: 946 KB, 960x960, R (22).png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20949677

>>20949566
we're blowing off time at work before going home and reading better works.

>> No.20949857

>>20949677
You're all resentful serfs that can't get their shit together. Slaving away while blaming everyone else and actively attacking anything that might help you become better. This guy should be most useful for wagies but they're also the ones that don't want to hear that they can be more competent.

>> No.20950299

>>20945891
I am already slowly eroding.

>> No.20950344

>>20944801
Haha, as if Rats are neurobiologically similar to humans. They have a different ratio of astrocytes per axon! What a buffoon. No wonder the far left hate him, they are very autistic about animal models.

>> No.20950363

>>20949227
>>20949677
Why would anyone listen to you over peterson?

>> No.20950401

>>20950344
The far left hate him because he's moderately right wing and points out how insane they are, while really they would be better off if they listened to his meme advice.

>> No.20950405

Can someone steelman his idea that information about the structure and shape of the DNA double helix somehow bubbled up through several levels of emergent systems and abstraction and ingrained itself in our psyche and things like the caduceus is a subconscious manifestation of that?

Sean Carroll said that when he's consulting for a film and he's given a ludicrous premise, he plays a game where he assumes he lives in a universe where that premise is true and try to come up with an explanation for it.

Just pretend you're an evolutionary biologist who has to do the same with petersons theory.

>> No.20950452
File: 59 KB, 1280x720, 99775cbe035b90a1b94cf1cda1535277.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20950452

>>20944801
>and you know, if you place yourself in that moment, if you _allow_ yourself to be consumed by it, well then that's when you've got it man, that's art, that's culture man, that's the universe talking directly to you, that's what music is and that's what it bloody means to be alive, that's what actually happens when you're listening, whatever that means, to Linkin Park man

>> No.20950457

>>20950405
He says himself that this idea is an example of him going far into hypotheticals and more pure intuition than formal thinking.
I relate it to idealism, nature used the form of the helix because of its fundamental properties. It's simple and fundamental, it's reasonable to expect to see helixes and similar forms everywhere and maybe especially in living organisms. You can notice that and be dismissive, call it a coincidence or you can try to get deeper into if there are underlying mechanisms. Perhaps it is more useful to think of these kinds of patterns more like Plato as things that exist as higher ideals or heavenly forms and each instance is a reflection of that higher form. That's at least a formal way to look at the commonalities in the patterns without dismissing it all as "coincidence" which ends all thinking.

>> No.20950498

>>20948546
It's lowly peasants like you that have turned this university into a shithole. Please do not return this term

>> No.20950680

>>20944904
darwinian materialist with some mental strife due to poor life habits

>> No.20950905

>>20944801
Peterson doesn't have any idea how big the numbers trillion and billion are, does he?
>this idea is a few trillion years old
>it certainly predates oral history which is only like a few hundred billion years old
The universe is estimated to be 13.7 billion years old, and humans developed into roughly our current form approximately 5-7 million years ago. Peterson is usually a pseud but even this kind of talk is egregious for him.

>> No.20950945

>>20944851
>"So I'm interested in the improbability of coincidence in this case. I say people in Scandinavia and people in the Amazonian jungle had independently developed an alphabet, which was the same alphabet, that would be impressive."
>"Yes, but it's also equally impressive that separated people did develop alphabets."
56:25
Dawkins intellectually mogged Peterson despite only talking for like 4% of this entire "interview." I don't even like Dawkins or hold him in high regard, but there's clearly a large gulph between the two in terms of critical thinking skills.

>>20944931
>God=/=religion
While this is a true distinction and usually helpful to point out, it's not relevant here because Peterson is pretty explicitly seeking to reinforce Christian metaphysics. I have not seen him demonstrate any interest or greater-than-layman knowledge of any other religious tradition.

>> No.20950959

>>20945487
It's believable precisely because it is supposedly Peterson saying it. The guy makes grandiose truth claims without the basic knowledge to back it up all the time, it's his conversational bread-and-butter.

>> No.20950960

juden peterstein

>> No.20950979

>>20946259
Based.

>> No.20950988

>>20948417
Zoomer-trads do, which is what he's describing as "people that larp as trad."

>> No.20951335

>>20950945
That separated people did develop an alphabet speaks to the underlying point in all of this, the idea of these patterns all reflecting something beyond what they are.
What's the use of saying anything to people like you? You will twist any explanation of anything to suit you.

>> No.20951350

>>20950960
Find another thread to sully you evil coward.

>> No.20951433

>>20951350
Are the children of Nod redeemable?
https://youtu.be/0-StbZDIRHU

>> No.20951467

>>20951335
Both Peterson and yourself seem to think that writing systems, especially those which developed in isolation from one another, are somehow similar in ANY way other than communicating spoken meaning in a written form, which on its own is a phenomenon easily explained by materialism on its own. (I'm not a materialist, just so you don't get confused)
Ask a linguist what the differences between Mayan script, Hieroglyphs, Phoenician-derived alphabets (including the one we use for English), and Chinese Hanzi are and they won't even know where to start. Even calling it an alphabet is a display of ignorance, because countless scripts throughout history are explicitly not based on phonemic representation. And even for the many, many alphabetic languages out there, there are in every example I'm aware of "letters" which do not map cleanly (or at all) into other languages. Take Arabic's ع for example, which is laughably represented in English as "3". Linguists estimate there are over 800 phonemes used in human languages. English uses 44.
If the universal phenomenon of language, or more specifically writing (as you and Peterson are referring to) was pointing to some metaphysical truth, then how do you explain all of these differences?

When Dawkins catches him on this, Peterson quickly retreats from it. He swaps to saying that the fact of different languages developing independently is somehow equally impressive to the false initial claim that unrelated languages were mysteriously similar. Which, they are not.
Communication is common across all animals, the only unique thing humans developed was the mental and physical ability for speech. Spoken word existed for uncounted millennia before any writing systems cropped up, which are natural extensions of language allowing for meaning to be transmitted across time and space. This basic functionality is enough to explain the independent development of writing systems in isolated places and times.
If you want so badly to read quasi-religious meaning into something, focus on the spoken word. But even then you'll have to account for the massive divergence in phonemes and patterns. Even linguists are increasingly less and less sure of any "single original proto-language" ever existening, nevermind the notion that it could be reconstructed. So, good luck with that.

>> No.20951559

>>20951467
>how do you explain all of these differences?
The mechanism of communicating through symbols is independent from the specifics of the symbols like logical statements are independent of the specific things you're applying them to.
>catches him on this
There's no "catching". You live in a fantasy world.
>unrelated languages were mysteriously similar. Which, they are not.
You then start talking about the common factors.
>This basic functionality
Whatever basic commonalities you agree on point to the fact that they all reflect something beyond what they are. Wings develop independently because they reflecting an underlying pattern to reality.
>If you want so badly to read quasi-religious meaning i
This is one of your coping mechanisms. You assign all this baggage so you don't have to really consider anything. The guy is not presenting some religious dogma but you're responding as if you're defending your own instead of simply considering ideas like a reasonable person.
>single original proto-language
Not necessary, it would detract from the point about things developing independently if it was true so it makes no sense to bring it up. Still everything has roots, not all the families of wings have the same genetic roots but they do have roots in the same phenomena that allows flight.

>> No.20952354

>>20951559
>You then start talking about the common factors.
Which are?

>> No.20952713

>>20944829
Christianity is just another iteration of the primordial truth

>> No.20952718

>>20952354
The basic functionality.

>> No.20952726

>>20944904
Nominal [name of chosen religion]

>> No.20952733
File: 153 KB, 264x225, 264px-YotsuyuCamo.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20952733

>>20945126
>>20945153
>>20945891
Silicate hands typed these posts

>> No.20952735

>>20944801
honestly people give him too much shit, not saying he's right about everything but he's right about cultural marxism, which is really just western marxism

>> No.20952736

>>20944801
>evolutionary astronomy
>computational theology
nice reference

>> No.20952744

>>20944829
I can’t tell if this is bait. I feel like an android failing voight-kampff.

>> No.20952755

>>20944904
Religion is social. If you believe in individual revelation and a direct line to God you‘re actually retarded.

>> No.20952760
File: 15 KB, 320x240, wakasakigahime.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
20952760

>>20952718

>> No.20952800

>>20952760
That's meeting you at your own premises where we should be able to approach the actual point from.
>Whatever basic commonalities you agree on point to the fact that they all reflect something beyond what they are. Wings develop independently because they reflecting an underlying pattern to reality.
The speculation about the magic helix snake is way beyond you. It's like you can't even conceive of speculating, thinking about things. You can't even start somewhere more reasonable because you think the objective is finding some petty gotcha instead of thinking.

>> No.20952821

>>20951467
I entirely agree, but you‘re maybe a bit too radical here. You make it seem as if there are non-phonetic scripts used to represent (spoken) language. There are of course non-phonetic scripts and non-spoken languages, but those are semantics more than anything and not concrete to rejecting his point.
Then there’s the whole matter of implying that Hanzi might be non-phonetic, might be ideogramms which is wrong, but people are quickly drawn to when thinking of examples following what they know languages are, that being simply a spoken tongue of a language.
Science has an enlightening purpose, which goes especially when you‘re talking to someone who is ignorant with being specific. I don’t want to lecture you. I‘m just saying that people jump to conclusions and when you’re talking down someone, deservedly, and don’t make a fuss over something essential to science but entangle yourself in semantics you have the same pitfall as the radical atheists and agnostics from the later 2000s when instead of leaving the Christians be they heaped criticism and yet more criticism upon them.

>> No.20953022

>>20952821
That's fair and a well-measured response.
I felt that diving into the specifics was the only way to get my point across, because otherwise I'm just saying "language is more complicated than that" and leaving it as so, like I'm making a unsubstantiated claim.

>> No.20954237

>>20944904

Utilitarian, vulgarian, Materialist, i.e. Anglo.

>> No.20954453

>>20944801
So basically hell really is other people - in the sense that if you reject the world, you reject God. Nietzsche was right, and that's why he went insane and died: In heaven, all the interesting people are missing.