[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 52 KB, 868x1024, standard_compressed_Sigmund_Freud.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19292150 No.19292150 [Reply] [Original]

Has Freud been debunked?

>> No.19292193

No, they can't say shit about his main theories yet. It's neither confirmable nor falsifiable at this point, so modern psychology and neuroscience mostly ignores him while seething how wrong he was, without providing much evidence.
Afaik there is groups in Vienna who want to use neuroscience to confirm his structure of the mind but I don't know how that's going.

>> No.19292200

I thought Jung debunked him?

>> No.19292209
File: 169 KB, 1044x869, debooonker.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19292209

>>19292150

Yes, but his debunkers were also debunked, so who knows?

>> No.19292290

Debunked?
>mommy porn everywhere on the internet
you are so blind its unbelievable

>> No.19292292

as >>19292193 said, his main theories have not been debunked yet and probably never will since they work well in psychotherapy, even though his theory of psychosexual development in children is rejected by modern psychoanalysts.
Also neuroscientific imagery confirms the existence of an unconscious mind.

>>19292200
Nah he just offers another perspective on certain issues, but psychoanalysis workst ust as well as Jung's analytic psychology so you can't really say he debunked him

>> No.19292316

>>19292150
nah only psychology got deboonked

>> No.19292320

>>19292290
>One drug-addled Jewish charlatan shills his subversive wares
>Other drug-addled Jewish charlatans spam the internet with their sick porn reflective of aforementioned shillery
>indicative of reality
Wew lad.

>> No.19292323

No, he was correct about everything except he doesn't understand that Hyper morality or super ego is put in your head by God himself

>> No.19292328

>>19292323
Meds

>> No.19292335

>>19292328
Gas chamber.

>> No.19292345

>>19292320
okay kike then explain to me why 100s of millions of people watch that shit, explain to me why gen z spam shit like: mommy gf, mommy milk everywhere on the web. You're such a pathetic fucking loser its unbelievable

>> No.19292347

>>19292320
what if Freud was right but his theories only apply to jews?

>> No.19292372

>>19292347
Kek this might actually be true.

>> No.19292390

>>19292290
>you are so blind its unbelievable
How can someone be unbelievable blind?

>> No.19292393

>>19292345
mommy posting is coincidental and ur just trying to justify you're sad depravity

>> No.19292395

>>19292347
This is very true. Freud is to jews as Jung is to non-jews

>> No.19292398

Beyond the Pleasure Principle and Civilization and its Discontents are still relevant.

>> No.19292435

>>19292200
Jung is far too mystical or spiritual for modern psychology to take seriously

>> No.19292497

>>19292292
>Also neuroscientific imagery confirms the existence of an unconscious mind.
Freud was far from the first to talk about the unconscious tho

>> No.19292668
File: 34 KB, 640x414, Freud or Fraud.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19292668

He was a kike, why would you even believe him?

>> No.19292683

>>19292668
funny how this meme ignores when rat man brought up fantasies of being fucked in the ass by rats BEFORE freud made any mention of it

>> No.19292688

>>19292193
What are his main theories?
>>19292292

>> No.19292712

>>19292683
> rat man has fantasies of being fucked in the ass
It really doesn’t take a genius to conclude from that that he wants to have anal sex

>> No.19292726

>>19292193
>he man you cant actually say freud is bebunked, because his theories cant technically be disproven.

go off yourself

>> No.19292736

>>19292150
Fun Fact: One of the first two people Freud did psychopathy with killed themselves after Freuds death in Freuds house after Freuds daughter agreed to let her stay the night at the house because she felt sorry for her.

That should tell you everything you need to know about if Freuds methods work.

>> No.19292851

>>19292736
what should that tell me?

>> No.19292933

>>19292736
you mean that it worked so well that Freud's death was this meaningful to an ex-patient?

>> No.19292942

>>19292851
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7xxgRUyzgs0

>> No.19292945

>>19292150
Yes, by Jung

>> No.19292985

Reminder that Freud's claim that a child is the equivalent of a phallus to a woman is a world-ending statement. Amen.

>> No.19293067

>>19292150
You can't debunk it because psychology is a meme "science"

>> No.19293916

>>19292150
He is proven more correct everyday by sheer virtue of the fact that his opponents, also known as modern psychiatry, are so off based

>> No.19294047

>>19292726
Yes, that’s how science works retard. For something to be proven true it needs to be proven false also, that’s what falsifiable means.

>> No.19294167

>>19294047
>For something to be proven true it needs to be proven false also
I never understood much about falsifiability, especially when people apply it to something beyond its empirical scope. Like when you say that all X is B but it happens that occasionally X will be C, still, the rule is X = B but precisely because there will be C occasionally then it makes true that X = B? Help me to get any sense out of it.

>> No.19294181

>>19292193
>Afaik there is groups in Vienna who want to use neuroscience to confirm his structure of the mind but I don't know how that's going.
I don't know about that but there are a small minority of neuroscientists who are interested in psychoanalysis, and vice versa like Mark Solms, who say contemporary neuro findings about memory suggest Freud's views on repression and memory/forgetting were on base.

>> No.19294296

>>19292497
You're right, let's say it confirms the existence of an unconscious mind in general