[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 86 KB, 626x800, Cioran_in_Romania.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18503257 No.18503257 [Reply] [Original]

>{Beckett] was a great writer. Yet I fear people will say: he was overrated. I've thought long and hard about it, and I can't say exactly why, but he will be considered overrated, fantastically overrated. I say that with regret, we were very good friends. He used to support me financially, his wife even more so.
Was he right? Is Beckett considered overrated?

>> No.18503262

>>18503257
He didn't say he was overrated he said people will consider him overrated.

>> No.18503324

Beckett is overrated.

>> No.18503328

idk but waiting for godot sucks

>> No.18503957

>>18503257
Beckett is underrated

>> No.18503971

>>18503257
He was overrated at some point in the 20th century but currently he couldn't be more underrated.

>> No.18504285

>>18503262
OP didn't say he said he was overrated.

>> No.18504310

>>18503262
He is just projecting his own opinion onto people.

>> No.18504637

>>18503257
Beckett is and always will be massively underrated because everyone always sees Joyce as "the great irish writer", whereas Beckett is just that dude who makes plays in which nothing happens.Truth is, Beckett's minimalism is far more ingenious and artistically legitimate than Joyce's maximalism. I read someone once describe him as being like the yukka and plants which are able to grow anywhere– his writing is like the singular bud that springs from the cracks of an otherwise inhospitable concrete wasteland.

>> No.18504710

>>18504637
calling Beckett minimalist and Joyce maximalist is an npc reading of both of them

>> No.18504748

>>18504710
Brainlet detected. Even Beckett himself described his work in relation to Joyce in that way. Is Beckett an NPC?

>> No.18504764

>>18503257
Cioran loved Beckett so much that he ended up hating him

>> No.18504899

>>18503257
>He used to support me financially, his wife even more so.
Shill detected

>> No.18504900

>>18504748
>is Beckett an npc?
>"the world sucks, let's all make jokes about it"
Kinda on the nose

>> No.18504910

>>18504900
And you say MY reading of Beckett is an NPC reading.

Also, isn't "the world sucks, let's all make jokes about it" basically just the defining paradigm of 4chan? The group of people who are most likely to consider themselves non-NPCs?

>> No.18504919

Why did older writers always pay for each other's gibs?

>> No.18504923

>>18504919
Platonic frens

>> No.18504983
File: 39 KB, 652x470, Aaah.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18504983

>>18504910
>basically just the defining paradigm of 4chan?
No. What use is 4chan if there is no outrage and reaction? The world sucks and it is justified to be mad at it.

>> No.18504994

Cioran's GoF essentially lambasted any ideology, philosophy, and probably Cioran himself, which I'm sure he knew. People know him for his sheer pessimism but's GoF one of my favorite short essays of all time and is about as neutral as it gets. His fondness for Beckett, whose prose is descriptive rather than prescriptive and leaves it open to such wide interpretation, makes sense I suppose.

>> No.18505723
File: 78 KB, 1469x814, 156878964526.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18505723

>>18504983
>What use is 4chan if there is no outrage and reaction?
Outrage culture is more the domain of reddit or tumblr. If you want to get mad at "society", go cry about it over there. Amazing that you're actually siding with the presenter from Joker and not the Joker himself in this instance, since he's basically the posterchild for 4chan at this point. You either laugh at the clown world, or you live long enough to see yourself become the clown.

>> No.18505736

>>18505723
>Outrage culture is more the domain of reddit or tumblr. If you want to get mad at "society", go cry about it over there.
Bullshit, newfag. /pol/ is nothing but outrage and has been for well over half a decade.
>You either laugh at the clown world, or you live long enough to see yourself become the clown
Cringe

>> No.18505752

>>18505736
>/pol/
reddit central
go back

>> No.18505771

>>18503257
Beckett is underrated because he never wrote a masterpiece. He's sort of like Dali - embraced a style and rolled with it absent-mindedly.

>> No.18505772

>>18505752
Fuck off newfag. You know shit
>le 4chan is Joker
Cringe af.

>> No.18505788
File: 724 KB, 220x146, 156870256.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18505788

>>18505736
>/pol/ is nothing but outrage and has been for well over half a decade.
>/pol/ is the entirety of the website, despite its current status as a refugee camp for r/The_Donald retards and /x/-tier schizos
You need to go back

>> No.18505807

>>18505788
>the most visited board on the site since /b/ became irrelevant
>every other poster on every board visits it
>the most in news board from 4chan
>"I-it's not representative"
You are both a retard and a newfag. Fuck off from here.
>"but but muh r/Donald and reddit
Same shit in 2013. No fuckin surprise you don't know shit.

>> No.18506052

>>18505807
>You're wrong REEEEEE
Did I hit a sore spot? Don't worry. Just two more weeks and you'll be vindicated!!

>> No.18506101

>>18506052
You are quite literally, absolutely, 100% wrong, newshit. None of the the "le quirky" posturing is gonna help you here. Better cure your retardation.

>> No.18506317

I remember when I read James Knowlson's bio of Beckett I got the impression they (Cioran / Beckett) were just shallow acquaintances but then I found out elsewhere that they in fact shared a mutual admiration and that Beckett very much enjoyed reading him. Beckett also enjoyed the company of Giacometti whose artistry is similar to that of Beckett and his minimalism though in the medium of sculpture instead

>> No.18506373

>>18506101
Suck two more cocks faggot

>> No.18506550
File: 34 KB, 600x482, 1624040676071.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18506550

>>18506373
t.
>suck two more cocks faggot
Now we are getting to 4chan way of reacting none of your faggot ass newshittery dumbass.

>> No.18507342

>>18504994
>GoF
whats this

>> No.18507358

>>18506550
Keep seething massive faggot. Only newfags brag about being oldfags

>> No.18507462
File: 2.56 MB, 322x178, 1624018839103.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18507462

>>18507358
Only newshitters have opinions like yours, you retard. I am having a field day making you seethe.

>> No.18507469

>>18504748
I believe that that take is awful yes. I wouldn't call Beckett an npc but you probably aren't either, but you seemed that way from your awful take

>> No.18507534

>>18507462
Quite an accomplishment.
gg

>> No.18507551

>>18507469
>your awful take
see:
>"I realized that Joyce had gone as far as one could in the direction of knowing more, in control of one's material. He was always adding to it; you only have to look at his proofs to see that. I realised that my own way was impoverishment, in lack of knowledge and in taking away, subtracting rather than adding."
Again, not my take, its the difference between them as posited by Beckett himself. You can't even justify why you think its awful, just "Hurrr npc but not really"

>> No.18508163

>>18505771
Are you aware that the trilogy exists