[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 928 KB, 782x782, 5dc-1[1].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18397758 No.18397758 [Reply] [Original]

was jung right and does the repeating of these patterns throughout history?
is all ways of trying to separate people just complex zodiac reading?

>> No.18397794
File: 6 KB, 228x221, 1622809717806.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18397794

My zodiac sign is Cancer. What does that say about me?

>> No.18397799
File: 885 KB, 1920x1080, Screenshot (23).png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18397799

>>18397794

>> No.18397808
File: 93 KB, 1080x1330, f38.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18397808

>>18397758
Leo, INTP, 5w4

>> No.18397871

>>18397758
None of that matters.

>> No.18398065

>>18397758
The tarot is nothing like the others tho. It doesn't represent who you "actually" are, it just offers a secret understanding of worldly knowledge

>> No.18398120

>>18398065
yes it does https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QIPKBHqCz8M&t=625s

>> No.18398131

>>18397758
Jung is literally the mf behind that mbti etfp poo poo shit

>> No.18398133

>>18398131
No he literally isn’t

>> No.18398137

>>18397758
Maybe I honestly see it as a way for people to classify and atomize themselves further while still knowing ultimately nothing but feeling a sense if psychological security in their new “personality” type. I feel he’s mostly right but I havent read much about Jung

>> No.18398150

>>18398133
I haven't read very much Jung but in Modern Man in Search of a Soul there's a chapter where he talks about the usefulness of classifying people into different personality types and claims that every man unequivocally fits into some grouping of the functions he outlines.

>> No.18398183

>>18398150
Yeah and the archetypal classification is great. INT-NIG shit is not based in archetype.

>> No.18398196

>>18397758
you should add the fag flags to that

>> No.18398199

>>18398183
It was my understanding that those classifications are based on the very functions that Jung believed in using to classify men (introverted/extraverted: thinking vs. feeling & intuition vs. sensing).

>> No.18398240

>>18398199
yes, but he didn't believe they were independent and uniformly distributed.

>> No.18398420

>>18397758
Nationalist, INTP, Sagittarius (December master race) and whats the last about?

>> No.18398428

>>18397794
you have about six months anon

>> No.18398433

>>18397758
>was jung right
No, Pythagoras was right.

>> No.18398452

>>18398433
No he wasn't. Heraclitus btfo Pythagoras.

>> No.18398456

>>18398433
/thread

>> No.18398600

>>18397808
ah yes, my more successful older brother
t. aquarius, INTP, 5w6

>> No.18398618

Mbti may be bullshit but it's fun and there's undoubtedly some essence of truth to it. Who all is /infp/ here? The description of the infp type perfectly describes the way my mind has always worked. I recently met another person who typed as infp, even before she told me I'd felt a strong connection to her, I understood her in a way I've never felt with anyone before, it was uncanny.

>> No.18398857

>>18398618
Replace your post with a zodiac sign and it works the same.
>Horoscope may be bullshit but it's fun and there's undoubtedly some essence of truth to it. Who all is sagittarius here? The description of the sagittarius personality perfectly describes the way my mind has always worked. I recently met another person who's a sagittarius , even before she told me I'd felt a strong connection to her, I understood her in a way I've never felt with anyone before, it was uncanny.

>> No.18399221

>>18398857
The thing is, Zodiac is based on the date of your birth (i.e. arbitrary unless you believe in the occult), MBTI is based on self identification and self description. Even if it cannot accurately classify people according to their core personalities, it can classify people according to what they believe or want their personalities to be. Which in a way is a part of their personality. So it isn't 100% arbitrary like Zodiac is.