[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 5 KB, 225x225, anarchism.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17988684 No.17988684 [Reply] [Original]

i see so many people over at *AHEM* reddit, saying you cant be an anarchist if you are not a feminist?
what if im only seeking to liberate myself from oppression? what if i dont give a fuck about women?
shit makes no sense. can someone explain?

>> No.17988690 [DELETED] 

also
Anarchism, liberty, does not tell you a thing about how free people will behave or what arrangements they will make. It simply says the people have the capacity to make the arrangements. Anarchism is not normative. It does not say how to be free. It says only that freedom, liberty, can exist.

—Karl Hess, “Anarchism without Hyphens”

>> No.17988728
File: 121 KB, 828x810, 1617801018195.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17988728

>>17988684
take the ted pill

>> No.17988738

>>17988728
i kinda forgot who he is? care to explain?

>> No.17988745
File: 81 KB, 640x640, 1549845329763.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17988745

>>17988684
Plz stop.

>> No.17988752

>>17988745
stop what?

>> No.17988770

>>17988684
That's just deacceleration and sabotage from big gay corporations and the goverment, don't listen to them. They want you to put all other fucking retarded ideas first before anarchism, divide and conquer, really. First feminism "You can't be an anarchist and not be feminist", then the animals "you can't be an anarchist if you aren't vegan", then the trans, then the trans rights to diddle little kids.
They want you to stop fighting the system, and start fighting for things inside the system "Oh yeah, I will fight for womyn rights for them to have equal wages!" Fuck that, the real "wage gap" is between the exploited and their exploiters.
In an anarchist society, things that are right will come naturally, the rest is just capitalism faggotry.

>> No.17988781

>>17988738
read industrial society and it's future big guy

>> No.17988791

>>17988770
>things that are right will come naturally
Nothing comes naturally in any society

>> No.17988810

>anarchism is the belief that Hierarchies are unjust until proven otherwise
>feminism is a movement with the goal of equality between the sexes
Uhh... OP, I found your problem.

>> No.17988858

>>17988791
Define society.

>> No.17988874

>>17988858
A group of people in which nothing comes naturally.

>> No.17988963

>>17988684
Uh, so anarchists advocate for the complety lack of hierarchy. Feminism, in the simplest sense of the word, says that women and men should be equal. If they're not, then there must be some kind of a hierarchical relation between them. Honestly, it's not hard to see where they're getting it from, but at the same time I wouldn't say that an anarchist must necessarily be a 21st century sjw-type feminist together with all their claims.

>> No.17989432

>>17988684
Every woman is a feminist until the roving bands of rape gangs raid the village.

>> No.17989943

>>17988684
Feminism is hardwired into the socialist project. If you prefer to be a dickwad socialist, you can, but you’re doing it wrong if you think women need to be singled out simply for being women, and kept dumb, barefoot and pregnant, open to sexual harassment or rape, until marriage bondage, and in some cases even after. No socialists are about freedom for all, but not the freedom to rape.
Tell us about your mother, OP.

>>17988963
>Uh, so anarchists advocate for the complety lack of hierarchy
No.
A challenge to all unjustifiable hierarchies. A man knows how to fix some machine and the woman doesn’t? Clearly he’s justifiably higher in this respect. Should she then be allowed to rape and kill him? No, of course not. Neither should he.

>> No.17990443

>>17989943
Not the guy you were arguing with but
> I wouldn't say that an anarchist must necessarily be a 21st century sjw-type feminist together with all their claims.
And I imagine that they include your claim within 21st century feminism not to mention he never argued that a Man who knows what a women doesn't, is caused by some level of hierarchy.

As for >>17988684 most reddit anarchists are generally very "left" anarchists (I'm not a fan of rand or an-caps BTW) and more often than not an-comms or variations of such. So when arguing with them it comes naturally for them to assume that hierarchy is/was influenced by socialist views.

Though in all truthfulness if you're looking for an anarchist movement that pushes for a disenfranchisement of women you're not going to get very far most of the time, also if you want to liberate yourself from society then I suggest reading into either individualist anarchism (e.g Stirner etc).

Or alternatively taking the Ted pill and walking out to some woods somewhere, a /lit/ anon has already done it.

>> No.17990447

>>17990443
And by hierarchy I was referring to state/market not individual or intellectual

>> No.17990510

>>17989943
How do you abolish rape? I know exatcly how you can abolish capital relations all you need to do is say "this factory is now mine". It is the result of simple not respecting an established convention. You can abolsh marriage which is simply not respecting it as existing. What you can't do is abolish rape. Rape is rape, people can always force sex on people. You can abolish marital rape in the sense that rape can be "legitimate" through marriage,but that first requires having a concept of "legitimate" relations to begin with, and since we are abolishing things we are abolishing the concept of "legitimacy" to begin with.

>> No.17990515

>>17988738
He's the Unabomber

>> No.17990519

>>17988874
That's a shit definition try again

>> No.17990544

>>17989943
>Should she then be allowed to rape and kill him?
You currently aren't allowed to do that under "statist oppression"

>> No.17990546
File: 33 KB, 640x360, FFEAEF66-298C-4F2D-864B-8FCF33B74B06.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17990546

>>17990510

>> No.17990593

>>17990546
The implicit assumption is that if you abolish the state that would not also abolish rape. The state protects people from rape. Without the state you would need some other structure in place to protect people from rape. All this is fine if you want, but I would say that this means that while you can be an anarchist AND a feminist, you can also be a statist and a feminist so the idea that there is no anarchism without feminism is requiring them to be inseparable falls flat on its face because there obviously can be feminism without anarchism.

>> No.17990603

>>17989943
Intolerance of rape is intolerance of African culture, you bigot.

>> No.17990621

>>17990593
>The state protects people from rape
Ha! You’ve been blocked. We’re moving on with other business.

>> No.17990629

>>17990546
who the fuck are they?

>> No.17990649
File: 201 KB, 1194x1240, sticker.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17990649

saw this a while ago. notice anything missing?

>> No.17990667
File: 193 KB, 1174x1392, mechanicus.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17990667

>>17990443
>individualist anarchism (e.g Stirner etc).
so, ive heard about this, can you be an individualist anarchist and still have a job etc? because the thing is, i kinda just want to look out for myself and my position on the job etc, in society im more of an outcast i dont have any friends and i didnt go out too often even before covid.
anyways i knows there is mutualism, and that i can help other people if i have something to gain from it or if it pleases me.

>> No.17990678

>>17990629
I forgot his name, but that’s Ketchup on the right. They were at OWS and interviewed by Stephan Colbert

>> No.17990679

>>17990649
its just like >>17988770 said. holy fuck.

>> No.17990682

>>17988752
It's a mentally ill tranny, dont worry about it

>> No.17990691

>>17990649
>anything missing?
Anti-zionist

Notice it doesn’t say anti-white. We’re mostly white ourselves, so we’re pro-white, just not white supremacists

>> No.17990693

>>17990667
>>individualist anarchism (e.g Stirner etc
People really need to get on that william b greene bandwagon sheesh

>> No.17990699

>>17990691
Og zionism is based and socialist, that won't work

>> No.17990707

>>17990691
please for the love of allah define white supremacy so we can put an end to this madness

>> No.17990709

>>17990682
The animé says “all females have babies” though.

>>17990699
Og? Statist is what it is. Einstein wasn’t so thrilled with it and he was socialist

>> No.17990722
File: 8 KB, 231x218, F48F0F8C-29C9-4ED0-9202-849031E5018C.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17990722

>>17990707
Aw read a fuggin book already, can’tcha!?

>> No.17990737

>>17990693
humm whats he about? care to explain a bit?

>> No.17990739

>>17990691
I was thinking anti-state, but maybe it's implied.

>> No.17990747

>>17990709
Einstein was literally a zionist until he made a surprise pikachu face when it turned out Jews were just as capable of violence as anyone else.

>> No.17990757

>>17990722
Niggerish/faggoty clenched energy.
Pissypussywoman no like know she pissypussywoman

>> No.17990768

>>17990739
Okay, that’s right. Either a mistake or a weasely sticker

>>17990747
That’s what I said

>>17990757
Meds. Now.

>> No.17990771

>>17990709
Not originally

>> No.17990782

>>17990768
no you said he was anti-zionist. He was zionist. He just also thought Jews were literally incapable of being violent so he supported nationalism but only for Jews.

>> No.17990806

>>17990737
He was an individualist Mutualist from Boston ma, a member of the first interactional, and friends with Proudhon. He advocated mutual banking, and helped develop theories of credit and currency, particularly arguing for new systems that worked without gold, since it was viewed as a primitive form of currency. He petitioned the city of Boston to loosen corporate laws to allow prols to have an easier time starting their own corporation. Argued that anti-usury laws were necessary in the transition to statelessness. And was a Yankee Colonel in the US civil war. Also did calculus for fun, and was a very into the free love movement.

>> No.17990807

can we stay on topic?

>> No.17990824

>>17990807
It depends on what feminist means if you can be anarchists without it. Do you mean the suffragists? Or do you mean a like total girl boss? If the former, yes, that's required. If the latter, no fuck white liberal feminism

>> No.17990828

>>17990782
>no you said he was anti-zionist
Check it.

>> No.17990831

>>17990828
I did check it. That is how I know he believed Jews were incapable of being violent until that was proved retarded.

>> No.17990853

>>17990737
>>17990806
Get greene pilled
https://books.google.com/books/about/Socialistic_Communistic_Mutualistic_and.html?id=T6ARAAAAIAAJ

>> No.17990866

>>17990824
Why is it necessary for the state to allow women to vote in order to be an anarchist?

>> No.17990873

>>17990831
No dummy. Check what I actually said. “Einstein wasn’t so thrilled with it” geez Louise

>> No.17990885

>>17990873
Einstein WAS thrilled about Zionism and ONLY Jewish Nationalism, until he was proven retarded about his assumptions about Jews

>> No.17990886
File: 68 KB, 1914x252, ppl.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17990886

>>17990824
well i kinda can get behind the former, but what most people preach is the latter, which for me is just an excuse for whoredom, also women deeply irratate me, they always want to be the center of attentions and MOST of them dont bring anything to the table, there are intelligent women out there ofc there is, but the vocal ones are the dumb whores.

>> No.17990917
File: 31 KB, 750x682, lp1c6znzxgq61.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17990917

>> No.17990948

>>17990866
You don't need a state to hold elections or community votes

>> No.17990951

>>17990886
Idk you might just need to have a close friendship with a female to get it

>> No.17990957

>>17990948
Then why did you need to support giving women's suffrage when you could have just held the votes without the state?

>> No.17990966

>>17990886
>by not including these other oppresed perspectives
this implies the reason we listen to "anarchist" perspective is because they are "oppressed". The reality is that anarchism is not about "liberation" it is about the destruction of the state (and capitalism which only exists because of the state)

>> No.17990975
File: 161 KB, 620x450, C1001907-5391-4C27-BD00-58C426440607.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17990975

>>17990957
Because the masses didn’t join Emma Goldman at the time

>> No.17990989

>>17990951
well the closest was a friend that we use to be in call on discord, with other 2 males ofc. and she was just daddy's girl, as i said wants everyone attention, she is always right even when she is wrong, i think that this is what modern feminism does do women.
anyway, after this 2 year taste of friendship i got with some people i cant say for sure i want anything of the sort on the next 10 years.

>> No.17991009
File: 17 KB, 180x175, u.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17991009

what is your guys take on Illegalism?

>> No.17991011

>>17990989
Diversify your female experiences

>> No.17991055
File: 417 KB, 683x1024, C3841D8E-DD3D-4AA2-8457-1D5EEAEDD4EA.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17991055

>>17991009
That picture always reminds me of a Hannah-Barbara cartoon

Doesn’t that include shit like “the deed” assassinations? Abandoned a hundred years ago for good reason.
I’m getting interested in the Situationists

>> No.17991146
File: 82 KB, 512x384, hanna.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17991146

>>17991055
>Propaganda of the deed
>bandoned a hundred years ago for good reason.
you telling me that bombing and assassinating the ruling class isnt a good thing?
desu i believe that this is one of the good ways to get workers and opressed people to revolt, fucking meetings and fucking speeches are outdated..

>> No.17991166
File: 126 KB, 429x600, 8682DD83-C114-4741-8C3A-9107F87B9985.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17991166

>>17991146
That’s the mugs!
And yeah, no. That shit never worked. Ramping up the meetings among other things is whats needed though. Have you read Gelderloos

>> No.17991181

>>17991166
not at all, care to explain it a bit?

>> No.17991189

>>17991055
>misidentifying illegalism as propaganda-of-the-deed

This is almost as bad as when you tried to say the nation-state wasn't modern.

>> No.17991227

>>17991181
I haven’t read it yet. Apparently he makes a case for a stronger response. Which is going to be risky.

>>17991189
Oh brother. Just type to me like a human being for once
Kingdoms and empires are quite like modern states. Less porous obviously

>> No.17991237

>>17988684
Anarchy is anything goes. You can be racist, and an anarchist if you really want to be. Modern anarchism, sadly has been co-opted by marxists who try way too hard to make it communist when it doesn't have to be. Avoid anarcho-commies, and embrace anarchist individualism and post-leftism. Fuck communal herd mentality

>> No.17991248

>>17991227
i will not type to you like a human being because you are not one

>>17991237
>mfw pseuds think post-left anarchy and individualist-anarchy is when you're racist and an anarchist

post-left critique comes from inside the left, not outside of it

>> No.17991280

>>17990917
SavEd

>> No.17991289

>>17991248
>Pseuds think that anarchism is when you police moral, and you respect human beings
Post-leftism has nothing do with the left. That's why Bob Black calls cops on anarchists instead of defend them, you retard

>> No.17991386

>>17990966
humanism exists only due to capitalism. no public servants without bankers.

it's weird that atheists hate to hear this, too busy getting a hardon for their republic

>> No.17991393

>>17991009
Protonazism and a bastardization of the left.

>> No.17991400

>>17989943
>>17990546
>>17990621
>>17990691
>>17990722
>>17990768
>>17990828
>>17990873
>>17990975
>>17991055
>>17991166
>>17991227
You would be much happier if you settled down with a nice husband and learned how to cook.

>> No.17991426

>>17991393
How the fuck does it have anything to do with nazis

>> No.17991430

>>17991400
this but unironically

>> No.17991444

>>17991426
>Extreme nihilism
>Might makes right
>Manic looting
Illegalism ruins socialism

>> No.17991446

>>17991430
I wasn't being ironic. Butts is obviously unhappy and her mental state has declined over the years. Her posts are stupid but too ineffectual to get upset about, so I pity her instead.

>> No.17991463

>>17991400
>>17991446
Yes, even if she didn't use the trip she'd be recognizable because of her tendency to reply to multiple posters in a "sassy" or "witty" way, her nonsensical opinions born from misinterpreting books and a very bitter and unhealthy lifestyle, and her writing style in general. I don't think she's a tranny; there's nothing manly about her posts. She's clearly a woman.

>> No.17991475
File: 52 KB, 438x438, 1599942259678.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17991475

>>17988684
then become an anarchist and say fuck norms and fuck society

>> No.17991488

>>17991475
Well, most anarchists will say huummm you aint humm a true anarchist

>> No.17991530
File: 178 KB, 746x528, 1618041405864.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17991530

>>17991444


>>17991444
>ruins socialims
And i would i want to be part of a community of people that put anything progressive in higher places then the destruction of the system? Also if you dont follow every rule they say, you aint a true anarchist in thir eyes, fuck em.

>> No.17991563

>>17991530
You mean illegalists? Or me? Because illegalists are going to force their norms on you, violently. They ruined the international. It only leads to implosion and counter rev

>> No.17991569

>>17991444
>>17991530
Also those trips baybe

>> No.17991665

>>17991488
Oh well then you should give a fuck what some turd online says about it not being real anarchism. Fuck those fags, too

>> No.17991784

>>17988684
Intersectionality means you need to be antirascist, antisexist, antihomophobic, etc. all together. Read Kimberle Williams Crenshaw

>> No.17992160

>>17990649
oh no tranny bros we got too cocky

>> No.17992594

>>17988684
Im an anarchist but im also a feminist
to be honest, a weird type of feminism based on the principle of fighting against nature that in practice is pretty conservative

>> No.17992839

>>17991530
Sorry about the bad grammar, it was 4 fucking am, i was almost sleeping