/lit/ - Literature

File: 60 KB, 700x435, maincurrentsofmarxism.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Fri Feb 5 18:49:31 2021 No.17468676 [Reply] [Original]

are there any good intellectual biographies for Marx and/or Marxism? "Main Currents of Marxism" by Kolakowski looks decent but also seems to be very critical of marxism from what I've heard. Is there a better, perhaps less critical theoretical history of marxism or should I just bear it and grapple with the criticisms? mostly looking for something that lays out Marx's theoretical influences

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 18:53:45 2021 No.17468702 >>17468676 He's a failed philosopher with a categorically failed and destructive philosophy. There's very good reason for most secondary texts to be critical.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:02:19 2021 No.17468775 File: 14 KB, 333x499, The Political Economy of Marx.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>17468676 See this and also the two volumes of A History of Marxian Economics by the same authors

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:03:42 2021 No.17468781 >>17468702 >Just trust Plato when he says the Sophists were all just big dummies bro

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:06:02 2021 No.17468796 >>17468781 >>Just trust Plato when he says the Sophists were all just big dummies bro What did he mean by this?

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:07:34 2021 No.17468808 >>17468781 >defending literal sophism classic Marxist

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:07:40 2021 No.17468809 >>17468796 With this level of reading comprehension no wonder you think Marx was wrong

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:08:48 2021 No.17468816 >>17468808 I'm not you troglodyte, my very obvious point is that you shouldn't just read the critics of a movement to understand it. Again, anti-Marxists and illiteracy go hand in hand so I'm not surprised but c'mon now.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:11:35 2021 No.17468844 >>17468816 Don't care much for illiteracy, but Marxism and being a nigger faggot go more hand in hand

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:11:55 2021 No.17468850 >>17468775 thanks, will look into this

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:15:24 2021 No.17468876 >>17468809 I'm well aware of what you meant - Gorgias and all that. But you're coming across as someone who seethes at the sight of someone critiquing big daddy Marx.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:17:18 2021 No.17468891 >>17468676 Kołakowski is based. Read his later essays on religion as well.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:31:14 2021 No.17468999 Marxism by Sowell

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:35:03 2021 No.17469026 >>17468702 Imagine thinking you don't need to know your enemy

Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:36:09 2021 No.17469033

>>17468876
No but you don't read Kant before you read Hume, this is improper conduct and it will give you odd views on the writers you skipped over. I don't care about criticizing Marx, most Marxists don't, just don't come here and proudly say "Yeah that's right I read esoteric Neoplatonist tomes without having read a word of Plato".

Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:39:34 2021 No.17469062
File: 668 KB, 598x990, tranny_tube.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

>>17468676
lmao why are leftypol trannies so obvious?
>marxism is based the other internet trannies told me so I'm just looking to be told how good it is
fucking disgusting.
first of all you shouldn't read any book at all, you should fucking kill yourself.
second of all anyone with as much knowledge as kolakowski had of marxism is going to be critical of it.
there truly are no bigger subhumans than leftist trannies on the internet.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:44:19 2021 No.17469099 >>17469062 the only question remaining is when does hbomberguy become hbombergal?

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:46:00 2021 No.17469117 File: 23 KB, 852x480, 1 (13).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>17469062 >do we look like trannies to you

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 19:59:21 2021 No.17469211 >>17469062 i'm cis but ok, fucking freak lol

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:02:15 2021 No.17469231 File: 27 KB, 324x499, Berlin_MArx.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] This is what you're looking for.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:08:59 2021 No.17469282 >>17469099 I hope never. I hope his explorations into manhood (the onions thing, arguing with buff homo nazis, and his bald spot) have made him have a perverse sense of masculinity, but a sense of masculinity nonetheless.

Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:41:27 2021 No.17469467 [DELETED]

>>17468676
>are there any good intellectual biographies for Marx
MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICHMICHAEL HEINRICH MICHEL HEINRICH MICHAEL

Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:43:36 2021 No.17469474

>>17468676
>are there any good intellectual biographies for Marx
MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH MICHAEL HEINRICH

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:48:16 2021 No.17469499 >>17469282 I still think it'd be funny if all of breadtube went the path of ContraPoints and Philosophy Tube.

Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:50:44 2021 No.17469513

>>17468676
If you are looking for the history of thought leading up to Marx, I really don’t think the first volume of Main Currents has been surpassed. Kolakowski’s main criticism of Marx is that the political logic of his critique of capitalism entails the political practice of Stalinism. If you don’t think that’s true, or think even if it is Marx’s critical project could still be valid then it’s really not got much teeth.

Michael Heinrich’s biography only goes up until 1843, so it really focuses on Marx’s formative influences. If you want a more general biography then I’d go with the one by David McLellan.

McLellan also has a book called Marxism after Marx, and I think that’s one of the better ‘histories of Marxism’ and is far less critical than Main Currents.

The book mentioned by >>17468775 is excellent for what it is, but it exclusively is focused on the academic development of Marxian economics.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:51:17 2021 No.17469515 >>17469499 Which breadtuber will become a trannie, place your best

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:55:32 2021 No.17469542 >>17469515 Knowing Better probably won't, because Knowing better, uh... probably knows better... huehuehue

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:57:06 2021 No.17469549 Hal Draper, Marx’s Revolutionary Theory

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 20:57:27 2021 No.17469552 >>17469513 >Michael Heinrich’s biography only goes up until 1843 that is the first volume. he is still writing the rest.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 5 21:12:52 2021 No.17469623 >>17469513 thank you very much, super helpful info and recs

Advanced search
Text to find
Subject [?]Search by post subject. Leave empty for any.
Username [?]Search for user name. Leave empty for any user name.
Tripcode [?]Search for tripcode. Leave empty for any.
Email [?]Search by email. Leave empty for any.
Filename [?]Search by image filename. Leave empty for any.
From Date [?]Enter what date to start searching from. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
To Date [?]Enter what date to start searching until. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
Image hash
Search in	All Posts OPs Only
Deleted posts	Show all posts Show only deleted posts Only show non-deleted posts
Internal posts	Show all posts Show only internal posts Show only archived posts
Order	New posts first Old posts first
Capcode	All Posts Only by Users Only by Mods Only by Admins Only by Developers
Results	Posts Threads
Action	[ Simple ]