[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 3.46 MB, 2245x1164, athecucksbtfo.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16690442 No.16690442 [Reply] [Original]

Materialism utterly BTFO by Orthochad
https://youtu.be/NXLGcVCtT88

>> No.16690446

>>16690442
>2 hour video
Tl;Dr?

>> No.16690465

>>16690446
The whiteboard is the TLDR.
>The four figures are the unconditionally valid syllogistic forms of deductive arguments.
>In the middle is the key for what the letters represent.
>Therefore an example of AAA is:
-All animals are biological beings
-All dogs are animals
-Therefore all dogs are biological beings
>On the right is his argument using unconditionally valid syllogistic forms to logically disprove materialism

>> No.16690484

>>16690442
>conflates materialism and physicalism
we got too cocky orthobros

>> No.16690865

>>16690442
Why won't he debate southern israelite

>> No.16690894

A camera and a whiteboard, that's all you need to make an absolute moron out of yourself.

>> No.16690952

>>16690484
Is the same thing, both say that matter is primary.

>> No.16691176

>>16690894
Go ahead and refute him tranny

>> No.16691287

>>16690952
>have one thing in common
>”Is the same thing”

>> No.16691304
File: 2.07 MB, 3840x2160, image.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16691304

>>16690442
Just read David Bentley Hart. He's an Orthochad who does a much better job refuting materialism.

>> No.16691316

>>16691176
All things that exists are particulars
No universals are particulars
----------------------------------------------------
No universals exist

>> No.16691331

>>16691316
FUCKING KEK

>> No.16691395

>>16691316
holy based...

>> No.16691398

>>16691316
>All things that exists are particulars
nigga...

>> No.16691400

>>16690952
We're matter and (physical) energy, not just matter.

>> No.16691403

>>16691398
It's an argument using unconditionally valid syllogistic forms to logically disprove universals

>> No.16691408
File: 8 KB, 247x204, 1603521781221.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16691408

>>16691316
... bonito

>> No.16691432

>>16690442
take a shower bro

>> No.16691458

how do we keep winning theistbros?

>> No.16691508

>>16691458
its just too easy

>> No.16691511

>>16691458
>>16691508
Pretty sure Hume and Russell already BTFO you fags

>> No.16691561

>>16691511
>a fat hypocrite and a cuck
>BTFOing anyone
my sides

>> No.16691592

>>16691403
then would you say existence does not exist, or that existence is not a universal?

>> No.16691597

>>16691592
The syllogism is valid bro. If you don't like the assumptions that's just like your opinion man

>> No.16691812

>>16690442
>reasoning from false premises
Nice one, pseud.

>> No.16691817

>>16690484
Physicalist is just the contemporary form of materialism.

>> No.16691828

>>16691812
>false premises
Sure thing midwit

>> No.16691837

>>16691817
>Physicalist is just the coping form of materialism
ftfy

>> No.16691838

>>16690465
>>The four figures are the unconditionally valid syllogistic forms of deductive arguments
So, Orthochad has not read a single logic book written in the last 500 years?

>> No.16691988

>>16691838
>reading anything written in the last 500 years
ngmi

>> No.16692012

>>16691597
Syllogisms are for brain dead retarded children and religious intellectuals only.

>> No.16692031
File: 123 KB, 1000x1000, 1585412223163.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16692031

>trying to refute materialism with a brain made out of matter
nice try

>> No.16692087
File: 96 KB, 500x500, 1579896004344.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16692087

>>16692031
>refutes it with the immaterial intellect instead
...heh, nothing personal redditor

>> No.16692095

People shouldn't be using logical arguments in an empirical matter.

>> No.16692102

>>16692095
>an argument about the metaphysical nature of the intellect
>empirical
Philosophically illiterate

>> No.16692110

>>16691511
Orthobros love Hume though

>> No.16692125

He's wrong for acting as if materialism is something that can be refuted. Idealism or materialism isn't a conclusion one finds to reason, but it is something that is self-evident to the class of beings capable of intuiting Ideas and appears self-evident to to those incapable of doing so. Materialists are not a group that can be reasoned with, they are a caste of automatons trying to drag us into an abyss of nihilism.

>> No.16692139
File: 280 KB, 669x669, 1604142537009.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16692139

"Btfo" "Chad" "cucked".
Truth is even if materialism isn't wholly correct (which it isnt atleast in it's current conception) becoming master is truly what makes you a Chad and btfos cucks. Not having yourself orientated toward understanding the material is a full ride into loserdom and suckerhood.

>> No.16692266

>>16691316
>All things that exists are particulars
Retarded

>> No.16692901
File: 217 KB, 1064x1337, 1600778258094.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16692901

>>16690442
AAAEAEEAEAEEEIOAOOAIIEIOAEIOAEEEIOOAOOAOIAIAEEAIIIAI

>> No.16693108

>>16692901
kek

>> No.16693266

>>16691403
simple analytic proposition, nothing to write home about

>> No.16693297 [SPOILER] 
File: 151 KB, 907x1360, 1604189877339.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16693297

>>16691988
ahem...

>> No.16693317

>>16691304
>Hart is a convert from high-church Anglicanism to Eastern Orthodoxy. Politically, he identifies as a Christian socialist as well as a democratic socialist
DROPPED