[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 7 KB, 205x246, 91231310.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15939749 No.15939749 [Reply] [Original]

>reading translated poetry
you don't do this /lit/, right?

>> No.15939764

>I don’t have to translate poetry written in my own language

>> No.15939824
File: 36 KB, 960x574, 1595521637645.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15939824

>>15939749
I read the translations of poems originally written in my mother tongue so I can harshly criticize the translator's choices

>> No.15939906

>sir gawayn and the green knight translated to modern english but translator ensured it still fit the original meter
I don't know how to feel, but it was the only copy at the store

>> No.15939930

>>15939906
It's alright, lad. Narrative poetry can still be enjoyed in translation.

>> No.15940123
File: 59 KB, 1200x675, gai1553953399397.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15940123

>>15939749
>not reading it in the language you're studying so that you get a fuller grasp on what's being said
NGMI fag

>> No.15940144

>>15939824
Basado. I remember reading Rimbaud's in an English translation for smug entertainment

>> No.15940157

>>15939749
do the poems in don quijote count?

>> No.15940221

In fact you should read poetry translated even if you are proficient enough in the original language to read the prose in it. When the meaning is more or less exact, then you can grasp it clearly even if a bit slower, and losing the momentary impression is not that important. But if you will read something designed to operate fully with your senses and feelings, then getting slowed down and being forced to think on words and expressions meaning will significantly harm your experience. Of course the translator may lose or alter some details, but you may lose them even while reading the original.

>> No.15940222

>>15939749
>reading poetry
what are you, a faggot?

>> No.15940347

>>15939749
What else can I do ??????

>> No.15940805

>>15940347
learn every single language you want to read poetry in to fluency

>> No.15941139

>>15940805
Can’t be that hard!

>> No.15941181

>>15939749
KEK I do, but I tend to use bilingual editions, anon. So I end up can go to heav'n when I die.

>> No.15941237

>>15939824
Going to a special place in hell.
>>15939930
>>15940123
>>15940144
>>15940221
>>15940222
>>15940347
Hell

>>15940805
Blessed

>>15941181
Heretic