[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 645 KB, 1909x2560, 91QZyhtsWVL.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15358120 No.15358120 [Reply] [Original]

Which is a better primary source to learn about the beliefs of the nazis, Goebbels Diaries or Mein Kampf?

>> No.15358187
File: 62 KB, 680x680, youremakingmenervous.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15358187

>>15358120

>> No.15358725

>>15358120
Beliefs? Mein Kampf. If you want to know how it actually played out? The Goebbels Diaries. He's the primary source for NSDAP history.

>> No.15358975

>>15358725
Wasn't MK garbage ranting? Or is that just AJP Taylor lies

>> No.15359363
File: 418 KB, 768x1043, derangriff-1933-01-30-7-180604100643-thumbnail-4.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15359363

>>15358120

Nazi Party newspapers like Der Angriff and Völkischer Beobachter (don't bother with Der Stürmer though because that's a meme paper that was basically software pornography and had extremely low readership compared to other newspapers). They're your best source for what your "Man on the Street" Nazi was saying and thinking.

>> No.15359405

>>15358975
It's a bit rant like, but not too bad. It follows Nazi policy to a T since it was written by the man who implemented it. Shit like Myth of the 20th Century is a meme, Hitler never read it and Goebbels thought it was garbage.

>> No.15359935
File: 1.50 MB, 737x1346, W-Wowie!.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15359935

>>15358120
>Which is a better primary source to learn about the beliefs of the nazis

>>>/pol/

>> No.15359945

>>15359935
/pol/ is literally the worst place to learn nazi history. I was a /pol/ tard before reading a lot about the nazis and realized everything /pol/ told me was a lie.

>> No.15359977

>>15359945
for example?

>> No.15360149

>>15359945
wowie another born again convert

>> No.15360436
File: 26 KB, 308x308, scoobydoobydoo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15360436

>>15359945
>he got vaccinated

>> No.15360450

Neither. Rosenberg's writings are far more interesting from an intellectual point-of-view, and generally better written.

>> No.15360469

If you really want to learn about this subject you shouldn't be confining yourself to one primary source that's "better" than the others. Just read both.

>> No.15360544

>>15358120
Fascism: A Reader, edited by Roger Griffin

>> No.15360547

>>15360450

sorry nobody trusts jews

>> No.15360574

>>15360469
This.
>>15360450
Rosenberg's writings were only taken seriously by a tiny portion of the party, Hitler never read any of it or barely any of it at all. It's not a very good way to understand the normal beliefs and ideas of most of the party.

>> No.15360585

>>15358120
Read scholarly articles by George Mosse and Emilio Gentile. They're historians but base their work closely on primary sources, unlike Marxist historians, whose analyses of fascism are usually conjecture

>> No.15360693

>>15360547

>Rosenberg
>Jew

wrong

>> No.15360757

Arendt's Origins of Totalitarianism is a must

>> No.15360785

I don't know why more people don't talk about Hitler's Table Talk, it's an insane book

>> No.15360904

>>15360785
>insane
Why?
The book is considered by some to be a forgery, otherwise yeah, it has interesting quotes.

>> No.15361184
File: 35 KB, 559x556, haha fag.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15361184

>>15359945
what a fag

>> No.15361209

>>15359945
>/pol/ is one person

>> No.15361225

>>15359945
>he thought we were serious

kek

>> No.15361384
File: 24 KB, 361x408, A7FAC173-5035-49E6-9DD3-B8C70F8ECB95.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15361384

>>15358120
>The private and secret dairies of Hitlers’s partner in crime...a shocking revelation of evil. “Unique and sinister”

Imagine wiping the world so hard that you continue to live rent free in the worlds conscience

>> No.15362389

>>15361384
>he says as he obsesses about fictional Jewish conspiracies

>> No.15362606

>>15359405
it's garbage though

>> No.15362617
File: 34 KB, 324x505, 1587979011429.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15362617

>>15359363
>n-nobody read Der Stürmer

holy fuck you apologists are shameless

>> No.15362625

>>15361225
>merely pretending!!!

go back, this is not a pol board

>> No.15362630

>>15362617
soiboys hate nazis

>> No.15362645

>>15362630
whatever helps you cope

>> No.15362661

>>15362645
seethe

>> No.15362678

>>15362661
nazis lost bro

>> No.15362693

>wanting to learn about nazis beliefs
>reading their propaganda

>> No.15362714

>>15358120
Read Franz Neumann’s Behemoth. This book was used by the allies to defeat Nazi Germany.

>> No.15362723
File: 749 KB, 2560x1721, mk.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15362723

>>15358120
The critical edition of Mein Kampf, the absolute standard in Nazi/Hitler studies.
Doubles as a filter for pseuds dismissing quality scholarly work because it's German, and it gives monolingual Anglos anxiety. It's actually a threefer.

>> No.15362734

>>15362678
i'm muslim

>> No.15362769

>>15362734
lol

>> No.15363172

Just finished up Night by Elie Wiesel.
Does /lit/ have any other recommendations for WW2 fiction for me?

>> No.15363223

>>15358120
In his diaries he says he wants all Juice to be sent to Madagascar after the war.

>> No.15363239

>>15363223
He goes on to say they have to leave Europe or Europe will never know peace

>> No.15363249

>>15362389
>Israel doesn't exist

>> No.15363266

>>15363239
How could he read the writing so early on...

Was he really an avatar bros?

>> No.15364933

bump

>> No.15364997

>>15358120
Table Talk and Hitler Speaks

>> No.15365039

>>15358975
>not reading it yourself
>taking someone else's judgement
>>15359935
>I am a dilating tranny marxist
>implying anyone on /pol/ is a genuine nazi
>>15360469
true
>>15360544
cringe
>>15360757
>a jew's book is a MUST
ok reddit
>>15362389
>fictional
ok retard
>>15362606
ok jew
>>15363266
implying that's early

>> No.15365091
File: 101 KB, 785x731, k0IGUXx.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15365091

>>15365039
lmao engage coitus

>> No.15365117
File: 42 KB, 590x447, E9FBF190-A633-4290-983B-DD60AB9A4BB5.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15365117

>>15359945
Embarrassing

>> No.15365275

>>15363172
Go back to pool stormfag

>> No.15365592

I like Goebbels. He seemed like a decent guy minus killing his daughters

>> No.15366172
File: 76 KB, 1200x630, Goebbels Lenin Quote.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15366172

>>15365592
Goebbels was the only non-cringe Nazi. His life was a great tragedy, he found meaning in the NSDAP, and ended up holding the entire thing together after Hitler bitched out in 1942. It ended up killing him and his family in the end.

>> No.15366882

>>15358975
MK is written like an older family member telling you a longwinded story that's kind of interesting but boring

>> No.15366963
File: 6 KB, 220x229, NPCangry.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15366963

>>15365091
have sex nazi incel

>> No.15367068

>>15366172
This. Goebbels is among my favorite historical figures
OP, read both multiple times in multiple translations

>> No.15369009
File: 57 KB, 968x681, 36-goebbels-afp.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15369009

>>15367068
Goebbels is kind of cute bros

>> No.15369026

>>15369009
He looks like a goblin

>> No.15369060
File: 351 KB, 700x767, pools-closed1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15369060

>>15365275
pool's closed

>> No.15369072

>>15369026
yeah he's cute like a hairless cat

>> No.15369073

>>15365592
I don't really like him (it's kind of difficult to actually look past the harm his actions caused) but he's definitely the most interesting Nazi. Someone like him following the path he did is a good reason to not just treat Nazi Germany as some cartoon villain land where evil but stupid people seized power by force, which is a worrying trend in popular perception.

>> No.15369078
File: 10 KB, 225x225, download.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15369078

>>15369073
drink bleach

>> No.15369095

>>15369078
That's much more of a Hitler response than Goebbels response, anon.

>> No.15369101

>>15369073
I don't really see why everyone sees him as such a supremely evil figure. He had a shit childhood and just wanted to be accepted. You can even argue that the murder of his children was justified.

>> No.15369108

>>15369101
He killed his wife and children going out like a dog

>> No.15369119

>>15369101
He was the Nazi minister for propaganda, those words alone are enough for 90% of people.

>> No.15369124

>>15366172
Redpill me on goebbels

>> No.15369126

>>15369108
It's better than going out in Nuremberg or Jerusalem

>> No.15369131

>>15369124
like every Nazi, he was a repressed homosexual

>> No.15369153

>>15369126
human garbage

>> No.15369156

>>15369124
He was a depressed guy who had a bad childhood and found belonging in the Nazi movement. He was very interested in art and used his position as minister of propaganda to create.

>> No.15369182

>>15369009
>>15369026
>>15369009
Why does everyone (minus Hitler) give off this feeling they´re on edge? Magda in particular seems to think: "Oh, shoot! they´re taking a photo of us, gotta act relaxed!" The kids seem to handle it quite well, aside from being a liitle take aback as kids tendd to be in public. But Goebbels, he seems to project anxiety. I guess it is the crooked smile and the way he cocks his head a little It´s just a publicity photo op, why be so anxious?Hitler, meanwhile, is totally relaxed, as you might expect from an excellent public speaker.

>> No.15369183

>>15369156
to create bullshit

>> No.15369194

>>15369183
we get it you're jewish

can you fuck off this thread if you have nothing to contribute other than seething?

>> No.15369201

>>15358120
Recently watched a conference by Johann Chapoutot, a French scholar on Nazi ideology, and he said Hitler isn't really the best source for understanding Nazi beliefs, because he was the face of the movement and its supreme leader but not its brain (at least not its main theorician). It's not really well-known but there was an entire class of diligent upper bureaucrat who spent their days arguing and counter-arguing and writing and planning about what is nazism and how it should be implemented. It's probably better to read the most proeminent among those than to read either Hitler or Goebbels.

You can start with Reinhart Höhn and Carl Schmidtt (later was a bit of an uneasy fit within the NSDAP and never become as central as the former, but he was his mentor and is also tremendously interesting and influent in his own right).

It's also worth noting that Höhn, like several high-ranking nazi law experts, ended being a foundational figure of German postwar corporate managment. There is a clear filiation between contemporary "agile" managment and nazi theory of organization.

>> No.15369202

Inside the third Reich by Speer was really good too.

It's a bit heavy on the hayday of Hitler's reign, which basically nothing seems to happen except dinner parties and listening to Hitler charm everybody he meets.

But it eventually does get into the dark times, and Speer coming to realize how despicable Hitler is, and the flaws inherit of the entire Nazi system.

>> No.15369205

>>15369182
Goebbels was a deeply anxious man. I'm not sure about Magda.

>> No.15369209

>>15369194
nazis lost dude

>> No.15369215
File: 150 KB, 1024x634, brandenburg-gate-1945.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15369215

>>15369201
some brain

>> No.15369226

>>15369215
I'm surprised they left the gate standing. That'd be the first thing I'd think they'd destroy as symbolism

>> No.15369237

>>15369226
They tried, I think. I know the gate took many direct hits from artillery and tanks.

They were using it as a landing beacon, and planes would land on the main road there, up until the very last minute, and the soviets weren't very happy about that.

>> No.15369238

>>15369182
Maybe Goebbels was a speg? His wife would be intimidated, that's natural since she's in the presence of the Führer.

>> No.15369249

>>15369209
so what?

>> No.15369253

>>15369237
It basically was destroyed, all that was left was a smoking hulk, almost all the stonework and decoration on it was destroyed.

All that was left was just the basic structure, it had to be totally rebuilt.

>> No.15369256

>>15369249
think about it

>> No.15369262

>>15369209
meh, there's always next season.

>> No.15369271

>>15369262
yeah CCP should be crumbling soon

>> No.15369296

>>15369253
Now they have that disgusting modern art kike memorial right by it when it was a beautiful complex before Berlin was ravaged.

>> No.15369319

>>15369256
whats there to think about?

>> No.15369350

>>15369319
I know that's hard for you folk

>> No.15369362

>>15369319
he is just a seething autistic jew

you can find him on /tv/ /his and /lit/

just ignore him

>> No.15369497

>>15369362
I'm not jewish but whatever helps you cope.

>> No.15369647
File: 27 KB, 494x378, 1568435759012.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15369647

>>15369182
goebbels was worried about having to fight off hitler's advances

>> No.15370042

>>15369497
>>15369647
there he is

>> No.15370617
File: 10 KB, 216x234, images.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15370617

>>15370042

>> No.15370716

>>15370617
Nazis are based, MIGA is for faggots

>> No.15370732
File: 85 KB, 291x344, 1496363588592.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15370732

>Nazis are based

>> No.15370796

>>15358975
Imagine being so lazy stupid and cowardous to read one of the most important books in world history. Youre the kind that rants against Mein Kampf and muh nazis and has studied nothing of the period. Fucking retard

>> No.15370969

I was reading a collection of Hitler's speeches recently and it was great. He was criticizing the unsustainability of the capitalist world economy based on mass production for infinite "markets" that don't really exist, and other perfectly sensible things.

>> No.15371081
File: 77 KB, 620x413, PepeChan.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15371081

>>15359935
>>reddit

>> No.15371090
File: 6 KB, 210x240, soyboy.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15371090

>>15362625
>go back, this is not a pol board

>> No.15371335

>>15370969
That's a very good primary source. I hadn't thought of that

>> No.15371428

>>15370617
>>15370732
Oh no! He put a red hat on an already forced meme!

>> No.15372020

>>15369647
Hitler and Magda were almost a thing for a while

>> No.15372163

>>15369201
Schmitt was forced out by the SS in 1936, and belongs more to the Conservative Revolutionary camp than the National Socialist camp. Schmitt was only an opportunist, not a real nazi, his ideas didn't influence the nazis much.

>> No.15372260
File: 13 KB, 334x432, goeb.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15372260

>>15369124
To me, Goebbels is interesting for a variety of reasons. First, he was not a product of the First World War/military like most head nazis. He was a product of the 20's. Secondly, he was very pro-Soviet Union until Hitler shut down the 'left' camp of the party. Third, he was a very dramatic man, both in life and in death. Fourth, he's probably the best public speaker since the advent of film and sound recording, and I think he even beats Hitler in that respect. His Total War speech is probably the greatest speech ever given. He was a brilliant and tragic figure. After 1942, Hitler stopped nearly all public appearances and Goebbels picked up the slack of the lead figure. The biography by Peter Longerich is pretty good.

>> No.15372271

>>15358120
Read Albert Speer's memories.

>> No.15374144

>>15372271
speer was a coward

>> No.15375222

>>15371428
lol cope

>> No.15375225

>>15374144
like any good Nazi

>>15372260
You sound like a cock

>> No.15376069

>>15375225
Zzz

>> No.15376105

>>15372260
Wish we could have seen more of him.

>> No.15376156

>>15359945
> falling for /pol/'s history memes

>> No.15377739

>>15359363
>basically softcore pornography
unironically more family friendly than what you see on american television.

>> No.15377816

>>15377739
OK incel

>> No.15378059

>>15372260
If “his side” hadn’t lost he would have unironically been revered by many for his talents alone and taught in unis as the greatest 20th century orator.

>> No.15378212

>>15378059
nah he was a sniveling pig, there's a reason "his side" lost

>> No.15378517

>>15369202
>>15372271
Take everything Speer said after the war with a grain of salt. He tried to downplay the Nazi leadership and undermine his own role in the war and the holocaust. There is a recent biography of Speer by Magnus Brechtken, which analyses everything Speer invented or wrote after the war together with historical documents from the actual war.

>> No.15378878
File: 33 KB, 463x489, soyjak1.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
15378878

>>15375225
>You sound like a cock

>> No.15378884

>>15378212
Because they were up against vastly greater numbers. The k/d ratio on the Eastern Front was absurd

>> No.15378964

>>15378059
Unfortunately, Shitler ensured that they would lose through his retarded foreign policy. Sadly, Goebbels was too loyal to him, even to the end.

>> No.15379027

>>15359945
Hey Rabbi

>> No.15379097

>>15379027
>someone disagrees with me therefore they're Jewish
>>>/pol/

>> No.15379375

>>15379097
It's obviously a joke. Unlike the Liberans who believe that people who disagree with them are bots

>> No.15380540

>>15378884
whatever helps you copes

>> No.15380561

>>15366172
>the only non-cringe Nazi
Herman Goring seemed like a right lad

>> No.15381410

>>15380561
Goering is hilarious, big nigga just used everything to enrich himself.