[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 70 KB, 655x487, Kn.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11647890 No.11647890 [Reply] [Original]

>But I think I am right. Has a single good author ever owned a dog? Hamsun didn’t have a dog. Tor Ulven didn’t have a dog. Did Duras have one? I find that hard to imagine. Ibsen, did he have a dog? No. Faulkner? I believe he did. In that case, perhaps his position in the literary canon ought to be reconsidered? Virginia Woolf also had dogs, but only so-called lapdogs, which are too small and pet-like to cause fear in anyone, so they don’t count.

Does /lit/ agree? Can you own a dog and write great literary prose?

https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/the-trouble-with-dogs-for-a-writer

>> No.11647900

Didn't DFW have a dog?
>inb4 he doesn't count because he's a hack

>> No.11647906

Gene Wolfe loves dogs.

>> No.11647907

>>11647890
If the claims in that quote are true, then yes. Woolf and Faulkner are great writers.
What a retarded thread

>> No.11647941

>>11647890
I can't tell if that article is sincere or ironic, and I'm too lazy to read it. Anyone care to elucidate?

>> No.11647947

>>11647941
Your mother elucidated her breasts to me last night.

>> No.11647969
File: 225 KB, 769x856, cats.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11647969

>>11647890

>> No.11647978

>>11647890
I thought this was going to be more about the dog's overbearing demands on a writer's time and attention, which I agree with. But this stuff about aggression and submission is so beta it's hard to read.

>> No.11647988

>>11647947
WHAT the-

>> No.11647993

>>11647969
Lovecraft was a patrician.

>> No.11647996

>>11647907
>What a retarded thread

Indeed. Why would we discuss a book excerpt featured in the New Yorker by Karl Ove Knausgaard? Especially considering the piece deals with literature and writing.

Where do you people think you are? I'm here for the jezebels and london frog posts.

>> No.11647999

>>11647890
Hurr good authors don't have dogs oh wait half the authors i listed had dogs but they don't count because reasons

good quote

>> No.11648006

>>11647996
Didn't mean this thread. The article is retarded and so is Knausgård

>> No.11648011

>>11647996
lol same here. I'm here to redpill on the inferiority on women and to give encouraging words to London frog who posts really funny things unrelated to literature. Who cares? We're a collection of robots who just enjoy our online friendship. Fuck literature fascists

>> No.11648013

>>11647907
And Duras is

>> No.11648017

>>11647978
Never trust a man who dislikes dogs.
I have never been proven wrong in this code. Although I like dogs like this and so will never be a good writer:
https://youtu.be/cGoGJ3vsKqs

>> No.11648037

>>11647890
Tolstoy, Steinbeck, Cheever, Orwell, Hemingway, Fleming, Wodehouse, Vonnegut, London owned dogs.

>> No.11648050

>>11648037
>Has a single good author ever owned a dog?

None of those you listed are good.

>> No.11648058

>>11648050
Why do you even bother having opinions if that's what you're going to do with them?

>> No.11648068
File: 36 KB, 320x400, twain.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648068

>>11647890
In order to be a true patrician writer you must own and prefer cats. We all know this.

>> No.11648073

>>11648050
The sad thing is that you're probably not trolling and you truly believe this.

>> No.11648082

Boatswain - Byron’s Dog

>> No.11648095
File: 1.93 MB, 235x240, yes.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648095

>>11648011

>> No.11648117

>>11647890
Salinger owned dogs

>> No.11648121

>>11647890
>Duras
lel

>> No.11648122

Everything I've read about or from Knausgard has reeked of middlebrow and this thing is no exception.

>> No.11648129
File: 106 KB, 960x792, f029aed7-8c19-4c1a-8bf0-5220d4462e29.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648129

"My relationships with my cats has saved me from a deadly, pervasive ignorance"

>> No.11648141
File: 176 KB, 333x507, white-on-dogs.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648141

>Blocks your path.

>> No.11648143

>>11647941
It's a John Green quote

>> No.11648147
File: 21 KB, 361x450, Gramsci.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648147

Gramsci had a German Shepard

>> No.11648148
File: 152 KB, 1200x800, quiet now.jpg!d.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648148

>>11647890
Cats are for fags and women.
Lapdogs are for fags and women.
Dogs are for men.

>> No.11648149
File: 98 KB, 1280x421, wolfe.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648149

>>11647906
Yeah no shit

>> No.11648160

>>11648148
Yeah, you have to be physically active yourself in order to give them a good run. Not for people who like to sit around and read books all day.

>> No.11648168

Joyce and Mishima involve dogs in their work

>> No.11648172

>>11647890
theres always the type that either
>thinks cats are respectable and dogs are just sheep, willing to wag its tail for anyone
or
>thinks dogs are admirable, loving and fun and cats are cunts
or maybe theres a middle ground. i dont know, but i like dogs. cats are annoying as fuck to have around. i want a pet to play or hunt with, not a pet that needs my attention. i already have a girlfriend for that
>insert joke about getting pussy

>> No.11648180

>>11648148
Cats are awesome for the barn.
But yeah, I don't see the relationship with cats. And I hate this fear for working/guard dogs coming from late liberalism.

>> No.11648197

>>11648160
>not living the /fitlit/ lifestyle
get on it man, work your body and your mind

>> No.11648201

I buried my dog with the intro from this:
https://web.archive.org/web/20080315035332/http://www.prospect-magazine.co.uk/article_details.php?id=7738
His parable of the abused dog is also amazing.

>> No.11648204
File: 191 KB, 750x998, brother, would you spare me some oats.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648204

>>11647890
>https://www.newyorker.com

>> No.11648209

>>11648204
Beautiful.

>> No.11648228

>>11648204
THIS WOULD NEVER HAPPEN IF WE STILL HAD CATHOLIC BASED FEUDALISM IMPOSED
I WILL BE ABLE TO WOO A VIRGINAL QT WHO WORE DRESSES THAT WERE THE APOGEE OF FEMININE AESTHETICS, WITH HER LONG, UNCUT HAIR DESCENDING TO A CHASTE WAIST
BUT NOPE
YOU FUCKERS WANTED A GODDAMN IPAD AND PIZZA HUT ON EVERY DILAPIDATED INNER-CITY STREET INSTEAD. LMAO DUDE TECHNOLOGY AND LIBERTY AKA UNBRIDLED DECADENCE
FUCK MODERNITY

>> No.11648236
File: 391 KB, 1024x1002, modernart.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648236

>>11648204
>googles images of Laura Aguilar

Wow. Those photos.

>> No.11648238
File: 55 KB, 612x594, comfy celine.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648238

Céline is ten times the author that navel gazing neurotic will ever be and had dogs, cats and birds.

>> No.11648243

>>11648238
I hate those "animals are more noble than people" people

>> No.11648249
File: 59 KB, 685x398, celine bird.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648249

>>11648243
Why do you think it's necessarily about nobility?

>> No.11648264

>>11648228
yikes

>> No.11648266

>>11648249
Like respect. He doesn't like people because they can have different opinions and treat other people rudely at times but thats a pretty shallow way to look at people.

>> No.11648269

>>11648238
he was also a fucking nazi

>> No.11648276

>>11648266
I think it's hard to go through two world wars with a positive opinion of humanity desu.

>> No.11648290

>>11648269
People of character often are since the alternatives are so lowly.

>> No.11648316

>>11648050
Two great bitches and their dawgs:
Emily Dickinson, Carlo
Emily Bronte, Keeper
Samuel Johnson also had a famous dog, Boswell, and a favorite neighborhood cat (of which see either the epigraph of Pale Fire or The Life of Samuel Johnson) Hodge.
>This reminds me of the ludicrous account he gave Mr. Langton of the despicable state of a young gentleman of good family. 'Sir, when I heard about him last he was running about town shooting cats.' And then in a sort of kindly reverie, he bethought himself of his own favorite cat, and said, 'But Hodge shan't be shot: no, no, Hodge shall not be shot.'
-James Boswell, The Life of Samuel Johnson

>> No.11648321

>>11648228
>>11648264
Lol, Americans amirite

>> No.11648344

>>11648236
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

>> No.11648402

Fuck me, I just adopted a rescue dog two weeks ago and I haven't been able to write a word because I've been so busy with him. This article confirms what I thought.

Would I look like a terrible person if I took him back to the shelter and exchanged him for a cat? He's already attached to me so I'd rather do it now before he's too comfortable.

>> No.11648441

>>11648148
>tfw pibull owners are both delusional and in need to affirm their masculinity by buying a dog

>> No.11648454

>>11648402
Do you not consider these things before you decide to do something like that? The dog is your responsibility now, own up to it. Fucking faggot

>> No.11648461

So, basically, betas love cats and alphas love dogs and cats.

You have to be a strong, masculine character to have a dog respect you as the leader.

>> No.11648484

>>11648461
not true

my dog respects me as the leader and i'm a shy and really timid girl

>> No.11648504

>>11648484
Male dog? May be because he sees you as something to protect. Best be careful if that s the case.
Dogs always bond better with the opposite sex.

>> No.11648540

>>11648484
>girl

h-hey, I hope everyone here is treating you well.

>> No.11648568

>>11648402
Watch these videos, please.
https://youtu.be/alo0iAbV2TA
https://youtu.be/qdB48hnjT8w
Take the time in the first few weeks to train him right and you will get on fine. You can use a crate, it's actually beneficial. And rather than long walks any sort of training that works their brain will tire them out even more.
You should be able to write nearly the same amount once he is established. Don't take him back.

>> No.11648572

I miss you Chloe. You were the best of girls. I loved you more than any other living thing on this planet. You were my best friend when the world had abandoned me. Good dog.

>> No.11648586

>>11648402
>>11648568

This is an excellent post. You'll be just as distracted by the cat in the first few weeks as well. You'll have plenty of time to write once everyone becomes accustomed to their routine.

Do you know what breed of dog he is?

>> No.11648587

>>11648011
Boards were never meant to be dedicated to one specific topic, they were originally meant as a gathering place for people sharing a specific interest.

>> No.11648600

I dislike dogs, cats, and the very concept of pets.

I vastly prefer plants, which are silent rather than a constantly whining nuisance, and also prettier than the ugly little beasts.

>> No.11648612

>>11648402
>>11648454
>>11648568
>>11648586

I can't believe this piece of shit is going to take a dog back to the shelter because of what Karl Ove Knausgaard wrote.

You'll never be a good writer, with or without the dog. Man up and take care of your obligations.

>> No.11648617

>>11648402
You made the decision, you little turd, now take responsibility.

>> No.11648627

>>11648600
You remind me of my roommates best friend. He was a homosexual as well.

>> No.11648673

>>11648572
If you like rap you should listen to Esoteric's "Saving Seamus Ryan". It's a concept album about going through hard times with his dog.

>> No.11648679

>>11648627
Impressive levels of insecurity.

>> No.11648729

>>11648600
>>11648679
>very concept of pets
>vastly prefer plants
>constantly whining nuisance
>ugly little beasts
>Impressive levels of insecurity

Do you actually write like this or are you playing some type of character?

>> No.11648736

>>11648729
>are you playing some type of character?

It's a character that sucks "impressive levels of cock".

>> No.11648744

>>11648729
Yes.

>> No.11648755

Is this guy really afraid of golden retrievers? the fuck is wrong with yuropoors.

>> No.11648975
File: 40 KB, 534x356, hc.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11648975

>>11647890
He reviewed Houellebecq, the greatest living author, even though he was scared to read him because of his greatness. And Houellebecq is the ultimate dog lover.

>He famously claims to be indifferent to the honours and attention he attracts. As we chat on the steps, a BBC film crew buzzes around us. Houellebecq waves them away with his fag smoke and we start to talk about dogs, in particular, his faithful pet, a Pembroke corgi called Clement, who has been left behind in the author's home near Dublin.
>'This is one of the difficulties of fame and travelling,' says Houellebecq. 'It is always hard to abandon him.' Houellebecq reminds me that this is the same breed as the Queen's dogs ('I am more English than the English', he jokes lamely). Then, for a brief moment, he looks genuinely near to tears, raising his doe eyes heavenward. 'The love of a dog is a pure thing,' he says. 'He gives you a trust which is total. You must not betray it.'

>> No.11648995

Joyce was attacked by a dog as a kid and remained afraid of them for the rest of his life.
Also thunderstorms.

>> No.11649394

I don't like dogs but this essay confirms Knausgaard's hack status. I mean, he's implying Duras is a good author, Virginia Woolf too.

lmao

>> No.11649402

>>11648975
>Houellebecq, the greatest living author
lmao

>> No.11649421

>>11648236
perfect unity

>> No.11649437
File: 25 KB, 420x278, d.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11649437

>>11647890
The hack is immunised against all dangers: one may call him a scoundrel, parasite, swindler, profiteer, it all runs off him like water off a raincoat. But bark at him and you will be astonished at how he recoils, how injured he is, how he suddenly shrinks back: “I’ve been found out!.”

>> No.11649522

>>11648402
Subhuman

>> No.11649547

>>11647890
>submissive faggot mistreating a dog because he can't assert himself

Thanks for the warning, OP, I won't read his books now.

>> No.11649563

>>11648975
So there is some truth in the article

>> No.11649589

Thomas Mann. What a dumb thing to say.

>> No.11649611

>>11649589
MUH POLISH SHOTA

>> No.11649623

>>11647993
"Niggardly"

>> No.11649787

>>11647890
I don't understand the popularity of Knausgaard. Are his books really that great or worth reading?

>> No.11649898

>>11648402
Give that dog to someone responsible. He deserves better.

>> No.11650118

>>11649437
very nice

>> No.11650457

>>11649611
>MUH MEMES
Why not actually bother reading the authors memed here so we can at least have a coherent discussion?

>> No.11650598

>>11649787
I've read My Struggle books 1 and 2. Gonna start 3 after I finish my current read.

I think book 1 is the heaviest, most depressing book I've ever read. But they're both real, mundane and beautiful. Give it a shot. Also read Winter and really liked it.

>> No.11650638

I think that might be the dumbest thing I've read all year.

For fuck's sake, I hate how writers love holding contrarian beliefs just for the hell of it.

>> No.11650771

>>11650638
make sense that some smarmy apartment dweller limousine liberal rag like the new yorker is run by cat people though

>> No.11650901

kek all these dogfags getting butthurt over funny article... not high iq enough to have a sense of humour :(

>> No.11652043

>>11649787
It's just slightly elevated moeshit.

>> No.11652063

>>11648236
>>11648204
>died of diabetes

>> No.11652111

>>11648204
That filename

>> No.11652148

>>11648122
I read the first chapter of the first book of My Struggle and I never got that impression. This article does seem pretty midcult though

>> No.11652167
File: 3.44 MB, 1818x1228, 0179876_0179876-R3-043-20.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11652167

This is retarded

Anyway, my dog is a fount of literary inspiration

>> No.11652190

>>11647993
That isn't Lovecraft

>> No.11652198

>>11647890
Umm, Schopenhauer...

>> No.11652242

>>11647890
Steinbeck

nuff said.

>> No.11652274

>>11648149
kek

>> No.11652275

>>11648228
calm down virgin

>> No.11652324
File: 20 KB, 366x274, ooo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11652324

>>11648238
they were trained to literally eat jews

>> No.11652336
File: 14 KB, 220x264, byron.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11652336

>>11648082
Not to mention his fucking bear that he owned, Byron was a real G

>> No.11652427

>>11650457
I did and Mann is mediocre.

>> No.11652802

>>11647941
Knaussgard is a hack

>> No.11652903

>>11652336
>Byron was a real G
People like you who think you're oh so clever when you juxtapose some niggar slang with something classic and refined are such tremendous faggots. "Man, Mozart is such bae!" "Whoa, Based Shakespeare!" Stop trying so hard to fit in, you fucking walking embarrassment.

>> No.11653486

>>11652903
You’re weird.

>> No.11653490 [DELETED] 

>>11652903
cringe

>> No.11653525

>>11652903
4chan pre-reddit invasion
>>11653486
>>11653490
4chan post-reddit invasion

>> No.11653588

>>11652903
Cringe and bluepilled

>> No.11653961

>>11647890
WHAT ABOUT SCHOPENHAUER YOU PSEUD

>> No.11654363

>>11652903
based, i hate this reddit 'lol it's highbrow but lowbrow muh epic thug man book review' humor

>> No.11655852

>>11653525
>keeping track of an imageboard's userbase

>> No.11657579

>>11648441
>>tfw pibull owners are both delusional and in need to affirm their masculinity by buying a dog
>tfw local shelter is filled with pitbulls and have to send them off to be euthanized and out of drunken pity decide to adopt three of them and raise them in my house in the middle of a crowded city in my meager 700sqft yard

>> No.11657625

>>11655852
>being reddit

>> No.11658207

>>11648204

Let them take editorial positions, they said. What could go wrong, they said. WASP sensibilities will never get overturned by the vulgar tastes of a culture destroying minority, they said.