[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 160 KB, 799x548, 800px-B._PINELLI,_Enea_e_il_Tevere.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10772134 No.10772134 [Reply] [Original]

After a year of rejections, I finally caved and published my ancient Greek tragedy script through Amazon Kindle Direct.

Tell me what you think -- especially the bad:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07B44SKC5

>> No.10772139

S'not awl that aynchent now, innit?

>> No.10772165

>>10772139

It felt like it was, gathering dust and all.

>>I mean the style Anon, THE STYLE

>> No.10772226

shameless self-bump

>> No.10772264

I don't have a kindle but it doesn't sound terrible from your description.

>> No.10772265

>>10772134
>https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07B44SKC5
I used the name Diomedes for a mount and blade group I played in when we had to find 'spartan' names lmao

>> No.10772270

If it’s ancient, why does it only have two acts?

>> No.10772279

>>10772264
That's nicer than anything I was expecting desu.

It has a preview mode, and there will be a paperback version coming out in a few days too.

>> No.10772284

>>10772265
LOL -- nice! It's a pretty strong name, I always liked it anyway and when I found out about his character in the Iliad, I really wanted to do some 'fanfiction' thing with it since he's such a minor character.

>> No.10772287

>>10772165
>>>I mean the style Anon, THE STYLE
I knew that! But there aren't even any Ancient Greeks alive, so who's your audience, smartguy?

>> No.10772289

>>10772270
I just meant mainly the tone, subject matter, and style.

There's also no Chorus or masks, but I wanted to 'adapt' the ancient style to modern times while still telling a heroic tragedy in those mythological settings.

>> No.10772303

>>10772287

See:
>>10772289

It's about the feeling that this is an ancient myth for modern audiences without doing some post-modern bullshit and setting it in modern times. I tried to be 'classical' in approach.

>> No.10772472

Another shameless bump

>> No.10772477

I also shipped diomedes with athena

>> No.10772481

>James Fox
This is an alias, right? It better not be.

>> No.10772492

>>10772477

In my play Diomedes worships a specific version of Athena he calls Anake, which is personified as a dragon. The idea was that he goes through so much in the backstory of the narrative that he winds up perverting his idea of her until she no longer embodies pure, civilized truth and justice, but the natural, barbaric truth of nature in its austere, uncaring way.

>> No.10772494

>>10772481
Why does it matter, yo?

>> No.10772502

>>10772494
It's obnoxious. And it also foreshadows how bad your play is going to be if you suck even at picking an alias.

>> No.10772507

>>10772502

I'm not going to disclose that on 4chan, obviously. Have you read the 'look inside' opening to the play? -- That might be a better way to determine the quality than the author name . . .

>> No.10772509
File: 20 KB, 508x493, 4ddb6ee0d5fd6d7fe78f0d503411aea4.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10772509

>>10772507
>than the author name . . .
>. . .

>> No.10772514
File: 465 KB, 480x454, 1516234812388.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10772514

>>10772509

>> No.10772556

I read the first page or so. Although honestly Im going to be biased because ancient Greek shit gets my dick hard as diamonds, but I'll try to critique the writing itself.

You describe settings and landscapes very well, its extremely easy for me to paint a mental picture based off of your writing. Its also relatively concise and to-the-point, but descriptive enough without being rambling.

The one negative that jumps out at me right from the get go is some of your sentences could be restructured slightly to read with a little more fluidity. Its almost like you hit the nail on the head a little too hard at times; your approach could be more delicate if that makes sense.

>The port city of Lavinium is one of these places
I know this wouldn't be in the actual play if it were performed, but its just an example of you being little too direct I think

>Even in that beautiful country, no solace is to be had
"Even in that beautiful county, there is no solace to be had" reads a little better I think.

>Long days, long nights, long months spent alone longing for company
This is kind of just a play on the "the hours turned to days, days to months, months to years" cliche that's a little overplayed. "many a moon was spent longing for the touch of another, if not just for some company to pass the time" is what I would have done, even though its still kind of cliche as fuck.

Again though, I feel like an asshole for picking apart little details like that, and my writing is by no means perfect or even published, so take it with a grain of salt. But its little shit like that jumps out at me almost immediately

>> No.10772585

>>10772556
PLEASE don't feel like an asshole -- I honestly, sincerely enjoy negative criticism than positive or 'constructive'. I know what I did right, but I need to be told what I did wrong more often than not!

That said, I'm right there with you in term of ancient greek stuff being my fetish.

But I think your points were totally valid and I'm always open to changes in my writing. I'm going to reproach the opening a few monthes from now with this in mind. THANK YOU anon

>> No.10772594

>>10772585
You have a good attitude

>> No.10772598

>>10772594
unctuous, you wanted to say

>> No.10772619
File: 3.83 MB, 720x404, Crusade in 3, 2, 1.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10772619

>>10772598
Says the guy who uses an obscure word when he could have just said 'brown-nose'

>> No.10774072
File: 15 KB, 240x304, IMG_0288.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10774072

I love you OP

>> No.10774085

>Ancient Greek play
>title in latin

:thinking:

>> No.10774168
File: 141 KB, 803x688, pepe_meme'd.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10774168

>>10772134
>Ancient Greek Tragedy
>Written in English

>> No.10774180

>>10772619
>brown-nose
The thing is, I first heard about this word from you. I'm not a native speaker so I happened to know the word "unctuous" before knowing the word "brown-nose" (and I think it's too vulgar).

>> No.10774192

>>10774168
This person only knows English

>> No.10774199

> I wrote an Ancient Greek play
> not in Ancient Greek
> Latin title
Nah, thanks.

>> No.10774211

>>10774192
My classic greek is shit, desu. Only took 3 semesters.

>> No.10774760
File: 923 KB, 290x163, Planet of the Kek.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10774760

>>10774085
>>10774168
>>10774192
>>10774199

OP here -- I just mean the style and context, not the language or setting anons

>> No.10774764

>>10774072
I love you more

>> No.10775092

>>10774764
lmao that was shit bro kys yourself

>> No.10775096

>>10775092
was meant for >>10772134