[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 145 KB, 800x540, 1519329873675.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10742051 No.10742051 [Reply] [Original]

Has a single good fantasy book been written after Lord of the Rings?

All of the other ones seem to try too hard and it shows in the writing.

>> No.10742083

Book of the New Sun

>> No.10742091

>>10742083
That's sc-fi. But Wizard Knight was good.

>> No.10742097

earthsea trilogy (ignore anything after 3)

>> No.10742104

>>10742051
>tfw I cried during Many Partings and Homeward Bound
Hold me bros. It's all over...
I need to get the Silmarillion and Children of Húrin soon.

>> No.10742145

>>10742104
Do Book of Lost Tales 1/2 and Lays of Beleriand instead of the standalone Children of Hurin book.

>> No.10742166

Harry potter

>> No.10742176

>>10742166
" !"

>> No.10742184

>>10742051
>Narnia
>Book of the New Sun (Pretty much any Meme Wolfe actually)
>The Black Company
>The Last Unicorn
>The Once and Future KANG
>Chronicles of Amber
>Lord of Light
>Gormenghast
>Anything by R.A. Lafferty
>Til We Have Faces
>Little, Big
>The Dying Earth
>The Anubis Gate

Plenty of good fantasy hiding behind mountains of shit.

>> No.10742185

>>10742176
Based !poster

>> No.10742208

LotR isn't fantasy

>> No.10742212

It is not like Lord of the Rings is any good

>> No.10742213
File: 17 KB, 246x251, balobalobalo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10742213

>>10742208

>> No.10742222

>>10742145
>Book of Lost Tales 1/2 and Lays of Beleriand
>here are eight different versions of the same story, and half of them have sleepytime fairies!
>don’t forget to buy all thirty volumes!
Nice try, Christopher

>> No.10742388

>>10742051
The recent publication of Beren of Luthien is absolutely wonderful.

>> No.10742470

>>10742051
First law series.

>> No.10742945

>>10742208
DELETE THIS

>> No.10743332

>>10742097
This desu comfy af

>> No.10743983

>>10742051
Weaveworld

>> No.10743993

Brandon Sanderson's books.

>> No.10744037

Terry Pratchett.

>> No.10744076

Feist

>> No.10744090

The Traitor Baru Cormarat

>> No.10744766

>>10742051
Stormlight Archive, Mistborn Trilogy, some of the Discworld books, Rumo if you can read german, the First Law Trilogy comes close

>> No.10744799

>>10742388
I tried looking at a sample of this on Amazon but all it showed was Christopher talking about his dad and his mother, and this is AFTER the introduction where the book is supposed to "start". How long does this go on for? Are there interjections in the middle of the story? It says it's ~220-230 pages but I'm not going to (((buy))) it if it's half composed of familial footnotes, let's say.

>> No.10744814

Very few sci-fi and fantasy writers can manage exposition effectively.

>> No.10744957

>>10744799
it's compiled from a few different version of the tale, and the only time Christopher interjects is between each section. it's really very minimal on comentary and footnotes.
the tale is presented as a complete narrative, but you also get to see how the tale developed over the years
i highly recommend it

>> No.10745213

>>10744957
Tevildo was a mad man

>> No.10746255

>>10742051
ASOIAF is better than LOTR

>> No.10746700
File: 46 KB, 303x475, 76620.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10746700

>>10742051

>> No.10746734
File: 47 KB, 474x750, 3498c16dfe1603026012b58a5782d3fffb3d062a14b870922410e5d0e11930bf.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10746734

>>10742184
This is a very good list

>> No.10747821

>>10742208
Has a single good fairy story been written after The Lord of the Rings?

>> No.10747901

>>10742184
>no first law
Dropped

>> No.10748116

>>10746255
Reddit

>> No.10748132

>>10742184
I've read some Wolfe, Lafferty, The Dying earth and Lord of Light .
They were all good, my biggest aversion to fantasy as a genre is the sheer amount of nerds who just produce their own sort of RPGs without any knowledge about litterature outside of it

>> No.10748133

>>10747821
Little, Big

>> No.10748606

>>10742097
My fiction professor hates genre fiction, but she liked Earthsea. Actually, even Harold Bloom liked LeGuin.

>> No.10748755

>>10748116
Seriously now, is a Game of Thrones not a good fantasy book?

>> No.10749020

Stardust.

>> No.10749055

>>10748755
Grimdark, edgy, tax policy lmao, sjw's, sunset found her squatting, le ebin trope subversion, fat pink mast etc. No surprise people here don't like it. If this board existed in the 90's it would be praised though.

>> No.10749087

>>10742184
Assassin's Apprentice.

>> No.10750195

>>10748606
Love the magic system in Earthsea.
Le Guin was a great author, even if she was a commie.

>> No.10750200

>>10748755
you can do a lot worse than ASoIaF, but it still doesn't hold a candle to Tolkien.

>> No.10750484

>Lord of the Rings
yes, yes, Aragorn driving out the orcs in righteous battle is all well and good, but what was his tax policy? Where are the powerful queens and intriguing eunuchs?

>> No.10750518

>>10748755

I think they're great books. A little too easy to read and short on the philosophy side but written and structured well (the release structure was horrible though)

>> No.10750558

>>10750518
>>10748755

I think they are okay. Decent fun reads but the surface level politics and philosophy is completely shallow. George's short stories though he wrote in the 80s are pretty good.

>> No.10750578
File: 31 KB, 640x361, IMG_0407.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10750578

When did /lit/ become to seriously discuss genre fiction shit lol.

>> No.10750615

>>10749055
>tax policy

What’s this?

>> No.10750674

>>10742091
It's sci-fi/fantasy that leans more to fantasy at times.

>> No.10750684

>>10750578
The serenity behind his disdain is kingly.

>> No.10750747
File: 1.79 MB, 3000x2756, mkppnul0b2gy-min.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
10750747

>>10750615

>> No.10751009

Dune by Frank Herbert. Its sfici, but magnificent one

>> No.10751016

>>10742051
>LOTR
>fantasy
"No!", it is entirely distinct from fantasy dreck stylistically, I'd argue it does not really belong to the genre at all.

>> No.10751024

>>10751016
This is like when people try to argue crime and punishment isn't a crime novel. You're pathetic.

>> No.10751063

>>10751024
genre != subject

>> No.10751120

>>10751063
And subject is setting? Explain how the distinction you draw between LOTR and ''fantasy'' isn't completely arbitrary.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fantasy

>> No.10751145

>>10747821
Johathan Strange and Mr. Norrell.

>> No.10751147

>>10750195
I put down Left Hand of Darkness after about ten pages. Boring AF.