/lit/ - Literature

>>19258623
>>19258635
Can I ask you both some questions? Sins are lies by essence, correct? Meaning that sins are lies to God, and when you lie to God you are also lying to yourself, right? It is the most blatant and audacious of lies to sin against God, correct? and when you murder someone, you will always be a murderer, right? and when you lie, you will always be a liar, correct (if you do not repent)? and God did not destroy a city until He sent them a prophet, right? this is because they had to be aware of their sins before they could be destroyed, correct? and the prophets therefore had to be aware of their sins, because they were the ones who had knowledge of God in the purest sense, right? so if they sinned, they would be the biggest liars on the face of the earth, correct? this is because they had the most knowledge of God, therefore their sin is maximized because they knew the consequences of their actions more than anyone, right? and liars are liars to themselves, and honest people are honest to themselves, correct? meaning that an honest person will believe himself more, and a dishonest person will distrust himself more, right? so if an angel reveals himself to a liar, they will not be able to believe their senses, because they have ruined their testimony to themselves on account of their lies, and if an angel comes to an honest person, they will be able to believe it, because they have safeguarded their own testimony.

therefore, if a prophet is a liar, he would be liable of being destroyed more than anyone on the face of the earth. This is why Allah says in the Qur'an that if Muhammad had lied about Him, he would be killed on the spot (and others who are not prophets lie about him and are not destroyed because they do not have knowledge). this also means that naturally, the jewish depiction of the prophets is incorrect, because if a prophet lies to God, then he lies to himself, and if he lies to himself, he cannot believe himself, as he lied against God. this means that the prophets had to be infallible, as sins are lies by essence and if they are honest, this means they can never sin. Salam!