[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 8 KB, 409x410, ss (2012-09-15 at 02.13.12).png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9955305 No.9955305 [Reply] [Original]

Hey /jp/.

I'm using Tae Kim's guide to learn japanese, but I don't feel like I make any progress. I often have to look up Kanji I should already know, often don't get something and so on.
Anyone made the same experience? What should I do?

>> No.9955327 [DELETED] 

You should suck my cock dude

>> No.9955372

Have you ever learned a foreign language, or is jap your first? It's normal to feel like there's no progress, just don't try to rush things or lose your confidence. It's not about knowing jap in a year or less, it's about learning jap.

Take your time with kanji, it's normal to mix/forget those just as you would with new words in a foreig language. Imagine someone learning english from scratch, it'd be normal for them to mix up words and definitions from time to time.

If you don't feel like learning today, don't, you'll just end up wasting your time as you may have trouble actually learning. Knowing your learning pace and the best methods for you is the best way to learn a language. Whatever you go for, just don't give up easily.

>> No.9955373

How long have you been studying? It takes years to know the kanji well. Don't pay attention to those people who "learn" them in one or two months.

>> No.9955382

>>9955305

It takes time. Progress is too slow to be really noticeable.

>> No.9955404

>>9955372
It's my first foreign language (English doesn't count, because it's similar to my native language and well, everyone can speak it)

>>9955373
It's been some months now, I don't put a lot of time into it. More or less my daily Anki repetitions.

>> No.9955424

>>9955305
OP here. Oh, and my current also is to go to university and study japanese there. I think it'll be a lot easier if I already know the basics

>> No.9955442

>>9955404
>>9955424
Do you have any study material other than Anki/Tae Kim? You could pick up a game without kanji to gain vocabulary through the kana. Personally, I find memorising kanji to be immensely easier if I can use it in a context. Learning kanji through vocabulary learning is a bit more dynamic than grinding both, at least for me. Maybe at university you could get some better studying tips, I can only speak for experience.

>> No.9955444

>>9955305
Use Heisig and review by looking at the keyword and then writing the kanji. Brute forcing it is just going to make you forget unless you want to put years into it (when you don't have to).

>>9955373
Don't listen to this person, OP. You can learn the writings and meanings of all of the jouyou kanji in a few months if you apply yourself. Don't let the rote memorization fools draw you into their nonsense.

>> No.9955450

Wrong board.
Ask >>>/lang/ or >>>/a/. Latter have constant Japanese learning threads up, check the catalog.

>> No.9955454

>>9955442
Learning kanji through vocabulary is basically looking at a bunch of squiggly lines that have no meaning to you and hoping you'll remember the gist of them. It's better to quickly grind through the kanji first, and everything else will be infinitely easier.

>> No.9955472

>>9955444
Not him, but Kanji Damage works well for me.

>> No.9955481

>>9955472
Either one is fine. Try both, OP. Heisig uses visual mnemonics and Kanji Damage uses verbal mnemonics. Personally, visual mnemonics stick in my memory more. When using Kanji Damage I felt like I had to write them over and over or I'd forget.

>> No.9955489

>>>/a/73801817

>> No.9955491

>>9955481
I did that. ;_;

>> No.9955497

>>9955491
What do you mean?

>> No.9955499

>>9955497
I wrote 1 thousand kanji over and over.

>> No.9955504

>>9955499
That sucks. At least you learned them, though!

When using Heisig I would focus on the visuals for about 30 seconds to 1 minute, then write the kanji 5 times, or 10 if it was more difficult (Heisig says only write it once). Then I would review by looking at the keyword and writing the kanji once, each time I reviewed.

>> No.9955510

>>9955504
I just glanced at a kanji poster once. It ain't that hard... If a Japanese baby can do it then so can you.

>> No.9955516

>>9955510
One day I hope we can just get brain implants that will make us fluent.

>> No.9955528

Try Genki.
If that doesn't work either then you're probably just to stoopid to learn Japanese. Tough luck.

>> No.9955533

Do this OP:

1. Use Heisig to learn the writings and meanings of the jouyou kanji
2. Go through Tae Kim and learn the vocabulary and grammar he presents
3. Start going through the Core 2000 and then Core 6000 vocabulary decks on Anki.

I say do the core decks after Tae Kim because they have example sentences which allow you to see the vocabulary in context; these would be useless to you if you didn't know grammar.

>> No.9955547

Thanks for reminding me to do my reps OP. As a reward you can smell my smelly neet pussy.

>> No.9955554

憂 is actually Chinese language, not japanese. All kanji stem from Chinese.Japanese just copied.They always imitate our culture.

>> No.9955549

>>9955547
btw i'm a girl

>> No.9955562

>>9955444

You can learn something in that period of time, but for your brain to recall all of that information it takes time.

>> No.9955572

>>9955554
Go away, hanja (韓字) are a Korean invention. Suck it, China and Japan.
Confucius was the greatest Korean.

>> No.9955576

>>9955562
That's why you do SRS with Anki. You're not supposed to just blow through Heisig and then never review any of it.

>> No.9955591

>>9955576

He's one of those guys who took 5 years to learn 1000 kanji the traditional way, and attacks Heisig whenever it's mentioned.

>> No.9955597

>>9955576

Are you arguing with the right person? I'm telling OP not to do that, and to not expect to learn japanese in under a year.

>> No.9955602

>>9955572
Any source?

>> No.9955605

>>9955597
There is no reason that someone with a normally functioning brain, sufficient time to study, and motivation cannot be reading Japanese in a year or less. The methods and resources available today have made it much easier.

>> No.9955610

>>9955605

See:

>>9955591

>> No.9955613

>>9955554
>our culture.
黒人ゴーホーム

>> No.9955618

>>9955605

I'm not saying that you can't become proficient to a certain degree. For example, you learned hiragana in a day right? But how long was it before you were able to instantly recognize and read them? It takes time for your recall to catch up with your learning, and no amount of repetition can force that process.

>> No.9955683

>>9955618
Sure, reading speed takes time to develop.

>> No.9955711

>>9955533
Not OP, but how should one do core2k/6k?
Some people recommend writing the word+sentence each time, but that takes ages. I do that for hard sentences, but most of the time I just write down the word in kana+kanji. Yet my retention is still bad.
Is that normal?

And do I have to finish the entire guide before starting that? While I stopped at around 150 in core because some things were confusing, I was thinking I'd start studying new cards after finishing the "essential grammar" part. Which is roughly up to 3/4ths of the guide.
Asking because reading it is such a pain for me. It's nicely written and all, but every time I open it it feels like sticking my head into a grinder. Should I just shotgun what I have left and go back to the confusing parts once in a while? Or should I go through the rest thoroughly no matter what?

>> No.9955724

>>9955711
You should just give up before you commit sudoku.

>> No.9955758

>>9955711
IMO go for comprehension and recognition. Get your writing practice from Heisig.

>> No.9955777

>>9955758
Yeah, done that already. I've no problem with writing. People just recommend doing so in core because it supposedly makes it easier to remember. Actually, from what little I've studied, I generally remember the kanji first, before the actual word.

>> No.9955802
File: 48 KB, 547x709, anki-decks.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9955802

dem decks

>> No.9955817

>>9955802

You could have Core 2k and Core 6k in one deck.

>> No.9955842

>>9955817
I prefer the way these are laid out.

>> No.9955865

>>9955842
Also the large deck with 2000 and 6000 doesn't look like it has separate audio recordings of the word and the example sentence, or am I looking at it wrong?

>> No.9955868

>>9955842
Why is there 10 steps for 2k then only 10 steps for 6k?

I'm done with step 3 on 2k so far but it starts to get hard and some words are veryhard to memories.

>> No.9955875

>>9955868
6k has 12. Some of the later steps have more cards than the previous steps.

>> No.9955887

>>9955875
Ah, I missed that. How far are you? Or are you done with them all? If so, do you think it was worth it or do you recommend to just create a deck and add your own sentences?

>> No.9955893

>>9955875
Just checked.

Core 2000 have around 1000 cards per step

Core 6000 has around 1250 per step, and steps 9 through 12 have about 2500 cards each

>> No.9955928

>>9955887
I'm starting on core 6000. I just have all the decks already loaded for convenience. Personally, I like having the vocabulary and sentences already laid out for me. It saves me a lot of trouble. But use what works for you. If the core decks are causing you a lot of grief then you should definitely try modifying the way you study them or either try a different method.

>> No.9955977

>>9955928
It's just that AJATT and all the other preachers say that you should go bilingual after 1k sentences. Well I'll just keep going till I drop. Thanks for replying. Have a nice evening or hurricane.

>> No.9955985

>>9955977
monolingual*

>> No.9956041

>>9955977
I never used a monolingual dictionary until after I hit 10,000 sentences, and my Japanese is fine. Use what's fastest and most convenient.

>> No.9958133

I found that if you know the word already thanks to your anime, it's way easier to learn a kanji, for example 動 I learned it because you always hear 動かない in any series, so it was pretty "click" the moment I realized the meaning and reading. I'm sure I won't ever forget it.

のワの

>> No.9958168

No matter what some idiots tell you, Do Not use Heisig, unless you want to waste time learning a lot of silly stories for 2000 characters, only to find yourself unable to read shit anyway at the end.

>> No.9958588

I've been using both the Heisig and kanjidamage decks on Anki, because I couldn't figure out what people were saying was the better one.
Is it redundant to use both?

>> No.9959427

>>9958168
What do you recommend then?

>> No.9959438

>>9958168
except heisig never teaches you to read.

ironic how you weren't able to comprehend this.

>> No.9959489

is there a guide or textbook that teaches all the grammar you need up front so you can start reading with a dictionary right away?

>> No.9959528

>>9959489
Like Tae Kim's guide? Don't really know what you mean.

>> No.9959538

>>9959528
I don't know, I haven't really looked into anything yet. I've been learning runes incidentally just from playing eroge and I figured I could start picking things up for real if I had somewhere to start. from hearing people talk though it seems like all the guides are focused on vocabulary though which seems like a stupid way to learn a language.

>> No.9959548

>>9959538
You've gotta learn vocab for a language to have any purpose. There are guides specifically for vocab just because each word has a character to it.

>> No.9959559

>>9959548
obviously memorizing vocabulary is something you need to do for any language, but for any beyond your first I think grammar should be the first thing you should learn. once you have that down you can start trying to read shit while looking up words.

>> No.9959618

You are simply retarded, OP. You will never learn japanese. Deal with it.

>> No.9959660

>>9959548
>each word has a character to it.

That's just completely wrong.

>> No.9959668

>>9959660
You get the drift.

>> No.9959782

Start reading stuff.

>> No.9961006

>not making your own kanji decks
FAGS

>> No.9961008

>>9961006
>anki

>> No.9961021

>>9961008
think it's bad?

>> No.9963706

>>9959668
very cute

>> No.9963751
File: 47 KB, 459x674, please respond.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9963751

have you done your reps for today?

>> No.9963807

>>9958588
Yes, it is. You should be able to tell that one of them is working for you. Either Heisig's visual mnemonics or KD's verbal mnemonics should be sticking more. Use whichever works for you. I like Heisig more, personally.

>> No.9963819

>>9958168
I went through Heisig, and most of the mnemonics eventually dropped away. And I gained the ability to write and recognize all of the jouyou kanji. Vocabulary would have been an absolute nightmare had I not already known how to write and distinguish the kanji being used.

>> No.9963841

>>9963751
Yes

>> No.9964713

>>9963751
Not yet (10:13 AM here)
But holy shit, 1267 cards sure are a lot

>> No.9967647
File: 2 KB, 269x62, ss (2012-11-01 at 12.23.48).png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9967647

>>9964713
samefag here, my daily stuff

>> No.9969630

I tried a few methods when I started, try HumanJapanese (IOS/PC) for the basics and Kanji de manga for beginners kanji.

>> No.9969667

>>9955305
tae kim's guide is more like a complement to formal nihongo classes

>> No.9969690

>>9963751
not today, i'm too lazy

>> No.9970233

>>9969690
Please don't say you are lazy.

>> No.9971437

where do I get the anki decks?

>> No.9971463

>>9971437
through anki obviously. download public decks

>> No.9971507

What exactly is heisig?

Ive got the deck on anki, however there are no readings or stroke order to go along with it so I feel like im missing something

>> No.9971525

>>9971507
Heisig wrote short stories for every Kanji to make it easier to remember them

>> No.9971535

I've been mining sentences. Just realized I've finished the last part of my book.

Don't know if it's worth it, though, since adding ~30 sentences, mapping out the readings and defining the shit I need on the back card can easily take an hour. Maybe it'd be better to use that time for pre-made decks instead.

>> No.9971543

>>9971437

Its better to make your own i'd say, extra level of reinforcement.

>> No.9971555

>>9971543
That's they say, but fuck if I know whether it holds any merit.

>> No.9971784

>>9971507
>What exactly is heisig?
Shit.

>> No.9971803

Just a reminder.

http://pastebin.com/KaWcfU4K

This is the pastebin of the daily japanese threads that used to be posted here (and then got crossboard link sage'd over to /a/)

It has some good recourses and download links. I'd reccomend, although personally i didn't use heisig for kanji.

>> No.9971879

>>9971803
what did you use then?

>> No.9971912

>>9971803
There were DJTs here as well?

>> No.9972004

What's a good site where I can translate something? It doesn't need to be accurate or anything as long as it's better than google translate.

>> No.9972015

I want to start with kanji. I already downloaded Anki, which decks should I download?

>> No.9972062

>>9972015
JLPT N5 Kanji

>> No.9972119

>>9971437
Download and install anki, then click open the program and click "get shared" It will take you to the website where you can download the decks

>> No.9972132

>>9971507
What you're looking for is the book "Remembering the Kanji" by James Heisig. There are three volumes. Vol. 1 teaches the readings and writings of the jouyou kanji (a supplement is available online for the additional 2010 jouyou kanji), vol. 2 teaches readings, and vol. 3 teaches advanced kanji. Most people volume 2 and pick up the readings from vocab. Volume 3 isn't really necessary either. You can acquire them in various places online.

But yes, volume 1 will contain the mnemonics, stroke order, etc. You're not supposed to just have the deck.

He also wrote a book called "Remembering the Kana" if you need help with that.

>> No.9972136

>>9972132
most people don't use volume 2*

>> No.9972172

>>9972062
Thanks, buddy.

>> No.9972254

>>9972004
please respond

>> No.9972262

>>9972132
I meant "Vol. 1 teaches the meanings and writings of the jouyou kanji." Just noticed the mistake.

>> No.9972293

>>9972254
Bing Translator is sometimes better. But besides Bing and Google Translate I don't know sites where you can put in whole sentences, maybe others can help out

>> No.9972316

Just use Kanji damage and learn the meanings and onyomi, kunyomi can wait with the rest of your vocab. Anyone just learning meanings though is fucking retarded, and as far as I'm aware that's all the first book of RTK teaches you.

Mneomics are stupid too, "HURR DON'T MEMORIZE A SHORT SYMBOL, REMEMBER A FAR LONGER STORY INSTEAD!" Your brain tends to make a connection with radicals in a similar vein to the stupid stories anyway.

>> No.9972388

>>9972316
>"HURR DON'T MEMORIZE A SHORT SYMBOL, REMEMBER A FAR LONGER STORY INSTEAD!"

If anything, your ridiculous criticism would be better directed to kanji damage, since it uses verbal mnemonics (memorizing a story) whereas Heisig uses visual mnemonics.

>> No.9972412

>>9972316
If you really want to memorize the readings to badly, you can use volume 2 of Heisig. I can't understand how you can say "mnemonics are stupid" and then recommend Kanji Damage, though. It's like people will say any inane bullshit to denigrate Heisig.

>> No.9972437

>>9972412
>>9972388

I just recommend the anki deck because it trims some fat and gives you additional information about the kanji, like if it tends to use it's kunyomi in jukugo, how it's used, wether a radical usually has a certain meaning, ect, and gives you a nice collection of common words they're used in to study off of.

You can use anything in a similar vein really. I know all the reading in the deck with reasonable accuracy, and I've never paid attention to mnemonics. I do think it's likely a waste of effort.

>> No.9972447

>>9972437
I highly doubt that you have not come up with your own mnemonics. Regardless, you're basically saying people shouldn't take shortcuts and should just brute force everything. There's no reason to learn shit like a Japanese kid when you don't have to. If it worked for you, though, that's great.

>> No.9972480

>>9955305
1st year - 10ji/day
5 before bef 5 before breakfast
2nd year 5ji/day
5 before bed, weekly reviews
start reading manga
3rd year 1ji/day
weekly reviews
write down any interesting new ji and meet some jap friends to learn bushi, read a book
4th year several ji/week
continue with jap friends, try and read some literature or at least a couple of VNs or light novels
5th year
collect interesting books
you should be fluent by now, its time to try out for JET if you've finished college, or else just take a trip to japan

i never used a book to learn more than a few ji. once u know bushi you dont need them anyway

i use lingoes and youtube MMD movies

>> No.9972483

>>9972447

>I highly doubt that you have not come up with your own mnemonics.

In a way, I didn't make a conscious effort to do so though.

Sort of like, "Oh yeah I remember that, because it kind of looks like this"

And perhaps you're right, I don't think it is a short cut, and I really think a person should search their options before dedicating time to a certain method, I've done a lot of very inefficient routines, but this one worked out.

>> No.9975890

Reps for today done, my fellow /jp/sies?

Captcha: man thanks

>> No.9976850
File: 305 KB, 650x365, YuruYuri01-00002-650x365.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9976850

>>9975890
Hi /jp/sie. I only have 49 reps today (yay). Gonna clear them out and add some new sentences right away.

Have a good day /jp/, and don't forget about your Japanese studies!

>> No.9976891
File: 4 KB, 391x34, allicrab.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9976891

>>9975890
not yet

>> No.9976926

>>9976891
Which program/website is that?

>> No.9976953

>>9976926
wanikani.com, still in beta. I like it

>> No.9976957

>>9976953
Thanks, I will have a look at it.

>> No.9976987

Tae Kim is about grammar, not kanji.

>> No.9977136

>>9971535
why do you do this? just copy paste from whatever source and cloze the part that you want to learn.

>> No.9977397
File: 39 KB, 516x436, Untitled.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9977397

>>9955802
Are the core 6000 decks a good complement to the core 2000 ones? I used to do only the first core 2000 one, but I think I started enjoying doing my reps and learning the language and picked up a couple of extra ones.

>>9955442
What games would you recommend, anon? Or rather, is there a good place to find games in Japanese? It would probably be incredibly easy to do so if I searched in Japanese in the first place, but I don't have that luxury yet.

>> No.9977448
File: 3 KB, 485x36, fug.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9977448

fug

>> No.9977455

>>9977397
>Are the core 6000 decks a good complement to the core 2000 ones?

You should do the core 6000 decks after the core 2000 decks. 2000 starts off with more common vocabulary while the 6000 decks move into more advanced vocabulary.

>> No.9977994
File: 14 KB, 240x79, a.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9977994

>> No.9978006

People here actually use mnemonics? If you were autistic it wouldn't be necessary.

>> No.9978037
File: 5 KB, 493x119, reps.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9978037

>>9977994

>> No.9978045

>>9978006
Being autistic doesn't mean you have great visual memory.

>> No.9978093

>>9978037

You should try studying with a timer that sounds off every X seconds to remind you to answer.

It makes you a lot faster with reviews.

>> No.9978102

>>9978093
Well I was writing all of them, and I took a few breaks in between.

>> No.9978173

>>9955305

Nah, it's fine. It's only natural to make mistakes and what have you while you still go at it.

Progress is slow, but just keep at it.

I learn through a messy but broad combination of Tae Kim, reading manga with furigana and all-kana videogames to learn vocabulary, Anki to recall and review the Kanji and vocab I've encountered and Genki because why the hell not, can't hurt to read more.

I feel like I've made decent progress, nothing even close to approaching literacy but occasionally I'll be able to catch the gist of a sentence and it'll feel good.

Just immerse yourself, do all of the everything.

>> No.9978197

>>9978173
I tried raw manga too (Ika Musume). But I had to look up every single word and it took me like 15 minutes for the first page. Games will probably be the same

>> No.9978242

>>9978197
You need to know about 4,000 words to function independently without looking shit up all the time.

>> No.9978254

>>9978242
Yeah. I just can't enjoy a manga if I need hours to understand one chapter

>> No.9978278

>>9978254
Then grind some vocab.

>> No.9978298

>>9978278
I try to, but it takes up a lot of time

>> No.9978301

>>9978278
that's what he was saying

grinding is hard work

>> No.9978313

it's hard as fuck, it's going to take a lot of time

>> No.9978323
File: 64 KB, 516x490, Untitled.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9978323

>>9977397
Oh, one thing I don't understand about the core 2000 3 deck is that the font is smaller for some reason. That, and there seem to be less pictures. Did I fuck up the download process or broke something somehow?

>> No.9978332

>>9978323
Should I use Anki 1 or 2? What about mobile devices?

>> No.9978334

>>9978298
Welcome to language learning.

>> No.9978340 [DELETED] 

>>9978332
I just started to use Anki 2 because the website tells you to download it now instead of anki 1.2. So I updated. I actually like the previous Anki better because there was a gigantic repeat audio button in the taskbar glued to the window. On this one, you have to open a separate drop-down menu and click "Repeat" or press the R button. It's a little annoying.

>>9978334
Oh. I understand.

>> No.9978346

>>9978340
I think I read something about Anki 2 not being compatible with the Android/iOS App so far? Did you try that out?

>> No.9978350

>>9978332
I just started to use Anki 2 because the website tells you to download it now instead of anki 1.2. So I updated. I actually like the previous Anki better because there was a gigantic repeat audio button in the taskbar glued to the window. On this one, you have to open a separate drop-down menu and click "Repeat" or press the R button. It's a little annoying.

If you make your own decks or something, I don't know what's different, but if you're just using it to study shared decks, there's virtually no difference.

>>9978334
Oh. I understand.

>>9978346
Sorry, added a bit of info to the post. I don't have such a phone to try it out, apologies.

>> No.9978365

>>9978350
Okay, thank you anyway

>> No.9978367

>>9978323
Just redownload it and see.

Also you don't need to do multiple core 2000 decks at the same time. Just do the first step, then do to step 2 deck when you finish it, etc. You can set Anki to give you more then 20 new cards in the options menu.

>> No.9978380

>>9978367
...why not? Well, regardless, it's too late now. Even though I only have 40 cards seen on step three and a little less than a thousand on two, my OCD would kill me if I let the reps build up.

And I mean, it's not that bad. I'm learning more vocabulary, the sentences don't seem that much more complex, my workload didn't increase by that much... I'm actually thinking of downloading some core 6000 decks now.

>> No.9978397

>>9978380
You're just making things more complex than you need to, with no benefit to gain. They're arranged in steps so that you can do them in sequential order.

>> No.9978400

>>9978397
Also I would not be surprised if the sentences in later decks build upon the vocab learned in previous decks, meaning that if you do them out of order you will not get much benefit from the example sentences.

>> No.9978421
File: 39 KB, 516x415, Untitled.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9978421

>>9978400
I actually managed to guess what this sentence in 3 was on my first try! I was so proud. It was all because the first deck taught me what よく means.

Which I guess kind of proves your point, BUT STILL. I don't want to give up on my decks now! I know I'm just making a fool out of myself by not increasing the number of cards I learn on a single deck, since other decks still add more new cards on total I have to do, but this method just feels right. I've been looking so long for a way to stop fighting my tools and get to learning, I don't want to change it now.

I'm sorry, anon. I'm letting you down. I wish I could cater to your advice, but I'm too stubborn.

>> No.9978494
File: 59 KB, 516x327, Untitled.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9978494

And I'm done. Fuck that Tae Kim deck, it is awful. See you guys tomorrow!

>> No.9978527

>>9972480
>2 years to read manga
The fuck are you doing? Even if you took lessons from a twice a week class you would be reading shit faster than that.

>> No.9978567

>>9978421
You're fucking stupid.

>> No.9978879

>>9978421

No matter how many anki decks you spam, you're not going to become fluent because you don't have any direction or context. Seriously. I was exactly the same until I started taking actual classes.

It's tough, but I really don't think you CAN learn Japanese alone. This stuff is supposed to a supplement to actual, professional teaching, not a substitute, and if you use it as one you'll get nowhere.

That's just my opinion but, speaking from experience, getting an actual teacher and getting enrolled in a course was the best thing that ever happened to my Japanese learning. I'd recommend you do that.

>> No.9978923

>>9978879
What a load of bullshit. What did you do, try memorizing vocab for a few months and then give up and take classes?

>> No.9978934

>>9978879
I tried to do classes before. But all I can find is gimmicky classes which want you stuff like have conversations in context or do little theaters, and they force you to only answer questions in Japanese or else they'll deal some sort of awkward punishment like you're six years old on preschool. All I wanted was some serious classes where I could focus on learning.

I gave up on that. Teach me instead if you're so convinced it works.

>> No.9979468

>>9978242
No. I know more than 4,000 words and I still have to look shit up all the time.

>> No.9979505

>>9979468
Let's change the number to 20,000 just to be safe.

>> No.9979548

>>9979505
I'll have to get back to you on that, in about 15,000 words.

>> No.9979589 [DELETED] 

Leave it to /jp/ to attempt to learn Japanese by a Korean guy.

>> No.9979592

>>9979548
I doubt you still have to look things up "all the time" if you know 15,000 words.

>> No.9979647

>>9979592
15,000 + 15,000 = 20,000?
Come on, man.

>> No.9979652

>>9979647
Oops, I thought that was a separate person who was saying they are "in 15,000 words" as in they have learned that many. The comma threw me off.

>> No.9979784

>>9979652
構わないでね。

>> No.9980089

>>9978923
Insanity is doing the same thing, over and over againbut expecting different results, Anon.

>>9978934
Sign up for a proper university then. Seriously, I've not seen any of that shit.

>> No.9981802

こんにちは! done your reps?

>> No.9981929

Since Japanese is sometimes considered an Altaic language and since an Uralic-Altaic language group exists, but I am not sure if Japanese or Korean is included in that, would it be marginally easier for lets say a Finn to learn it when compared to a indo-European language speaker? Or is this too far fetched?

>> No.9981962

>>9979589
the Japanese imperial family is descended from Baekje immigrants, I don't see your point.

>> No.9981994

>>9981929
I thought that /jp/ was a linguistic expert. Apparently not.

>> No.9983892

>>9981994
You expected your question to be answered in 30 minutes?

>> No.9984256

>>9983892
It probably would have been answered if I hadn't saged. I don't know if it is a stupid question, I just have never before seen it been asked or answered before.

>> No.9984274
File: 2 KB, 136x57, allicrab.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9984274

>>9981802
erryday i'm waitin'

>> No.9984277

Is anyone using TextFugu here? Is it worth it?

>> No.9984292
File: 15 KB, 288x95, Capture.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9984292

>>9981802

>> No.9984343
File: 38 KB, 650x50, probably_closer_to_500.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9984343

>>9981802

SRS pls

>> No.9984354

http://www.guidetojapanese.org/blog/2012/07/08/review-of-ank/

What do you make of this, /jp/?

>> No.9984356
File: 38 KB, 516x337, Untitled.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9984356

Well, that was quick. It's amazing how fast the workload goes by when you focus on the job.

I'm feeling a little sad with only this much work though. I want another deck to complement these. I was thinking about downloading the first core 6000 deck, but that might be too advanced for me right now.

>> No.9984362
File: 19 KB, 668x92, in 3 hours.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9984362

>>9984277
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G55lRztE5Ls

>>9981802

round the clock d00d

>> No.9984366

>>9984354
>I use iGoogle

>> No.9984367

>>9984354
That Tae is a faggot

>> No.9984372

>>9984354
>If you are just starting out, given all new words you would need to learn (and quickly), I would not recommend SRS. Given the additional time it takes to make the cards and the time wasted reviewing words you already know, it’s not worth it. If you know a word, you don’t want to hide it so that it comes back in 8 days. You want to get rid of it and move on. You have thousands of new words waiting for you to waste any more time on ones you already learned.

It sounds like you should ignore everything that isn't part of his grammar guide.

>> No.9984373

>>9981929

Japanese is of its own language family.

There's a few advantage starting languages:

English; >90% of loan words are known already.
Chinese; >90% of kanji meanings are known already.

Some other languages will have phonological similarity; latin-based vowels are very similar, some European languages use the alveolar tap (so does English, but anglophones recognise it as T, or D, not as R, or L). This will make pronunciation easier and more clear, and will probably aid listening comprehension too.

Other than that, there's not really an advantage for any language.

>> No.9984374

>>9984372
What I mean is, his opinion on Anki is stupid. There are pre-made decks you can use. If you want to delete a card you just go fucking delete it. I can understand him disliking it since he has been using a different system for a long time, but his discouragement for new learners to use it is silly.

>> No.9984378

>>9984374
>If you want to delete a card you just go fucking delete it.

Or you can suspend it. I don't think he used the program very much, honestly.

>> No.9984382

>>9984354

How does he propose "learning" vocabulary without any SRS?

Just reading it and remembering it forever?

>> No.9984389

>>9984382
He says to flood yourself with new content and don't really worry about it, and you should learn by osmosis.

>> No.9984395

>>9984389
Seems legit.

>> No.9984400

>>9984389
How can I find new content?

>> No.9984405

>>9984389

Doesn't work.

Not at all.

I did that for 5 years before I started structured study. I picked up about 1.5k words, but that's not efficient at all.

>> No.9984414

>>9984400
Read more varied eroge.

>> No.9984415

>>9984405
Yeah, I didn't think it would. It's good that it worked for him, though.

>>9984400
Here's what he says:

>I personally recommend the “deluge” method of dumping your brain with TONS of interesting content. This means plowing through pages of books and manga, hours of dialogue, and conversation practice forgetting more words than remembering them. Don’t sit around wasting time entering and reviewing what you’ve already seen, just get more, more, and MORE STUFF!!! You’ll be surprised at how much just seems to stick somehow like osmosis. Some people feel this is not effective because they end up forgetting so much stuff. They don’t realize that the fact that they even remember forgetting it means they’re learning it.

>> No.9984459

My major problem with anki was the complexity of syncing. It seems completely uncontrollable and just arbitrarily writes old data over new, for seemingly no reason.

I lost all my review progress my due to the sync deciding an incredibly outdated version was clearly the most appropriate, overwriting the real deck. I still had the deck file, so I rewrote it, but doing that doesn't preserve the review spacing, so I had to regrind the entire deck (several thousand reviews due). This had the later effect of the second/third reviews hitting all at once, due to all being "started" at the same time.

>> No.9984474

How do you use the core decks?

I always understand what the sentence means, but I have problems remembering the Kanji readings when I have them introduced from the deck itself, and end up marking most as a fail. Soon enough I go in pathetic circles of 50% failed cards.

>> No.9984498

>>9984474
Nothing to do but keep grinding it.

As far as I can tell at least.

>> No.9984533

>>9984459
Were you using Anki 1 or 2?
Because syncing with Anki 2 is really good now, much faster with no conflicts.

>> No.9984543

I found this in my bookmarks; maybe it'll do someone good.

http://pastebin.com/Y3eLSAqV

>> No.9984546

>>9984533

I don't use anki any more, but this was over a year ago, so it would have been Anki 1.

Can it preserve review data, as well as cards?

>> No.9984548

>>9984543
Looks like the pastebin of /a/'s DJT, except with less stuff.

>> No.9984550

>>9984533
Do you also use it on a smartphone? How is it with compatiblity there?

>> No.9984560

>>9984543
How would you guys rate Genki?

>> No.9984567

>>9984560
I rate it a 4

>> No.9984566

Completely unrelated, but did anybody ever scan the new hori-zun books?

>> No.9984635

>>9984567
Out of 10

>> No.9984636

Quick question、what is that thing that looks like a quotation mark next to hiragana called?

For example, the thing that changes は to ば。

>> No.9984637

>>9984546
>Can it preserve review data, as well as cards?
When I upgraded to Anki 2 all my review data was there, from about 500 days ago.

>Do you also use it on a smartphone? How is it with compatiblity there?
On Android, yeah. But there is no stable version of Ankidroid 2 yet, although it works OK (I've been using it on a daily basis since April, no issues)

>> No.9984642

>>9984636

Also, where can I find a COMPLETE chart of hiragana and katakana?

I know most of the hiragana, I just need to practice and make it faster.

>> No.9984650

>>9984635
Actually I rated it 4 out of 6.5.

>> No.9984655

>>9984636
濁点 dakuten び
半濁点 handakuten ぴ

>> No.9984667

>>9984636
Wikipedia you dumb whore.

>> No.9984683

What romanization method does /jp/ use when typing?

チャンス
>chansu
>tyansu
パンツ
>pantsu
>pantu
シックス
>shikkusu
>sikkusu

etc...

>> No.9984684

は = ha
ば = ba

ひ = hi
び = bi

and so on.

>> No.9984687

>>9984684
was meant for
>>9984636

>> No.9984691

>>9984683
Top one.

>> No.9984693

>>9984683
I think the first one is the most correct and easier to use.

>> No.9984694

>>9984655

Thanks.

>>9984667

Fuck you too.

>> No.9984699

>>9984683
>チャンス
Does this mean "to be asphalt"?

>> No.9984702

>>9984694
You wanna fuck bitch? Get on your knees and whip out your ass.

>> No.9984703

>>9984691
>>9984693
Hmm, I use the bottom version. From what I've seen, it's what most Japanese people use, and it's less key strokes.

>>9984699
What?

>> No.9984705

>>9984642

Again, wikipedia.

You won't find a "complete" chart anywhere, though - there's kana combinations used which aren't listed in any chart I've seen. Like: ティ、セィ、ドゥ, etc.

>>9984699

'Chance'...

>>9984683

I use tu, ti and si, as they don't take as long to type. Screws me up if I write in romaji, though.

>> No.9984712

>>9984703
チャン=歴青 which means asphalt or bitumen.

>> No.9984717
File: 1.34 MB, 315x315, fugg u.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9984717

>>9984694
No really. Wikipedia has everything you asked and it's also accurate.

>> No.9984725

>>9984712
れきせい is a more common reading, I'd think. チャン alone sound like a Chinese name.

>> No.9984732

>>9984717

Maybe I just wanted to talk to you guys instead.

If I googled everything I wouldn't be able to talk to you guys as much.

>> No.9984733

>>9984683
I like to write like I was on paper with kana. So not shortcuts like tu, si, etc...I'll keep that for later.

>> No.9984734

>>9984725
It's also a counter for games of mahjongg.

>> No.9984756

>>9984734
Mahjong is a Chinese game, so the readings for mahjong terminology isn't really applicable outside of Mahjong. Nobody would read 中 as "chun" anywhere but a mahjong parlor or something.

>> No.9984767

>>9984756
It was actually invented by a Korean named Park Jong-sik, and the game was marketed in the United States as a Chinese game because back then Korea was a little known place in the west, and everybody knew China. Mahjong actually is a Korean invention.

>> No.9984783

>>9984767
Please go back to /pol/, Kimchi.

Coreans go home.

>> No.9984866

>>9984637
Is there even a Ankidroid 2? Can't find it in the play store

>> No.9984974

>>9984866
http://code.google.com/p/ankidroid/downloads/list
Latest version is Beta 20.
I don't recommend upgrading if don't really know how these kinds of things work at all.
If you can install this, then trying with the default deck is obviously safe.

>> No.9985772

Can I just use the core 2000/6000 decks and learn by osmosis? They have 6000 vocab words and sentences.

>> No.9985899

>>9985772
Perhaps supplement with a Dictionary of Basic Japanese Grammar

>> No.9985992

>>9985772
How about you just move to Japan and learn by osmosis.

>> No.9986178

>>9985992
Why would I want to leave my room?

>> No.9986213
File: 164 KB, 1562x693, 1335489311857.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9986213

>Tae Kim
-Corean name
-using a Corean's advice to learn Japanese
not even once nida

>> No.9986317

>>9986178
So you can learn by osmosis.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action