[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 59 KB, 488x480, 1212381437435.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
776057 No.776057 [Reply] [Original]

http://comipress.com/article/2008/06/04/3588

So, I herd that Kara no Kyoukai sucks, and everyone here likes it only because they're T-M cocksuckers?

>> No.776061

I haven't read the novel and only watched the first movie and yes it definitely sucks. It's incoherent pointless shit. Shiki being moe is the only redeeming factor.

>> No.776065

PROTIP: it's for the fans.

>> No.776066

It had good production value and an awesome soundtrack.
Nothing much apart from that.

>> No.776070

Thats why it has 7 movies with irregular Contiuity

>> No.776075

>>776057
>>To be blunt, the writing is bad.
I agree wholeheartly, LOLNASU doesn't even begin to explain the shitty dialogues that plagued this movie.

>> No.776077

Literary critic refuses to suspend disbelief, finds that books don't work that way! News at 11.

>> No.776079

>>776065

You are a faggot and there really aren't enough type moon fags for that to be true. Even if it was the movie didn't have to suck (or maybe it did because of the source material).

>> No.776085

>>776079
>>there really aren't enough type moon fags
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA OH WOW

>> No.776087

>>776075
I liked it. Nasu has a very unique writing style, and the chapters work as standalone stories. If you like bland, "proper" writing (as opposed to odd kanji selection and mollusks) there are plenty of places for you to get it.

>> No.776096

>>776087
It's not a question of being "unique" or "proper" though, actually the writing style of Nasu isn't that weird at all.
It's a question of being good or shitty, that's all.
The witting in the first movie of KnK was laughingly bad.

>> No.776097

So, I herd that [X] sucks, and everyone here likes it only because they're [thing associated with X] cocksuckers?

You know, this is really quite excellent pasta. I can see [thing associated with X] being replaced with 'Touhou', 'Key', 'eroge', 'weeaboo' and plenty of other things. I shall save this for later.

>> No.776106

Since this is /a/ I'm taking your mean the KnK movie. I'm not a T-M fag but I found it pretty good and enjoyed most of it.
Granted I'd take a case-of-the-week themed BONES KnK series over the movies.

>> No.776110

>>776097
Butthurt type-moon fag, always there to the rescue.

>> No.776111

>>776106
[spoilers]This is /jp/[/spoilers)

>> No.776112

>>776106

But this is /jp/...

>> No.776116

>>776111
Protip: Don't browse both at the same time

>> No.776118

>>776112
>>776111
Sadly I figured that out way too late

>> No.776125

So I heard this trolling sucks and everyone here bites it only because it's summer.

Yeah, who am I kidding, this bullshit happens year round. Let's just feed all the bad trolls so no one bothers to be good at it anymore. Faggots.

>> No.776183

I know OP is a troll but holy shit, the guy who wrote that article is a douchebag.

OH YEAH I'M GONNA CRITICIZE THE ENGLISH VERSION OF THE NOVEL THAT WAS TRANSLATED BY FANS.

Also, he keeps bringing up that it's just like a doujinshi. I have some news for him.

>> No.776193

I never understood how people get to criticise the writing.
The story gets completely through, what's more to want?

>> No.776194

>>776183
The guy who wrote that article is a japanese, retard.

>> No.776200

>>776193
YEAH LIKE ALL THESE NARUTO/SASUKE FANFLICK I WRITE, WE GET THE FACT THAT NARUTO WANTS TO POUND SASKAY SWEET ASS, WHO CARE IF THE WRITING SUCKS?

>> No.776229

I'm not a big fan of Nasu, but I liked Kara no Kyoukai. Then again, I also liked Shingetsutan Tsukihime. I enjoy watching animu that you ADHD kids just can't watch.

>> No.776240
File: 384 KB, 1024x768, 1212843440693.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
776240

>>776229

>> No.776242

the copy that i have says that it's from the 23rd printing, and it's from 2004. book was first printed in 2000 i think.

also, i lent it to my moonspeak teacher, and she came rainbows, and she is VERY picky on books.

so yeah, KnK must suck really really hard.

>> No.776250

>>776057

http://comipress.com/article/2008/06/04/3588

What? Nasu's writing sucks because it isn't easy to comprehend? Holy shit. Try reading real books. I thought his writing sucks because he gives everyone ridiculous superpowers.

>> No.776262

>>776250
He didn't say that Nasu's style was hard to comprehend, and frankly it isn't at all, read the article for one.

>> No.776277

>>776075
>LOLNASU doesn't even begin to explain the shitty dialogues

WELCOME TO BOOKS.

>> No.776282

I always assumed that Nasu is a shitty writer who ( accidently ) manages to create good atmosphere and has interesting ideas that he ruins with powerlevels. Now I know it's true.

>> No.776295
File: 36 KB, 701x369, 1212844491338.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
776295

wat

>> No.776305

>>776295

Was that really necessary?

>> No.776306

>>776305
>>776295
Same faggot.

>> No.776342

>"Just then ----------a boring shadow was projected onto my retinas. A person-shaped silhouette rose into my field of vision."

Lol'd at this.

>> No.776407

>>776277
>>WELCOME TO SHITTY BOOKS
Fixed

>> No.776415

>>776407
gay :o

>> No.776423

>>776415

>> No.776427

>>776423

>> No.776431

>>776342
BEST WRITING EVER LOL

>> No.776438

>>776415

>> No.776439

You know what's funny? As Nasu is pretty much an amateur writer and H-games can't even be compared to real literature, I decided to read something written by a real romance novel author so that I could prove my point better. Best selling author Nora Roberts writes pretty much eroge-level shit, except it's target audience are women. I decided to read her book "Morrigan's Cross" as it seemed to have vampires, wizards and other Type-Moon-like shit. Considering that I facepalmed constantly during Tsukihime, it couldn't be worse, right?

Holy shit, I was wrong. Therefore I just can't call Kara no Kyoukai shit. I would like to, but I can't.

>> No.776476

>>776439
Read better books.

>> No.776527

>>776476

Comparing Nasu's writings to "Crime and Punishment" wouldn't really make sense, would it?

>> No.776625

I'm pretty sure light novels and eroges just wanna be anime script level prose instead of serious literary works.

>> No.776641

>>776527
Better than comparing it to something written by NORA ROBERTS.
Of course 90% of every books is utter shit, well 90% of everything is shit, so you shouldn't base your standard on them but on actually good books.

>> No.776692

>>776641
>Better than comparing it to something written by NORA ROBERTS.

Why? They both write similiar shit that has the same purpose. The only difference is that Nora Roberts seems to be a better writer and writes less retarded sex scenes.

>> No.776731

>>776692
Comparing shits isn't very productive, is it?

>> No.776764

If shit like that is more important than, say plot, characters, setting etc, it's no wonder most books are boring pieces of literary masturbation.
I'd rather take something interesting to read instead, even if it's not "well written". Seriously, most of the things he points out I don't really care about. It feels like he's trying a bit too much, but then again I don't jerk it to well written page long bullshit descriptions.

>> No.776779

>>776527
>>If shit like that is more important than, say plot, characters, setting etc, it's no wonder most books are boring pieces of literary masturbation.

You can have both, fucktard.
Not something an illiterate faggot would know of course.

>> No.776814

>>776731
>Comparing shits isn't very productive, is it?

I don't think Type-Lunatics consider Tsukihime to be shit. And I'm fairly sure Roberts' target audience doesn't consider her works to be shit. Comparing Kara no Kyoukai to what you consider a good book makes about as much sense as comparing DBZ to "The Brothers Karamazov".

>> No.776823
File: 20 KB, 214x271, 1212850514285.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
776823

>>776779
>it's no wonder most books are boring pieces of literary masturbation

Holy shit.

>> No.776857

>>776476
Any recommendations?

>> No.777949

fuck da gaters karan no kukai is da shirt ;P

>> No.777954

>>777949
Person is under 18, illegal content.

>> No.777961

>>777949

Stop bumping shitty dead threads from page 6 or whatever, you faggot. Go fag around in /a/ with the rest of your kind.

>> No.777974

>>777961
Don't forget to report.

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action