[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 210 KB, 460x567, a37c3c1cab1f494d7768db9c9d16acca.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7619704 No.7619704 [Reply] [Original]

What if the Nasuverse was integrated into the Potterverse?

>> No.7619709

It would be shittier?

>> No.7619712

combining two of the worst fantasy worlds can only get you something better, I guess.

>> No.7619724

Then maybe my girlfriend would show some interest toward it.

>> No.7619729

Considering that the 'Potterverse' is nothing but concentrated fail that already draws in other universes like a black hole of bad fiction, well, you see where I'm going with this.

>> No.7619730

Hogwarts gets destroyed by rival Clock Tower Academy, Voldemort's plans stopped by Burial Agency, world goes on as normal.

>> No.7619734

>>7619724
Which, potter or nasu?

>> No.7619735

Voldemort can kill servants. Discuss.

>> No.7619736

But it already is. Sea of Estray is pretty much all of those small magic schools in Europe put together.

>> No.7619744

>>7619734
Nasu of course. Bitches love Harry Potter.

>> No.7619748

>>7619729
>concentrated fail
>>>/b/

>> No.7619753

I wonder what the Nasu version of My Immortal would be like.

>> No.7619754

>>7619736

Isn't the Sea of Estray a giant floating mountain range full of alchemists?

>> No.7619758 [DELETED] 

>>7619748
This.

Get the fuck out.

>> No.7619771

>>7619753
Kara no Kyoukai? Similar levels of mary sue at least.

>> No.7619790

The Nasuverse is more similar to His Dark Materials, I think.

>> No.7619806

I would enjoy something of homolust.

>> No.7619807

>>7619754
No, that's Atlas.

Sea of Estray is basically a lot of magi getting together for drinking bouts and shit while doing their magic crap on their own and taking pupils instead of having to deal with any organized education. So basically they're what Europeans in general would have been if some of them were magicians.

>> No.7619834

>>7619807

No, Atlas is in Egypt.

I bothered to look it up because it amused me.

The Sea of Estray, together with the Atlas Institute, is an organization called the original form of the Magic Association.
Among the founders of the Magic Association, there had been many heretical magi who were exiled from the Sea of Estray and the Atlas Institute and had no place left to go. The base of the Sea of Estray is in Northern Europe. This base, with the nickname of the Moving Stone Coffin, is itself a moving mountain range. Normally it is wandering at sea as its name suggests, but sometimes it comes up on dry land. It seems they research mainly body alteration, but the specifics are unknown.


So not alchemists.

>> No.7619839

>>7619834

Source being Fate/Complete Material
http://www.heavens-feel.com/completematerial.html

>> No.7619857

>>7619790
>The Subtle Knife
>a tool that can create windows between worlds and can cut easily through anything.
Subtle indeed.

>> No.7619859

Harry Potter VN where?

>> No.7619873

>>7619857
It's subtle because it can cut windows between worlds by findings the gaps between fundamental particles.

>> No.7619891 [DELETED] 

The Potterverse was barely explained and should not even be called a universe. I mean She could of went deeper and expanded the universe a bit, she still has a chance to also, but she just didn't and it wasn't the focus.

>> No.7619889

>>7619873
But you can't cut true love with it.

>> No.7619900

Shiki can kill Voldemort without destroying the horcruxes first. Discuss.

>> No.7619898

>>7619704
Harry Potter's story continues uninterrupted since they take place in England, Nasu's stories continue uninterrupted since they take place in Japan. Congratulations, OP, you made nothing happen.

>> No.7619910

>>7619900

So can Ciel with 7th scripture, although it's more like she destroys the "free fragment" of Voldemort's soul and his Horcrux soulchunks still exist, but the soul that drove the meat-mech around is obliterated.

>> No.7619915

>>7619898
Clock tower.

hur durr

>> No.7619951

>>7619891
There is still the huge issue as to why western mages are so much more powerful and versatile than eastern.

>> No.7619961 [DELETED] 

>>7619951
When was that even said? I dont remember that.

>> No.7620248

Oh boy... just imagine Rin summoning... Harry Potter...

>> No.7620404

>>7619704
I guess there would be a route where Voldermort's soul fragment starts taking over Harry's body, causing him to rape the maids, which in turn makes Hermione put him out of his misery.

>> No.7620413

>>7620404
You mean he doesn't rape Hermione?

>> No.7620414

Also a route where Hagrid has to supply Harry Potter with magical energy I guess.

>> No.7620419

>>7620248
I can't really imagine how the dynamics between them would be.

Don't know how Harry would deal with tsundere.

>> No.7620434

>>7620404
>I guess there would be a route where Voldermort's soul fragment starts taking over Harry's body, causing him to rape the maids, which in turn makes Hermione offer him her asshole.

>> No.7620452 [DELETED] 

>>7620419
Harry, in the beginning at least, was very down on himself, thought he wasn't worth a piece of shit, and was very mellow but at the same time was very depressing in his head. I think in book 5 he had depression. The movies dont really show this at all of course. I guess he would just follow rin for the most part, much like how he follows and goes along with what ever Hermione told him to do.

>> No.7620578

>>7619898
Hogwarts is actually in Scotland

>> No.7620591

>What if the Nasuverse was integrated into the Potterverse?

Deaths in Hogwarts would skyrocket thats for sure

>> No.7620614

>>7620434
I wonder why Rowling didn't have a scene in the books where Harry suppresses Voldermort in Hermione's ass.

>> No.7620626

>>7620614
Is her ass magic or something?

>> No.7620633

>Kid with dead parents finds out that they died trying to prevent him from being involved in magic.
>Hidden magic potential awakens.
>Goes to a school with a bunch of other magicians. Makes friends with some of them, but others try to kill him.
>Has a seemingly innocuous ability that gets played up to mary-sue proportions.
>Summons a spiritual being to protect himself.
>Fights to keep a magic artifact out of evil hands.
>In the end, the evil magicians are defeated and everyone is happy.

Seems like the only difference is that the sex scenes were taken out.

>> No.7620654

>>7620626
Probably a reference to Ciel.

>> No.7620658

Moar like :

>Voldemort does his usual attention whoring shit
>Clocktower sends some mages over to seal him
>The end

>> No.7620698
File: 263 KB, 512x1536, 1310697587010.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7620698

if tsukihime had been a real novel do you think it could have been popular with normalfag kids?

>> No.7620709

>>7620698
>real novel
What is a false novel?

>> No.7620717

>>7620633
It always bothered me how if you were born with innate magical ability, you could be at the top of the wizarding world.

Such bullshit.

>> No.7620718

>>7620698
No, there's way too much pseudo philosophy, technical terms, and pacing issues.

Tsukihime is one of those works that would've benefited from a good editor. It still would. The manga was the best attempt to incorporate everything, and even it has issues.

I'd love to see D.C. or Marvel do a Westernized graphic novel version of the Far Side of the Moon, with more action in it and something of a tie in to Near Side. It would be

so

glorious.

>> No.7620715

>>7620709
Most people dont consider visual novels to be "real" novels.

>> No.7620731

>>7620717
Eugenism is no bullshit. Some people are naturally better than others.

>> No.7620737

>>7620731
Not to that extent.
Harry didn't even need an education: he was essentially a dropout that somehow became the most prestigious auror to support his family effortlessly. It's bullshit.

>> No.7620740

>>7620633
Most of these are common elements in fantasy in general.

>> No.7620755

>>7620731
Talent does not translate into superiority automatically. Genetics does not directly translate into aptitude. Aptitude in one area does directly translate into aptitude in other areas. (Savant syndrome, I'm looking at you.)

Lots of people in high places that would like others to believe they're "better" than the lesser plebeians, often have zero moral fiber, very little common sense, no idea what they're actually doing, and egos that don't match their actual skillsets.

It's why you see children of uber wealthy families end up destroying their inheritances.

Real skill is forged, not inborn. Natural talent is often wasted by failing to cultivate the personality, character, and determination to use it properly.

>> No.7620759

>>Natural talent is often wasted by failing to cultivate the personality, character, and determination to use it properly.

Story of my life ;_;

>> No.7620763

>>7620759
Some people are just too addicted to the immaterial to be satisfied by the sad world around them.

>> No.7620784

>>7620737
i never felt like Harry was overpowered. Sure, there was a lot of that "youareouronlyhope" bullshit in later books, but most of the time he was just lucky or aided by others.
There was only one discipline in magic that he was really talented and he made use of that, but other than that Rowling didn't really portray him as "flawless"

>> No.7620788

>>7620759
>Natural talent
Don't flatter yourself. The only way to prove that you have it is to actually achieve something.

>> No.7620787

>>7620763
And this is a problem why?

>> No.7620793

>>7620788
So many achievements go overlooked because they benefit nobody but yourself.

>> No.7620803
File: 733 KB, 919x1641, 1310699601788.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7620803

Negiverse > Nasuverse > Potterverse

>> No.7620811

>>7620803
Naruto > *

You have to admit Kishi is great at world-building.

>> No.7620821

>>7620811
>Naruto
>Great world building

Jesus you are a retard.

>> No.7620833

>>7620821
>I hate naruto because it's popular. Am I kool yet? XD

Naruto isn't great, but pathological hatred of Naruto is an /a/ meme. Don't bring it here.

>> No.7620836
File: 32 KB, 370x260, 1310700491285.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7620836

>>7620833
Leave. Now.

>> No.7620855
File: 130 KB, 512x512, 1310700794173.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7620855

I wanna see Arcueid kill everyone...

>> No.7620857

>>7620833

Eat shit and die.

>> No.7620888

>>7620833
To my eternal shame, I have read Naruto and am still reading it. I do not have any sort of irrational hatred towards it. I hate is because it's a fucking godawful manga.

That you would think there is any good point to that train-wrecked piece of shit, let alone the worlds setting (which is definitely one of its worst features) only serves to show you are a bumbling fool who doesn't belong. Shut the fuck up and get out, you piece of shit.

Also
>greentext

>> No.7621204

>>7620888
>To my eternal shame, I have read [insert title here] and am still reading it. I do not have any sort of irrational hatred towards it. I hate is because it's a fucking godawful manga.

>That you would think there is any good point to that train-wrecked piece of shit, let alone the worlds setting (which is definitely one of its worst features) only serves to show you are a bumbling fool who doesn't belong. Shut the fuck up and get out, you piece of shit.

>> No.7621831
File: 43 KB, 640x480, 1310724448204.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7621831

>>7620811
Naruto had two chances at good world-building (the betrayal at the end of the chuunin exams and the hokage summit), but both times it was wasted in favor of a generic good vs. evil plot. The only 'worldbuilding' present in Naruto is that different countries have different types of ninja's and some are infamous for being ruthless. That is all there is to worldbuilding in Naruto.

If you're going to talk about decent worldbuilding in shonen manga, pick Bleach instead. Soul Society and its inner working is described in good detail over time. Hueco Mondo is also a rather interesting place.

>> No.7621836

>>7621831
why are people that read shitty big 3 mango even posting here? get out

>> No.7621845

I thought this thread couldn't get worse, I was wrong

>> No.7621853 [DELETED] 
File: 649 KB, 1274x1170, 1310725445049.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7621853

>>7621831
bleach best

>> No.7622035

>>7621836
Because you're not the boss of me *v*

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action