[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 96 KB, 610x473, Shirou vs Saber.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4762514 No.4762514 [Reply] [Original]

>> No.4762529

Is this one of those bonding through beating the crap out of each other things.

>> No.4762531

Shirou (HF) > Arika > Nanaya/Tohno Shiki > Shirou (Fate/UBW) > Ryougi Shiki

>> No.4762532
File: 169 KB, 860x1254, 1268260707434.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4762532

Does Kanshou and Bakuya Overedge count as a Noble Phantasm?

Since it's a move (a) Shirou created and only (a) Shirou can do.

>> No.4762538

>>4762529

No. Black Saber is cut in half on the left, and Shirou is braindead on the right. Black Saber was trying to congratulate Shirou on his victory, but quickly realized that 'Shirou' is functionally dead.

>> No.4762540

>>4762529
No Shirou's mind is dead. And Saber will revive in 10 minutes. Rin has to beat Sakura in those 10 minutes or else she will be raped for all eternity.

>> No.4762545

>>4762532
That wasn't Overedge. Overedge is something else. That was Crane Wing.

>> No.4762568

>>4762531

Herp.

>Shirou (HF) > Arika > Nanaya/Tohno Shiki

Tohno would win the fight, but overuse of his eyes would cause him to die very soon after.

>> No.4762573
File: 93 KB, 803x1161, Character Material_53.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4762573

>>4762545

Functionally, Crane Wing and Overedge are identical, except for (presumably) the damage of the last attack, since Overedge reforms Kanshou and Bakuya into larger, (presumably) more damaging forms.

>> No.4762578

>>4762568
I can imagine him beating UBW Shitou and dieing afterwords. But I don't think HF Shirou would lose. MAYBE Shirou would die afterwords.

>> No.4762581

>>4762568
I'm not sure, Shirou with the speed of Nine Lives might be more than Shiki can handle.

>> No.4762584

>>4762531
Ryougi can so beat Tohno/Nanaya.

>> No.4762596

Seriously, you guys are fucking stupid.

The match would probably be a draw because:
1. To use "Unlimited Blade Works" It requires that a spell be chanted. Since the two of them fight at melee distance, it would be very difficult to perform.
2. Since both of them are human, they're (believe it or not) on about on an equal playing field. Considering that Shirou's swords are projections, they will undoubtedly have flaws which result in the lines of death becoming visible. But, Shirou can recreate as many swords as mana permits while Shiki can only keep his eyes strained for so long.
3. No shikifags, Nanaya mode won't kick in. Shirou is human.
4. Yes Shiroufags, unlimited blade works can be destroyed. UBW is just a reality (environment) contained within a barrier, so Shiki can kill it (Reread Ciel's route).

I can imagine the fight now! Two guys with no real strategy rushing head on at one another. Projecting swords over and over again just to have the lines cut, meanwhile both brains are pulsing, their lungs screaming for oxygen, they want to regurgitate blood. The fight goes on for about five minutes before Shirou is out of mana and Shiki is lying on the ground with his brain pounding in his skull like a piston.

tl;dr they're both human and both fight at melee distance using weapons of about the same length. One can kill things instantly and one can create things instantly. A battle of "LUL I KILLED UR SWORD" "LUL I GOT ANTOHER ONE."

>> No.4762594

>>4762581
He wouldn't exactly do Nine Lives on someone he doesn't really need to. But I'm sure he would use other Noble Phantasms.

>> No.4762602
File: 24 KB, 861x324, 1208564048940.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4762602

>> No.4762604

>>4762584
No. No she would not. Akasha personality would. But not Ryougi (1) (Female personality) or Ryougi (2) (Male personality).

>> No.4762613

>>4762604
In a straight up fight she'd fuck him up royally. Any personality.

>> No.4762614

>>4762596

That is...exactly it.

>In the case of him ending up fighting with Tohno Shiki, the probability of defeat is high due to having his projected Noble Phantasms one-sidedly killed, but that is under the precept of Shiki overusing his Mystic Eyes of Death Perception to the point were he will overload and self-destruct after the battle. Also, things would be different if Shirou were capable of an Excalibur-like prana discharge.

>> No.4762617
File: 130 KB, 741x648, 1207755396151.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4762617

>> No.4762626

One can instantly create and the other can instantly destroy.
It's a tie.

>> No.4762633

Protagonist showdown?

>> No.4762634

>>4762596

>Projecting swords over and over again just to have the lines cut, meanwhile both brains are pulsing, their lungs screaming for oxygen, they want to regurgitate blood. The fight goes on for about five minutes before Shirou is out of mana and Shiki is lying on the ground with his brain pounding in his skull like a piston.

Problem: being out of prana just makes you feel tired.
It does NOT eliminate you.

Exhausted Shirou then kicks comatose Shiki until he dies

>> No.4762665

Didn't Nasu say that if Shiki tried to use his eyes on Unlimited Blade Works his head would literally explode?

I remember reading that somewhere.

>> No.4762675
File: 385 KB, 750x1150, powerlevels.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4762675

>>4762665

>> No.4762948

>>4762665

Sorta kinda.

See >>4762614

>> No.4763190
File: 69 KB, 600x450, 1233541844885.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4763190

Yet another power levels thread. I'm game! The way I see it, Shirou/UBW would win out of either pure luck or a battle of attrition. All Shirou has to do is keep projecting swords until Shiki's brain hits the wall, that is, if Shirou can keep up.

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action