/jp/ - Otaku Culture

[ToyDuckGuitar !!E2OnoQD6Kk8 No.]

25 most popular titles on vndb, sorted by rating as of November 11th, 2009:
1 Umineko no Naku Koro ni
2 Ever17 -the out of infinity-
3 Fate/stay night
4 Clannad
5 Tsukihime
6 Cross†Channel
7 Saya no Uta
8 Gyakuten Saiban
9 True Remembrance
10 Planetarian ~Chiisana Hoshi no Yume~
11 Yume Miru Kusuri
12 Kira☆Kira
13 Kanon
14 Narcissu
15 Chaos;Head
16 Utawarerumono
17 Kagetsu Tohya
18 Melty Blood
19 Crescendo -Eien Dato Omotte Ita Ano Koro-
20 Kana ~Imouto~
21 Princess Waltz
22 Yukizakura
23 Wanko to Kurasou
24 Wind -A Breath of Heart-
25 Sagara-sanchi no Etsuraku Life ♪

Discuss.

(previous threads at http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/jp/thread/2864507 and http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/jp/thread/2568873 )

[ToyDuckGuitar !!E2OnoQD6Kk8 No.]

Detailed statistics:
Pop # Rating # Name Popularity Rating
10 1 Umineko no Naku Koro ni 48.71 9.37
3 2 Ever17 -the out of infinity- 82.86 9.27
1 3 Fate/stay night 100 9.07
7 4 Clannad 55.25 9.05
2 5 Tsukihime 92.49 8.91
19 6 Cross†Channel 32.19 8.59
4 7 Saya no Uta 70.82 8.58
24 8 Gyakuten Saiban 27.37 8.53
15 9 True Remembrance 37.59 8.49
8 10 Planetarian ~Chiisana Hoshi no Yume~ 53.85 8.43
5 11 Yume Miru Kusuri 67.71 8.3
21 12 Kira☆Kira 27.88 8.27
22 13 Kanon 27.77 8.16
9 14 Narcissu 52.62 8.13
11 15 Chaos;Head 39.52 8.11
6 16 Utawarerumono 57.93 8.06
14 17 Kagetsu Tohya 38.12 7.91
20 18 Melty Blood 28.76 7.79
13 19 Crescendo -Eien Dato Omotte Ita Ano Koro- 39.07 7.78
12 20 Kana ~Imouto~ 39.14 7.75
16 21 Princess Waltz 37.26 7.72
18 22 Yukizakura 34.85 7.46
17 23 Wanko to Kurasou 36.71 7.4
25 24 Wind -A Breath of Heart- 26.73 7.12
23 25 Sagara-sanchi no Etsuraku Life ♪ 27.6 7.06

[ToyDuckGuitar !!E2OnoQD6Kk8 No.]

Some observations on differences between this list and the last one:
-Cross Channel enters the list at #6. Saya no Uta shifts to #7.
-Gyakuten Saiban enters the list at #8, shifting the rest of the list further down.
-Kira Kira enters the list at #12.
-Chaos;Head's ratings changed, and it has dropped from #10 to #15.
-Same thing with Princess Waltz; it dropped from #16 to #21.
-Red Shift has dropped off the list.
-One has dropped off the list.
-Tears to Tiara has dropped off the list.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706175
>>vndb
Nothing to discuss here.

[Anonymous No.]

Fascinating.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706177
... Bad formatting man. Next time you post one of these clean it up a bit could ya?

Also

>14 Narcissu
Still glad that its going so well for a doujin game.

>20 Kana~Imouto~
My god, it's been years since I last played Kana. ... I miss her ;_;

[Anonymous of Croatia !na1byG1GU. No.]

All I see is a list of translated visual novels, nothing more nothing less. The numbers are random.

[Anonymous No.]

>Kira Kira only at the 21th place on the popularity list
More people should play it.

[Anonymous No.]

Observations:

Sharin isn't on that list when it gets an average of 9.17 with 65 votes.

[ToyDuckGuitar !!E2OnoQD6Kk8 No.]

>>3706296
>Sharin no Kuni
>Popularity
>Ranked #43 out of 2803 with a score of 17.72.

[Anonymous No.]

why is melty blood on there

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706175
What is there to discuss?
I don't go around like a faggot fanboy voting for VN.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706569
What I meant is that popularity isn't a good way to sort VNs.

[Anonymous No.]

1 Ever17 -the out of infinity-
2 Fate/stay night
3 Tsukihime
4 Cross†Channel
5 Saya no Uta

This would make a decent top five of translated VNs imo.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706633
I lol'd.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706633
>0 Umineko

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706633
Why is F/SN there?

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706633
Thank god you aren't making the top 5 then.

[Anonymous No.]

>vndb
Stop using it. Getchu is superior.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706639
>>3706649
What's the matter? Too POPULAR for you?

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706670
>>3706648
>>3706639

Too much discussion about it. The more discussion about it the more you realize about the flaw.

[Anonymous No.]

Untranslated games > Translated games. No exceptions.
When a translation for a game is released, that game instantly becomes dull and boring.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706710
Nah, the game doesn't become dull. We do.
"Oh, I've seen 200 threads about Sharin no Kuni already, I'm so sick of it"
Stick with AGTH and you can enjoy in solitude mostly

[ToyDuckGuitar !!E2OnoQD6Kk8 No.]

>>3706619
Yes, but ratings of unpopular games are less reliable, as there are less votes to decide the average player's opinion.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706708
>Too much discussion about it
>Too much discussion about Cross Channel
>Too much discussion about Saya no Uta

Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah sure.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3706726
At least CC and SnU get some discussion. Where is my Ever17 discussion, /jp/?

[Anonymous No.]

umineko, ever17, fate, clannad, and tsukihime are now all officially shit.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3708091
It was good so no one is bitching

[Anonymous No.]

>>3708091
We used to discuss it all the time, I guess we just ran out of things to say.

[Anonymous No.]

Herpaderp. All I can say for vndb is that it's utterly useless for finding new, decent stuff to play. Then again, seems like I'm shit out of luck whatever I try.

Needs moar horror gaems. :V

[Anonymous No.]

Smalltime

[Anonymous No.]

>FSN #3
>Phoenix Wright #8

Something is wrong here...

[Anonymous No.]

>>3708115
As for FSN and Tsukihime, that as already the case.

[Anonymous No.]

So the Top 25 is just a summary of the English VN community. No surprise there.

[Anonymous No.]

>>3708215
Yeah, really no surprise, coming from an English website.

[Anonymous No.]

http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm5930997
VNDB popularity ranking (based on amount of votes) for 2002~2008 games during january 2009
Excluded: non-eroge (exception for Key works), official translations, free doujin

ロリコン乙