[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 91 KB, 400x419, fujiya20071016cake.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242398 No.3242398 [Reply] [Original]

So /jp/ what will you be voting for in ixrec's poll

Baldr Sky Dive1 "LostMemory"
Sekien no Inganock -What a Beautiful People-
Swan Song
Gore Screaming Show
Himawari
RuiTomo
Saihate no IMA
Hoshizora no Memoria
Never7 -the end of infinity-
Extravaganza

>> No.3242415

in before 200 replies of "my choice is better than yours"

>> No.3242421

Saihate no IMA

>> No.3242429

my choice is better than yours

>> No.3242433

Himawari since it's part of my favorite genre, the great"ADV game about living with loli aliens" genre.

>> No.3242435

>>3242421
Also, aren't there many Japanese-reading Anons who want to see it translated? I expected there to be a lot more nominations for it.

>> No.3242438

>>3242429
No mine is better than yours. Fuck you.

>> No.3242439

I intend on waiting until most the votes are done then choosing among the top contenders.

>> No.3242441

>>3242415
This

>> No.3242444

The cake is a lie, and by extension, the poll is a lie too.

>> No.3242449

Never7.

>> No.3242452

>>3242429
>>3242438

Both of your choices are shit-tier. My choice is god-tier.

>> No.3242457

Baldr Sky
Downvote Swan Song if such still applies.

>> No.3242481

I thought you couldn't vote down in the next poll?

>> No.3242497

I honestly don't know, probably going to roll a die so I can pick between Baldr, Sekien, Swan and Rui.

>> No.3242502

>>3242439
Secret Ballot for final poll.

>>3242481
Correct. No down votes in the final poll.

>> No.3242504

Inganock.

>> No.3242507

SnI. Was originally going to vote Swan Song but if the alternative is some fag /m/ game I might as well support the other likely option.

>> No.3242508

Not voting, because of forums.
If I would vote:
Sekien no Inganock -What a Beautiful People-
Gore Screaming Show

Down:
Baldr Sky Dive1 "LostMemory" because TakaJun may do it.

>> No.3242515

Swan Song.

>> No.3242522
File: 143 KB, 600x800, ing_chara04.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242522

Shameless copy pasta.

So are we going to let those /m/fag crowd the final vote for Baldr Sky Dive1, or try to fight with something else?

Do you want your first fantasy Liarsoft VN and bet on our furry darkhorse Sekien no Inganock?
Or get the short but punchy disaster drama Swan Song, written by Kira Kira writer Setoguchi Ren'ya?
For moe/sci-fi combination you can go to Himawari (scenario-driven) or Memoria (character-driven).
Gore Screaming Show or Extravaganza split the gore/BlackCyc fans into two group, so less chance they could win.
For drama there's Ruitomo with black magic, curses, and occult elements; and Saihate no IMA with internet networking. Both are hardest to translate and very likely only Ixrec could enjoy them as challenge.

Or just let the vote goes along naturally? Have fun.

>> No.3242540

Split between Swan Song and Inganock

>> No.3242548

Swan Song > Never7 > the rest.

I'd be happy to see any of them translated.

>> No.3242552

Ruitomo or Never7

>> No.3242556

What the hell is with this sudden burst of interest in Inganock. And don't try to claim you've always been interested in it because I've seen practically nothing about it posted on /jp/ before this poll

>> No.3242562

Baldr Sky isn't a /m/fag game, it's a fucking great eroge pretty much loved by anyone who played it.

Saihate no Ima is pretty much the spiritual successor of Cross Channel for those who loved it, it focuses on the similar theme of people connecting to other people.

Himawari may be classified as moe sci-fi eroge but at its core it's a beautiful story about moving forward in life, it doesn't focus so much on the sci-fi and much more on the characters themselves.

Hoshizora no Memoria is also quite a good eroge, more on the fantasy side rather than sci-fi though, it's a real moe eroge with great art and one particularly good route.

>> No.3242570

>>3242562
especially since /m/ hates Baldr Sky

>> No.3242573

>>3242556

That's because it was overshadowed by Sharnoth. Inganock is the prequel to Sharnoth though, so it makes sense to play it first.

>> No.3242576
File: 151 KB, 600x800, ing_chara10.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242576

>>3242556
http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/jp?task=search&ghost=&search_text=inganock

We talked about Sharnoth quite a bit, and impressed with Liarsoft brand company. However since before the vote someone offers to translate Sharnoth, the votes all move to Inganock, making it a darkhorse in the voting race.

Most of liarsoft fans prefer the latter too, due to non-intrusive gameplay and scenario.

>> No.3242585

>>3242573
>Inganock is the prequel to Sharnoth
What the fuck? They have nothing to do with each other except thematically, besides, if you were going to mention this then it would make sense to play Selenaria first since it's the first game in the Beautiful series.

>> No.3242588

>>3242576
Sharnoth was quite average, not bad but not really memorable, even if you don't count the horribly boring gameplay part.
Ignanock is better for sure and I quite like it but to say it's better than Baldr Sky, Ruitomo, Swan Song or Himawari?
Personally I don't think so but opinion, etc...

My favorite Liar-soft eroge will always be Forest though, I think I'll make a thread about it to hype it a bit.

>> No.3242589
File: 293 KB, 800x1200, where.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242589

Best two characters of Ruitomo. Routes fucking where? ;_;

>> No.3242593

Saihate no Ima. Just because I want to troll Ixrec.

>> No.3242594

Swan Song

>> No.3242604

>>3242588
>Forest

Never heard of it, you should do that then

>> No.3242624

Swan Song. It's short, so it would be released quickly, and another god tier VN could then begin translation.

>> No.3242626
File: 380 KB, 1250x1000, frie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242626

1) Souten no Celenaria = Celenaria of the Bluest Sky
2) Sekien no Inganock = Inganock of the Brightest Blaze
3) Shikkoku no Sharnoth = Sharnoth of the Deepest Black
4) Hikari no Valcia = Valcia of the Purest Light (Valusia of Shinewhile)

Same theme, and probably universe. Not sequel/prequel in a sense. They all have different storyline, characters, and art style. All have great music though.

>>3242593
That is no trolling. That's a good vote.

>> No.3242629

>>3242507
Swan Song is more likely to win than SnI. If you vote SnI instead of SS, Baldr Sky is actually more likely to win.

>> No.3242646

>>3242626
>That is no trolling. That's a good vote.
I know, but I hear it's really fucking hard to read, and really really fucking hard to translate. I'd like to see Ixrec pulling out his hair trying to translate it. He liked Cross Channel, so he'll probably like that enough to translate it as well, if he can.

>> No.3242705
File: 475 KB, 1250x1000, suny.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242705

>>3242646
He played Swan Song and Sekien no Inganock so far and he liked it. GSS and Baldr Sky Dive1 are waiting on his desktop.

He also likes good challenge, so Ruitomo and Saihate no Ima will be level upgrade and getting rid the hardest stuffs from the VN pool worthy to translate.

>> No.3242711

>>3242588
Forest is fucking weird, though. But I'd like to see it translated.

>> No.3242724
File: 136 KB, 806x632, 80.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242724

>>3242711
Weird but awesome.

>> No.3242729

>>3242705
>Ruitomo
So why is this hard to translate? Lots of technical terms like Saihate? Or just really strange writing like Cross Channel's?

>> No.3242741

>>3242729
Strange writing, lots of play on words.
Tomo loves that kind of shit.

>> No.3242758

>>3242629

Yeah the prelim poll didn't last long enough for you to see SnI's true force. It's definitely the favourite out of it and SS.

>> No.3242772

I'm voting baldr, I don't wanna hear a fucking thing about this "Taka might translate it" shit. I've heard so many MIGHTS when it comes to translations I'm sick of it.

Either he's in the middle of translating it, or he's not. Those are the only two options, and seeing as how he isn't. I'm voting for Baldr

>> No.3242777

>>3242724
...Couldn't you translate it then? I'm sure you could get other people to join the project easily.

>> No.3242789
File: 454 KB, 1250x1000, wedw.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3242789

>>3242758
>>3242629
SnI: Saihate no Ima OR Sekien no Inganock?

>> No.3242802

>>3242789
Pretty sure they mean Saihate.

>> No.3242820

>>3242772
This.

You're a fucking dumbass if you're voting Baldr down (or at this step, not voting for it) just because Takajun "might" translate it.

>> No.3242845

>>3242820
What if I'm voting for something else because I'd rather see them translated?

>> No.3242862

>>3242845

That has nothing to do with what I was bitching about, so there is no problem with that

>> No.3242884

>>3242789

Inganock

>> No.3242894

>>3242845
Read my post again. I don't give two shits about people voting for something else if it's what they want translated. What I do have a gripe about is someone not voting for a particular VN because another translator "might" pick it up.

>> No.3242974

>>3242894
>>3242820

Glad to see you feel the same way about it as me, now let us pray we win(even though I'm pretty sure we won't).

>> No.3243076
File: 627 KB, 800x800, bern.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3243076

>>3242974
I will pray to the Witch of Miracles, comrade. Only then will our victory be assured.

;_;

>> No.3243093

I'm voting for Hoshizora no Memoria
My mind is steel. No one could possibly change my mind.

>> No.3243095

NURSERY RHYME

>> No.3243097

>>3242570
Why? Let me guess, not enough /m/.

>> No.3243111

>>3243097
I think he's just exaggerating. The first thread about Baldr Sky was badly received, because no CGs with mecha were posted and .moelicious was in the link so for some reason they assumed it was "non-/m/ related moe shit". The second one was well received though, because there were a few mecha CGs posted.

>> No.3243113
File: 706 KB, 630x630, 20080704004040.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3243113

I'm going to vote for Himawari because lolis who love to drink and are voiced by Tamura Yukari (in the drama CD only) are my fetish.

>> No.3243137

I am planning to vote Baldr Sky. However I have absolutely the biggest desire to vote for Himawari and Swan Song ;_; and I might have to downvote those to win ;_; seriously, what the hell is this? Some kind of anime? Or is it Princess Waltz? With all the 'making us fight the things we like' ;_;

>> No.3243143

>>3243111
Oh

>> No.3243150

>>3243137
You won't be able to downvote on the final vote.

>> No.3243154

I will let you guys choose for me.
:3

>> No.3243182

>>3243154
Vote Inganock.

>> No.3243201

>>3243111
Another copy pasta:

Sample of bad reception: http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/m/thread/3706518

Sample of *better* reception: http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/m/thread/3709569

Basically as long as the OP pic is mecha, they'll fap. Otherwise gb2/jp/

>> No.3243203
File: 127 KB, 505x723, 1239265693500.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3243203

>>3243182

>> No.3243211

>>3243154
Why don't you choose for yourself?

Do you want scifi? Baldr Sky
Do you want occult? Ruitomo
Do you want drama? Swan Song
Do you want mindfuck? Never7

>> No.3243219

>>3243211
>>Do you want mindfuck? Never7
Weak mindfuck.
Saihate no Ima is more of a real mindfuck.

>> No.3243222

Going to vote for Baldr Sky, as there are no hard sci-fi VNs translated, it also has something to almost everyone.

>> No.3243227

>>3243211
>>3243203
>>3243182
I meant that I am not going to vote.
I will play whatever you guys choose.

Also, is anyone translating Shikkoku No Sharnoth ?
My memory is a bit fuzzy.

>> No.3243237

>>3243227

Apparently but the link someone on /jp/ gave the other day led to nothing more than a person saying "I'm translating it". Which I really don't know if I should be believing that or not

>> No.3243240

GSS

>> No.3243252

>>3243201
Those both look like bad reception to me.

>> No.3243258

>>3243252
Well, one was a little better. And at least one person from /m/ voted for it.

>> No.3243268

>>3243240
I thought you were cool Sudo!

>> No.3243272

Never7 -the end of infinity-

was gonna vote Gore before I saw it

>> No.3243274

Remember11 > Ever17 > Never7

>> No.3243279

>>3243240
Friends don't let friends vote for GSS. Don't do it.

>> No.3243281

>>3243268
>was gonna vote Gore before I saw it

"Saw" it? not sure I understand

>> No.3243293
File: 175 KB, 800x600, 1250450008670.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3243293

>>3243240

Ignore all these haters, odds are they've never even played it.

>> No.3243302

>>3243293
It's mainly the people who have played it who are against voting for it. Everyone who hasn't played it thinks it's the best thing ever just because it has an interesting premise.

>> No.3243313

so when is the voting starting?

>> No.3243319

>>3243281
as in "scrolled through the list"

>> No.3243321

>>3243293
Every GSS voter should vote for Extravaganza as it is superior black-cyc title. But still personally there are some better titles there to translate before them.

>> No.3243322

>>3243313
Ixrec said he wanted to put the vote up once he thought that most people would have finished Cross Channel. So a week at most, probably.

>> No.3243326

>>3243293
Thats because about 20% of /jp/ has some level of proficiency with moonrune. The other 80% likes to pretend.

>> No.3243329

>>3243322

What does CC have to do with this? I fail to understand, does he think people are so busy playing CC that they can't take a whole 2minutes to post a vote

>> No.3243332

>>3243329
I don't know either. But that's what he said. I'll see if I can find the chat log.

>> No.3243336

>>3243332
>http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/jp/thread/S3234181#p3239049
><Ixrec|GSM> how long do you think until everyone finishes CC?
><Ixrec|GSM> the marathoners I mean
><Ixrec|GSM> I'd liek the poll to come after them

>> No.3243337

Can anyone compare 12Riven with Never7, remember11 and Ever17

>> No.3243338

>>3243326
I haven't played all the games in the list, but I've played GSS and I'd say it and Never7 are the least deserving of votes. That isn't to say they are bad, they're good, they're just not as good as the others.

>> No.3243340

>>3243337
Ever17 is the only one that can be considered as really good.
Remember11 isn't bad but honestly is full of wasted potential.
Never7 and 12riven are garbage.

>> No.3243342

>>3243338
This. Seriously, is it so hard to understand? Why does everyone assume that people hate GSS just because they don't think it's the best game ever?

>> No.3243346

>>3243321
Not really. If all Black Cyc titles were the same sort of thing; but they AREN'T. GSS and Extravaganza are very different kinds of games - GSS is a lot nicer, for one thing. It's filled with moe, has fun characters, has Gore, has a really nice traditional Japanese horror setting.. plenty of reasons why it would appeal to people that Extravaganza doesn't appeal to.

Heck, from my point of view, Mugen Kairou 1+2 are better than both those games, but that doesn't mean people should be voting for them instead of Extravaganza or GSS if those games are more appealing to them.

>> No.3243351

>>3243340

That's a pity. Someone did subtitles videos of the beginning of 12Riven, and it looked pretty cool.

>> No.3243355
File: 188 KB, 1440x900, 34.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3243355

I really live this artstyle for some reason.

>> No.3243356

>>3243351
The demo was the best part of the game.

>> No.3243372

>>3243346
Extravaganza has plenty of moe, although not as much as GSS, sure.

>> No.3243497

<Ixrec|BS> chapter 1 finished
<Ixrec|BS> yep, it's that good

BS = Baldr Sky Dive1

>> No.3243504

>>3243372
GSS has too much random rape. It's good but it's a game I'd want to see translated.

>> No.3243540

>>3243497
He's only playing through. He hasn't played BS yet.

>> No.3243576

>>3243268
>>3243279
I've played a little of it and read reviews, it seems intriguing to me. The other two I voted for on the previous poll were Inganock and Swan Song. I may change my vote to one of those two (Inganock is more likely), GSS isn't final.

>> No.3243598

I'll vote for Gore or Extravaganza.

>> No.3243635
File: 306 KB, 1250x1000, plev.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3243635

>>3243576
I don't think you need high-tier translator to tl GSS. I prefer him to translate something which no other translators would touch, such as harder ones.

Swan Song is a good choice.

>> No.3243699

>>3243635
Couldn't Takajun do Swan Song?

>> No.3243747
File: 161 KB, 1250x1000, stay.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3243747

>>3243699
Yes. But that means not picking Baldr Sky Dive1.

>> No.3243766

Just vote for whatever. He'll drop any project Takajun picks up and choose another so either way, it's pretty much a win-win situation considering you get 3 votes.

>> No.3243770

>>3243766
>considering you get 3 votes
Not in the final vote.

>> No.3243808

Changing what I voted for in the prelims, and currently tossing up between Extravaganza and Baldr Sky. So difficult to choose ;_;

>> No.3243895

>>3243808

Black-cyc fans like us really should get together and choose which to pick, I honestly don't care which one we go for.

>> No.3243905

>>3243747
TakaJun doesn't want popular. And we won't get it until December which is when he plays Dive2.

>> No.3243918

Who the hell wants to bother with just part 1 of a game? *coughbaldrskycough*

>> No.3243925

I'm torn between Baldr Sky, Sekien no Inganock, and Swan Song.

>> No.3243959

>>3243895

Lets band together and push Extravaganza. I've already finished Gore, and I'd prefer something I haven't read be translated. That, and /jp/ would troll my beautiful Yuka ;_;

>> No.3243960

I'll probably vote for either Swan Song or Gore Screaming Show.

>> No.3243963

>>3243959
>Yuka
Erotical black hole. Seriously, worse slut since Sakura.

>> No.3243978

>>3243918
That part 1 has more content that many "full" games

>> No.3244027
File: 150 KB, 600x800, ing_chara09.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244027

Another Inganock character because I can.

>> No.3244036

more like Ingacock

>> No.3244047

I guess I'll have to end up voting for Saihate, since it's the only title that's never going to be translated otherwise (although Extravaganza is probably a pretty close second)

>> No.3244049
File: 146 KB, 600x800, ing_chara02.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244049

Swan Song doesn't have lolis.

GSS have old immortal grandma loli.

Baldr Sky have Nanoha, Makoto, and Noi.

>> No.3244055

>>3244047
Me too. It's not as popular as the other titles, though. It barely made the top list.

>> No.3244071
File: 117 KB, 600x800, ing_chara11.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244071

Saihate no IMA doesn't have lolis

Ruitomo and Memoria have flatchest heroines.

Himawari has space alien loli.

Extravaganza has tentacles.

>> No.3244076

>>3244049
>>3244071
Lolis are overrated.

>> No.3244078

I'll vote for Saihate no IMA myself even though it probably won't win; it's not like the popular titles need any help. Even if it doesn't win, something else good will win. None of the games in that list are anything less than fantastic except never7 (which doesn't stand a snowball's chance in hell of winning anyway)

>> No.3244082
File: 126 KB, 600x800, ing_chara03.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244082

Is nekomimi furry?

>> No.3244095

Voting for Inganock.

>> No.3244100

>>3244082
No.

>> No.3244101
File: 159 KB, 600x800, ing_chara21.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244101

How about tiger lady?

>> No.3244105

>>3244071
Saihate no Ima has 2 characters who could be considered loli.
Also a big part of the game is spent on the cast childhood so you get to see all of them in their loli/shota forms.
And one of the healthy heroine has a sex scene in a flashback when she was a delicious loli.

>> No.3244112

>>3244082
That doesn't look like it's only cat ears.

>> No.3244117
File: 189 KB, 600x800, ing_chara19.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244117

Flora moe?

>> No.3244118

The eponymous brain tumor-chan herself would probably be considered 'loli' enough for many people. She's flat-chested, at least.

>> No.3244119
File: 115 KB, 800x600, 21.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244119

Saihate no Ima is fucking great.

>> No.3244122

>>3244117
Mai waifu.

>> No.3244134
File: 151 KB, 600x800, ing_chara18.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244134

...Okay this must be getting too far. Lucky just a side character.

>> No.3244144
File: 187 KB, 600x800, ing_chara13.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244144

Loli, naga-boy, and mecha-legs.

>> No.3244151
File: 101 KB, 600x800, ing_chara20.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244151

I'm sure that's a talking bird.

>> No.3244152

>>3244118
Azusa could be considered loli, or jailbait I guess, junior high level and pretty flat-chested
There's Gene and Shirley who are completely flat too.

>> No.3244183
File: 142 KB, 600x800, ing_chara12.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244183

A smoking naga lady this time.

>> No.3244197
File: 101 KB, 600x800, ing_chara14.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244197

I bet you can make nice reaction image out of this.

>> No.3244211
File: 138 KB, 600x800, ing_chara05.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244211

Marionette heroine.

>> No.3244234

>>3244183

If this is a main character with a route, I'm sold.

>> No.3244244
File: 120 KB, 600x800, ing_chara15.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244244

Big black furry detective.

>> No.3244247

>>3244234
It's not.

>> No.3244258

>>3244247
;_;

>> No.3244261
File: 144 KB, 600x800, ing_chara22.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244261

Winged shota?

>> No.3244271

Saihate no IMA. Wish the dumbasses that voted Never7 had decided to do some research and realised I/O is what they were actually looking for.

>> No.3244278
File: 183 KB, 600x800, ing_chara08.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244278

Heavy chick we got here.

>> No.3244295
File: 161 KB, 600x800, ing_chara17.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244295

Light chick.

>> No.3244309
File: 91 KB, 600x800, ing_chara16.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244309

Every VN needs a troll character.

>> No.3244314

Himawari, definitely.

Because I know it's the only chance we get to ever see it translated.

TakaJun will probably translate Baldr Sky, and Swan Song will probably be translated later.

These are the only 3 I really want to see translated.

>> No.3244321
File: 110 KB, 600x800, ing_chara07.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244321

I see what you did there.

>> No.3244326

I am so torn between Himawari and Sekien no Inganock! I don't know what I will pick.

I love Loli's so Himawari its a real contender, yet, i was very interested in Sharnoth, and I'd be fine playing another Liarsoft title, besides, it has a loli as well.

>> No.3244343
File: 146 KB, 600x800, ing_chara01.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244343

Closing time with the illegal magic doctor protagonist, Gee.

Inganock of the Brightest Blaze.

>> No.3244354
File: 136 KB, 600x800, ing_chara06.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3244354

Oops forgot the last one. This shota must be the real troll.

>> No.3244402

>>3244047
Yeah, same here. I don't expect it to win, but hopefully at least get enough votes not to be forgotten.

>> No.3244492

http://amaterasu.is.moelicious.be/blog/?p=8

SS and SnI will be next.

>> No.3244532

sekien is pure garbage furry shit. Baldr or Himawari is where the votes should go to.

>> No.3244540

>>3244492
So, what's Ixrec going to do? Marathoning the 10 finalists and choose the one he likes the most?

>> No.3244550

>>3244540
Then what would be the point in the final vote? He's probably just reading them now so he can weed out everything he doesn't find "excellent" and take them off the poll.

>> No.3244568

>>3244492
8/10 for the 1st chapter sounds about right.

>> No.3244668

Even if Himawari has Aqua I'm still going for Baldr Sky ;_;

>>3244492
I'm pretty sure he has already played those. He's only playing the games on the top 10 which he hasn't played.

>> No.3244676

>>3244668
I don't think he's finished either of them yet but is still playing them.

>> No.3245501

Swan Song review:

http://amaterasu.is.moelicious.be/blog/?p=16

>> No.3245526

>>3245501
Holy shit, how short is this game?

>> No.3245713

>>3245526
Not super-short, about 12 hours of reading.

>> No.3245811

>>3245713
Ah, since he got 3/4 way through the game that quickly I thought it was even faster than Saya no Uta.

>> No.3246488

bump

>> No.3246568

RuiTomo

>> No.3246584

>>3242562
>Saihate no Ima is pretty much the spiritual successor of Cross Channel
Does it end sadly like CC?

>> No.3246615

if Saihate no IMA is similar to cross channel I'd rather he translated something different. Diversity in ability to choose is in my opinion most important.

>> No.3246623
File: 104 KB, 804x604, p011.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3246623

RuiTomo
it's actually a really fun read

>> No.3246633

I hope either Inganock or Baldr Sky win.

>> No.3246641

So what's the appeal of Inganock? I looked in the CG pack and there's only one hscene and it's furry. It doesn't look like you can do the loli either.

>> No.3246647

>>3246641
The story.

>> No.3246651

>>3246623
dat smile...

>> No.3246654

>>3246641
contrary to expectations, /jp/ doesn't really care about the eroscenes or the heroines. it's more about BRIXSHITTING GRIMDARK SCIFI stories and settings.

>> No.3246661
File: 28 KB, 330x306, B0ABBBD2B8D1A4B5A4F3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3246661

>>3246623
Where is my fucking fandisk.

>> No.3246671

>>3246654
No, I care about the heroine. But I'm even more excited for Iganock now I learn there's no h-scene for her. I want to be the valiant protective brother figure, sex would taint that.

>> No.3246682

>>3246654
Yeah well I don't care for hscenes either unless it's a nukige I'm playing.

So its story really is good? I thought people were voting for it because of its setting.

>> No.3246683

>>3246671
are you one of those faggots who installed FSN with the non-ero option? I wish I could spit in your face.

>> No.3246701

>>3246683
Do you like your mollusk that much?

>> No.3246709

>>3246701
Don't knock it till you try it. Feels good man.

>> No.3246719

>>3246709
>Feels so good I want to vomit.
FTFY

>> No.3246738

Inganock: H scene with a furry but supposedly great story

Baldr Sky: Supposedly great story fucking hard game play and 3 heroines and a priest with chainsaw arms. But has a super cliffhanger ending and it's only half of the full story.

Swan Song: Supposedly great story a couple heroines and a few rape scene's.

>> No.3246779

So when's the next poll due?

>> No.3246894

I can't tell you how much I hate those botvotan reverse weeaboos who need to die asap. That's the cancer killing the eroge industry.

Liarwankoshit ･･･ 81
SWAN SONG ･･･ 84
BALDR SKY ････ 87


VOTE FOR REAL DEAL, BECAUSE IT'S SUPERIOR. JAPANESE PROFESSIONAL EROGE CHAMPS AGREED. REJECT PIG DISGUSTING DISNEY SHIT WITH WASH DOWN LOVEY-DOVEY PLOTS.

>> No.3246898

>>3246738
correction for baldr sky: has rambling insane priest with chainsaw arms voiced by wakamoto, and the endings dont leave any cliffhangers, but there are a lot of unaswered questions/mysteries.

>> No.3246909

>>3246894
>REAL DEAL
This again?

>> No.3246918
File: 33 KB, 400x350, 1162441257575.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3246918

>>3246894
wat

>> No.3246924 [DELETED] 

>>3246898
Another correction btw, the gameplay is not hard, there are FOUR difficult settings.

>> No.3246942

>>3246898
Another correction btw, the gameplay is not hard, there are FOUR difficulty settings.

>> No.3246958

Hoshizora is a fucking retarded moefest.

Swan Song may be pretentious but at least it's better than antyhing else on the list bar Inganock.

>> No.3247035

Baldr Sky's "gameplay" is utter shit btw

>> No.3247074

>>3245501
We will see what he will think after seeing the normal ending.

>> No.3247076

>>3247035
well, that's just matter of opinion, I personally like it a lot

>> No.3247100

>>3246958
Try to actually play them before talking.

>> No.3247168

>>3246942
Try hard mode last boss in Chinatsu's route. That's fucking impossible.

>> No.3247176

>>3247035
Ixrec said it reminded him of ZOE.

>> No.3247181 [DELETED] 

OP here. I just found a far superior board without morons so I'm leaving Retardchan forever now:

http://poosalmer.com/wakaba/wakaba.html (a = h)

>6956e9fbc907fea58a1c5adce058e4bf

>> No.3247208

>>3247176
ZOE? That's odd.

>>3247168
Which last boss? There are two.

>> No.3247236

>>3247176
Sorry but no fucking way. ZoE's epicness came from fluid action, homing lasers, ZERO FUCKING SHIFT, vector cannon and godlike music. Their only common point could be "pew pew robots fightan"

>> No.3247257

>Inganock
>only one hscene
>furry

okay I'm voting Baldr Sky to try to help defeat this shit

>> No.3247273

Baldr Sky looks more like Mechwarrior 3050 than ZOE.

>> No.3247279

>>3247257
She's not really furry.

>> No.3247287

>>3247074
Normal ending remains the most memorable ending I've ever had in an eroge and I played it years ago.

>> No.3247366
File: 427 KB, 805x632, 1251284871260.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3247366

>>3247236
Enjoy your fluid action.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJWuVeL57Xw

>> No.3247385

>>3247366
That pretty clunky with brief stops after each hit

>> No.3247399

>>3247385
That's a sarcasm.

>> No.3248578

* Ixrec|SS is now known as Ixrec|GSM
<Ixrec|GSM> my god, those last two scenes of SS felt like Coco's route
<Ixrec|GSM> and I'm still not even done with act 3!

12 hours ago or so.

>> No.3249179

What is the game play in these games anyway? Baldr Sky sounds scary enough like one with strategy in it, and I like simple ADV style.

Also which game has the best characters? Because I usually play VNs for characters first, story second. (The story is like filling, which adds details to the characters)

>> No.3249213

>>3249179
Only Baldr Sky having intense gameplay (with 4 difficulty levels). Sekien no Inganock have simple investigation/dialogue minigame. The rest are basic ADV/NVL. Check this post: >>3242522

What do you mean about characters? Chara development? Characters chemistry? Gar? Moe?

>> No.3249262

>>3249179
Baldr Sky has 4 different diffucult, and at easiest it's pretty easy and there isnt't too much of those action sequences to distract you from story. Also characters in it are top-tier and there are lots of good interactions between them.
For other games don't really know, but I have heard that ruitomo has good characters also.

>> No.3249265

>>3249213
>Gar? Moe?
Moar

>> No.3249298

>>3249262
Compared to Sengoku Rance or most Alicesoft's 1 hour gameplay and 1 minute story approach, Baldr Sky Dive1 have 1 hours story for 1 minute battle. Simplified comparison though.

Ruitomo is known to have the best characters chemistry. Though I don't know what that means.

>> No.3249316

>>3249265
Baldr Sky has both, theres also bit of both in GSS and Extravaganza, altough not in such good balance. For others don't know as haven't played them.

>> No.3249319

>>3249298
Among all the eroge in that list, Saihate no Ima has the best character chemistry, it's really awesome to see them all interact with each other.

>> No.3249331
File: 115 KB, 800x600, 2009-08-2818-13-051.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3249331

>>3248578
I'm glad Ixrec is liking Swan Song, it's pretty much my favorite eroge, I wonder what he'll make of the ending.

>> No.3249337 [SPOILER] 
File: 158 KB, 1440x900, 37.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3249337

GAR +. Moe?
This?
From Himawari.

>> No.3249475

How good is the soundtracks for these games? I know Baldr Sky has 'Run Through the Sky' which supposed to be really good. This is the only thing I haven't seen asked yet.

>> No.3249488 [SPOILER] 
File: 63 KB, 800x600, 014.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3249488

>>3249337
Aqua is <3. But there are some other awesome characters in the other games too.

>> No.3249487 [DELETED] 
File: 63 KB, 800x600, 014.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3249487

>>3249337
Aqua is <3. But there are some other awesome characters in the other games too.

>> No.3249492

>>3249475
They all have a good soundtrack.

>> No.3249503

So which of these games have proper routes and mulitple endings? The main thing that disappointed me about Cross Channel was the fact that the interactivity meant nothing in the end.

>> No.3249508

>>3249503
More than that, which of the game has a happy ending?
C+C's ending kinda depressed me.

>> No.3249527

>>3249503
Baldr Sky has 3 routes but you have to play them in a certain order.

Inganock is linear.

Swan Song has 2 main endings and a bunch of bad endings. The main endings only branch in the last chapter so you can't really say it has several routes.

GSS has several routes, though you have to play them all to unlock the final and true route.

Himawari has several routes but once again you have to do them in order.

Ditto for Ruitomo

Saihate no Ima doesn't really have different routes, let's say without spoiling too much that it's kinda similar to Cross Channel, only one ending.

Hoshizora no Memoria has several routes, though some routes can only be unlocked after finishing some others.

Didn't play Never7.

Extravaganza has A LOT of different routes and endings.

>> No.3249532
File: 175 KB, 800x1223, 000492.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3249532

>>3249508
GSS endings are actually pretty happy. Not counting the bad ones, of course.

>> No.3249535
File: 478 KB, 1250x1000, tues.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3249535

>>3249475
Shikkoku no Sharnoth Original Soundtrack
http://www.mediafire.com/?tjthwjmm1hl
http://www.mediafire.com/?getojzofygi

Sekien no Inganock Original Soundtrack
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=6OWQX7I3

All these Liarsoft's soundtrack sound graceful and set up great atmosphere.

>> No.3249539

>>3249527
Never7 has a last route that's only unlocked after you finish the first routes.

>> No.3249551

>>3249475
The latest eroge of that list I played was Hoshizora no Memoria and I can say it had an awesome soundtrack.

>> No.3249616

Is Ixrec still waiting for people to finish Cross Channel before the next round of voting?

>> No.3249727

>>3249616
I think it was said that voting would probably start tomorrow

>> No.3249776

>>3249535
Listened through Inganock's OST, and it's incredible. Downloading Sharnoth now.
>>3249727
That would be nice.

>> No.3249852

>>3249535
Fuck yes.
Thanks a lot.

>> No.3250255

So I'm playing Baldr Sky right now and holy fuck the story got me hooked. I'm still at chapter 4 though.
How many chapters does this have?
Also how do you set all the text speed to max, I already set it to max but some of the text aren't obeying it.

This game has my vote.

>> No.3250268

>>3249535
I've been downloading Baldr Sky's Material Disk off torrent for a while now, thank you for a direct download. As Baldr Sky's Material Disk only has 2 Seeds I can connect too.

Note: Material Disk contains some of the soundtrack.

>> No.3250296
File: 200 KB, 800x1125, 000268.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3250296

The GSS people are so screwed, no way he's gonna find that game excellent when *trying* one of the first 3 routes, the best routes come after.

I'm gonna lol even more when he happens to decide on misono's route. That route is so fucked up and different from the others

>> No.3250378

>>3250255
theres 14/15 chapters depending on route and 3 different routes that diverge on chapters 4/5 also theres 2/3 different endins depending on route (the final chapter is different). theres sometimes parts where the text dont obey the speed settings, but there shouldn't be too many of them

>> No.3250421

>>3250378
Thanks. I guess I can live with the text speed, kinda annoying though.

>> No.3250453

>>3250421
How often do you get those text slowdowns? there really shouldn't be many of them, only at the most important points of plot and you sound like that you are having them all the time?

>> No.3250648

>>3250296
Akane's route is pretty weird too, if you ask me. In fact, Aoi's route is probably the most "normal" one of them. And that doesn't tell much in GSS.

>> No.3250660

>>3250648

Luckily Aoi was the character I liked the most, by far.

>> No.3250722
File: 92 KB, 800x600, 000149.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3250722

>>3250660

She changed her hair, and even was willing to get her friend gang-raped just for you anon. Of course your gonna love her

>> No.3250838

>>3250255
In some Visual Novels I've noticed the text drops speed at random parts I think it happens at random. Does it go to the default speed or maybe even a bit slower?

>> No.3250886

To me, Saihate no IMA seems by FAR the best game on that list (except maybe Baldr Sky, which I've already played). Can't believe it wasnt' among top 3 in the preliminary voting.

It's a shame we can't downvote in the final voting. The only reason GSS didn't win the last time around was because it was getting so many downvotes. It's probably going to win the actual voting hands down.

>> No.3250930

What IRC channel does Ixrec hang out at?

>> No.3250938

>>3250930
#ammy@irc.rizon.net

>> No.3250945

>>3250886

Somehow I doubt that, but it's like I said before. He won't find it excellent anyways. Also if GSS does win it's because everyone else is so fucking spread out on votes

>> No.3250968

>>3250938
Thanks, bro

>> No.3250992

>>3249527

as a completion fag, that makes me want to vote for GSS even more so than I already do.

>> No.3251522
File: 97 KB, 800x600, pel_04.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
3251522

Wild Androgynous petition thread.
>>>/d/1859951

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action