[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 85 KB, 250x260, 250px-Battler_death.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977204 No.2977204 [Reply] [Original]

Witches don't exist. We know this to be a fact.

So who do YOU think is killing everyone /jp/? Personally, I say it's Kinzo.

>> No.2977211

Come back after you've read more than the first episode.

>> No.2977209

Depends on the episode.

>> No.2977215

>>2977209
Let's say three.

>> No.2977214

Battler

>> No.2977216

It's you, OP. You are the killer.

>> No.2977222

>>2977214
...Holy shit, that works!

>> No.2977223

>>2977215
We know Eva is at least a culprit because she kills Battler. Not sure who is conspiring with her, Hideyoshi maybe, perhaps Rudolf and Kyrie are culprits too.

>> No.2977225

The killer is the answer to who was phone.

>> No.2977230
File: 33 KB, 240x249, 1245940339420.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977230

>> No.2977233

>>2977223
I'd pin the first twilight of episode 3 on Rudolf and Kirie.

>> No.2977239
File: 169 KB, 527x480, The true culprit 2.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977239

Jessica is the mastermind every ep. She may or may not get her hands dirty

>> No.2977260

Ep 3

Nanjo is already dead
Nanjo believes in witches
Nanjo is not Nanjo

>> No.2977271

>>2977260
Nanjo is a witch.

>> No.2977280
File: 112 KB, 534x479, jessicatrice alt.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977280

>> No.2977283 [SPOILER] 
File: 37 KB, 180x208, culprit.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977283

I'm friends with Ryukishi07, here's a MASSIVE SPOILER revealing the culprit. Don't tell him I posted this.

>> No.2977291

>>2977260
I don't know what the hell you're talking about, but Nanjo is pretty suspicious. I'd place him more as the staker/symbol writer though.

>> No.2977292

>>2977222
>>2977214
That goes against the rules of mysterys.

The detective cannot be the culprit.

>> No.2977317

>>2977292
Actually there was a Higurashi arc (I think it was manga only) that did just that.

>> No.2977325

>>2977292
Do you really think Ryukishi cares about that?

Also, there is more than one Battler. Or something.

>> No.2977335

>>2977325
Ryukishi has already referenced the rules before.

And can you show me evidence of the existence of another Battler? You can't, can you?

>> No.2977341

>>2977292
The rules of mystery also say doctor must be trustworthy.

>> No.2977350

>>2977341
I'd certainly trust Nanjo to diagnose me after I'm dead.

Or to tell me that my grandfather is perfectly healthy.

>> No.2977362

>>2977204
>>Witches don't exist
Fuck off and die shitty band wagoner.

>> No.2977360

>>2977317
Higurashi is entirely different. Keiichi is hardly the 'detective' of the series.

>> No.2977369

>>2977362
Show me proof that magic exists.

>> No.2977372
File: 42 KB, 426x400, 1234742291094.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977372

Kohaku.

>> No.2977373

>>2977335

Red text from the exchange between Battler and Beato:
My name is Ushiromiya Battler.
It was from Ushiromiya Asumu that Ushiromiya Battler was born.

This Battler cannot say that he himself was born from Ushiromiya Asumu.

Therefore, there has to be another Battler that WAS born from Asumu separate from meta-Battler. Maybe it's a simple meta-Battler piece-Battler distinction (piece-Battler was born from Asumu while meta-Battler was created in a different fashion) but in any case, that at least proves the existence of a Battler separate from himself.

>> No.2977375

obviously it's Jessica and she makes the servants help her

>> No.2977377

>>2977292

The detective isn't Battler though, it's the Meta-Battler who is watching from outside.

Episode 3 makes in-game Battler suspicious, since there's a survivor after he's killed.

>> No.2977380

>>2977373
I don't think you get how baby making works...

>> No.2977387

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8cGDmpDV-A

Video that reveals the culprit

>> No.2977381

>>2977373
The most simple explanation for that is the original Battler died shortly after being born, and the Battler we know was used to replace him. Asumu/Kirie child switch.

>> No.2977393

>>2977372
*Guinness Beer Exchange*

>> No.2977399

Everyone is in on it at some point except battler.

>> No.2977409
File: 49 KB, 512x384, 1232925126856.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977409

>>2977387
Of course!

>> No.2977411

>>2977381
This. Asumu was going to name her kid Battler and then she had a miscarriage. She steals Kyrie's kid through a conspiracy or maybe Kyrie gave it up herself and he was also named battler.

I doubt the fact that battler is not Asumu's son will have any large significance in future.

>> No.2977412

>>2977214
Dnied in red I think.

>> No.2977415

>>2977399
Nobody is actually dying. It's a huge inside joke just to troll Battler after being away for 6 years.

>> No.2977417

>>2977399
Everyone isn't REALLY dying. There are no murders or murderers or magic or anything like that. It's all just a surprise party just for Battler.

Welcome home, Battler!

I hope you wake up from this dream, soon.

>> No.2977425

>>2977381
The simplest explanation is: we've been trolled.

>> No.2977421

>>2977415
>>2977417
What the, get out of my head, Sakura.

>> No.2977422

>>2977415
Well, I wouldn't put it past grandfather

>> No.2977437

>>2977431
Looks like the red is the only thing we can trust.

And Gohda

>> No.2977431

Nanjo has to be in on it. All the servants with the golden eagle are in on it. Jessica is in on it. George is in on it. Maria is in on it. Natsuhi is in on it in first episode. Rosa in second. Eva in third. Kyrie in 4th.

>> No.2977439

It's all a dream

>> No.2977440

>>2977415
>>2977417

Best ending ever.

>> No.2977446

6 years ago Battler told Jessica and Maria that their little witches game was stupid.

>> No.2977452

>>2977446
I went "holy shit", but then I remembered that Maria was angry at Jessica, not Battler

>> No.2977454

>>2977415
>>2977417
The Game already did it.

>> No.2977460

>>2977437
Can't trust Gohda because all the other servants threatened him.

>> No.2977462

Which episode was it where Jessica stopped Kumasawa from telling a story? Did we they ever elaborate on that?

>> No.2977466

>>2977452
Maria would be angry at Jessica if she passes of magic as stupid whenever Battler is in earshot. She doesn't understand it's sekret.

>> No.2977471

>>2977387
Im liking this one, however:
http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm7516387

>> No.2977475

>>2977462
Isn't it in episode 1? It was probably just a generic scary story about Beatrice.

>> No.2977487
File: 21 KB, 327x216, 1245742449529.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977487

>>>/rs/when_you_die_in_the_game_you_die_for_real

>> No.2977491

I say it's Godha.

>> No.2977505

>>2977491
He did get fired from his last job. I wonder why.

>> No.2977511

George is the real main character of Umineko

>> No.2977514

>>2977505
probably because he kept eating the food

>> No.2977532

>>2977528
I'm pretty sure Battler's blue about small bombs was not refuted.

>> No.2977528

>>2977491

He's the main chef, so he could've slipped something into the food. Hallucinogens?

>> No.2977526

>>2977514
Well it is delicious

>> No.2977527

>>2977204
Kinzo is already dead.

>> No.2977533

>>2977527
What? Kinzo is shown multiple times in episodes 1 and 2.

>> No.2977535

>>2977532
It wasn't. Every crime = small bombs.

>> No.2977538

>>2977533
Kinzo died before the start of the game. He is therefore outside of Beato's field of influence. He is burned every time to hide his time of death.

>> No.2977547
File: 631 KB, 800x600, smallbombs.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977547

>>2977535

>> No.2977575

It's always the butler.

>> No.2977578 [SPOILER] 
File: 13 KB, 150x112, redherring.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977578

Don't worry guys, I've found the REAL culprit

>> No.2977595

>>2977578
I'm laughing like an idiot
Well played, anonymous

>> No.2977596

>>2977575
BUT THERE ARE 5 SERVANTS
3 MALE ONES
AND 2 BUTLERS

>> No.2977602

RUH-ROH RHAGGY!

>> No.2977637

The murderer is Goat-Kun!!

>> No.2977640
File: 32 KB, 250x142, neuro.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977640

Hannin wa omae da

>> No.2977651

>>2977637
Goat-kun is a fucking loser.

>> No.2977660

>>2977651
I know right
just like the rest of us

>> No.2977671

>>2977660
No, Goat-kun has hopes, he has dreams. Hes got real life experiences, his sempais, and even a girl back home hes going to marry. He even has mackerel curry.

>> No.2977675

LITTLE GIRL LITTLE GIRL HAAH HAAH

>> No.2977863
File: 48 KB, 646x505, Scrn.0013 20.43.33.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2977863

>> No.2979579

>>2977292

This. I'm sure Ryu-kun is breaking some mystery genre "rules" as it is, but I don't see him pulling this shit. If he does I'm going to rage SO hard.

>> No.2979593

>>2977292
I doubt Ryukishi07 gives a shit about some made up rules.

>> No.2979610

Battler due to roid-rage. He then killed himself when he came to his senses.

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action