[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 41 KB, 743x491, archerideal.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2199229 No.2199229 [Reply] [Original]

So basically in Nasuverse, you shouldn't help other people , and put your own needs before anything else ?

Whoa. Wonder why they always teach us in elementary school to care for others.

>> No.2199251
File: 24 KB, 308x500, b17e901e3a766ec4c5e1f65432cdad70.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2199251

Poor Archer, he really is the epitome of "nice guys finish last and then become assholes."

>> No.2199254
File: 69 KB, 432x720, temperance.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2199254

Sorry, I was meaning to post an Archer pic.

>> No.2199256

FSN's theme is how to conciliate ideals and reality. Archer was trying to save everyone and ended up having to kill a lot of people to do it, whereupon he became bitter about his beliefs.
Where the fuck are you reading "it's wrong to help others"?

>> No.2199257

>>2199229
No, the point was that trying to save everyone is impossible, and trying to be that ambitious will only result in you turning in a broken, bitter shell of a man.

>> No.2199261

>>2199257
But hey, you save a lot of people in the end.
That's good.

>> No.2199305

It's not about either extreme.

The storys ultimate moral is that no one path is suited for anyone, You need to walk your own path with conviction and strength, whether it's following a childish ideal, or abandoning your innocence to ensure happiness.

>> No.2199369

>>2199261
But he failed to achieve his ideal (just as Kiritsugu had). As a result he was left a bitter shell.

>> No.2199375

>>2199369
The outcome was positive from the point of view of humanity, though.
So it was the better choice.

>> No.2199427

>>2199369
It's not so much he failed to fulfill the idea, as it failed him. You could say the whole world is wrong if conflicts can never cease, even in a minimal scale.
Heck, the reason he died is not because he tried to do something beyond him, fell in battle etc, he was executed for the crime of one he saved yadda yadda.

Archer's ideal is too good for the world.

>> No.2199708
File: 40 KB, 450x450, archer'sworsenightmare..gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2199708

>>2199427
Archer's story has to be the ultimate BAD END of Type-Moon. He had a lover that he lost, we don't know if she left him or died and who she was, he lost Ilya and was betrayed by one of the people he saved. He fucked up his body trying to help people, made a deal to the fucking world to SAVE people and the reward for all of this?

Being sent to hell over and over again to wipe away the disaster. So, in a moment of desperation he plans a Xanitos Gambit to create a time paradox so he never existed, except he even knows the chance is less than zero.

Jesus Archer . . .

Why won't anyone give you a good end?

>> No.2199749
File: 45 KB, 300x300, archerilya..jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2199749

>> No.2199759

>Jesus Archer . . .
>Why won't anyone give you a good end?

It's Shirou.

Even the three scenarios still point Shirou to the same direction. Afterall in UBW ending, Rin can still fail at stopping Shirou to grow up as Archer in personality.

>> No.2199769

>>2199708
What foolishness, Instead of trying to save people, what he should of been doing was trying to kill the world!

>> No.2199858

>>2199769
There's no finesse in that.
now, TAKING OVER the world, now that's an idea.

>> No.2199911

>>2199427
>he was executed for the crime of one he saved

I remember it saying he got killed by a person he saved, not because of it? I always thought that was a fitting thing to make him lose every hope in keeping its ideal.

>> No.2200017

>>2199911
Al elaborated elsewhere, ONE of the people he saved in that big disaster, was one of the people responsible(or he was the only one responsible, but you get the point).
And after he was saved, and people wondered 'How the fuck this happened', suddenly 'ARCHER DID IT'.

And with the world against him, even if it was an undeserved fate for him, since he at least saved everyone in his sight, he had no regrets at that point, and he accepted it.

Hence, why people say shit 'Archer is emo', they should be stoned.

>> No.2200044
File: 42 KB, 450x543, archerbondage.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2200044

>>2200017
Thank you! Archer's not emo, just occasionally batshit insane.

But, Even though that Archer=Shirou, but Shirou/=Archer. Heroic Spirit EMIYA has nothing to get him out of that pact. It states very clearly in UBW that he cannot be saved and that chances are he's not going to recall that promise he made to Rin. It'll be in his records, but he may never see it again.

>> No.2200070

>>2200044
Not insane.
Very, very bitter. Ad angry at the fucked up teenager he was/is.

>> No.2200085
File: 234 KB, 770x514, e705c5395d63cc9bba1fe2300b86a65b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2200085

>>2200017
>Hence, why people say shit 'Archer is emo', they should be stoned.
Easily trolled, I see.

>> No.2200093

>>2200085
Not really, I never respond to such posts.
Just die a little inside.

>> No.2200110

>>2200044

That is because Archer is just a copy of Heroic Spirit Emiya.

Remember what made Saber special was that she remembered the events as she was the real Arthuria and not a copy, Heroic Spirit Emiya is screwed because he already out of the time axis as even if Archer got Shirou killed nothing would have changed.

>> No.2200142
File: 140 KB, 1024x768, archercrows.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2200142

>>2200110
No, Archer is not a copy of EMIYA. He IS Emiya. Because he's a counter guardian and not a true heroic spirit he gets Records of each war he fights in. Except those records are not placed in any certian order. He has to find each record and read over them. They're not memories.

But, Archer has records of every version of the fifth he fought in. He is not a copy like Lancer or Rider or the others. He is Emiya, just like Saber is Arturia.

>> No.2200162

ANYBODY ELSE THINK THIS IS FUCKING STUPID BECAUSE THIS WAY OF THINKING ONLY WORKS IN ANIMELAND

>> No.2200170

>>2200162
not really

>> No.2200195

>>2200162
Not really, no.
What you do with your life, at what extent you follow your ideals and beliefs and whether you regards them more than the view of the world for you for example, apply everywhere.

>> No.2200237
File: 65 KB, 800x600, hollowhotspring.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2200237

>>2200162
Ah the smell of troll.

>> No.2200258

>>2200162
YES, BUT MAYBE TURN OFF YOUR CRUISE CONTROL

>> No.2200311

>>2200142

He is a copy dumbass, you even explained WHY he is one you dumbass, dont get hang up on terminology since ever since the Grail was corrupted it can create some else that just heroic spirits ... Rider, Caster and True Assassin would never been summoned otherwise.

They are copies, none of their memories go back to the original because that is what the Grail does, it creates copies ... not summon the originals.

Saber is the only exception to that because she is still alive when she is summoned and that is because The World intervenes.

>> No.2200963

This thread makes me feel sad...

>> No.2201011

>>2200311 True Assassin would never been summoned otherwise

True Assassin was originally the only Assassin that could be summoned.

>> No.2201087

For a while I actually thought Archer was a fictional character like Assassin, specifically one that Shirou had based on himself and written a story about.

>> No.2201159
File: 76 KB, 400x400, f810bf16322205c2e956d781017044aa.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201159

>>2199708
You know who else got shafted? Bazette.
Nasu hates the Irish, I know it.

>> No.2201170

>>2201159
Is this StPals art? I thought they only did chibis and shit

>> No.2201181
File: 84 KB, 400x400, 45ff35abfb09f9a4e20ed9303fffc126.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201181

>>2201170
He does a wide variety of things.

>> No.2201184
File: 83 KB, 400x400, 1208835686912.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201184

>>2201170
Nah, he did a lot of F/SN work.

>> No.2201188

>So basically in Nasuverse, you shouldn't help other people , and put your own needs before anything else ?

That should be the case IRL

>> No.2201205

>>2201159
whut? Bazette wasn't even mentioned in FSN except as a generic master killed off, and in Hollow Ataraxia thanks to servant Anonymous she manages to survive and find inner peace with herself.

>> No.2201217

Nasu is saying that you can do anything you want to. Just don't become an emo faggot and try to kill yourself or turn back time just because you didn't get what you wanted. Saber and Archer are both fagets. Iskander is the man.

>> No.2201222

>>2201205
Her major goal in life was to rescue Cuchulain from his fate. Hell, she even got him as a Servant - then, suddenly, Kotomine.

>> No.2201229

>>2201222
And she grows the fuck up in hollow ataraxia and gets a good end.

>> No.2201239
File: 129 KB, 700x525, ed53e8dcd1a09bebc7ca04b8802c3815.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201239

>>2201217
I hereby support this statement.

>> No.2201258
File: 43 KB, 634x474, whackoff.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201258

Shiki doesn't care about Ciel's bathroom pipes.

>> No.2201260

>>2201229
Still, she was shafted in F/SN. Which is sad, because if she was around them, her fight with Kuzuki would have been epic.

>> No.2201269

>>2201239

samefaggery

>> No.2201282

>>2201269
Ah, what? I was only looking for an excuse to post that pic.

>> No.2201291
File: 166 KB, 604x517, orei3.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201291

>>2201269
Because only one person likes Iskander?

>> No.2201307
File: 450 KB, 960x1338, 1232514847124.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201307

Iskander highjack.

>> No.2201311

>>2201258
>Ciel's bathroom pipes
If you know what I mean.

>> No.2201313

Archer has memories of every time he's summoned. He says as much.

>> No.2201320

>>2201313
Every time he's summoned as a counter guardian. He won't remember the events of the Grail war, wjoch is pretty sad considering RIn and Shirou were finally able to restore his resolve.

>> No.2201321

>>2201313
He has records you dumb faggot. All the copied heroic spirits that participate return to the root, that's how the path is made. They all get the record of their experience in the holy grail war. However, it is unlikely that they will ever "remember" any holy grail war they experience because that information is insignificant to the information from the era received from the holy grail and their own memories.

>> No.2201332

>>2201320
which*

>> No.2201336
File: 251 KB, 800x570, saber drunk.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2201336

haha i have been looking for an excuse to post this pic.

>> No.2201345

>>2201260
>Still, she was shafted in F/SN.
Except she didn't yet exist at the time, how can she get shafted? You're thinking retroactively.

>> No.2201358

>>2201345
Huh ?
She was Lancer's master.
The one whose arm was found.

>> No.2201361

>>2201336
Oh you!
I don't know if that picture make me wanna cry or laugh.
Or maybe just give me raging hard-ons

>> No.2201362

>>2201336

I cant tell if Saber is taking part in that willingly or not...knowing Gil, probably not.

>> No.2201366

>>2201358
Bazette "existed" in F/SN in the same sense that Ren "existed" in Tsukihime.

>> No.2201374

>>2201361
It's just three bro-kings chilling out. Nothing sexual about it.

Unless you want to have sex with your bros, which isn't awesome.

>> No.2201383

>>2201345
But, she was there. She's part of canon now, and thus, got shafted.

>> No.2201389

>>2201336

This is instantly and permenantly my new favourite picture.

>> No.2201400

>>2201383
That's like saying Bill got shafted in Kill Bill vol. 1

>> No.2201410

>>2201374
Saber is a hoe, Gilgamesh and Iskander agreed.

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action