[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 478 KB, 690x389, Marisa Sakuya Reimu.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13701417 No.13701417 [Reply] [Original]

So JP which fight was better
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H8ROf8ZOA1Y

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G98Pn4JLDR8

>> No.13701453

>>13701417
I stopped caring long time ago to be honest, I even haven't watched the latest one.

>> No.13701551

>>13701417
Minus because his Marisa doesn't have a broom piercing her dress.

>> No.13703238

That broom clipping through her skirt looks ridiculous.

>> No.13703251

>>13701417
Minus' video is amazing.

>> No.13703266

is Yukari strong enough to fight 3 playable characters at once?

>> No.13703273

>>13703266
Danmaku has nothing to do with strength, so that's not the question.

>> No.13703292

>>13703273
Strong youkai = strong danmaku.

thats why a fairy can be a stage 6 boss

>> No.13703306

First video is better.

MinusT is terrible as always. The whole video my head was filled with 2 questions: "what the fuck is happening here?" and "why should I care about anything happening here?".
Music choice is awful ,especially in the final part of the battle.
It heavily suffers from lack of sound effects.
No exposition, no climax, 10 minutes of almost monotone flying around. The last survival spellcard looked so fucking stupid. The most anticlimactic ending of the fight possible.

At least it's better than his previous video with Yuyuko.

>> No.13703325

>>13703306
Fuck you it was great.

>> No.13703671

>>13701417
minus has gotten better, that was pretty fantastic

>> No.13703887
File: 682 KB, 980x1284, 3a42135bc30fd4e1db4d1988bfd78aa1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13703887

MinusT is fantastic as always.


Although the amount of eye porn that may be in their next Okuu video will not likely match the amount of testosterone in the other Okuu fight.

Still, it's going to be amazing as fuck.

>> No.13705182

>>13703306
The talking and other retarded made up plot events that he puts in are worthless. It's neat to see how he renders the actual spell cards though. The Marisa/Flandre video is his best.

>> No.13705266

>>13705182
>The talking and other retarded made up plot events that he puts in are worthless
I wonder why there are no action films without any dialogues/plot and with just non-stop explosions and shooting. Though I bet you would love such movie.

>It's neat to see how he renders the actual spell cards though.
Neat? In Okuu's 3D Dogifght video author replaced red bullets of Subterranean Sub with fragments of wall That's why I call NEAT.
MinusT just makes carbon copy of original spellcards even if they look extremely stupid in 3D. Like for example Danmaku Barrier. Why the hell did Reimu stay inside it? There were huge gaps in it, she could just fly away at any time. In game you are limited by screen boundaries, but in video there is absolutely no reason for Reimu to rush to the middle after each wave. It looked extremely retarded.

>> No.13705316

>>13701417
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9prBkwb0Og

I really like this one.

>> No.13705330

>>13705316
I prefer Okuu one without sound effects

>> No.13705333

>>13705330
Oh yeah that one is good too.

>> No.13705423

I like the Reisen one, the one that ends with Tewi stealing everyone's wallets.

>> No.13706074

>>13701417
>>13703306
I think MinusT is what wrestling fans would call a "spot monkey".
https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20090329002717AAaDyZZ

>> No.13706934

>>13705266
The talking/context is already provided in the fucking game. Play it and ya will find out.

The videos are obviously meant to be his reinterpretation of the game's battles and how danmaku looks in 3D.

>> No.13706968

>>13706074
Except there is REASON behind these videos, they are meant to interpret the game's battles.

>> No.13707123

>>13701417
MinusT's.

>> No.13707216

>>13706934
>The talking/context is already provided in the fucking game. Play it and ya will find out.
I don't think game explains why Reimu, Marisa and Sakuya are fighting TOGETHER vs Yukari. Because it didn't happen.
And I wasn't complaining about lack of "plot" anyway, it was more about lack of intro/buildup.

>The videos are obviously meant to be his reinterpretation of the game's battles and how danmaku looks in 3D.
That's why I gave a perfect example of why his "interpretation" is stupid. You can't just blindly copy game mechanic. Imagine a movie based on a JRPG where heroes stay in line and make their attacks in turn.

Well, it's SHINY and that's why all the fags like it. It will definitely win this year's nico contest. And that's sad.

>> No.13707271

>>13707216
He obviously doesn't blindly copy game mechanics since it's a 3 vs 1, and it's fucking 3D, it wouldn't even work if he sticks to strictly 2D play style with the heroes going back and forth while the villain only moves slowly.

And no it's not just shiny, it's well-choreographed and look fucking impressive.

And all the intro/build up can be interpreted from the games, it's obviously the plot from PCB.

>> No.13707303

But the question is, will he make video better than this one?
https://youtu.be/lx3Tq0QLoOU

>> No.13707403

>>13707271
>He obviously doesn't blindly copy game mechanics
So why did he copy the strategy for beating Danamku Barrier? It obviously doesn't work in 3D. By the way the other survival spellcard (Boundary Between Youkai and Human if I recall correctly) looked extremely stupid too. I would call it "fish in aquarium".

>it's well-choreographed
I'm not sure about it

>look fucking impressive
and that's just synonymous to SHINY.

>And all the intro/build up can be interpreted from the games
You seriously don't understand the role of character introduction and buildup. How about creating mood? Or just creating a bare minimum of affection to characters?

>> No.13707440

>>13707403
>So why did he copy the strategy for beating Danamku Barrier? It obviously doesn't work in 3D. By the way the other survival spellcard (Boundary Between Youkai and Human if I recall correctly) looked extremely stupid too. I would call it "fish in aquarium".
Because at that point he's trying to make it look the game, duh.
>I'm not sure about it
His choreography rivals actual professional work.
>You seriously don't understand the role of character introduction and buildup. How about creating mood? Or just creating a bare minimum of affection to characters?
The characters are already introduced in the fucking game, we all fucking know them and their motivation. The mood is already created by the fight and the music, the affection can also be felt by how hard they fight.

>> No.13707456

>>13707440
>make it look like the game*

>> No.13707500

>>13707440
>Because at that point he's trying to make it look like the game, duh.
And as I already said 3 times it looks extremely stupid.

>The mood is already created by the fight
The mood for fight is created by fight. Yeah.

>and the music
You mean THIS ONE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RHEiY0rOQ2k? What mood does it even create? It's some playful-happy shit and not something suited for an intense fight. It's not suited for any fight at all.
If he wanted to make it look like the game why didn't he copy the original mood of the battle?

>> No.13707514

>>13707500
>And as I already said 3 times it looks extremely stupid.
It's danmaku, I accept it. Danmaku is not about practically, it's about beautiful pattern.
>The mood for fight is created by fight. Yeah.
Exactly what it sounds, the harder we fight, the more in the mood we are.
> It's some playful-happy shit and not something suited for an intense fight.
That's definitely not playful-happy shit, it's a nice instrumental with some rocking tunes actually.
>If he wanted to make it look like the game why didn't he copy the original mood of the battle?
Because he's being selective, he mixes his own style in his reinterpretation of the battle.

>> No.13707550

>>13707514
>It's danmaku, I accept it. Danmaku is not about practically, it's about beautiful pattern.
And we are back to SHINY. Yeah, this video has lots of bloom and other shader effects and it looks like it's all that matters for you.

>it's a nice instrumental with some rocking tunes actually.
So it's not playful-happy shit because it's instrumental? And it suits for a fighting scene because it has electro gutar, right? I don't see any point in continuing this discussion after this.

>> No.13707556

>>13707550
Yeah, you think it looks stupid, I think it looks awesome. You also has a different perception of music.

Not much else to discuss.

>> No.13707561

>>13707556
>you also have*

>> No.13707601

>>13707556
Yeah, because you have shit taste. I wasted several minutes explaining why it looks stupid and in the end you ended with "oh, I guess we have different tastes" bullshit. Why did you even join this discussion if you know you won't be able to back your words?
Open minded shiteaters like you is the main reason we don't have nice things any more.

>> No.13707648

>>13707601
Not the guy you're fighting with, but please stop sperging out.
Thank you.

>> No.13707780

>>13701417
I prefer the above more than MinusT's. The fighting chirography is more visually impressive IMO. It means they are using their powers to the fullest, while MinusT's is a bunch of dicking around.

>> No.13708408

>>13707780
Top one felt like it was animated by a guy who was gargling Yukari's dick.

>> No.13708668
File: 372 KB, 1920x1080, [Touhou 3D] Humans vs Yukari.mp4_snapshot_11.03_[2015.06.29_13.18.04].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13708668

>>13701417
I wish he uploaded this somewhere else.

>> No.13708948

>>13707303
The camerawork is nice, but the models and spells look like shit.

>> No.13708949
File: 130 KB, 587x562, Yukarin's balls.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13708949

>>13708408

>> No.13708957
File: 933 KB, 300x300, 1391106394193.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13708957

the video that wasn't cringe-worthy
none

>> No.13708990

I think his Reimu vs Remilia video was a masterpiece while his other works kinda lacking ballance between accurate representation and common sense. Yuyuko and Yukari ones also too distended and repeat themself, especially Yuyuko one.

>> No.13709210

I'm a bit disappointed by minusT too. I usually like his interpretation of the spellcards in 3D, but here you mostly have close up of the characters flying at high speed and you can't see shit. Not a fan of his music choices either.

>> No.13709220

>>13703306
look at you being contrarian

>> No.13709222

god i hate this site sometimes

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action