[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 520 KB, 842x1191, sheet.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9543944 No.9543944 [Reply] [Original]

Detailed results on the 10th Anniversary Type Moon popularity contest are out:

http://www.typemoon.com/special/special_tm10thkekka/votefes/index.html

>> No.9543953

That's some shitty taste.

>> No.9543964

what a pile of shit

>> No.9543969
File: 212 KB, 800x600, 1nl9.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9543969

>>9543953
I'm disappoint that the best girl only got 17th place.

>> No.9543974

My my, what shallow taste.
I still don't see the appeal of Saber.

>> No.9543978

The male results are pretty much invalid because of all the fujoshi who piled on the franchise because of F/Z.

As for the girls... Illya, Akiha ;_;

Rest is more or less predictable and my favorite girl is high enough, so I'll permit it.

>>9543974

I don't care much for her, but if you don't understand the appeal of the most perfectly executed moe character in recent history, you must be new to the whole otaku entertainment thing.

>> No.9543984

is fourth tohsaka?
It doesn't look like tohsaka.

also why isn't shiki there, but shirou is?
Shirou's pretty retarded.

>> No.9543991

>>9543984
They like Shirou because he has a chance to become manly EMIYA.

>> No.9544000

>>9543969
Even worse, the second and third best are right next to her. I don't think I'll ever be happy with popularity rankings, especially not Type Moon's.

>> No.9544003

>>9543984
When his personality isn't inverting, Shiki is a generic "nice guy" dating sim protagonist. He's pretty boring. Even Nasu admitted that Shiki came out too similar to typical VN protagonists.

Shirou has a pretty distinct character and displays considerable character development across FSN. Shiki's personality pretty much stays the same.

>> No.9544005
File: 14 KB, 208x300, akiha 2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544005

8 male characters before Akiha
Fucking gaylords

>> No.9544011
File: 969 KB, 1000x1348, Archer Rin.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544011

>>9543984
I've never liked this picture much.

>> No.9544059
File: 93 KB, 600x600, 070404.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544059

Would be a perfect top 5 if not for Toesucka.

>> No.9544123
File: 1018 KB, 850x1133, gilgamesh_carrying_saber.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544123

I really can't believe Gilgamesh took 9th. This is kinda some bullshit.

No homu.

>> No.9544136

Fuck homo bara liking scum

>> No.9544179
File: 261 KB, 800x980, akiha1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544179

>>red saber and Akiha so low
>>Arc being beaten by Rin of all things

Quoting the results, but that is some BS, dude.

I'm glad Karen is somewhere on there though.

>> No.9544190
File: 361 KB, 800x600, KireiBlackKeys.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544190

Not Kirei and King of heros ninth.

Also what the fuck is doing extra/caster there? Christ, Japan taste is....

>> No.9544192

So, which place took Robin the bird?

>> No.9544214

So Shiki lost her first place? Damn.

>> No.9544233
File: 29 KB, 299x376, 1229312795484.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544233

Wow what?

>> No.9544245

>>9544190
>what the fuck is doing extra/caster there?
Your taste isn't much better, in my opinion. It is, but not by much at all.

>> No.9544253

>Akiha
>16
I'm mad.

>> No.9544272
File: 222 KB, 600x663, 23563250_p0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544272

Waver should be #1.

>> No.9544277

>akiha
>16

Well fuck you too japan

>> No.9544282

>>9544245
Anyone who likes F/SN Caster and F/E Caster is automatically a retard with shit taste.

>> No.9544295

>Akiha above Ilya

suck it spermguzzlers!!!

>Akiha 16th, even losing to dirty smelly boys

;_________________;

>> No.9544360
File: 224 KB, 669x1000, kimono ilya.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544360

>>9544214
Shiki only came first on a mobile site poll which had a tiny voting population. It wasn't really representative.

>>9544295
How can you dislike the best Type Moon and like that bitch instead?

>> No.9544395

>>9544360
I was just surprised, really. I thought the actual loli would have more (spermguzzling) fans. I like Ilya, Akiha is just far more suited to my tastes.

>> No.9544400
File: 2.42 MB, 4000x3000, 1227507614808.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544400

>>9544360
Yo nigga you best not talk smack on my woman I will bring your world down around you

>> No.9544436
File: 162 KB, 600x600, 1339168715769.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544436

I don't understand why:

Ilya so low
Girugamesh, shirou, sakura, rin so high
Seiba first
Arc not first

But really. I don't understand the popularity of gilgamesh at all. All throughout FSN and FHA he's nothing but a disney-tier manly man antagonist. I could write any essay comparing him to Gaston from the beauty and the beast.

>> No.9544442

>>9544436
>I don't understand the popularity of gilgamesh at all.

Fujoshi and F/Z.

>> No.9544445

>>9544436
Go on then. It best be on my desk by friday, hyperkike!

>> No.9544460

wow, I can't believe these results

>> No.9544467

>>9544436
> I could write any essay comparing him to Gaston from the beauty and the beast.
Do it faggot, fucking do it. Oh wait you know you won't because you're a fucking failure.

>> No.9544468

>>9544400
Did you actually enjoy her constant nagging? One of the reasons I thought Midday Moon was the best Tsukihime ending was that Akiha was out of the way.

>> No.9544476

>>9544445
>>9544467
He said he could. He never said he would.

>> No.9544480

>Faggot Lancer
>No kotomine
>Kohaku lower then Sakura Thewhora

I'm quoting the ranking, fuc off

>> No.9544492

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PK3x2DOoJIc

>> No.9544495

>>9544468
She just wants you to be a little more refined, it's part of her love. If you don't get it, you don't get it.

>> No.9544501

>sakura not 1st.

>> No.9544506

>>9544476
It's easy to say could but it doesn't mean anything unless he does something.

>> No.9544508

Why is SUGOI not 1st place?

>> No.9544549
File: 144 KB, 945x1356, 1256001378872.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544549

>>9544468
Dude you're tripping balls or something, why would I care if she nags Shiki hes a straight fuckup and deserves it

>> No.9544552

>>9544508
Her huge tits are a turnoff.

>> No.9544570

>>9544552
what? those tits are amazing. also why is her hotter sister not up there?

>> No.9544580

>>9544576
um why? shes fucking hot and cool.

>> No.9544576

>>9544570
Touko is definitely not top 20 material.

>> No.9544577

How could arc and sugoi lose to rin, thats bullshit.

>> No.9544589

>>9544576
haha
but Lancer is, right?

>> No.9544598

Okay, first of all: since the Fate series has had much more exposure than Tsukihime, it's only natural that its characters are gonna be higher up. This isn't supposed to be fair and impartial. It's a goddamn character popularity poll.

Japan (where most of the votes come from) also has its own set of defined morals and ideals, so what you deem to be a good trait might be seen as negative by the Japanese. Read: You think Saber is boring? They think she's perfect. (So do I, but that doesn't matter.)

As to why Kotomine isn't on there and Sakura is higher up than Kohaku is, I have no explanation. Fuck it.

>> No.9544593

>>9544576
Not him, but she's definitely in my personal top 10.

>> No.9544595

>>9544576
then why the fuck is lancer there.

>> No.9544599
File: 43 KB, 471x595, 1176872137071.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544599

>>9544589
Why can't you let Lancer have this one victory?

>> No.9544605

Stop being mean to Chuchu

>> No.9544619
File: 43 KB, 640x480, kotominekirei96fatezero.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544619

>>9544598
Combining Kotomine's points from FSN and Zero gives him 6269 points, which would place him at 11th place ahead of Kiritsugu.

>> No.9544625

>>9544598
sakura is actually in a decent spot, its that sugoi,arc, and no fucking Kotomine or Touko. this list is shit. Also saber is boring no matter what country you come from. where the fuck is gilles de rai.

>> No.9544629

>>9544619
he should be in the top fucking 10.

>> No.9544633

>>9544619
What the hell were they thinking by separating the two?

>> No.9544634

who was voting?

>> No.9544635

>>9544625
oh and ahika should be much higher. saber should be in like 18th place.

>> No.9544642
File: 84 KB, 744x744, 27162804.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544642

Popularity comes and goes, but excellence is forever.

>> No.9544643

>>9544635
I'm sure they'll reconsider their choices based on your tastes for next time.

>> No.9544647

>>9544625
>>9544635
Like I said, Tsukihime isn't as popular as Fate.

>> No.9544644

>>9544634
Everyone was. You mean you didn't vote?

>> No.9544650

emyia and archer shouldn't even be on this fucking list, fucking retarted fangirls have shit taste. he was a shitty boring mc and archer was boring and old news.

>> No.9544655

>>9544644
Nope. I can't into the runes.

>> No.9544656

>>9544635
Blue saber just needs to switch spots with red saber.

>> No.9544657

>>9544647
What? I swear Tsukihime had a much bigger and older fanbase.

>> No.9544659

I liked Saber.

>> No.9544664

>>9544659
She was boring as watching paint dry.

>> No.9544666

>>9544650
nope, they are fine

Kiritsugu shouldn't be on this list. He's a fucking joke. A retarded way for Nasu to force his stupid believes.

>> No.9544667

>>9544659
That's natural.

>> No.9544671

>>9544657
Not these days, man.

>> No.9544677

>>9544667
I liked her too
which doesn't change the fact she's overrated

>> No.9544690

>>9544666
>Nasu
F/Z was written by Urobuchi Gen.

>> No.9544696

>>9544690
the character didn't change since F/SN

>> No.9544703

>>9544666
did Kiritsugu even have any character development at all. im on ep 19 in zero and hes not even the fucking focus. Is the anime adaptation just bad or something? how different are the books? is there much more character development with the masters? rins dad died without him barley showing any human emotion. you barley get to know the characters in this anime, unless thats how the book was also..

>> No.9544708

>>9544666
Have you actually read or seen Fate/Zero or FSN? The whole point of both Fate/Zero and FSN was that Kiritsugu's ideals are retarded and lead only to misery.

>> No.9544720

>>9544657
laughing elf man.jpg

>> No.9544715

>>9544696
But F/Z was far more over-the-top

>YEAH blew up a skyscraper after evacuation everyone. So ruthless, so steel, so broken man! He certainly should regret that, he made that kid cry, evil man, that!

>> No.9544722

>>9543944
wait, where the fuck is >>9543969 her mother. i thought she would have some fans.. also what about Kiritsugus partner women.

>> No.9544723

>>9544703

I think F/Zero really shined with Rider and Waver's relationship, more than anywhere else. It was the best part imo.

>> No.9544735

>>9544722
I don't think anyone cares about Maiya.

>> No.9544748

>>9544708
That's what I'm talking about. Nasu forcing his retarded ideology upon players by the means of
>Nasu:You want to help "invisible people"? You want to do something more then just be nice for those who are around you? Too bad you're going to end up a broken faggot. As a proof, I give you Kiritsugu. See how broken that idiot is. You don't want to end up like him, do you?
>You: Oh no! You're so right Nasu-sama! Haha, what a loser this Kiritsugu, he lost sight of what's important!
>Nasu:That's right. You're so smart for figuring it out on your own!
>You:Thanks!

>> No.9544744

F/Zero should of been a vn.

>> No.9544752

>>9544735
Why? I thought Maiya was hot. what the fuck is wrong with japan?

>> No.9544760
File: 55 KB, 400x225, vote16.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544760

Who drew this? Is there a more complete pic out there?

>> No.9544762

>>9544722
Iri should have followed the example of her daughter and been a loli.

>>9544744
Nasu really disliked the fact that a VN mostly restrictied him to a single character's viewpoint, which meant he wouldn't be able to balance the appearance of multiple characters or show lots of fights between different groups of Servants.

>> No.9544774

>>9544762
What's stopping anyone from making a VN from many viewpoints? Or 3rd person?

But then, Nasu proved over and over again that he's not a sharpest stick in the store....

>> No.9544789

>>9544748
People who are willing to sacrifice the few to save many tend to be psychopathic, Machiavellian and view life as meaningless.

http://www.economist.com/node/21530078

>> No.9544792
File: 205 KB, 588x814, 1177788753188.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544792

>>9544774
What store sells sticks?

>> No.9544794

>>9544762
>Iri should have followed the example of her daughter and been a loli.
yeah and look where that loli is, in 17th place. plus fuck lolis they are overrated. I just think the fate/zero anime was too fast paced and nobody felt anything for the characters because of it. I dont know about the books but I would of rather had a vn, at least we could get to know the fucking characters before they die to feel anything for them.

>> No.9544797

>>9544748
No, Nasu wasn't that bigoted. While I agree somewhat with you, there were also several instances where Kiritsugu's character and purity were complimented.

The basic message was this: the path Kiritsugu took was indeed "justice," but it was never fit for a human being.

>> No.9544803

>>9544760
Looks like the style of the new guy who did MHY.

>> No.9544804

>>9544789
Would you stop it? You know your Nasuverse stuff pretty well, but you're always trying to propagate your own viewpoints as fact. Enough already.

>> No.9544806

>>9544762
So nasu is not going to make vns any more? what about Tsukihime 2 and actually continuing the universe.. I hope he doesn't stick with books and anime because it sucks.

>> No.9544809

>>9544789
Nasu sama is proud of you

>> No.9544815

Fuck your ''detailed'' bullshit, I didn't wait two months for a reprint of the Suck 20.

I knew I should have voted for Karen ;_;

>> No.9544820

>>9544804
These are not his believes

They are Nasu's

>> No.9544821

>>9544797
I didnt like how Kiritsugu had no screen time for 19 eps out of 25 for the anime, the whole anime was rushed. If anybody reads the books, tell me is its any better with the characters.

>> No.9544829

>>9544820
It's not. Go reread F/SN and F/Z. Nasu personally doesn't believe in Kiritsugu's ideals, but he still presents them fairly. See: UBW and Bad End 30.

>> No.9544832

Archer fucking sucked. That's my only complaint besides Ilya being so low.

>> No.9544835

So what is nasus next project? what are his future plans with the universe? has he said anything at all? will he make a new vn? Did Mahōtsukai no Yoru have a complete ending or can he continue it?

>> No.9544841

>>9544804
What I posted is taken from a published paper. I didn't make it up.

http://leeds-faculty.colorado.edu/mcgrawp/PDF/BartelsPizarro.2011.pdf

>> No.9544846

>>9544841
I'm not talking about that stupid paper.

>> No.9544850

Why is the Sōjūrō Shizuki from Mahōtsukai no Yoru and shiki not up there but emyia is? what is Sōjūrō Shizuki character like?

>> No.9544859

>>9544829
Nasu has said that in both ends of UBW Shirou is still a broken person because of his ideals.

>> No.9544860

>>9544850
He punches things.

>> No.9544861

>>9544821
>the whole anime was rushed

The 1st season was pretty slow paced to the point people were bitching about it.
2nd season had a few scenes rushed.
The only thing I remember from the LN that adds to Kiritsugu's character (and others) was internal monologue and 3rd person narrator, and I guess the two episodes of Kiritsugu's past were done in order to make up for the cut monologue/narration details.
LN still pays more attention to Waver and Iskander than the other masters/servants.

>> No.9544862

>>9544797
>Nasu-sama:Well, I know this is all noble and shit. But you must understand, that to fight for something always means to sacrifice yourself for something. Anyone who tries to do this is going to break sooner or later.
>You:I know! Like Kiritsugu and Shirou from Fate and UBW! This all will only bring them early grave.
>Nasu-sama:Good examples! Indeed, it is so. There is nothing but ruin there. So don't do that, don't feel worse then the poor losers who do that and enjoy your childhood friend's wide vagina like I did
>You: I sure will! I'm not an idiot!

>> No.9544870

>>9544859
Was that stated in the route? If it wasn't, there's no problem. Nasu can say whatever he wants outside of the novel, because that's his opinion.

>> No.9544878

>>9544841
>throwing random sources that happen to support your believes only because they, well, support your believes

can you get more pathetic?

>> No.9544881

>>9544862
To point out just one thing in your retarded (and kind of humorous) greentext fabrication, the entire point of UBW is that Shirou's not gonna break. It takes the help of Rin, but regardless.

>> No.9544893

>>9544862
When did Nasu fuck my childhood friend?

>> No.9544891

>>9544881
Nope. His all like
>I'm going to die but I don't care since it's my ideal
you're supposed not to want to be like him

And also, Rin's end suggests his going to give up and become an "honest man" after fucking her for some years

>> No.9544904

>>9544891
Yeah, so Archer entrusts Rin with the task of keeping him straight. That's the whole point of Rin being the heroine!

What part of Rin's end suggests that?

>> No.9544911
File: 323 KB, 850x498, gilgamesh_saber_dakimakura.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9544911

>>9544436
Read the F/0 light novels. He's a complete bastard, super bad ass and a lot of fun.

I don't really think the other series did him justice either, though.

>> No.9544912

>>9544878
>throwing random sources that happen to support your believes only because they, well, support your believes
Hahaha, I'll have to remember this next time someone throws a paper at me.

>> No.9544918

>>9544904
An ability of mind is to not see thing it doesn't want to see.
>After all Nasu-sama didn't write it directly, and that's why I believe he didn't hint something like that! Because I believe in Nasu-sama!

>> No.9544927

>>9544703
Why do people need character development so much? F/Z isn't about that

>> No.9544923

>>9544893
Blink and it happens.

>> No.9544925

>>9544436
> I could write any essay comparing him to Gaston from the beauty and the beast.
Do it so I can copy paste it to troll his thread.

>> No.9544928

>>9544861
so even the books are terrible with character development and character personality? I would think the books would actually have that. is there anything the anime skipped out on?

>> No.9544930

>>9544918
I'm sorry, but your post isn't really convincing me.
>I'm just gonna make offhand remarks instead of posting solid evidence!
Am I doing it right?

>> No.9544951

>>9544927
Because character development is fucking important to a story, unless you like flat shallow characters that get killed off before being something like in some shitty horror or action film. fate/zero was suppose to be character development about the masters and servants but so far, 19 eps in and there is nothing, nothing at all. no inner dialogues, characters die too quick before you get to know them, the main character is off screen for 90% of the show. its fucking annoying because this good be done well but it just comes at me as a shallow rushed piece of shit. kara was sone 10x better.

>> No.9544957

Where the fuck is Satsuki on that list?

>> No.9544964

>>9544957
26th dumb bitch

>> No.9544965

>>9544957
Who?

>> No.9544972

>>9544928
>is there anything the anime skipped out on?
The one's I can think of off the top of my head are
-Gilgamesh's flashback with Enkidu.
-Gilgamesh and angra maiyu

The 2nd season boxset will be released in September with extended/cut footage.
The anime has problems not with keeping all of the LN content adapted, but how it was adapted. (LancelotVSSaber, No dark dress for Grail Irisviel, Rider's army not having horses).

>> No.9544967

>>9544957
What don't you get about "no one cares about Sacchin"?

>> No.9544973

- Saber number 1
- Rin above Arc
- Shirou of all people is in the top 20, but not Shiki

What a bunch of crap.

>> No.9544981

>>9544973
Shiki the cardboard cutout?

>> No.9544988

It's fucking saber. 25k votes. What a surprise. I can just imagine all the people that voted for the only one they could manage to identify.

"is this the right shiki? oh fuck it, seiba."

>> No.9544993

>>9544981
Even as a cardboard cutout, he's more charismatic than most of the Type-Moon characters.
Take that like you want.

>> No.9544998

>>9544993
Shiki charismatic? Are you talking about Nanaya? Now he's smooth.

>> No.9545001

>>9544998
Nanaya's like the condensed version of all of Tohno's cool points. No wonder he scored so much higher than Tohno did.

>> No.9545003

Leave it to 4chan to be a fucking hipster and bitch on mostly anything the mainstream likes.

>> No.9545007

>>9545003
Don't worry anon. Saber will never stop getting my vote.

>> No.9545093
File: 403 KB, 638x900, Kotomine.Kirei.full.922445.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9545093

Sick japs didn't vote for Kotominte. Tasteless bastards.

>> No.9545098

>>9545093
Yes they did. He'd be near the top if he wasn't split in two.

>> No.9545104

>>9545098
And Shirou would be first if he wasn't not split into 3.

>> No.9545111

>>9545093
Only in the West where liking the villain is in vogue.

>> No.9545109

>>9544951
>fate/zero was suppose to be character development
It wasn't. It was admittedly a dark prelude for FSN. The characters are developed, that's the point.

Also, what are you, 12?

>> No.9545112

>>9545104
3...?

>> No.9545123
File: 66 KB, 400x587, 1190936253418.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9545123

>>9545112

>> No.9545127

>>9545123
Hm, I always did think Avenger looked a lot like Shirou.

>> No.9545175

>>9545109 Also, what are you, 12?
Well, it is a Type-Moon thread after all.

>> No.9545191

>>9545109
Just ignore him.

>> No.9545994

>>9544927
Exactly. For many years I didn't even know what character development is (in my language such term doesn't exist, there is only a distinction between static and dynamic characters) and I was able to enjoy fiction just fine
then I got into the world of playbypost rp and then I learned all about this "character development" and how it's supposed to be important

>> No.9546007

Thats the wrong rider.

>> No.9546037
File: 295 KB, 750x660, 5489579bd06b9668973d80bb524ae79b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9546037

>>9543944
Iskandar is only sixth? I am disappointed japan.

Actually, I'm generally disappointed from this whole poll.

>> No.9546041

>>9546037
Sixth is more than he deserved.

>> No.9546044

>>9544748
>>9544862

These are my thoughts about the FS series summed up. Nasu loves pushing his shitty ideology down into people's throats. It happened in KnK too.

This is the main reason I can't enjoy media made by authors which have a strong opinion on something and try to put some retarded message into their work.

>> No.9546047
File: 707 KB, 990x1008, 7d0736a8e404daa53c73cfa94e2e4638.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9546047

>>9546041
His rightful place is first.

Well, actually second.

>> No.9546048

>>9544690
>F/Z was written by Urobuchi Gen.
It was scripted by Nasu. Gen only wrote it out and the only thing he was allowed to add by himself was that lovecraftian monster of Caster.

>> No.9546062
File: 560 KB, 600x900, 3df4e5743cda8c610c435f7dd398138e.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9546062

>>9546047
First place should be yielded to your favorire TM girl. Or guy, if you swing that way.

There is no other acceptable second.

>> No.9546078

Kariya and saber are tied for number one in my eyes

>> No.9546092

>>9543944
Sakura at 8. You have gotta be kidding me.
Kohaku & Akiha at 13/18. Did everyone forget about Tsukihime already? Where is Tsukihime2?

>> No.9546099

>>9546092
Wormslut is still the least popular FSN heroine, but she is at least in the top10 now.

>> No.9546127
File: 2.77 MB, 2608x3711, 371041b9967e58198a5dc2abd6c485fb.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9546127

>>9544760

>> No.9546132

What is the result of the subsidiary question?

>> No.9546148

... At least Sakura is in the top10, I'm happy she gets some love.

>> No.9546164

>Kiritsugu above Shirou
>Shiki second
>Archer in top 3
>Rin in top 5
>Ilya and Akiha so low
>Sakura only 8th

Fuck this shit.

>> No.9546201

>>9546164
Dude, it's a miracle Sakura even placed, let alone got that high. She was 7th in the Fate only polls. I'm pretty happy at my waifu for doing that well.

I assume Arc places as high as she does because of robotic main heroine loyalty, but that she's at 5 sort of implies everyone forgot about Tsukihime, which explains why Akiha and Kohaku are so low. When you think about that, Kohaku is actually doing quite well, considering the last time she was taken seriously was, well, the early 2000s.

And Aoko, whose game just came out, is at 7...not so sugoi for her.

I'm pissed that Kotomine Kirie isn't here at all. Isn't he a billion times more awesome than Kiritsugu?

Karen continues to make a strong showing at the polls, I wonder if she's really cool in Ataraxia or if it's just because she's a nun that doesn't wear pants.

>> No.9546226

>>9544806
No, that's not happening. You know his direct involvement on those were minimal, right? The only anime he worked on directly was Cannan.

Witch on the Holy Night is his attempt to do third person as a VN. There's a translated interview about it where he talks about the changes they made to standard VN conventions in order to make it third person instead of first. The director sounds like he knows what he's talking about and he made some really smart decisions (and the results are good). Nasu's just a writer, remember.

>> No.9546228

From the results it pretty much shows that the voters are like middle-schoolers or something

All chuuni, little to no perverted decadence

>> No.9546230
File: 67 KB, 449x594, 1441.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9546230

>>9544993
Shiki is pretty much a generic "nice guy" VN protagonist who periodically turns into Rape Lincoln. At the start of the game the guy stalks a woman to her house, dismembers her and the process makes him feel so good he almost ejaculates.

>> No.9546276

>>9546201
Kirei may be better in Kiritsugu on Zero, but his involvement in Stay Night are meh.

Karen? Possibly because of her involvement in Carnival Phantasm that people start getting notice of her?

>> No.9546291

>>9546230
That's his nanaya bloodline going crazy.

I mean, what better way to make people love to hunt and kill demons than to make it so they have extreme sexual pleasure from doing so?

>> No.9546315

>>9546291
Nanayas are supposed to turn into emotionless machines when they hunt. Shiki entering homicidal rapist mode instead is pretty abnormal.

>> No.9546508

>>9544967
But that's wrong, you retard

I care

And I even voted for her ;_;

>> No.9547140

>>9546127

Thanks a billion! I would have never found that, I spent a few hours trying last night. I love you anon.

>> No.9547164

Mary sue in 2nd

japs confirmd no taste

>> No.9547172

>>9547164

What? Arc and Saber as WAY more mary sue than Shiki.

>> No.9547207

>>9547172
Arc and Saber have flaws

Ryougi is just hurr im strong and shallow and more of a plot device than a character

>> No.9547234

>>9547207

Yeah, no flaws ... expect the fact she has the urge to kill everyone she sees. You're a fucking retard.

>> No.9547245

Any i just glad Sakura and Homu are there

GJ on Lancer and Archer on actually reaching

<333333333333333333333333

>> No.9547260

>>9547234
But thats edgy and kids like it nigga you're dumb

>> No.9547274

I like the 2,the 7,the 8,the 10 and the 16

Never played any Type Moon stuff

>> No.9547276

>>9547207
Why don't you leave or learn some manners. Typing like a child doesn't help your case and resorting to phrases that are overly spammed makes you stand out.

>> No.9547281

>saber
>shiki
>archer
>rin

everything is right in the world

>> No.9547332

>>9547276
stfu autist

>> No.9547337

Lancer is the best blue haired character in all type moon games and the nasuverse.

>> No.9547374

>Slutkura above anyone

Japs sure love they're /d/ level slut queen

>> No.9547381

>>9547337
>best blue haired character in all type moon games and the nasuverse.
Doesn't that contain only Lancer and Ciel?

>> No.9547385

>>9547374
Japs love them Housewife characters

>> No.9547395

>>9547381
You're forgetting at least Shinji.

>> No.9547419
File: 157 KB, 792x1078, 5d05c9061503e4f5243a16d9b39f2b88.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9547419

>>9547381
Old version Touko, Shinji and Byakuya

>> No.9547423

>>9544468
she just wants his attention. did you ever try get get anyone's attention when they try to ignore you for no reason? that's how Akiha'd felt when she dealt with him.

>> No.9547433

Akiha had every right to nag Tohno Shiki

I mean would you let a lazy relative whos supposed to support you just fool around in your mansion

>> No.9547441

>>9547423
>did you ever try get get anyone's attention
Why would you do something like that?

>> No.9547445

>>9547381
That was the joke I wanted to make but I guess I forgot a few other characters :(

>> No.9547448

>>9547433
>whos supposed to support you
What?

>> No.9547456

>>9544468

She just wants what's best for him and that's the only way she knows how to express herself.

>> No.9547469

>>9547441
Sometimes it might be necessary. Well it's a what if situation.

>> No.9547475

>>9547448
Shiki is supposed to be the new head of the Tohno Clan

>> No.9547488
File: 72 KB, 640x480, 2011-08-09_162015.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9547488

Akiha thread?

>> No.9547489

>>9547475
Shiki is supposed to be the new head of the now decimated Nanaya clan.
Shiki will never be a new head considering he's not really a Tohno.

I do wonder why people would hate on Tohno Shiki's personality.

He basically has the same personality as Okazaki Tomoya from Clannad with more tweaks despite coming from a doujin eroge years before Clannad was released and I don't hear anyone badmouthing Tomoya.

>> No.9547515
File: 59 KB, 640x480, 2011-08-04_182039.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9547515

>> No.9547521
File: 203 KB, 495x641, danbooru_unf-p-113280396695925.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9547521

>35 バゼット・フラガ・マクレミッツ Fate/hollow ataraxia 1651

;_;

>> No.9547537

>>9547488
I'm ok with her kill me or suck me or anything she wants.

>> No.9547538

Well Shiki officially becomes the Head of the Tohno clan in Hisui's true end

>> No.9547541

>>9547538
At the expense of having Akiha killed though.

>> No.9547558

>>9547489
Shiki wasn't as stupid and annoying as Tomoya in the after story.

Probably if anyone dislikes Shiki it's because his character design doesn't interest them.

>> No.9547575
File: 84 KB, 640x480, 1313511844396.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9547575

>> No.9547626

I'm shocked how popular Alice is. Did the japs really like Mahou Tsukai that much to put her at #10?

>> No.9548298

>>9544703
>Is the anime adaptation just bad or something? how different are the books?
The adaptation isn't bad, but Kiritsugu still didn't have much character development until the very end.
In terms of character development it's no doubt Waver that takes the prize.

However, I always see people go on and on about character development, but character development isn't the only thing that's important nor is it an absolute necessity, especially in shorter stories where there isn't as much room for development.
One very notable difference between the anime Kiritsugu and the LN Kiritsugu is the incredibly higher level of character exposition.

Kiritsugu is the most explored character with the most traits explored and to the greatest length.
He may lack in character development but that doesn't make him a flat character, I don't know why people so often speak as if characters has to develop to be good.

>> No.9548317

>>9548298
Because fiction is bad if the characters aren't solving their complex emotional problems! My high school English teacher confirmed it, don't bother her.

>> No.9548336

>>9547626
Mahoyo was released just a few months ago, it's still fresh in the mind of a lot of people.
Actually the fact that Aoko/Alice aren't in the highest places show that Mahoyo didn't fare that well

>> No.9548369

>>9547164
Do you not get tired of overusing a retarded buzzword made for retarded people?

>> No.9548377

>>9548369
I think you should check the definition of "buzzword".

>> No.9548384

>>9548377
I think you should do that too.

>> No.9548394

>>9548377
You should check the definition of a ''definition''.

>> No.9548401

>>9548394
I'm sorry, I don't know what that is.

>> No.9548406

>>9548401
Confirmed for not knowing what ''is'' is. Check the definition after checking the ''definition''.

>> No.9548417

>>9548406
Please stop. I'm afraid I might lose my ability to form coherent sentences if I keep forgetting these things.

>> No.9548461

Saber a shit

>> No.9548484

>>9547558
Well, if it's the character design that annoys them, then at least people should be honest about it.

Saying that they hate his personality while there are others that came after him who have basically the same personality, like Tomoya, that isn't even hated and people even think is manly despite his emo-ness is beyond me.

>> No.9548523

>>9546044
I hope Mahou Tsukai is not like that...

>> No.9549661

>>9547489
Nasu was influenced quite a bit by Key games when making Tsukihime. I think it explains Shiki's personality.

>Nasu: So I wrote our first project while I was convinced that: "OK, we'll make a love game, but we're going to make the main character really cool." Like visual novels that already existed...however, the games I ended up playing before production were "ONE" and "Kanon," so I ended up mixing that style with my own preferences, which became the 「Tsukihime」 you know today.

>> No.9549674

I like Blue Saber's desgin

But she's flat as a character

Akiha deserves to be higher

>> No.9549678

Worst girl still #1, Japan really has shit taste.

>> No.9549719

>>9549678
Your favorite character is objectively shittier.

>> No.9549774

ok why is Mr. Firecrotch even in the top 20?

>> No.9549975

>>9549674
>Akiha deserves to be higher

Completely agree with you

>> No.9551077

>>9548298
>flat character

I want to thank you for reminding me these terms still exist because catchy internet lingo is making them forgotten. Hearing the word "deconstruction" thrown around, it was a relief to see someone type the terms "parody" or "satire".

I can understand splitting Shirou and EMIYA because they are technically different characters but why Kotomine?

>> No.9551095

>>9549774
bcuz ur a gayass from a

>> No.9551089 [DELETED] 
File: 134 KB, 450x600, 9a04f2348c01df3094ae0ed15690456c.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9551089

I can't believe Sion isnt even on the list

>> No.9552137

>>9551089
Sion is right after Tohno Shiki in the 30s.

>> No.9552199

Taiga is at 58. How could this happen?

>> No.9552678

>>9552199
Don't forget that Taiga's teenage version (Student 0) got 193rd place.

>> No.9552695

We will never get a Satsuki route will we?

>> No.9552700
File: 46 KB, 480x360, 1342715587096.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9552700

>>9552695
But being the Nasuverse's buttmonkey is Sacchin's defining trait. Her becoming a heroine would spoil that.

>> No.9558216

>>9552137
Not as calculated?

>> No.9558704

Japan sucks, Illya should be at first place.

>> No.9563038

Hup.

>> No.9563328

>>9558704

She should have had a route, too. Favorite heroine.

>> No.9565325
File: 82 KB, 846x862, 1340554370767.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9565325

>>9563328
At least she got her own manga and anime.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action