/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Reika bitch training

It's hard to agree on those, you know.
There are some games that yeah, but most of the time it just boils down to tastes.
for example, I've seen clannad being called kamige, and it's not even my favourite key game.

It is largely dependant on one's opinion so you aren't getting much out of this thread

>>7821240

Fuck I DIDN'T COVER ALL MY BASES

Those that are usually considered as such are Yu-No, Cross Channel, Clannad, Oretsuba, Muv-Luv Alternative and Symphonic Rain.

>>7821245
>>7821246

Damn, well you guys are right. I guess it is just opinion but I was gonna use this thread for a eroge-i-need-to-play list.

Would ever17 considered to be one due to every mother fucker playing it and saying it was good?

>>7821260
It's good if you didn't read many I guess, same for Sharin no Kuni.

>>7821260
>eroge-i-need-to-play list.
This always comes handy

>>7821263
Huh. Some of those years are very interesting, considering what /jp/ hates on.

>>7821263
Thanks man. I will be looking over these for a while.

the ones I can actually read the titles for

>>7821287
It lacks 2010, but for a general idea it had subahibi, IM verita, noble works and sona nyl somwhere around in the top10, the ruitomo fandisc was somwhere around too.

>>7821297
As far as I remmember, Subahibi was 1st, Real Imouto ga Iru was 3rd and Noble Works was 4th. Baldr Sky DiveEX was on it too, and so was Ushimirai.

>>7821285
In Japan the userbase is pretty different than /jp/, there's lots of more casual players and whatnot, since they don't rely on translations and patches uploaded on obscure sites but they have regular stores and advertising.

>>7821306
Yeah, and that goddamn white album was 6th, that I rmemeber well.

>>7821301
I really hope you're not implying that /jp/ has a more refined taste overall than 2ch.

>>7821263
Heh, Kiminozo made 1st, Muv-Luv made 2nd, and MLA made 4th place.

>>7821297
I think Sinsenmilla was there too in 2010.
and as far as 2011 goes, some of the titles that most likely will end up to that list are Kamidori, Grisaia, Eustia, Rewrite, Artemis Blue, Iritori, Tenshi no Hane and Euphoria

>>7821313
Irotyoridori, really?
Well, there's no real competition either. but that was boring as fuck, save for the true route, that was actually good with some great twists.

>>7821313
Rewrite isn't an eroge so it won't be there
Grisaia and Eustia will fight for the first place if things continue as they are, rest is fair game.

>>7821310
I'm saying it doesn't mean much if a game that gets criticized here is on the top of the list there. I don't even know what "/jp/'s overall taste" is supposed to be because I don't care for hiveminds.

>>7821313
Light titles this year will probably end up there too.
KKK looks promising as fuck and from the reviews, vermillion was solid.

OP can't inb4

>>7821321
/jp/'s taste is to hate anything that more than a few people on 4chan like, including people on /jp/.

>>7821318
I'm bracing for Grisaia to take 1st without a problem. Just the fact that it came out of nowhere and everyone loved it helps a lot.

>>7821317
well I pulled that list quickly by looking at this years top in EGS.

>>7821318
I'd say Kamidori might also have a shot for top place, considering it's the best rated title in EGS for this year, but I'm not sure at all if it's strong enough to that list with only gameplay as it's strongest point

>>7821334
Also its future sequels, which look really interesting.
Makes you understand why in hell frontwing wanted an anime project way before releasing it.

>>7821339
It'll probably fair better than himegari though.

Official /jp/ list of kusoge
1. Muv Luv
2. Cross†Channel
3. Umineko
4. Yume Miru Kusuri
5. Subahibi
6. Fate/Stay Night

Official /jp/ list of kamige
1. Clannad
2. Planetarian
3. Muramasa
4. Baldr Sky
5. Tsukihime
6. Grisaia

>>7821356
>Official
Please do not do that.

>>7821339
>I'm not sure at all if it's strong enough to that list with only gameplay as it's strongest point
Admittedly Alicesoft has its own dedicated fanbase but if Sengoku could get first place over the other games I don't see why Kamidori can't.

>>7821385
Sengoku was a huge success on a completely different level in Japan. There was no way it wouldn't take the first place.
Otherwise people who vote in these rankings are more into scenario-ge

Considering that HImegari got in to 9th place of the year 2009 the year of scenario-ge, I can see Kamidori being atleast in the top5 this year, maybe not the top place but it definately will be up there high

>>7821263
KiraKira was actually #1? What. Should I read it?

>>7821419
Kira Kira is by Setoguchi, if you can't read it in Japanese and therefore appreciate the writing there is no reason to read it.
Same for Swan Song.

>>7821419
It's pretty great even in English, provided you're not too autistic. You can skip Sarina's route, though(even if it does some things surprisingly well).

>>7821434
Pretty great until the routes branch, pretty bad whichever way you go after that, for me.

Damn, just kinda realising that it's already September. Feels like yesterday when we were discussing how this year was gonna be great for eroge while looking at all the upcoming releases.

>>7821468
Kirari's norma route was amazing.
The other routes weren't bad too

Oh shit all these games. Writing all this shit down, thanks a lot guys! Back log for months

And to the people that this thread offends I understand everyone has different opinions but there is a ton of shitty eroge just like every other medium. You may not like what others agree upon but chances are if a lot of people find it good it has to be at least average which to me is better than pure shit.

aka there are way too many eroge and this presents a good starting place

if you can read japanese :/

>>7821356

Official /jp/ list of kusoge
1. Muv Luv
2. Cross†Channel
3. Umineko
4. Yume Miru Kusuri
5. Subahibi
6. Fate/Stay Night
7. Clannad
8. Planetarian
9. Muramasa
10. Baldr Sky
11. Tsukihime
12. Grisaia

Official /jp/ list of kamige
1. Muv Luv
2. Cross†Channel
3. Umineko
4. Yume Miru Kusuri
5. Subahibi
6. Fate/Stay Night
7. Clannad
8. Planetarian
9. Muramasa
10. Baldr Sky
11. Tsukihime
12. Grisaia

>>7821263
Posting updated version.

>>7821835

I see what you did there

>>7821876
>2000
>化石の歌 on the list
I guess I should finish that one day. Game got meta in the first couple of minutes that it hurt.

http://erogamescape.dyndns.org/~ap2/ero/toukei_kaiseki/toukei_median.php?erogame=null&coterie=nu
ll

This list + salt = good idea of what the Japanese consider good. F/SN is kind of out of place because it was the first eroge a lot of Japanese people played, kind of like YMK on /v/, and obviously the games with 17 votes total can be ignored.

>>7821904
>1 マブラヴ オルタネイティヴ 全年齢版(非18禁)
Shit list