/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Why do you keep trying to troll with this thread?

>>7763371
I am not trying to troll. I am genuinely interested.

>>7763371
>>>/h/

MLA > Baldr Sky = Muramasa

prove me wrong

bump to piss off the japanese elitist superstructureXD

proof that MLA is the best

#1 Muv-Luv Alternative 9.29 (413)

at vndb

>>7763389
You can't be serious.

>>7763391
I'm sure the whole thread is serious.

Personal opinion:
Baldr Sky > Muramasa > MLA

Actually, compared to previous versions, this one makes sense.

whats da matter nihongo masters, afraid of telling your preference because of a possible backlash on your game's fanbase XD?

>Which mecha eroge is the best overall?
Don't know much about that, but Crime and Punishment is easily the best book of the bunch.

>>7763407
here comes the DEEP reading hipster faggot

Only the plot of MLA and ender's game have in common with each other

>>7763407
Hey ey, Neuromancer was really good, and Ender's Game was at least enjoyable if predictable.

>Translated by Constance Garnett
Nope.

Everything in that image is better.

Yeah, I know, it's a semi-troll thread, but imo:

Muramasa > Baldr Sky = MLA

All of them great games. You're missing out a lot if you know Japanese and haven't played them yet.

>>7763427
I never said they were bad. But if you want real literary merit, you go for Crime and Punishment.

why don't you try and go make this thread on /m/

>>7763430
>real literary merit
lol spoken like a true hipster

In my opinion
Baldr sky=Muramsa>>MLA
Having to read the shitfests of extra and unlimited is not fine with me.

>>7763443
>Having to read the shitfests of extra and unlimited is not fine with me.
This. Making the reader go through ML Extra+Unlimited and Unlimited-lite in MLA is pretty unreasonable.

>>7763455
I mean, reading them improves alternative, but seriously they are dull as fuck.
Baldr sky got it right, except for the read all the unskippable memories before entering the 5 route' part

>>7763443
>>7763455
mikoto is sad

>>7763455
They weren't THAT bad. Besides being somewhat cliche (but in most ways Extra felt more like a parody anyway) and in Unlimited's case having a horrible non-ending before anything happens (but then if you treat it as an intro to Alternative that's not so bad) they were perfectly solid at least as a mediocre time-waster tier eroge. (Leaving aside side-routes as I've heard they are horrible and not checked them out myself.) The only reason people seem to find them as some horrible experience is because they go into them expecting shit, and are anxious to get to the "real" VN they were looking forward to.

Sky because you get the experience actual mecha combat.

each one is pretty different from each other so they can't really be compared and it's up to taste to decide. altough with MLA you have to read 2 mediocre games to get to good parts when the other two are insteresting straight from the begining so I'd say MLA is worst and then tie with Muramasa and BS

>>7763371
>>7763397
>>7763425
>lolz i don't agree with him he must a trollz xDDDDD1

Get the fuck out.

Oh god, it's this annoying faggot again. You're not 'genuinely interested', you're just shit-posting.

If I tried to be "objective", I'd probably have to say Muramasa - a good theme whose faces are explored well and in a systematic way in the several routes.

However, MLA had the most profound impact on me (I read it way before either of the two other games were released, which may have something to do with this) so I consider it the best of the three. The two other are also great, but I still put them a few steps below MLA in my personal ranking.

>>7763459
Well, I didn't hate it myself even though I'm being harsh against it. ML was a solid slice-of-lifeish eroge with few funny moments. Give it 7.5-8 at best. But if I were to pit the Muv-Luv saga as a whole against Muramasa, I sure as hell can't say that MLA, which requires you to read ML Ex+UL to get the most of it, stands a chance against it. I remember having said this same thing in some thread yesterday.

Haven't played Baldr yet so can't comment about that.

>>7763492
best post in this thread

yes MLA best

>>7763487
Oh come on be gentle with me... I am genuinely interested. Look, there's an ongoing, civil discussion going on.

>>7763487
Hypocrisy?

>>7763487
Oh come on be gentle with me... I am genuinely interested. Look, there's an ongoing civil discussion.

For me it would be harder to rank KEY novels, really.
Baldr sky>muramasa>ML series

>>7763459
Well, I didn't hate it myself even though I'm being harsh against it. ML was a solid slice-of-lifeish eroge with few funny moments. Give it 7.5-8 at best. But if I were to pit the Muv-Luv saga as a whole against Muramasa, I sure as hell can't say that MLA, the game which requires you to read ML Ex+UL to get the most of it, stands a chance against it. I did give 10/10 for MLA, though. I remember having addressed this same thing in some thread yesterday.

Haven't played Baldr yet so can't comment on that.

>>7763459
Well, I didn't hate it myself even though I'm being harsh against it. ML was a solid slice-of-lifeish eroge with few funny moments. Give it 7.5-8 at best. But if I were to pit the Muv-Luv saga as a whole against Muramasa, I sure as hell can't say that MLA, the game which requires you to read ML Ex+UL to get the most of it, stands a chance against it. I did give 10/10 for MLA, though. I remember having addressed this same thing in some thread yesterday.

Haven't played Baldr yet so can't comment on that.

>>7763516
Why did you copypaste my post?

>>7763521
Sorry, it was an accident.

>>7763527
this yaroo...

Well, I didn't hate it myself even though I'm being harsh against it. ML was a solid slice-of-lifeish eroge with few funny moments. Give it 7.5-8 at best. But if I were to pit the Muv-Luv saga as a whole against Muramasa, I sure as hell can't say that MLA, the game which requires you to read ML Ex+UL to get the most of it, stands a chance against it. I did give 10/10 for MLA, though. I remember having addressed this same thing in some thread yesterday.

Haven't played Baldr yet so can't comment on that.

Which is the Neuromancer eroge?

>>7763472
Metarail when are you going to enter Ichijou's route? It's the best shit ever (IMO), Kanae's route is weak compared to hers (IMO).

>>7763551
I would suggest you to read the goddamn thread, but you seem mentally challenged.

>>7763551
http://vndb.org/v1306

>>7763561
lolz OP, don't act like you're some expert on the subject just because you're following the conversation of the nihongo hyperelitists, bywatcher

>>7763561
Just sobriety-challenged I'm afraid.

>Which mecha eroge is the best overall?

Demonbane

>>7763382
>>7763401
>>7763416
>>7763435
>>7763458
>>7763499
>>7763529
>>7763566
Same BETA is same.

It's funny how people have to say "MLA", and not "ML+MLA". You have to count in the prequels as well you know, otherwise it isn't fair.

The shittiest thread of the month is here, rejoice!

>>7763590
Thread isn't even bad. Pretty civil discussion and is going just in the direction I wanted it to. There's just one faggot being autistic. Read >>7763575

>>7763584
If we're counting all of the Baldr games as a whole too, then I guess Muramasa wins, right?

>>7763594
I didn't like janen hen at all in Muramasa.

>>7763594
except Baldr games aren't connected like ML+MLA are

>>7763575
BS1 wasn't bad. It isn't as good as 2 of course, but it sure as hell isn't as average as ML. The gap in quality between certain parts of MLA and ML is noticeable.

>>7763600
It really doesn't have any connection to the main game, since it's just a shitty fanfiction by guest writers

>>7763594
It isn't saying much, all three games are pretty huge and Muramasa is the only one who didn't happen to be cut into smaller games, but it does have its slow setting exposition moments at the beginning as well. If anything, the history, flying kendo and ezo culture lessons can be more boring than Extra and Rain route combined unless you like worldbuilding.

>>7763594
BS1 wasn't bad. It isn't as good as 2 of course, but it sure as hell isn't as average as ML. The gap in quality between certain parts of MLA and and the whole ML is noticeable.

>>7763616
BS1 feels like an actual part of a series that actually requires to read the second part and doesn't work as stand alone.

Okay guys, objectively speaking, which game is the Shakespheare/Tolstoy/Dostoevsky of eroge and which two enjoy the Twilight/Harry Potter-like popularity? In short, which game would be objectively deemed the best if there were professional literature critics reviewing eroge?

>Shakespheare/Tolstoy/Dostoevsky

It's funny because they all wrote overrated shit.

>>7763642
Man, you're so desperate.

>>7763647
>overrated
But you haven't even read any of them.

>>7763647
>>7763651
Come at me, broskis. Which is it? I demand to know.

Speaking of mecha eroge, is Zwei Worter any good?

After playing euphoria, I've been looking at some other Clock-up games and this one caught my interest.

>>7763654
everyone already knows what it is, they just don't want to say it. looking at your post, no wonder

>>7763652
I had to read a ton of Shakespeare in school, dropped War & Peace halfway through, and I just started Crime & Punishment, which actually doesn't seem that bad, but I can't judge it yet.

>>7763661
>everyone already knows what it is, they just don't want to say it.
Damn. What a bunch of pussies these people really are.

>>7763666
You just can't make the same shitty thread a bazillion times without everyone realizing that you're just trolling.

>>7763705
>objectively speaking, which game is the Shakespheare/Tolstoy/Dostoevsky of eroge and which two enjoy the Twilight/Harry Potter-like popularity? In short, which game would be objectively deemed the best if there were professional literature critics reviewing eroge?
Is no one brave enough? Are you afraid of getting ostracized by your eroge playing peers if you answer?

>>7763731
Twilight/Harry Potter = Tsukihime/Fate Stay Night.

>>7763731
Muramasa. There, I said it. You can fuck off now and take the rewrite dinosaur friend with you.

Twilight = Clannad.
Harry Potter = F/SN + Tsukihime

>>7763749
Except Harry potter is actually good while Twilight isn't.

Twilight/Harry Potter = Umineko

>>7763744
yet another victory for MLA

>>7763764
Where the fuck do you see him mentioning anything about MLA. Just kill yourself.

>>7763754
That's the point.

Pretty sure that every non-saged post in this thread is from the OP. Post some more Rewrite-dinosaurs.

>>7763642
>>7763731
Just so you know I'm not this guy. I'm planning on making these threads in the future as well, no way would I ruin my own thread by trolling it.

which game has the best muci

Which game has the best OST?

Oh look, it's this thread again.

>>7763836
MLA
Both BS and Muramasa have a a great soundtrack too but you just can't beat the soundtrack of MLA

>>7763836
all equal imo, each one has good and fitting OST for their general atmosphere

>>7763851
Except for those goddamn ML tracks before chapter 6-7, damnit

>Which mecha eroge is the best overall?
>In short, which game would be objectively deemed the best if there were professional literature critics reviewing eroge?
>Which game has the best OST?
Just stop replying to this faggot, he is just looking to spark a flamewar between fans by using "best".

MLA Fans = Twilight Fans = Arcueid fans = Call of Duty Fans = Naruto Fans = Orihime Fans = Sakura fans

>>7765283
Kageaki = Sasuke ripoff

>>7765283
>>7765304

Which game has the best protagonist?

>>7765355
I'd like to say Muramasa's Kageaki, but I've not read the other two yet.

>>7765504
You don't need to read MLA to tell that Takeru is a typcal shitty anime protagonist

>>7765526
and just how am I supposed to do that without reading it? I'll keep this neutral opinion of him until I've actually read Muv-Luv.

ender's game was the best book i ever read
its my favorite

The Op image makes me kind of want a visual novel comparable to all the other sci-fi greats.

A mote in god's eye has unlimited potential for moe UNLIMITED.

>>7765355
Kageaki easily.

>>7765355
Kageaki > Kou > Takeru

>>7765718
>Kageaki > Kou > * > * > shit > Takeru
fixd

Baldr because it has gameplay.

>>7765733
Looks like the kids woke up.

Is OP's image supposed to make me angry?

Because my jimmies are fairly rustled.

>>7765726
>BAWWW I HATE READING
autismical ADD fagget

>>7765784
What the fuck?

>>7765784
>>7765733

I've only read Muramasa, so I can't make proper judgment until I read Baldr and MLA. Though I'm afraid that I'm going to constantly compare them to Muramasa while reading and always finding Muramasa better because of nostalgia goggles.

>>7766085
For some reason I've been comparing every eroge to Muramasa ever since I read it a year ago. And no, it's not because of nostalgia goggles either.

which one has the best VAs?

>>7766654
Are you mentally incapable of posting without using the word best or something?

>>7766654
Your momma. No really, she sounds great with a cock in her mouth.

how good is baldr sky i wanna play it

thank you for possibly spoiling MLA for me

even if i deserve it for putting it off