[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 168 KB, 918x1361, 1279818779461.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5747688 No.5747688 [Reply] [Original]

No mystery novel prematurely blows its load by revealing the culprit's tragic backstory and reasons early on.

That means everybody who's tragic backstory we've already seen is a red herring and we should look towards characters that haven't been heavily developed yet for our criminal. These would be:

Hideyoshi
Rudolf
Nanjo
Kumasawa
Genji
Gohda

Those are your options.

>> No.5747716

sage

>> No.5747712

Gohda and the crimson pudding backstory.

>> No.5747725
File: 26 KB, 400x450, ObamaSmug.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5747725

>>5747716
>Using sage as an insult

>> No.5747732

Kyrie
Kyrie
Kyrie
Kyrie
Kyrie
Kyrie

>> No.5747738

>>5747732
We already heard Kyrie's tragic backstory. She would be too obvious.

>> No.5747743

>>5747725
>Not understanding cultural evolution

>> No.5747753

>>5747743
>Not understanding posting sage while saging is still retarded either way.

>> No.5747755

>>5747738
Kyrie's backstory has never been fully explored, only mentioned and alluded to. There's still the giant wad of HEY BATTLER IS YOUR SON RUDOLF SWITCHED BABIES FOR REASON X SORRY ABOUT YOUR EIGHTEEN YEAR HELL waiting to be blown for her.

>> No.5747758

>>5747725
>>5747743
>>5747753
Get the fuck out, all of you and never come back.

>> No.5747766
File: 313 KB, 1089x798, 7859467.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5747766

Kyrie.

She's either the badass culprit/mastermind or the only badass on the human side. I can't accept anything else.

Gohda gets some exposition in an extra TIP, by the way. But he is still... suspiciously mundane. So innocent that it's hard to believe he is.

>> No.5747784

>>5747766
I like Kyrie and I don't know why but I wouldn't mind her being the mastermind at all.

>> No.5747779

To be honest, we still have Kyrie, Jessica, Rudolf, and Rosa's backstory to contend with.

With Kyrie and Rosa, we've been given bits and pieces, but Kyrie obviously has a grudge, and Rosa seems like she would be very tied to Beatrice.

Rudolf and Jessica could be a case of them not being melodramatic fucks like George, but the fact of the matter is, the main characters and conflicts in the game revolve around them. Essentially, Rudolf and Jessica are in the center of a bunch of shit.

>> No.5747790

we no nothing at all about nanjo....

>> No.5747800

>>5747790
poor nanjo, ro7 always forgets about you..

>> No.5747809

>>5747790
He has a sick granddaughter. And a son who doesn't give a fuck.

>> No.5747814

>>5747790
>we not We.
>no not know.
>nanjo not Nanjo
>....

>> No.5747818

>>5747779
Rudolf is a man who caused half of Umineko with his penis. Jessica is more or less a tragic figure. Innocent, but because her meido is such a massive slut, she has to die.

>> No.5747843

You're forgetting slutty Asumu.

>> No.5747902

First twilights so far:
Ushiromiya Krauss-3
110010
Ushiromiya Rudolf-3
110100
Ushiromiya Kyrie-3
110001
Ushiromiya Rosa-4
100111
Servant Shannon-2
101000
Servant Gohda-2
101000
Ushiromiya Eva-3
010101
Ushiromiya Hideyoshi-2
010100
Ushiromiya Kinzo-1
001000
Servant Kanon-1
001000
Servant Genji-3
001110
Attending Physician Nanjo-0
000000
Servant Kumasawa-1
001000
Ushiromiya Natsuhi-3
010101
Ushiromiya George-1
000010
Ushiromiya Jessica-1
000010
Ushiromiya Maria-2
000011
Ushiromiya Battler-1
000001

For the next first twilight I bet in those persons:
Nanjo,Kinzo,Kumasawa,Kanon,Battler and Jessica

>> No.5747920

>>5747902
Nah, this is the truth being revealed, Battler has got to survive, same with Jessica, if only so they could be tormented by the fact that their supposed friend is a murderer.

>> No.5747942

>>5747902
Hah, poor Rosa.

>> No.5747954

You're forgetting Gohda's flan of doom.

>> No.5748016

>>5747779
Rudolf already knows that someone in the family wants to kill him, so why would he come to the island if he didn't have a plan? He can't do anything for his company if he's dead.

Plus, he's the other middle child. We saw how bad Eva was, and Krauss and Rosa can barely hold themselves together sometimes. No way can he be that calm and collected.

>> No.5748026

Nanjo never dies in the twilight... an accomplice for sure.

>> No.5748188

>>5748016
>No way can he be that calm and collected.
He's a skirt chaser but I don't remember him having outbursts of anger like most other characters. He seems rather easy-going.
I also don't think he cares much about inheriting everything like Eva. It has never been hinted at so far.

>> No.5748216

The weird thing about ep6 (which is a perfect forgery remember) is that canonically, everyone is pretending to be dead to play a trick on Erika.

There must be accomplices for this mystery to work, but they don't have to know what's going on.

>> No.5748251

>>5748188
Thats the thing.., somethings doesn't feel right with him..

>> No.5751024
File: 15 KB, 206x285, 1279297990750.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5751024

>>5747902
>Attending Physician Nanjo-0

>> No.5752499
File: 276 KB, 640x831, 1279280571855.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5752499

>>5751024
Drill stakes that leave clean wounds.

>> No.5752558

>>5748251
Maybe, just maybe he is actually nice guy? Not everybody on the island needs to be a dick.

>> No.5752592

Hideyoshi is the culprit. He's so unsuspicious that it's suspicious.

>> No.5752727 [DELETED] 

>>5747686

aS preVIouSlY MENtiONeD, ThESe MESsSageS wIll_coNtinuE_untiL_YoU PeRmAnENTLy sTop aTTACKInG_anD_fUCkInG wiTh www.AnonMoOoOtAlk.se (rEmOVe_tHe cOW soUND),_rEmove_ALl IlLEGAL CLOneS OF iT_AND Lies_AboUT IT ANd_dONate at_LeaSt_A miLliON_UsD to SYsOP As_coMpENSatIoN_For the massive dAmAGe_yOU_rETards_HaVE cauSed.
l tmsi t wxh tztctv ieagtgbwg hqq

>> No.5752739

>>5748016
>Rudolf already knows that someone in the family wants to kill him

This isn't true, He was just being dramatic about telling Kyrie and Battler the truth behind his birth.

>> No.5752757

>>5751024

Which means that Nanjo always has the opportunity to commit the first twilight, yes.

...inb4 Nanjo is a FT death in Ep7.

>> No.5752799

>>5752739
And also that he's probably Jessica's or Shannon's father.

>> No.5752815

>>5752757
Nanjo is like the Kingpin - his body is round but it's really all well-exercised muscle. That's how he moved all the bodies out into the storehouse.

>> No.5752907 [DELETED] 

>>5747687

As PreViOUSly MentIoNED, thEse_MEssSAges_WIlL ContINUe_UNTIl yoU pErmanentLY sTop atTACking aNd_fucKing With WwW.AnonmooOOTalK.sE_(rEMoVE_THE cOw_SOUnd), ReMove alL IllEgaL_ClonEs OF_It ANd LIES abOuT IT And DoNAtE_aT lEasT a MiLlion USD_tO_sySOp_as compEnsaTiOn_FOR_ThE_maSSIvE DAmaGE yoU_ReTaRds HAVe_CaUSed.
db xqh lzhd un ktx ra dzzhr ysmq igck gh

>> No.5752908

Counterexample: Death Note

OP you lose.

>> No.5753025

>>5752908
Are you retarded?

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action