[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 87 KB, 1024x768, 1275965003877.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5441939 No.5441939 [Reply] [Original]

I'm about to start F/SN

What should i expect? I decided to start it for this girl, all the doujin about her are delicious.

>> No.5441944

Enjoy watching her die in every route

>> No.5441946

INCONSISTENT PLOT

>> No.5441947

FOOD

>> No.5441949

You can't go for her before completing the first route.

>> No.5441951

you can't pick a girl. you have to play the routes in a certain order. during the first one your stuck with the ugly one

>> No.5441952

>What should i expect?
A shitty VN.

>> No.5441953

>>5441939
You picked up F/SN just for Rin? You've made a good choice.

Do the opposite anyone with a working brain and a good sense of self-preservation would do, all the time, you'll get far.

>> No.5441955

Shirou is Archer from the future

oooops.

>> No.5441957

Enjoy having her route not even be about her.

>> No.5441959
File: 164 KB, 800x600, 1275457463050.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5441959

JACKHAMMER

and cooking

>> No.5441961

Expect two good routes, and then one final absolutely terrible one.

>> No.5441962

It's literally a fantastic experience. You'll love it. Godspeed.

>> No.5441964

Sakura is her sister.

>> No.5441965

>>5441959
GOTTA GET BACK
BACK TO THA PAST
HAMMERAI-JACK!

>> No.5441966
File: 204 KB, 470x570, 1276895059389.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5441966

>>5441951
>during the first one your stuck with the ugly one

Pissed of Rinfag.

>> No.5441968
File: 146 KB, 1030x1236, 1226446842739.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5441968

>>5441947
You forgot your image.

>> No.5441971

>>5441961
Typical ADHD fag.a

>> No.5441972

ILYA IS SHIROU'S OLDER SISTER

>> No.5441973

Don't forget to create daily threads documenting your progress.

>> No.5441975

>>5441966

I'll never understand Rinfags inferiority complex toward the saberfags.

>> No.5441978

Cooking and repetition.
Don't expect it to live up to the hype. Nothing does.

>> No.5441982

>>5441973

I usually marathon VNs, so i don't open threads until i finished.

>> No.5441983

>>5441978
Awww, so jaded Anonymous! There there baby, it's okay.

>> No.5441984

>>5441975
Rin's delicious. Saber's not.
It's not that hard.

>> No.5441988

.....Is it okay to put some Sakura on this thread?

>> No.5441989

>>5441957
This.

I liked Rin a lot until after reading "her" (more like Archer's) route.

>> No.5441991

Rin and Saber were both awful characters. Rin is some sort of bad copy of Luvia and Saber is Agrias with even less charm. I'd choose Sakura in that game even though I'm not a huge fan of hers

>> No.5442001

Fate - Saber Route
UBW - Archer Route
HF - Sakura/Ilya/tKotomine Route

>> No.5442002

>>5441971
Not really no.
HF would've been great had Sakura not been present. Had it been just a Kotomine/Ilya route it would've been great, but I really just couldn't bring myself to give even one bit of caring for Sakura. Especially the whole "Woe is me" bit.

>> No.5442008

>>5442002
...Always

>> No.5442009

>What should i expect?

Shitty and retarded main character. Most of TMfags will label him as "not really stupid, he has a trauma", but in reality he's just tard.

>> No.5442011

>>5441983
It's the truth, friend.

>> No.5442015

>>5442002
Oh boohoo they talked about someone's sad past. That route was what wrapped up the story and the only thing decent in an otherwise shit VN.

>> No.5442017

>>5441988
No.

>> No.5442025

Shitty trolls ahoy.

>> No.5442030

A lot of sluts.

All the girls have sex with him after only 10-12 days, the only pure one is Sakura, because she has know Shirou for years.

>> No.5442032
File: 44 KB, 801x601, 1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442032

>> No.5442034

If FSN is so shit, then name a "Good" VN.

>> No.5442038
File: 42 KB, 801x602, 2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442038

>> No.5442039

>>5442009
Judging from all the time I spend with you clowns online, I'd be willing to bet that quite a few posters on /jp/ are about as oblivious, foolishly idealistic, and awkwardly clueless as Shirou.

>> No.5442041
File: 48 KB, 798x598, 3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442041

>> No.5442042

>>5442034
And then anon realized VNs were shit.

>> No.5442046
File: 42 KB, 500x755, 1272764959853.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442046

>> No.5442051
File: 258 KB, 300x559, 1273795227129.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442051

>> No.5442052

>>5442034
Ever17

>> No.5442053
File: 212 KB, 850x1209, 1273795443185.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442053

>> No.5442057

Expect pages upon pages upon pages of somewhat-logically-consistent drivel about magic that might be compelling to a 12 year old interspersed with cooking vignettes.

You're very correct about the doujins, though. That's far and away the best reason to play it.

>> No.5442059
File: 65 KB, 800x601, Capture.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442059

>> No.5442061
File: 117 KB, 400x480, 1273445409397.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442061

>>5442034

Umineko, Higurashi, Ever17, Chross Channel, Sharin no, Saya no Uta, Tsukihime
All superior to Fate/Cooking.

>> No.5442067

>>5442061
>Umineko
Your post = Invalid

>> No.5442068

>>5442061
>Umineko
>Better than Anything.

>> No.5442069
File: 618 KB, 809x656, 1275958857822.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442069

>> No.5442071

>>5442068
>>5442067
It's because F/SN is that bad. But even if you remove that the rest of his list is better anyway.

>> No.5442079

>>5442061
>Umineko, Higurashi, Ever17, Chross Channel, Sharin no, Saya no Uta, Tsukihime, Fate/Stay Night
For instant trolling, say someone's favorite VN is shit, then post this minus whatever their answer was.

>> No.5442084
File: 16 KB, 480x276, 1276961828112.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442084

>>5442067
>>5442068

Umineko is still better than F/SN.

>> No.5442088

>>5442079
Proves to be successful every time.

>> No.5442090
File: 621 KB, 850x1039, 1275966066655.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442090

I wish F/SN wasn't that long

It could have been long half of the time if Nasu didn't write like shit.

>> No.5442092

Wow, some people sure are desperate to let everyone know that F/SN is the worst thing ever written.

>> No.5442095

>>5442034

Anything but TM novels.

>> No.5442096

>>5442090
whenever they started talking about food i spammed left click.

>> No.5442097

>>5442092
If you don't want to hear people's opinions, why are you here?

>> No.5442098

Umineko is unlimited red herring works.

>> No.5442104

>>5442090
It's not really that long. I mean it only took me three days to read in its entirety.

>> No.5442106

>>5442097
Don't confuse "people sharing their opinions" with "people desperately bashing on something popular as hard as they can to appear cool and/or spark an argument"

>> No.5442109

Take it easy, guys. F/SN isn't the best VN ever, Nasu may write like shit, but it's still a pretty entertaining VN.

>> No.5442112

>>5442106
The two are the same. Also people who insist that anyone making fun of anything popular is only because it's popular are worse than people who actually do that.

>> No.5442113
File: 142 KB, 640x256, fateporn.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442113

>> No.5442119

>>5442112
Except you know, most of the people that say things like this about most of the popular VNs can't point out any really flaws to most of them.

>> No.5442128
File: 55 KB, 650x476, Kohakuuu.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442128

>>5442119

Bullshit, most of you F/SNfaggots know why people don't like this shit.

>> No.5442133

>>5442128
I don't mean just F/SN. You see it in Umineko threads, hell, I've seen people doing the same thing in Cross Channel threads.

>> No.5442135

>>5442112
It's true that some people genuinely dislike something that happens to be popular, but when they're extremely vocal about it it suggests that at least part of their dislike is because of its popularity. Otherwise they could just simply say they didn't like it and move on. They wouldn't feel the need to shit up every thread about it like what happens with F/SN.

>> No.5442143

>>5442135

Personally, i post in F/SN thread because

- I hate F/SN for his flaws.
- I hate the fucking fanbase who think F/SN is some kind of god work, an not Naruto in vn format.

>> No.5442150

>>5442143
And people like you are why /jp/ is steadily becoming shit. Just hide the damn threads and move on.

>> No.5442154
File: 43 KB, 668x700, 1246783560516.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442154

>>5442143
This is you, and no, I have never read FSN or seen the anime.

>> No.5442155
File: 84 KB, 800x787, saberprototype.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442155

>What should i expect?

Not Saver ;_;

>> No.5442162

>>5442143
Oh wow, butthurt much?

>> No.5442163
File: 24 KB, 800x536, 1277047003496.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442163

>>5442154
>>5442150

Your tears make me feel happy, F/SNfags.

>> No.5442169

>>5442143
>an not Naruto in vn format.
That's Demonbane. Not that F/SN is much better.

>> No.5442174
File: 87 KB, 640x480, 1273710097474.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442174

>>5442169

F/SN is Bleach, and Umineko is One piece, then?

>> No.5442180

Seriously though, FSN is bleach as a VN.

>> No.5442182

>>5442155
He's so fucking delicious.

>> No.5442185

>>5442143
>Naruto in vn format

What do people have against naruto? it seems whenever something is "bad" it's always compared to naruto.

>> No.5442190

>>5442185
Both get their extreme popularity from lolepicbattles and they both have shit writing and characters.

>> No.5442191

>>5442174
Never read/seen Bleah or One Peace, but Umineko turned into retarded trollfaces ant techno "music" in later eps.

>> No.5442193

>>5442182
Yes he is.

>> No.5442195

>>5442185

It's shit.

>> No.5442198

Saver is supposed to appear in Fate/Extra, right?

>> No.5442200

Whatever you do, do not play F/SN, it's a waste of 50 hours and a gateway VN of the worst kind.

>> No.5442202

>>5442185
I think it's just too popular with kids and people hate it for that.

>> No.5442203

>>5442185
Fanbases mainly.

>> No.5442207

>>5442191

Bleach is shit. One piece is actually good, but it gets trolled by Everyone, since the fanbase is fucking stupid and believe is the best mango ever.

>> No.5442211

I wish Rin hadn't JACKHAMMERED in one of the 3 alternate realities. Now she's just a slut.

>> No.5442217

>>5442207
It's fucking ten thousand chapters.

>> No.5442219

>>5442198

Seem so, but you can get fucked by him ;_;

I'd Gladys trade Sakura for a Saver route.

>> No.5442227

>>5442219
I really do hope you can get most, if not all of the other servants on a replay or something.

>> No.5442229

>>5442191
>>5442143
Don't want to be a dick but can you, please, take ten seconds to re-read what you have typed before hitting Submit?

>> No.5442231

>>5442217
It's long but it still manages to get better and better with each arc.

>> No.5442240 [DELETED] 

>>5442229

Nope, because so i can piss you guys moar

>> No.5442258

>>5442240
You really believe anyone is actually getting even slightly frustrated from your idiocy?
That's pure gold right there.

>> No.5442266

>>5442258

Yes, i do
And the fact that you are answering me, trying to prove your point show me your resolve.

>> No.5442280

You're all faggots.
That being said F/SN sucked.

>> No.5442291

As expected from the 1st day of summer.

>> No.5442295

>>5442291
But it has been summer status for several weeks now.

>> No.5442301

So this thread is shit

>> No.5442323

>>5442280
No you sucked your dog's cock, then swallowed. You fur-loving whore.

>> No.5442352
File: 127 KB, 550x450, 1270656146662.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442352

>this thread

>> No.5442364
File: 471 KB, 640x480, asuka_all_mad.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5442364

>>5442352
Epoch trullz

>> No.5442386

You and your poor ghetto trash low life negroid grammar.

>> No.5445036

bump

>> No.5445057

>>5442180
Sure it is.

>> No.5445199

Post [ VN i like (provide no arguments)] > [ VN i dislike (provide no arguments as well)] = guarantied shitstorm
>>5441939
Just read it and make your own opinion, try to avoid any possible spoilers/reviews/etc.
Expect it to be loooong, but the storyline (most likely) will keep you entertained, even if you end up disliking the whole thing.

>> No.5445218

>>5445199
nice bump faggot.

>> No.5445264
File: 655 KB, 800x600, maiwaifu.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5445264

>What should i expect?
The best VN of all time.

>> No.5445303

What to expect?
Prologue - omg what's this, fighting just starting? awesome and shit, awesome music too, et cetera.
Start menu- sound effect intro. SEEMS AWESOME.
Actual Novel - cooking, retarded people, whining, moeshit, tsundere shit. no good fights. "Heroes" who are weak faggots.

>> No.5445696

>>5445264

lolno

>> No.5445704

>>5441937

rEmoev yUor_ILLGEaL_CloEn_fo HtTp://TInyURL.cOM/3YTC6yx_iMMeidATeLY. zfh gmp aaj zs bwwa xsanlnh x pczanyiu

>> No.5445713

This thread, like /jp/, is shit.

>> No.5445719

Mediocre shit
Unlikeable characters especially moralfag prime, he's fucking dumb as shit
Ilya is somewhat likeable but she's still generic garbage

>> No.5445733
File: 104 KB, 225x350, 31621.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5445733

>>5445696

>> No.5445753

>>5441939
You may like it.

>> No.5445758

>>5445719
Pretty much.

The characters have no depth to them, no complexity, and the story line itself is mediocre, at best. The "Servants", which are supposed to be amazing representations of ancient heroes' fame and legend are nothing more than normal human beings with super strength and the ability to use magic, but seem to have no 'wisdom' and lack any indication that they actually did live a full life before that earned their hero status.

Zero was alright, FSN is shit.

>> No.5445763

You guys are far too extreme.
It's either the best or worst shit ever.
FSN is a solid title with some flaws but also some pretty good ideas.
It's not the best VN ever but it's definitely worth reading through, especially considering that there isn't much VN of this genre available in english.

>> No.5445780

>>5445763
In that case, go read Fate/Zero.

>> No.5445824

It´s a good novel to read, cool battles, stupid but likeable characters, it has flaws in some parts, most of it because of the ¨lost in translation¨, but at the end is just a simple VN, just enjoy it.

>> No.5445830
File: 50 KB, 333x350, 1276049206497.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5445830

>>5445733

>> No.5445836

>>5441966
>lo u mad
>>5442154
>lol delicious tears
>>5442162
>butthurt much?
>>5442163
lol delicious tears
>>5442180
>>5442185
>>5442191
>>5442207
>Naruto, Bleach, One Piece
>>5442240
>lol u mad i trol u
>>5442258
>no u
>>5442266
>lol ya u mad u mad


God, why don't you all go back to /a/? Why did you even come to /jp/? Because /a/ is shit? Then why are you turning /jp/ into /a/?

>> No.5445837

>>5445824
>Cool battles
>"lost in translation"

>> No.5445842

>>5445824
The translation is good, from what I saw.

>> No.5445849

>>5445758
Heroes are not recognized inherently because of great wisdom, or making sensible choices or whatever, in their legends, nor do they even wisen up during their own stories.
And I can understand not liking the characters or their direction, but saying 'no depth and complexity at all ' is kinda overkill.

I get the impression some people are laying it a bit too thick.

>> No.5445853
File: 56 KB, 225x350, 30257.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5445853

>>5445830

>> No.5445863

>>5445849
Those are called. Police Officer, firefighter, et cetera.

>> No.5445874

Aoko is still the best TM girl, right?

>> No.5445877

>>5445863
...Sure.

>> No.5445881
File: 254 KB, 706x1000, 1277053061157.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5445881

>>5445874
Of course.

>> No.5445900

>>5445849
Look, Diarmuid was a nice character. His past actually seemed to matter to him and his place in the novel, and he seemed to take what he learned from his past life with him into his eternal spiritual life.

The vast majority of servants in FSN do not have that same quality. Their past seem to exist for no reason other than to say, "Oh hey, this is where this character came from, it isn't original-do-not-steal, it's an actual person," and seem to have absolutely no affect on the servant at all. As if it were a blank slate.

>> No.5445911

>>5445874

You misspelled Kohaku.

>> No.5445925

i lol'd HARD when The Great King Arthur loses against some teenager faggot.

>> No.5445940
File: 81 KB, 800x600, 1265493945669.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5445940

Saber's route is to punish you before you start the good routes.

Rin's route is to make you feel like a badass.

Sakura's route is to make you feel absolutely miserable. Goddamn is Heaven's Feel sad.

>> No.5445942

>>5445900

This

I mean, they all Kings, great strategist, heroes who fought countless wars... Saber is fucking dump, like when she goes to the temple alone to fight Caster.
Wtf!?

>> No.5445946

>>5445900
...You really think so?
Excluding one case, their actions only make sense if you take their past life and grudges into account, when I read it. Perhaps you expected their past to affect them in a different way, but they are definitely affected and acting according to their 'life'.
You may call it 'shitty', but it is not non-existent.
Since you mentioned Zero, Dharmuind is nowhere near the ONLY one whose past and actions matter to him.
Your criticism kinda goes overkill in all aspects(no characterization, no depth, past lives have nothing to do with the heroes etc).

Well, whatever.

>> No.5445947

>>5445940
>Sakura's route is to make you feel absolutely miserable. Goddamn is Heaven's Feel sad.


No, it isn't because Sakura is a shitty and poorly written character.

>> No.5445952

>>5445942
Yes, cause Saber's leadership was glorious and never let into any trouble.
And leading teh country is the same as being summoned as a Spirit to fight a Celebrity Deathmatch with a man who wants to avoid fights.
Clearly, it makes no sense.

>> No.5445956

>>5445947
I felt sad for Shirou, not Sakura.

>> No.5445961

>>5445956

I felt sad for Kotomine and Ilya for being good characters stuck in a shitty novel.

>> No.5445971
File: 77 KB, 800x600, 1265495728903.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5445971

>>5445947

I respect your opinion, but I disagree with it very much. The only character in the Nasuverse I feel comes close to her is Kohaku. Rin was an alright character, but I found her really irritating sometimes because I hate tsunderes. Saber was just boring.

>> No.5445984

>>5445946
Oh please, what of Caster? The only way her past was even hinted at having affected her was how she didn't really trust people anymore. Other than that, it was thrown out the window. What? You loved Jason so passionately you betrayed your own family? Fuck that, you're now madly in love with a guy that you met for only a few days.

>Dharmuind is nowhere near the ONLY one whose past and actions matter to him.
I know, I just didn't want to list every single one, and settled for giving a single example.


>>5445942
It's supposed to be her moe trait: being a blockheaded and stubborn girl that would rather charge relentlessly into an enemy's fortress alone with no back up and no knowledge on anything about the enemy except that they are Caster and they will likely know that you are coming to their fortress the moment you step on the premises.

>> No.5445989

>Hey guys, I hate F/SN. Am I cool?
No. You're not.

>> No.5446010 [DELETED] 
File: 108 KB, 468x421, 1270005380440.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5446010

>This thread

>> No.5446008

>>5445971
Kohaku is Sakura done right. Both Kohaku and Sakura had similar situations growing up (raped every day, neglected, abused emotionally) but Kohaku is still a likeable character.

I prefer Kohaku over her just because Kohaku got her shit together under her own power and proceeded to fuck anyone who was related to the one responsible for fucking her life up. Rather than, you know, whining and crying about how shitty her life is and how much she loves her Sempai.

>>5445989
>>>/a/

>> No.5446015

>>5446010
See
>>5445836

>> No.5446029

>>5445984
So her hating pretty much most people because of the past experiences and falling for the man who believed unconditionally is not 'deep' enough or does not have enough references for you?
You have a better Idea of how Medea would actually act?
Your complaints makes little sense. And if you consider that 'Oh, silly girl's moe trait', you really fail at interpreting characters.
Well, whatever.
Again, it's obvious you dislike the characterization and how the heroes life is referenced and kudos for your opinion, but that contradicts the 'there is absolutely none' comment you made.
Characterization ,references and a level of complexity exists, which may or many not appeal to people.
You consider it shitty, we got it.

>> No.5446041

>>5446029
>Characterization ,references and a level of complexity exists, which may or many not appeal to people.
Look, I've given you examples of why I hold my opinions, but there has been nothing to suggest any sort of complexity in FSN.

>> No.5446055

>>5446041
...Sure.
All characters are simply straightforward one-dimensional caricatures and you always know what they are about since the start, eh?
Again, do not confuse 'done badly' with 'non-existent'.

>> No.5446063

Remember when take it easy was an unwritten rule in /jp/?

Guys, seriously, stop trolling F/SN. It's getting old. This place is almost as bad as /a/ now.

>> No.5446067

You know a character is good when he/she changes throughout the story.

>> No.5446074

>>5446055
Again, I have given you examples of why I hold my opinions, but there has been nothing to suggest any sort of complexity in FSN. And you still do nothing but say, "No, you're wrong. Why? Because you're wrong."

>> No.5446076

>>5446067
Not necessarily, no.

>> No.5446094

OP here, this thread still there?

I'm reading it right now and i'm around 4-5 day of Saber route, good stuffs for now.
I don't really like Shirou "lol you woman can't fight", but other than that it's pretty much ok

Rin still delicious.

>> No.5446098

>>5446008

Personally, I feel like the people who hate Sakura are the same people who hate Shinji from Eva (Yes, "/a/" oooh, I know, but bear with me), they're both very human characters thrown into situations so mind-blowingly out of their hands that they go into mental breakdowns. They aren't heroes, they aren't supermen, and they certainly aren't going to become one after years of the world relentlessly trying to convince them that they are shit. Sakura was the first character I could actually believe and understand in FS/N, and what's more, she made SHIROU into a likable character, a feat I didn't think could be possible after the last two routes.

And as for Kohaku, I liked her, but I found the whole "I guess I'll be a doll" thing pretty unbelievable. I had a lot of sympathy for her until the very end of Hisui's route.

>> No.5446105

>>5446074
Well, you have not given any example concerning complexity.
And whether you like it or not, the characters change, act differently in different situations and their thoughts and motivations are not apparent in first glance.
The lead alone is an example of that.
If you think this is just an 'NO U' thing, gongrats.

>> No.5446116
File: 7 KB, 164x292, 1274465464215.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5446116

>>5445853

>> No.5446132
File: 36 KB, 112x147, kohaku.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5446132

>>5446098


Or maybe she's just a shitty and unlikeable character.

Maybe.

Also, why do people compare Kohaku and Sakura?
They had a similar experience, but they reacted completely in different ways to it, personally i feel Sakura close to Akiha.

>> No.5446140

>>5446098
How was Shirou likable in HF? He threw away everything that was hinted at being worked up to in the previous two routes for some slut.
Fate: I want to save everyone.
UBW: Well, that's impossible, so I'll save everyone I possibly can.
HF: Fuck people, I'm saving my highschool girlfriend I love, and the rest of you can die in a fiery field!

>I found the whole "I guess I'll be a doll" thing pretty unbelievable
You've never been around child rape victims, I take it? It's a pretty common defense measure.

>> No.5446149

>>5446094
>I don't really like Shirou "lol you woman can't fight", but other than that it's pretty much ok

Don't worry, he gets over it. Oh wait sorry I forgot to troll.

LOL SHIROU SO DUMB HIS CHARACTER DOESN'T DEVELOP.

>> No.5446156

>>5446149
Don't be stupid, you know everyone here is talking about pretty much every character other than Shirou.

>> No.5446189

I enjoyed Fate/stay night. It definitely had its problems, and HF was my least favorite route, but it was still an enjoyable game.

>> No.5446214

>>5446140

Fate: I'm gonna be a superhero and save the world! Yeah!
UBW: Despite enormous evidence that it's a bad idea, I'm still gonna be a superhero and save the world! Yeah!
HF: Wow... I... wow... there's no way I can be a superhero. The best I can hope for is to keep the woman I love safe. I can't save everyone, and sometimes I can't even save a few people, but so long as I can just protect the one person I care about, I'll be happy.

That's how I saw it. The world is a cold, uncaring place, and Shirou accepted that. Trying to fight back against the world will just crush you in the end, so the best you can do take care of those you love, and hold on as tight as you can.

>> No.5446230
File: 661 KB, 1136x1626, 016.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5446230

>>5446140
>>5446098

I forgot, are the h-scenes voiced?
I want to heard Rin's delicious voice moaning.

>> No.5446253

>>5446230
They aren't, sorry. Not even with the voice patch.

>> No.5446255

>>5446214
Except it wasn't, "So long as I protect my high school girlfriend, I'll be happy", but "I will protect my high school girlfriend, even if it means killing hundreds of other people."

He completely tosses aside his ideals for a childish romance. Fate was insufferable because he held stringently to his ideals, UBW was great because he realized how impossible a feat saving everyone is, and then HF comes along and he decides to protect no one but one person.

>> No.5446302

>>5446214
Actually, its more like:
Fate:
Shirou: I want to save everybody!
END.

UBW:
Shirou: I want to save everybody!
Archer: That is both a logical contradiction and a denial of the self.
Shirou: But the ideal encompasses an aesthetic that makes the endless journey worth it. Why can't I selfishly pursue selflessness?
Archer: FUCK.
Gilgamesh: MONGRELS! THOSE SWORDS ARE FUCKING PATENTED!
END.

Heaven's Feel:
Shirou: I want to save everybody!
Archer: That is a logical contradiction and a denial of the self. If you do not realize this, you get no Sakura sex.
Shirou: You're right. I'm a moral relativist. God is dead.
Archer: That's the spirit. Here's a present before I go away, don't mind it if it starts to kill you.
Kotomine: But I'm still evil somehow, right?
Shirou: Right.
END.

>> No.5446305

HF true end=Future NTR

>> No.5446316
File: 347 KB, 800x600, HFtrueend.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5446316

>>5446305
But Sakura is dead in the true end, bro.

>> No.5446323

>>5446302
I like you. I'd allow you to come over to my house and fuck my sister, but she's a slut so I wouldn't wish that upon my fellow Anonymous.

>> No.5446326

>>5446255
>"I will protect my high school girlfriend, even if it means killing hundreds of other people."
Let's exaggerate what actually happened until the story is no longer recognizable!

>> No.5446332

>>5446326
To what extent is that an exaggeration?

>> No.5446335

>>5446326
Except that's pretty much what happened. Or did you miss the entire Shadow devouring the town parts?

>> No.5446344

>>5446326

Yeah, it's not like Sakura didn't eat and kill millions and Shirou couldn't kill her anytime.

>> No.5446366

>>5446326
>even if it means allowing hundreds of innocent people to die.

Better?

>Heaven's Feel:
>Shirou: I want to save everybody!
>Archer: That is a logical contradiction and a denial of the self. If you do not realize this, you get no Sakura sex.
>Shirou: You're right. I'm a moral relativist. God is dead.
>Archer: That's the spirit. Here's a present before I go away, don't mind it if it starts to kill you.
>Kotomine: But I'm still evil somehow, right?
>Shirou: Right.
>END.

This one gets me every time.

>> No.5446384

Shit. repetitive Shit.
Shit being trow at your face. then after you wipe out and wash yourself shit is being trow at your face again.

>> No.5446387

Heaven's Feel was good because it was the only end in which Shirou's ideal was actually tested.

Archer and Kiritsigu both had to kill a hundred to save a thousand, but Shirou gets off easily every single time until Heaven's Feel.

Shirou wanted to save EVERYBODY, remember? That's easy unless, say, someone you care about, through no fault of her own, is a source of destruction. This simple contradiction would kill his ideal either way. So rather than compromising like his father and archer, he chooses to do everything he can to save everybody, which means valuing Sakura's life more highly.
Whining about Shirou having to make hard choices displays the same sort of foolish idealism that most people criticize him for having.

The only person Sakura kills after they realize she's the Shadow is Shinji, anyway so I'm not sure where the sacrificing hundreds of people comes from.

>> No.5446397

>>5446387
He was allowing her to do so, it's a question of intent.

And he still got off easily in HF.

>> No.5446406

>>5446387
Because killing a thousand to save one whiny, useless girl is far nobler, right?

>> No.5446415
File: 84 KB, 800x600, 1228166656828.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5446415

Still waiting for a real VN about badass heroes with Gilgamesh as MC.

>> No.5446427

>>5446387

Yeah, by the time they actually realize that Sakura is the Shadow, it's too late. The only people she kills from then on are Zouken and Shinji.

It's the same compromise that Kiritsugu had to make at the end of the 4th war. In a sea of fire, he could only save ONE person, Shirou. Everyone else was a lost cause, but so long as he could save a single person, he could be happy. Again, the world is a cold, heartless, terrible place, and people are going to die for no reason at all. If you want to be happy and sane in such a world, you have to learn that some people just can't be saved, that sometimes you just have to do what you can for the few you care about.

>> No.5446430

>>5446415
http://may.2chan.net/b/res/123660960.htm
This should help.

>> No.5446443

>>5446427
It seemed to me that Shirou had a good idea what the Shadow was the first time it appeared, but he just refused to accept it.

>> No.5446446

>>5446387
>Shirou wanted to save EVERYBODY, remember? That's easy unless, say, someone you care about, through no fault of her own, is a source of destruction
Uh, no...
If that were the case, Saber would be a good king, seeing as she threw away her ability to care about people in order to save them.

It is impossible to save everyone. Shirou even acknowledges this when he recalls Kiritsugu giving him an example of a murderer, I think. How if you can only save the murderer, or the person he's about to kill, but you can't save both. How, by saving one life, you sentence another to damnation, so to speak.

Thus, logically, the ideal turns to "Save everyone that it is possible to save" which also has the hidden meaning of, "Save everyone that deserves saving", since you would not save the murderer and refuse to save the innocent and condemn him to death. This is UBW.

HF comes along and Shirou decides to save the murderer, spit on the innocent, and even dies for his sin of doing so in the "good" end.

>> No.5446452

>>5446430
Oh god, that thread was perfect until someone posted EMIYA.

>> No.5446465

>>5446452
You're just jealous of the smile of a tsun-tsun guy.

>> No.5446471

>>5446430
TM faggots, ruining threads even in 2chan.

>> No.5446475

>>5446427
After she killed Gilgamesh, the novel says she went to feed on people in the neighborhood of her own will.
She had control over it.

>> No.5446485

>>5446415
I would play it, especially if Tomokazu Seki voiced Gilgamesh again.

>> No.5446501
File: 394 KB, 640x480, 1277227287740.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5446501

>>5446485
>>5446415
It's called Rance

>> No.5446534

>>5446501
We already know that Rance and Gil are bros. and has been stated before that Rance is good but not enough, unless you're new here.

>> No.5446551

>>5446534
The people who stated this are pure faggots, as expected from the TM fanbase.

>> No.5446568

inb4 Rance 8 Spoilers

>> No.5446591

>>5446551
...Wut?

>> No.5446613

>>5446534
>We already know that Rance and Gil are bros.

No they aren't, because gil is a pussy that got beaten by a teenager boy and a slut.

>> No.5446620

>>5446613
Rance has had a lot of potential bad ends over the years that weren't much better, not that this line of thought isn't retarded, or that you all aren't retarded.

Which you are.

>> No.5446647

>>5446613
>MYFIRSTRANCEGAME!.jpg

>> No.5446654

>>5446613
...How is that relevant?

>> No.5446677

what is this you say?! rance 8?!

>> No.5446702

>>5446475
Shortly before that: "Still covered in blood, the woman's consciousness disappears in the back alley." She wasn't conscious of her own actions, she was just instinctually trying to stay alive.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action