/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>5165789
if you actually belive that your opion influences anyone elses then you're a moron

OPINIONS

oh didn't have that picture, saved

>>5165798
If you actually believe that was a honest opinion instead of a simple troll then you are a moron.

>>5165789
If you actually believe there are people who believe the plot of Umineko is good then you're even more of a moron.

Why?

If you believe your opinion is better than my opinion your a retard

I read Umineko for the Erika;-; and Kinzo parts

I think the whole meta-fiction part of Umineko is interesting, though R07 doesn't develop it very well.
But the whole mystery is pure shit, especially since the whole cross-dressing DID shit is confirming itself.
If it's revealed to be true, I don't see how anyone could defend this part of Umineko.

This thread

>>5165808
Added to my filter.

Umineko's plot would be good if R07 would stop introducing new characters every episode. Seriously, it was cute the first few times but now it's just stupid.

No OP, you are the morons.

>>5165826
I'm glad I don't have this virgin reading my posts anymore

>>5165822
I think I've read this post before

BRAIN PARASITES, CROSS DRESSING, R7 IS A GENIOUS

What is good in the plot of Umineko then?

But Umineko is good. Shame about the retarded fanbase that don't understand it though.

>>5165851
Erika

>>5165822
I don't expect a brick shitting answer anymore but a "lol magic DID meido" ending would make me rage.

>>5165851

the point at which the VN transitions from a mystery to a hilarious powerlevel battle over locked rooms with various colored text, leaving the reader completely dumbfounded as to what is going on

>>5165826
Half of /jp/ impersonates white ren, you'll be missing a lot.

>>5165883
>be missing a lot
No.

>>5165899
Jealous of my posts.

HEY GUYS

UMINEKO IS SHIT AND YOU BETTER AGREE WITH ME OTHERWISE THAT MEANS I GAVE INTO GROUPTHINK TOO

>>5167448

Wow, perfect summing up of these threads. Except for the SAGE.

>>5167458
Then no one would have read his post. Also Umineko is terrible

>>5165838
WHY is brain parasites stupi?

Cross-dressing is cheap, but doesn't explain EVERYthing.

>>5167785
2. All supernaural or preternatural agencies are ruled out as a matter of course.

>>5167866
C'mon, bet you guys didn't know about Knox's rules back then.

>>5167881
Can't say I did but I like how it discredits R7's previous work.

>>5167902
hey, "Abducted by Demons" is a great read nevertheless of us knowing the solution.

>>5167881
I actually knew about that specific rule from forever ago--it was in the intro to Asimov's trilogy about a detective in the future with robots. He was talking about how it wasn't really possible to write a good detective story because you could pull whatever shit you want out of your ass whenever you want.

>>5167785

There are no brain parasites in the original Higurashi. Hinamizawa Syndrome is a neurological disease triggered by stress hormones.

I've given up on the mystery, I know it will not be intellectually satisfying, because this story isn't actually a mystery.

I just want Battler and Jessica to fuck, my expectations have been truncated to just that.

>>5168021
I think that makes even less sense...

>>5167785
well, looking at ep4, we know that Beatrice wanted someone to solve it (ep5 we know its Battler, but since we are going before the commandments). Since someone has to solve it, and its not Nanjo (hes only a guest and has not shown any interest in the riddle), then it can not be a obscure medical condition. Higurashi had the excuse that Irie was obviously on at least Rika/Satako's side, Nanjo...we don't know for sure. Besides, Ryukishi said it was supposed to be a mystery, and following the actual Knox Commandments (not the in game one) no China Man can be the murderer. This has been thrown around as meaning "HURR DURR< THEN IT WAS BEATRICE< WHO"S ITALIAN", forgetting that the definition of Chinaman at the time was someone who was obviously evil/outside of the storyline/a clear mastermind. In otherwords, Umineko cannot be Higurashi because it cannot have a Takano. Takano was outside the storyline (I've only watched the anime/up to US manga/1st VN), very obviously evil (loved Oyoshiro-Sama, wanted to be a god), and a clear mastermind (gave Rena the Pandora's Box). Because this is not Higurashi, it cannot have Higurashi's plot premise. Contrapositive law.

>>5168030
R7 should write a spin-off VN for Erika

>>5168595
What, you mean Rei?

>>5168422
if solving the riddle let you into Kowadorian (or whatever the secret mansion is called), would THAT be anticlimatic, considering people has been inside of it in EP4?

>>5168859
>implying they actually were there and not just lied over the phone
>implying it was Kuwadorian and not just random basement
Seriously, do you believe that scene of their escape? It was made to clear all doubts about reliability of their story.