[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 263 KB, 800x600, 1273682000988.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5116732 No.5116732 [Reply] [Original]

Top ten favorite scenario writer from Comp Ace

1.Nasu ●「Kara no Kyoukai」
2.Maeda●「Little Busters！」
3.R０７●「Umineko」
4.Masaki Tsuzuki●「Nanoha
5.Sca-ji●「Subarashiki Hibi」
6.Sakakiraba Taku●「FORTUNE ARTERIAL」
7.Sekina Aoi●「Seitokai no Ichizon」
8.Tanigawa●「Haruhi」
9.Kenji Inoue ●「Baka Test」
10.Ameno●「D.C.II～ダ・カーポII～」

>> No.5116736

I'm not sure how some of these people are scenario writers, but okay. I guess this is mostly what you'd expect from self-selected polling.

>> No.5116737

>>5116732
I would enjoy being fisted by that huge hand of her's.

>> No.5116751

>4.Masaki Tsuzuki●「Nanoha
>5.Sca-ji●「Subarashiki Hibi」

I think the number of people that would actually think this is in fact very low, but Tsuzuki would obviously have more fans due to his very popular franchises (which is why he's too good to work on eroge any more ;_;)

>> No.5116761

but what about clannad...?

it's life...

>> No.5116763

Last year it was
01位 Maeda（ONE、Kanon、AIR、CLANNAD、Little Busters）
02位 Nasu（Tsukihime、Fate、428）
03位 R07（Higurashi, Umineko）
04位 Tanigawa（Haruhi）
05位 Baria Ago（21、Sorechiru、SHUFFLE）
06位 Takeuchi Kouta（Mai-HiME、D.C.II）
07位 Machida Touko（Scenarist of Lucky Star）
08位 Yamaguchi Noboru（Green Green、Yukiuta、Kamipani！）
09位 Kagami Yoshimizu（Mangaka of Lucky Star）
10位 Tanaka Romeo（Kana、Kazokei、CROSS†CHANNEL、Saihate no Ima、Chanter）

>> No.5116769

>>5116761
it's also six years old and nobody cares about it any more
get with the times bangkok

>> No.5116774

>1.Nasu ●「Kara no Kyoukai」

Nasu? KnK?
But it's the weakest work of Nasu, agreed by, rofl, Nasu.

>> No.5116779

>>5116774
I never take magazines or polls seriously. And neither should you.

>> No.5116783

I'm not sure whether I'm supposed to laugh or cry after seeing those lists.

>> No.5116792

Where's ZUN with his brilliant scenarios?

>> No.5116794

>>5116783
They're polls. Nobody really thinks Nasu is better than すかぢ, it's just that Nasu's works are more popular.

>> No.5116799

I think that Nasu write shit for schoolboys.

>> No.5116810
File: 27 KB, 465x379, 1258434761244.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5116810

>>5116761
The poll probably takes into account the overall work of the writer.

That being said,
>this list

>> No.5116816

>>5116794
I know that.
Still, they are fucking ridiculous in every aspect.
It's not even about who's better than who, but rather who's on the same list with who.
Well, I guess I'll laugh fro now... Though I wonder, does this mean Aniplex is going to have Nasu write an original anime for them next year?

>> No.5116823

Nasu is high thanks to the OVA of Kara no Kyoukai and the movie of UBW.
Same for Tsuzuki, he is high thank the movie of Nanoha.
Next year Maeda will probably be first, he wrote Angel Beats after all.

>> No.5116830

is sca-ji #5 on the list thanks to the tsui no sora anime?
http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm10626692

because that's a little unfair; those other things had more budget!

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action