[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 12 KB, 480x360, Ransama.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561487 No.4561487 [Reply] [Original]

So while reading through Umineko you find out that even though the witches have SOOOO much magical power, guns are still a threat to them. Even as great as all these "powerful" Umineko land witches are, they are still weak to lead bullets.

This got me to thinking. In both the Umineko world, and in Gensokyo, there exists a large amount of magical power. Has Zun actually said anything about guns in Gensokyo? Could all of the touhou's powers be rendered useless if space marines or whatever invaded and started shooting the place up, or does Zun actually respect his work enough to make his character's more powerful than guns?

Could the touhous defeat the witches?

>> No.4561494

Witches aren't real so yeah.

>> No.4561497

The witches aren't real bro.

>> No.4561501

Incoming power level speculation shitstorm.

>> No.4561504

super cool story ran

>> No.4561505 [DELETED] 

>Implying touhous are real

>> No.4561507

Accelerator doesn't have to worry about bullets, heh.

>> No.4561510

Yukari attempted to invade the moon, but failed horribly because most the lunar army was outfitted with firearms.

So yes.

>> No.4561513
File: 139 KB, 299x355, ayumi_sip.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561513

>> No.4561514

Shiki would kill them all

>> No.4561518

The answer to your first question is no, which turns the rest into meaningless speculation.

>> No.4561553
File: 28 KB, 506x426, 1266437670503.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561553

They are vulnerable to firearms, though how much of a threat a gun is to them is entirely dependent on their abilities.

A thing to keep in mind is that before Gensokyo existed youkai were being wiped out due to the advancement of technology which was one of the reasons for the creation of Gensokyo in the first place.

>> No.4561583 [DELETED] 
File: 236 KB, 600x650, rANoRGASM.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561583

>>4561510
>>Implying Yukari actually tried to win against the moon and failed while using her full power

>> No.4561592

>>4561583

Yukari is old so who cares?

>> No.4561593

>>4561583
Lol your fav character loses to a stupid gun

>> No.4561594

>>4561553
Allegory to sakoku, Last Samurai, etc.

>> No.4561598

Oh, what happens when someone in Gensokyo pulls out a weapon from other shmups.

Or even one of the wackier FPS gun.

>> No.4561595 [DELETED] 
File: 135 KB, 538x510, yukari pout.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561595

>>4561583
>implying Yukari didn't get raped by armies of moonbitch-level warriors

She couldn't walk for months.

>> No.4561602

>>4561595
Doujin fucking where.

>> No.4561608

>>4561595

>She couldn't walk for months.

That 's just osteoporosis

>> No.4561604 [DELETED] 

>Yukari attempted to invade the moon, but failed horribly because most the lunar army was outfitted with firearms.
Yukari had no hand in the battle itself. She just gapped a shit ton of youkai there.

>> No.4561619

When you think about it, firearms are pretty damn dangerous, even bringing magic into the picture.

What's the point of throwing a fireball at someone, which could light him on fire and burn him severely, when you can instead throw a piece of metal at him that'll pierce his body and destroy vital organs, killing him?

Technology is underrated in any fantasy setting.

>> No.4561643
File: 1.41 MB, 1500x1500, yukari gap red eyes.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561643

>>4561608
Oh you.

>> No.4561651
File: 609 KB, 1133x1600, the_tenkomori_13.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561651

Nothing

>> No.4561666

>>4561619
a military-grade 50 cal round = one shot can RIP a man in half.

Know your bullets, men. They're not all made the same.

Miltary rounds are longer and sharper-pointed.

>> No.4561671

>>4561619
If there's lots of magic in a setting, there's less incentive for someone to invent a gun. And it'd just be rendered useless by simple protection spells anyway..

>> No.4561681

>>4561487
You're stupid if you think respect for characters = make them infinity strong against anything conceivable.

Any well-made character has its flaws.

>> No.4561682

>>4561643

Why so old?

>> No.4561702

>>4561681
Well-made? I don't think you understand how fandom works.

>> No.4561706

>>4561487
Guns themselves are not powerful but the anti-magic toxin that it gives to humans.

>> No.4561734

I'll remember the fact that Yukari can be killed with a simple gunshot for future threads.

>> No.4561737

>>4561651
Tenkomori is awesome.

It's sad that nobody wants to translate Teddy-plaza's doujins because of LOL ARCHITECTURE CITYSCAPES

>> No.4561759
File: 231 KB, 777x958, tower.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561759

>>4561737
He's a building fetishist

>> No.4561762

If Yukari gaps magma into your bedroom your gun can't help you.

>> No.4561774
File: 22 KB, 320x320, 1214805835137.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561774

>>4561681
>well-made
>touhou

>> No.4561775

>>4561734
Well, unless it's somehow instantly fatal, she can just shift the border or life and death, or injury, or some other bullshit.

>> No.4561787

I always hated discussions like this.

"LOLOLOLO SUPERMAN VS. BATMAN WHO WOULD WIN"

It's stupid, pointless, and childish. What are we, 6 years old? Stop replying to this, really.

>> No.4561792

>>4561787
StarDestroyer.net
SpaceBattles.com

Take your vs threads there instead of here.

>> No.4561795

>>4561787

Batman wins because he has kryptonite. You should already know this.

>> No.4561796
File: 82 KB, 486x409, 1262613179164.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561796

>>4561787
typical butthurt superman fan

>> No.4561802

wasn't it said somewhere that shotguns are basically the bane of touhous?
then again, you have people like okuu who possess stuff a tad more lethal than shotguns...

>> No.4561804

>>4561734
She's a youkai. Being bulletproof is standard for all youkai, or healing incredibly fast if hit, or whatever.

>> No.4561815

>>4561795
>>4561796

batmind

>> No.4561822
File: 111 KB, 800x600, superior to nanaya.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561822

>>4561619
>Technology is underrated in any fantasy setting.

Oh you.

>> No.4561831

>>4561804
hurpdurp gonna pull shit out of my ass

>> No.4561832

>>4561804
Not exactly bulletproof but they can recover from being cleaved clean in two within seconds or something.

But they can't regenerate faith-based damage and people really trust their guns doing permanent damage, so yeah.

Gensokyo is a strange land. For example, if you shout "I'm a shark, suck my dick! " and really, truly believe it, you'll become a shark girl in a frilly dress with a huge dick and three remora girl attendants attached to it and tasked to suck it at all times.

>> No.4561859

>>4561832
That's not how it works at all. If you shout that, you attract some asshole fairy or possibly low-level youkai's attention and have a very bad day.

>> No.4561872

>>4561859

It's how his Gensokyo works and you can't do anything about it.

>> No.4561877

I know that serious Touhou mechanics discussion is impossible either way, but god, it's like this thread is specifically aiming to be anything but...

>> No.4561878

>>4561859
But then I can just shoot them. Problem solved.

>> No.4561879

>>4561487
So who other than Evatrice and furniture are actually vulnerable to guns? They obviously wouldn't work against Voyagers or Creators, who would just rez somewhere else.

>> No.4561888

>>4561879

Irrelevant. Witches aren't real.

>> No.4561891

>>4561487
It is mentioned in PMiSS that youkai are basically invulnerable to physical attacks, any wounds they do end up suffering healing as good as instantly, regardless of how severe they might have seemed. Spiritual attacks are the only way to truly hurt them.

>> No.4561900

>>4561891

Isn't Akyuu a dirty liar? Almost as bad as Umineko narrator. Bunch of lying jerks.

>> No.4561902
File: 17 KB, 500x400, 1207540558319.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561902

>guns and touhou
obligatory

>> No.4561909
File: 336 KB, 500x194, truth.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561909

>>4561872

>> No.4561918

>>4561900
Descriptive, not proscriptive.

Remember:

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheSalvationWar

So yeah, Akyu's only basis for physical weapons are low-quality iron-age weapons.

>> No.4561919

>>4561879
If a witch descends to the world of humans, she can be killed by guns
Creators are he gods of that reality, so they shouldn't die, but exposed voyagers should if shot

>> No.4561934 [DELETED] 
File: 4 KB, 778x72, 566456.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561934

Hello secondaries. ZUN stated multiple times that youkai can not be killed by conventional weaponry. According to ZUN they are only weak to spiritual attacks such as enchanted items or faith. They can also die of old age. But in general, youkai are eternal. Reimu has acknowledged the fact that youkai such as the faeries can never truthfully be exterminated.

Next time read some of the official books before making an ass of yourself. Also, the only reason why the Lunarians are able to defeat youkai is because they use a mixture of science and magic. The Watatsuki sisters for example have everything that Reimu has except more. If you're trying to kill a youkai your best bet would be to put down the gun and find yourself some faith.

>> No.4561925 [DELETED] 
File: 34 KB, 400x400, 1265475904854.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561925

>>4561787
>>Implying that American comic-book characters can beat touhous

>> No.4561944

>>4561925
I barely know anything about comics, but I know for a fact there are several characters that could easily wipe the floor with any touhou without even trying.

>> No.4561939 [DELETED] 

>>4561925

That's not what he's implying at all, you 'tard.

Get back to work, China.

>> No.4561957
File: 964 KB, 1135x1600, QUANTUM.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561957

>>4561934
This thread is so bad it needs a double black Tewi bombing.

>> No.4561959
File: 12 KB, 251x251, get out of jp.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561959

>>4561934
>Touhou canon

>> No.4561962

>>4561934

I'm not certain if you're being serious about any of this.

>> No.4561968

>the gun and find yourself some faith.

Or in the case of the ORIGIN of Gensokyo, lack of faith.

>> No.4561973

>>4561968

Is that you, Battler?

>> No.4561975
File: 542 KB, 703x800, yukarinsevenyearsold.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561975

>>4561934
>>According to ZUN they are only weak to spiritual attacks such as enchanted items or faith. They can also die of old age.
>>they can die of old age

>> No.4561991

>>4561975
Yukari manipulates the border of life and death to prevent herself from dying of old age.

>> No.4561992 [SPOILER]  [DELETED] 
File: 6 KB, 769x115, 22222222.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4561992

>>4561934
Also. See this.

>> No.4562002

>>4561992
So a buddhist chant would be more effective than a gun?

>> No.4562022 [DELETED] 

>>4562002
Pretty much.

>> No.4562025

>>4561973
Battler confirmed for strong opponent to Touhou's?

Assuming he stops crying, and gets a tampon for his eternally bleeding vagina.

>> No.4562041

>>4562025
No, actually. Quite the opposite. You see, Battler's denial only makes them stronger.

>> No.4562054

>>4561900
Descriptive, not proscriptive.

>>The Judge in Buffy The Vampire Slayer boasted that he could not be killed by any weapon "forged by man". Xander realized this was descriptive rather than proscriptive, and that man-made weapons had come a long way since his time. This led to a spectacular finale, set in a shopping mall, featuring a hand-held anti-tank rocket launcher.

Remember:
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheSalvationWar

So yeah, Akyu's only basis for physical weapons are low-quality iron-age weapons.

>> No.4562061

Battler's not a good case. He's got a fully-functioning SEP field that sees him through shit.

The best offense against Gensokyou's youkai, fairy, ghost, etc population is to outright forget them. Forget their legends, forget their origins, etc.

Battler would only be able to kill Tinkerbell. Forgetting Youkai/etc existence lead to them creating one last small bastion when it was once assumed they spanned whole continents.

Progress is the perfect enemy, not denial.

>> No.4562102

>>4562061
Bring on the GUNS THAT SHOOT LIGHTNING AND SHURIKENS!

>> No.4562105

>>4561919
Bernkastel said the only thing that can kill a witch is boredom. Your gun wankery is ineffective.

>> No.4562123

>>4561934
PMiSS is "by Akyu", unreliable narrator.

>> No.4562162

>>4562123
Is Akyu's unreliableness canon? I only hear about it on /jp/.

>> No.4562210

>>4562105

But witches aren't real so yeah

>> No.4562302 [DELETED] 

>>4562123
It's not "unreliable" as much as it is most parts are very outdated and Akyu is a combination of unrepentant.

On the same hand, she's wrong about all the Lunarians in their entries, which is the most obvious points. Personally, though, it seems to be to the point of being intentionally wrong; I think she was asked to stay as far from entries involving the Lunar Capital.

>> No.4562321

>>4562123
It's not "unreliable" as much as it is most parts are very outdated, a lot of what Akyu notes is hearsay, and she is rather unrepentant about it.

On the same hand, she's wrong about all the Lunarians in their entries which are the most obvious points. Personally, though, it seems to be to the point of being intentionally wrong; I think she was asked to stay as far from entries involving the Lunar Capital.

>> No.4562328

>>4562321

I don't know, that sounds pretty unreliable to me.

>> No.4562633

>>4562328
A lot of stuff we can easily understand is incomprehensible and incoherent to Akyu.

'nuff said.

>> No.4562750

>>4562633

So PMiSS is just a primary schoolgirl's social studies assignment?

>> No.4562791

>>4561909
>>4561957
I keep seeing this. Got a source?

>> No.4562801

>>4562791

Quantum something or other.

>> No.4562884
File: 495 KB, 1135x1600, onis_out_-_00.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4562884

>>4562791
"Why did she leave from the miniature garden?", by Maruchira

>> No.4562959

>>4562884
fkkin download link

>> No.4562979

>>4562750
After 1200 years she just can't learn better.

>> No.4563048
File: 148 KB, 324x262, genjii-bio.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4563048

Honestly, the way I see it, it's kind of pointless debating the logic of a series of games developed by a drunkard about a flying shrine maiden. I love Touhou for its sheer silliness - logic just doesn't mix with it.

Also, the reason Genjii was removed from the Windows games is that he concealed bazookas in his shell.

>> No.4563058

My favorite IOSYS song is Reason to Fly.

>> No.4563149

>>4561487
PC-98 Reimu fucked tanks up before she even knew how to fly,

>> No.4564135

>>4563149
that or Rika sucked.

>> No.4564446

>>4561651
You know, at first i thought "well that's a stupid idea"

now I think Yukari with a shotgun, or even Sakuya with any weapon is fucking dangerous. Yukari could gap the barrel to your face and blast you to smithereens. Sakuya can do the same shit she does to her knives. pretty much making any gun in her hands a fucking shotgun.

oh the wonders of science and magic

>> No.4564451

>>4563048
Genji was removed so that you never get Turtle rape doujins.

>> No.4564456

Genji appreciation thread.

>> No.4564464

>>4564456

He looks kind of like vin diesal.

>> No.4564465

Chiyuri had a gun.

She put bitches in their place.

>> No.4564523
File: 990 KB, 210x105, 1260605560894.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4564523

>>4564446
> oh the wonders of science and magic
Fuck yeah magitech

>> No.4564642

>>4564446
Yet Yorihime beat Sakuya. What does that tell you?

>> No.4564653

>>4564642

Moonbitches are cheating jerks.

>> No.4564757

>>4564653
Sakuya couldn't try and remember the basics of CQC.

>> No.4565699

The humans native to gensokyo has a small amount if guns, remember that gensokyo was once part of the outside world.

Personaly I think they are vulnerable to massed gunfire, while they can take a guy or five shooting at them.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action