[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 1.55 MB, 310x191, FcMwD.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554868 No.4554868 [Reply] [Original]

Apparently the Katana was quite weak compared to the European Broadsword!

>> No.4554876
File: 176 KB, 297x168, 1256744556753.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554876

>> No.4554878

Apparently I still don't give a shit!

>> No.4554888

It takes about 4 generations to create a standard katana... I don't see how a mass-produced western sword could stand up to it.

>> No.4554889

Katana is light and meant to cut through flesh and/or slice through open areas in armor.

Broadsword is heavy and meant to crush armor and deal blunt trauma if it didn't kill on a blow.

>> No.4554894

>>4554888
>It takes about 4 generations to create a standard katana
No wonder the nips got their asses handed to them.

>> No.4554895

>vice a sword to a table to give it extra support and prevent it from flexing
>hit it with a sword held in human hands
>somehow surprising that the one in the human hands breaks

Reverse the situation and the broadsword will break.

Hell, do ANY combination of weapons, and the one bolted to the fucking table will come out relatively unscathed

>> No.4554898

>>4554895
doubt it. the broadsword has enough weight behind it to snap a katana in two.

>> No.4554911

itt butthurt wapanese fags mad nippon is inferior

>> No.4554920
File: 7 KB, 107x550, 932479-1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554920

Bows were here. Your katanas are useless.

>> No.4554921

>>4554889
This is the real answer.

It's also why an armored knight would in fact win against a samurai.

>> No.4554923

Katanas aren't as good. Deal with it fags. Like it matters anyways.

>> No.4554924

>>4554889
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longsword

>Straight double-edged blades are often over 1 m to 1.2 m (40" to 48") length, and weigh typically between 1.2 and 2.4 kg (2½ to 5 lb), with light specimens just below 1 kg (2.2 lb), and heavy specimens just above 2 kg (4½ lb).

WHERE IS YOUR GOD NOW?

>> No.4554927

>>4554911
As a self-declared samurai and practitioner of Japanese swordplay, I can safely say that the OP is the one trolling.

You wouldn't know that though, since you have never been in the same room as a katana.

>> No.4554930

>>4554888
No, it doesn't. Quit being fucking retarded. The only reason they folded their metal so much was because Japan has fucking shitty steel materials that there is no other way.

>> No.4554932
File: 5 KB, 200x200, r9177_743743567.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554932

>this thread

>> No.4554934

Katana only as strong as spirit of wielder.

>> No.4554937

>>4554927
> As a self-declared samurai
I'm inscribing this in stone.

>> No.4554938
File: 95 KB, 400x400, 1250665161988.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554938

>>4554927
>As a self-declared samurai
Oh man, 10/10 trolling, I laughed.

>> No.4554940

>>4554927
BAHAHAHAHAHAHA

>> No.4554941
File: 28 KB, 400x307, ICHC_CantFixStupid.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554941

oh you silly /jp/ do you need to have the place you fap to nuked again?

>> No.4554944

Butthurt /k/ slav detected.

>> No.4554946

>>4554868
You know that shit's staged, right? That's totally not a real nippon steel katana, probably some 30 dollar stainless steel crap the way it looked and bent.

>> No.4554947

>>4554927
i could break a katana with my butter knife
shit sucks bro

>> No.4554948

The ignorance in this thread is astounding. Samurai wielding (japanese) katanas were known to be able to bisect fully armored knights with a single swing.

>> No.4554949

OP gif is from a German TV show. That German broadsword is superior to jap shit, cuz you know Germans make good stuff.

>> No.4554955

>>4554944
>instaraeg
lolumad?

>> No.4554959

>every wapanese response is sage
oh lol is dat sum butthurt?

>> No.4554961

>>4554946
>nippon
We won the war, your name is Japan. Now say your name is Japan unless you want another nuclear bitch slap.

>> No.4554962

>>4554949
Shamwow could block a katana, true story.

>> No.4554965

You're reading this because every samurai had the grace not to cut existence in half.

>> No.4554968
File: 33 KB, 360x410, H21.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554968

KABOOOOOOOOOM

>> No.4554971

>>4554948
Really?
Care to provide an example of this?

>> No.4554974

Mythbusters tells a different story, and I'd be inclined to believe them a hundred times before I'd believe German TV

>> No.4554976
File: 55 KB, 500x375, DURR HURR.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554976

>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948
>>4554948

>> No.4554978

This is why gaijin are looked down upon by the modern world... They do not know how to appreciate the arts, and cannot appreciate the spirit and dedication that goes into forming each and every katana.

Threads like this make me glad I moved to Japan.

>> No.4554979

>>4554971
He's trolling, it's off of some weeaboo copypasta, who was also probably trolling.

>> No.4554981

You're all ignorant pricks. This video is obviously 'shopped. The lighting is all wrong.

>> No.4554984

Reported for /k/ invasion thread, hope you all get banned.

>> No.4554985
File: 43 KB, 816x1056, 1267853578741.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4554985

itt samefagging /k/ommando

>> No.4554990

this is the gayest fucking thread ever


fucking fake and fucking gay....ill fap to all of your deaths ftw

>> No.4554992

>>4554948
I lol'd.

>> No.4554994

brb, making more "I'm a bisexual vegetarian" threads in /k/

Let the tears commence.

>> No.4554999

Badly forged japanese katana is as sharp as a club.
Next time get some real katana.

>> No.4555009

>>4554994
HEY
THAT WAS ME
DO NOT TAKE CREDIT FOR MY WORK FAGGOT

>> No.4555011

>>4554984
>/jp/
>katana
I don't see how. We are attempting to have a cross board discussion about a Japanese culture item and the various myths surrounding it. It's on topic for this board.

>> No.4555013
File: 10 KB, 200x239, bullet stab.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555013

HAHA dumb nips

>> No.4555018

>>4555011
Protip: I don't know if you noticed, but /jp/ isn't "Japan/General" any more.

>> No.4555023

>>4555018
Hurr durr.

>> No.4555036

>>4555023
>can't read

So sorry to hear that

>> No.4555037

katana isnt meant for swordplay, its to cut faggots up

>> No.4555039

>>4555018
Katana IS otaku culture in case you never noticed.

>> No.4555041

the smith intentionally made the jap shit inferior

>> No.4555048
File: 43 KB, 460x500, Oh look, It's THIS thread again.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555048

we told you last time, many anime and video games portray a full-plate clad, claymore wielding combatant (it's a human tank ffs) as superior.

Now go back to your LARPing your tremendous faggot.

>> No.4555057
File: 21 KB, 292x400, NA004621.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555057

In appreciation of our Otaku friends, let's post dead Japanese.

>> No.4555065

I have nothing against the katana, it is a wonderful pull-cutting weapon, but does anyone on /jp/ actually believe the longsword was exceptionally heavy and used for bashing through armor when we had all these nifty war hammers?

Also I don't think many people realize just how short the katana is.

>> No.4555068
File: 51 KB, 324x246, 1252460472244.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555068

>> No.4555075

>>4555036
>newfag who didn't listen to what moot said

So sorry to hear that.

>> No.4555078

They kinda hit it one of the weaker points. They should have moved down a bit, which is a more realistic hit point.

Besides, a samurai is such a superior fighter, he could kick the shit out of any prissy knight with his weak-ass (in comparison) armor. I mean, look what they did to the Mongols. Total ass kicking.

So, who likes cats?

>> No.4555081

And this the reason why I like guns more.

>> No.4555082

>hurr lets nuke again photos of nanking photos of dead japanese soldiers

Christ, a couple years and a board name change later and /b/tards still haven't noticed that /jp/ doesn't give a rip about World War 2.

>> No.4555085
File: 431 KB, 1480x1078, GuadNakagumaMatanikauDeadJapanese.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555085

>> No.4555086
File: 377 KB, 400x320, 1213639365618.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555086

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Hy_A9vjp_s

6:00 minutes in.

European sword manages to break the stationary sword where the Japanese one only bent.

>> No.4555095

I wanted to like Japanese horse archers.
But they're just such faggots.
Crecy was here, Japan is fgts.

>> No.4555106

>>4555065
katana is a quick-draw weapon, two guys sit kneeling in front of each other and have a showdown at high noon like the wild west.

Happy now? Now scoot along and troll /a/ or something, kiddies.

>> No.4555110

>>4555086
>模造刀

not a real katana

>> No.4555116

>>4555081
This, who the fuck uses swords anymore.

>> No.4555123

>>4555116
People who believe in honorable battle or those with respect for their opponents.

>> No.4555128

>>4555086
this just shows how truly reliable european weaponry is, it broke to another european weapon

>> No.4555130

>>4555078
Weren't the samurai fatass politicians? While the knights were conscripted warriors from birth?

>> No.4555132

>>4555123
And that is why guns win.

>> No.4555133

>>4555123
HURR IMA CUT U CUZ I HAS HONOR
faggot. Learn to use a gun.

>> No.4555143

>>4555123
sup /k/ommando

>> No.4555145

>>4555130
Other way around.

>> No.4555146

>>4554868
>gif
>trying to show how not powerful a katana is
Glorious Katana is glorious, the guy handling it is just too weak and do not have enough spirit.

>> No.4555151

>>4555132
>>4555133
The joke is on you. I've been training in Gun Kata for several months now.

It lacks the spirit of swordplay, but it's all the modern world will allow.

>> No.4555153
File: 54 KB, 450x533, 1267857392064.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555153

/k/- Katanas are inferior, look at this overwhelming evidence.
/jp/- NO IT IS RIGGED
/k/- No, it isn't.
/jp/- YOU HAVE NO HONOUR.
/k/- Japan losts. Honour counts for nothing

>> No.4555162

>>4555151
The joke is on your I am a sword master and know over 700 techniques, and my Gun Kungfu is so strong you would not believe.

>> No.4555164

While looking at this thread, i'm reminded of this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Shiroyama

U mad?

>> No.4555165

My weeaboo friends still dispute this video.

"REAL KATANAS ARE MADE FROM HIGH CARBON STEEL LINED WITH OBSIDIAN"

FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK Real Katanas, the quality they used back then would shatter the second they hit another sword due to the fact they were brittle as shit due to folding the steel and the fact the steel used in them was not much better than dirt.

"European Swords were all made from bronze!!!"
FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

>> No.4555167

>>4555151
You realise gun kata is meaningless if any fool with a nugget can pick you off from hundreds of metres away?

>> No.4555181

>>4555167
I don't know what a "nugget" is, but someone isn't going to be able to hit what they can't see. Use your head.

>> No.4555184
File: 29 KB, 449x1560, crushinggreatswordplus5.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555184

Great sword here, katanas are for backstabbing faggots.

>> No.4555188

>>4555165
The bronze age was what? Fucking before Jesus.

>> No.4555194
File: 77 KB, 1024x768, OHILOLD.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555194

>>4555181
hurr durr.
You're right. Use the katana to chop through 7.62x54r.

>> No.4555197

>>4555181
>LOL IMA NINJA
I'll behead you and your family in my sleep, that is how strong my karate is.

>> No.4555198

>>4555181
>to be able to hit what they can't see
Come on, it's /jp/ here, we can do that.

>> No.4555208

Katanas only have one cutting edge.

That makes them shit enough.

>> No.4555210

>>4555181
Samurai = Ninja?

Oh /jp/, how you've fallen.

>> No.4555215

Real man don't use swords. Aikido is the only wait.

>> No.4555223

>>4555210
Meaningless titles. All Japanese males were trained in the arts of stealth and battle.

>> No.4555226
File: 86 KB, 1180x1474, nuclear-explosion.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555226

Nukes were here. Your melee weapons are useless.

>> No.4555248
File: 23 KB, 555x239, your_a_faggot.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555248

>> No.4555256

>>4555208
Oh Christ, the only thing double-edged swords are good for is cutting yourself.

>> No.4555260

>>4555194
Goddamnit, why does that bubba'd nugget actually look kinda nice?

FUCK, I'M LOSING IT.

>> No.4555263

>>4555226
Economic Imperialism was here, your atomic weapons are useless

>> No.4555270

I find this insulting, as a practitioner of Ninjitsu.

>> No.4555273
File: 262 KB, 706x279, 1264923660903.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555273

>>4555260
Does this turn you on?
How does this make you feel?

>> No.4555289
File: 63 KB, 686x572, unsuccessful troll.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555289

>come to board full of older, out of shape guys that worship lolis that shoot magical bullets
>talk about swords

>> No.4555339

You people who claim that guns are superior seem to be forgetting that a true Japanese Katana forged by a real Japanese swordsmith can easily cut through bullets.

See this video for proof: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIDWG9Zn8j8

With a real Katana your guns are useless. In fact, a real Katana can cut right through your gun like a knife through butter.

Hope that clears everything up.

>> No.4555343
File: 95 KB, 460x329, 1237149761986.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4555343

>>4555289

>implying you aren't butthurt

>> No.4555351

>>4555339
You seem to be forgetting that NO-ONE will be able to see a bullet coming. And even if they cut through it, what about he fragments?

>> No.4555356

>>4555256
Stabbing, multi-directional attacks.

What the hell.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action