/jp/ - Otaku Culture

why compare shit to more shit

>>4349627
It can't be helped, all VNs are shit.

仕方ない

Why is TYPE-MOON so shitty compared to AliceSoft?

Why are there so few Nitro and Age threads?

>>4349655
Because not translated.

>>4349656
We got Saya, Phantom, Kikokugai, and a Demonbane anime. Surely that is enough?

>>4349668
Good, butchered, new, shit.

I really don't think Tsukihime is all that 'better'.
Besides, the two universes are virtually parallel, the only difference in flavor comes from the legendary nature of the Servants.

>>4349891
Tsukihime and F/SN are nothing alike.

>>4349925
-Blond main heroine who appears suddenly in the life of the protag? Check.

-Same heroine is originally the strongest but lost most of her powers at the beginning? Check

-Protagonist had a near death experience when he was a child that shaped his personality? Check

-Also gained some power during this experience? Check.

-Girl of a good family linked with the color red with a tsundere streak who is a constant factor in the story? Check

-Domestic girl who had a rape experience in the past who pushed her to the dark side? Check.

>>4349940
You forgot:

- Best characters don't have a route? Check.

>>4349940
Superficial oversimplified similarities that have nothing to do with how the actual story progresses?
Check.

>>4349948
He basically rehashed the main heroines and their characterization, same for the overall progression of the story.
It's the same shit with a different setting.

>>4349940
Hey FSN is original, because it offers you all those interesting cooking scenes.

>>4349940
-In one case, she only appears in two routes out of five. IN the second, she is a constant factor. So, different.

-Even at full power, it';s not like Saber can march into the Holy Grail.

- How their personality was affected and why is way fucking different.

-Shirou did not gain 'powers' because of it,, more like how it;s expressed.

-Akiha's role in near side is very fucking limited. Also, 'good family factor; is irrelevant since Shiki is part of it. And the Tohsaka's do not have actual influence in the city, they just have a mansion and no money.

-Sakura, even without sexual abuse, would have the issues. Not to mention how each reacted to their experiences. What pushes her to the dark side eventually is not the past, but current events.

So really, oversimplified links that have nothing to do with the actual story.

>>4349972
Your butthurt is showing far too much.
Cosmetic differences are normal but the setup are pretty much the same.
Same for KnK as well, Nasu keeps rehashing the same story with some differences here and there.

>>4349956
Except the heroines act almost nothing ali,e and the direction and the thems of the story are nothing alike.
Whether it's good, or shit.
Traits and ideas are rehashed, but that's it. 10 similarities vs 100 differences do not an identical story make.

>>4349983
This has nothing to do with butthurt.
I seriously cannot understand how it's the same story.
You just saying 'it is' does not mean much.

>>4349972
>Shirou did not gain 'powers' because of it,, more like how it's expressed.

Shirou wouldn't have trained to be a magician had he not been saved. He didn't get them out of nowhere like Shiki did, but it's still a main factor.

>And the Tohsaka's do not have actual influence in the city, they just have a mansion and no money.

Are you kidding? They're the family responsible for the entirety of Fuyuki. They certainly have magical, if not financial, contacts.

>Sakura, even without sexual abuse, would have the issues

Not at all. Sakura likes Shirou because he's the only good thing to happen to her. If she grew up as a Tohsaka she wouldn't have any issues (well, except the MAGUS GOAL MAGUS GOAL MAGUS GOAL MAGUS GOAL MAGUS GOAL MAGUS GOAL MAGUS GOAL one that plagues Rin. )

>>4349992
The point is the Matou training and being brought up to be used as a grail.
Sexual abuse came on quite later in her life.
You could argue 'One crazy old guy using them for his selfish goal/needs', but that's very, very fucking broad.

>>4349984
The overall progression of the characterization of Saber and Arc is basically the same in their route, of course their personalities are different in the beginning but that's just a cosmetic difference.
Fate could easily be seen as a remake of Arc's route.
Sakura's rape story has been rehashed since KnK.

>>4349997
>>One crazy old guy using them for his selfish goal/needs
Not much, they were both adopted by some old guy for their own need and that is what broke them.
Similar setup.

>>4349999
'The overall progression of the characterization of Saber and Arc is basically the same in their route, of course their personalities are different in the beginning but that's just a cosmetic difference.
Fate could easily be seen as a remake of Arc's route.'

...Sure, whatever.
Who cares about different personalities of the male leads and the heroines and different events, on different circumstances. COSMETIC.

And sharing a painful experience does not lead to the same story.

I know you are either retarded or trolling now, so I will just let you keep rolling.

>>4349997
>Sexual abuse came on quite later in her life.

If by quite late you mean age four.

Am I popular yet?

>>4350014
You are the one being deluded.
The date, the ending, the overall way the romance progressed with Arc/Saber becoming softer after a sexual encounter that was out of her control.
Even Saber/Arc as characters are pretty close.

why is OP so shitty compared to the rest of us

>>4350024
Sure man.
UBW and HF share the same characters in the same setting, so they are identical, you just fuck a different girl.
I mean, Tsukihime and F/SN have exactly teh same circumstances, just replace vampires with Servants.
Arc and Saber are identical, not to mention their interactions with leads.
Not to mention all the events taking place on towns/cities in JAPAN.
I mean, hey.

>>4350023
No, Sion.

Harry Potter = Tsukihime = Fate/Stay Night
amirite?

>>4350056
No, you forgot to add Twilight.

Why is Naruto so shitty compared to Bleach?

Why is Clannad so shitty compared to ONE?

>>4350119
This is why I still like /a/.

Why is Ever17 so shitty compared to Memories Off?

Why is Umineko so shitty compared to Higurashi?

>>4350135
...
FUCK.

Why is Sharin no Kuni so shitty compared to G-Senjou?

Why is Sengoku Rance so shitty compared to Pretty Soldier Wars AD 2048?

Why is Cross Channel so shitty compared to YMK?

>>4350183
Because Maou is overrated.

Why is Kikokugai so shit when compared to Kill Bill?

Why do you keep on remaking my thread, OP?

Why is it that whenever I make a shitty thread, some faggot starts reposting it?

Why is Baldr Sky so shitty compared with BATTLETECH?

>>4350225
>Kill Bill

Oh wow and I thought I was the only that think that way.
I still enjoyed it nevertheless.

>>4350411
Eyem the bone of my sword

Why is Toehoe so shit compared to Space Invaders?

>>4350023

Am I popular yet?

>>4352136
Don't mind me, just stealing your magic wand

FS/N doesn't have the Kohaku route.

>>4349940
You forgot:

Main villain is in love with the main heroine? Check

>>4352243
Kotomine likes Saber, Rin and Ilya?

>>4352184

>>4352246
Gilgamesh is the main villain, he is also the most powerful character in FSN

>>4352276
Sure bro, I believe you.

Kohaku route? I liked it better when it was called Umineko!

>>4352276
>Gilgamesh is the main villain

Kotomine is the main villain in 2 out of 3 routes.

Also, retard-san that keeps saying Tsukihime = F/SN: massive over-generalizations mean that I can say Alice in Wonderland is the same as the pilot for Friends.

Over-generalizing common themes from heroic fiction means everything is everything. That's why you don't over-generalize.

Because you have shit taste.