/jp/ - Otaku Culture

I hate spoiling threads.....

it ruins umineko for me!

That is... quite the wacky theory.

Wrong OP

Kanon is clearly everyone on the island, all at the exact same time

Erika is the metaphoric representation of Kinzo's late wife. She doesn't believe in love because she thinks her husband is cheating on her. She tries to find evidence of this but fails to and dies. She also tried to force a marriage with her husband but in the heart his still belonged to Beatrice.

*in the end his heart

Wrong, OP.

Kanon, Erika, and Battler, 3 bodies, entered and exited in the room. (red)

In red. Kanon can't be Erika, nor can he be Battler.

>>4100913
Ah, so that's what that part was about. (At least the cheating part, not the kinzo's wife part) The machine translation had me confused on that part.

>>4100941
I don't think that anon's interpretation is clearly stated, but it certainly is a very good interpretation. It makes sense.

>>4100941
The funny thing is that Erika quotes one of the poems in Bernkastel's Letter, that TIP that was released around Episode 3, I think?

Erika is a representation of my hand, which rubs my penis.

>>4100965
I like this idea.

>>4100913
>Erika is the metaphoric representation of Kinzo's late wife.

I thought that was Virgilia all along, with Kumasawa merely being the cover.

>>4100979
how is she so flat

>>4100992
16 and jap.
need i say more?

>>4100992

Flat? Who's flat?

Ryukishi stated in an interview that the shkanon theory is way off.

>>4101004
>Implying erika is japanese

>>4101008
Link? Oh god link, please let this be true.

>>4101008
Ryuukishi also said in an interview he loves the cock.

>>4101008
NO SHIT!
As unsurprising as it is, I request sauce to such interview.

>>4100913
But they WERE already married. Maybe forcing a "real" marriage by doing another wedding. At least to her.

>>4101010
>implying I was implying that, rather than outright stating it.

>>4101008
I'm sure a friend of a friend told you this.

>>4101008
No he didn't.

Will you guys fucking stop with the 'X is Y" theories?

>>4101007
Until we have seen Erika through the eyes of a detective, or it is stated in Red, Erika simultaneously has a DFC and tits. Isn't it grand?

>>4101032
Seconded. Even though it is a japanese/fantasy-oriented mystery novel, I doubt that R07, having mentioned rules proper of the golden age of mystery, would fuck up with shit like that.

>>4101044
It's like I'm being presented with a Schroedinger's cat riddle! MARVELOUS!
The only way we can find out is opening the box, if you know what I mean.

>>4101020
>implying HE was implying you implied that, rather than outright saying it

I don't exactly remember the red truth at the end of EP6 that Beatrice trolls Erika with. Something like "Kanon entered the room" and "Kanon was never in the room". And I understand this brought back the Shkanon theory, as that was one way to explain how he could come rescue Battler and there's still that red truth

I propose this. It doesn't exactly support Shkanon, but I'm just sharing it with you all anyway.
Either Shannon or Kanon (or both) keep the other as a split personality.
So for instance, Shannon has Kanon as her split personality (or whatever the appropriate mental disorder is called). But that's -her- Kanon, not the actual one walking around the place.
The fantasy explanation to this could be that as furniture they were made to be "linked", somewhat like they did in EP4. So if one dies, the other's soul will be with the other.

>>4101092
That seems like a fairly magical explanation, don't know if want.

>>4101092
Even worse than Shkannon.

Magic exists. Game over.

Kanon = Beatrice would explain a lot. Why he is almost always the one to meet people prior or after they "meet" Beatrice, he interacts with the people about Beatrice the most, and is the only one who thinks of her as a rival of sorts.

I'm leaving now. Some food for thought.
If you were to choose ANYONE without an alibi (confirmed by the detective) in any given murder, regardless of character or compelling motifs, how would you execute the murders without getting spotted? You may count on accomplices.
This method of reasoning is obvious for some. But try giving the murders an angle aside from being an observer.
Night, ol' chaps.

>>4101092
>The fantasy explanation to this could be that as furniture they were made to be "linked"

As in, they form Furnizord alongside Genji and the other servants while Power Rangers theme song blares in the background?

either way, jessica is a lesbian

>>4101131
>Why he is almost always the one to meet people prior or after they "meet" Beatrice

That's happened like... twice?


>he interacts with the people about Beatrice the most

I think that'd be Battler.

>>4101180
Battler only interacts with Beatrice in episode 4 and in episode 2 when he's drunk out of his mind.

Kanon interacts with Beatrice in episodes 1, 2, 3.

>>4101170
>Jessica is a lesbian
I can dig it.