/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>3756257
Not everyone likes her, for starters.

>>3756257
Well, if you're going to answer your own question like that, there isn't much for us to say.

>>3756269
Yeah, people LOVE whores.

>>3756264
More people like her than her competition, at least.

>>3756284
I see nothing evident to that.

>>3756287
Nobody likes Luvia

>>3756305
...And?

This thread is now about a good girl.

I don't like Rin but I am quite partial to Kaleido-Ruby.

What does that mean?

>>3756342
It's normal. They're not even similar.

>>3756257
But the girl in your pic is Kaleido Ruby not Rin.

Rin is better than the other heroines. Discuss.

Kaleido Ruby is pure you motherfucker.

Do you like fires, OP?

Yeah, well, Rin's like a fire - shining and warm, but you can get burned if you're not careful.
...
...I love fires...

>>3756358
Doesn't say much since Sakura and Saber are mediocre characters. Discuss.

>>3756358
Kaleido-Ruby > Rin, though.

In fact, all mahou shoujo versions of TM characters end up being superior to the originals.

>>3756402
>In fact, all mahou shoujo versions of all characters end up being superior to the originals.
Fixed.

>>3756402
I don't know if I would consider Magical Amber to be better than Kohaku.

Perhaps you meant to say "at least as good as".

>>3756257
Rin is my waifu. You do not talk bad about her. She's just tsundere.

>>3756402
Except Phantasmoon. Phantasmoon is shit.

>>3756353
Kaleido Ruby IS Rin.

I know, the truth is hard to take. You'll get over it eventually.

>>3756435
I rather Phantasmoon, i don't really like Kaleido ruby

>>3756518
But Phantasmoon isn't even canon.

>>3756446
BULLSHIT

>>3756446
THAT'S A FUCKING LIE!!
UOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHH!!!!

>>3756546
They have the same identical features, right down to the size of their (small) breasts.

>>3756537
And this picture from character material?

>>3756537
She is more canon then most things out of BMW.

At least she is based on official artwork.

>>3756554
Official artwork doesn't necessarily mean it's canon.

>>3756603

EVERYTHING IN CHARACTER MATERIAL IS CANON

>>3756603
Curry Du marche would argue differently.

>>3756612
If you say so, bro.

Rin fails as a heroine.

>>3756665
Saber is a glutton, so she fails too.

>>3756665
I'll assume adultery has to do with envy, but where is lust?

>>3756680
Sakura has adultry so she fails as well.
Ilya, Wrath.

>>3756683
Lust is fine for a heroine.

>>3756665
According to this the only decent TM heroine is Hisui.

And I am OK with that.

>>3756665
So how many of these will Caster have

>>3756683
Just like Envy, lust can't possibly be a bad thing for a heroine to have. The first is essential for many stories, and the second is unpossible to do without for an h-game.

>>3756665
reimu is a horrible heroine

>>3756665
Arcueid has none of these qualities, she is perfect anyway

>>3756703
During the events of the game at least Caster doesn't really have any of those sins, although if she ended up with Shirou that would be adultery. And you could maybe call it Gluttony to be stealing energy from everyone in the city.

>>3756717
Well, she's not the heroine of a visual novel - at worst she'd be a protagonist, for whom it's OK to have any or all of the sins.

>>3756738
She fails into almost every category and is the worst TM heroine.

>>3756745
>although if she ended up with Shirou that would be adultery

I think the fact that Jason kicked the bucket around 2000 years ago absolves her of that

>>3756773
I'm talking of course about faithfulness to her current Master.

>>3756746
You stupid idiot, you are always sying she is the worst Type-moon female, but you never said why, can you explain it? she is the perfect woman, wich means no one of the Type- moon females is nearly as good as she is

>>3756777
I think were there to be a theoretical Caster route, it would hinge upon Shirou finding her before Kuzuki.

>>3756799
Even then, her original master would still be dead

True best heroine.

The only thing for a Theoretical Caster route would be who is the Seventh Master? Would Shirou still end up summoning Saber?

>>3756808
Not a heroine, just a fighting game character.

>>3756825
And that makes her less of a heroine, how?

>>3756811
It would be quite funny to see Shirou try and manage Saber and Caster

>>3756861
Quite hopeless as well.

It would never work.

OP is a fag.

>>3756916
I wish they'd had a Bad End with the different heroines literally pulling Shirou apart as they fought over him.

>>3756931
That's a good end.

>>3756665
Saber:
gluttony
sloth
pride
wrath

Rin:
sloth
pride
greed
wrath

Sakura:
gluttony
greed
wrath
adultery

>>3756924
FUCKING SUDO

>>3757111
Kohaku:

Perfection

>>3757111
I think you forgot envy in a couple of those

>Adultery
Lust

>>3757120

>>3757132
Envy wasn't on the wheel. It'd apply to all of them anyway.

Rin is alot like fire INDESCRIMINATE and ALL CONSUMING.

>>3757132
Envy isn't an option. See:
>>3756665

>>3757120
Not really a sin, though these philistines seem to hate her for it all the same.

>>3756924
More like OP is correct.

>>3757254
Sup, OP?

>>3757111
Man, those are some wrathful heroines.

>>3756254
hey please stop spamming ur shitty board on Ynontalk dot com except with "a" insted of "Y" thanks in advanenc

>>3757278
Why do you defend Rin so much? She's a filthy girl. She even lets some guy, who she's only known two weeks, fuck her and cum all over her.