[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 157 KB, 1280x960, 1204420302541.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212658 No.212658 [Reply] [Original]

Did anyone else think Clannaids was infinitely better to UBW?

Clannaids was pure awesome, mostly due to Akio, Tomoya, and Sunohara. And Ushio. I actually wanted to keep playing, unlike UBW where I was hoping I would get to the end soon.

UBW was filled with the same repeating text twenty times over but said in a slightly different way and a boring, cliche retard as the main character. The only real appeal is the sex scenes, which are uninspired crap to begin with.

In other words, plot (Clannaids, Ever17) > porn with plot (F/SN)

>> No.212667

Your pic says otherwise.

>> No.212668

NOBODY FUCKS IN CLANNAD

>> No.212670

>>212658
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

HAHAHAHA, AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

8/10 just from the first line. Would be trolled over and over again.

>> No.212674

>>212668
Yes they do, just not in the game. Look in the tubes.

>> No.212676

>>212658
It's not porn with plot, it's plot with porn.

You've got it backwards like with your mouth and your asshole, retard.

>> No.212678

>>212670
It's funnier that you can't come up with an argument.

>> No.212681

Clannad is Porn with Plot without Porn.

>> No.212683

7/10
Sex scenes were a total fail, contrasting with the rest.

plus retarded shirou: "having sex means getting naked. I forgot about such a simple, scary fact."

>> No.212685

I think the budget between the games is the difference.

>> No.212689

>In other words, plot (Ever17) > porn with plot (F/SN)

fixt

>> No.212692

Well, legend has it that we got the leaked patch because of Sunohara, so I think I have to agree with OP.

>> No.212697

>>212689
In other words, plot (Clannaids) > porn with plot (Tsukihime)

fixt again

>> No.212698
File: 133 KB, 1024x600, 42.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212698

I played both completely and yes I prefer Clannad though they are in different genres to begin with.
They are both in my top10 but they don't even come close to my number one.
Pic related.

>> No.212704

Clannad>Ever17>Phantom>Tsukihime>FSN>YMK

>> No.212706
File: 365 KB, 640x480, 1168754396254.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212706

Best game ever.

>> No.212707

Obvious troll is obvious, as ClannAIDS has this name for a fucking reason.

>> No.212714

>>212658
you are retarded because what you are doing for the most part is saying a romance movie is better then an action movie.

2 different genres to compare them and say one is better is simply your own preference. stop trying to be an elitist faggot.

>> No.212719

>>212698
If it was good it would be translated.

Besides, anyone who can read Japanese belongs on 2ch and not here. Your kind is responsible for the disease called Moe that's spreading throughout Japan so get out.

>> No.212730

>>212719
You are a fucking retard.

>> No.212731

>>212714
Haha, F/SN is an action movie?

Good one.

It's a dating sim with violence and porn.

>> No.212737

lol opinions etc.

But I liked Clannad more than UBW.

I was expecting UBW to be totally epic, but it wasn't all that in the end. Clannad was sadder.

Only if Clannad was popular like FSN... we could get much more doujins and neat figures.

>> No.212748

>>212737
>Only if Clannad was popular like FSN

....what?

>> No.212773
File: 207 KB, 1021x598, 1205541108075.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212773

I agree with >>212698
I have enjoyed both Clannad and F/SN but that fine game is on another different scale of epicness. And the porn is not only normal porn, it's /d/.

>> No.212784

>>212737
LOL, people who think BAAAAWWWW = quality.

>> No.212785

The simple fact that Clannad has Sunohara and Akio makes it better.

It's also about 5 times longer so there's much more development, and like the OP said they don't repeat the same thing over and over again throughout the story so it has about 20 times more content.

And Tomoya is a main character with a brain and not pure-hearted good guy, which is a nice change.

I've watched shounen with more interesting plots than F/SN.

>> No.212787

>>212658
Tomoyo's face in the top left panel always cracks me up for some reason.

>> No.212788

>>212748
It's sad but true.

I believe things will get better now that we have an anime.

>> No.212790

>>212698
>>212773
Same person

>> No.212796

>>212788
No it's not, Clannad is much more popular than FSN. In Japan and here.

>> No.212812

>>212796
No it's not, the Type-Moon fanbase is much bigger than the Key fanbase in Japan. Clannad and the other Key's game are pretty popular of course.

>> No.212826
File: 467 KB, 1024x768, 1205541622712.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212826

>>212790
Nah, not really. I'm the annoying namefag that usually posts 3D PIG DISGUSTING. I'm just surprised that there was another gentleman who knew the game.

>> No.212822

Gais, anything related to Key sucks. Face it.

>> No.212833
File: 55 KB, 509x650, 1205541673338.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212833

>>212822

USO DA

>> No.212842

>>212822
Is that so? You're missing some nice visual novels.

Your loss.

>> No.212843

>>212812
Meh, from what I've seen Key is much more popular because it's a larger business and it's games aren't strictly 18+ hentai games so the audience is a bit wider. And everyone knows about the Clannad anime.

And Key makes better games, don't forget that.

>> No.212854

>>212826
Everybody posts 3D PIG DISGUSTING and have been for years, you tard.

>> No.212865

>>212843
You're wrong, Type-Moon is incredibly popular in Japan, far more than the other galge brands.

>> No.212868

Remember when everyone thought UBW was made of GAR and jawesomeness?

And then it was translated.

>> No.212875

ITT People who have never been to Japan argue over which porno games the Nips prefer.

>> No.212869

>>212843
I'm a keyfag too, but I must admit type-moon seems to be more popular on Japan.

Just look at how many doujinshis and other fan merchandise TM products have. I searched for Clannad doujins on Share and I found only 20. FUCK I NEED MORE!

>> No.212886

>>212869
I wonder why a hentai game would have more porn that a G-rated game.

Hmm.....

>> No.212889

>>212842
Maybe, but I can't stand VNs about school, love, relationships, etc. I can't digest that kind of material anymore. F/SN has that as well, yes, but it's a lot more action-oriented, it's more adventure-like, and that's what hits the spot for me.

>> No.212890

>>212875
Clannad isn't a porno game, retard.

>> No.212903

>>212748
Count the dojinshi with FSN.
Count the dojinshi with Clannad.

>> No.212904

>>212889
If you want action why the hell are you reading a VN?

>> No.212910

>>212854
I'm sorry, should've made it clearer. I post H!P and Momusu 3D PIG DISGUSTING fagottry in you /jp/.

>> No.212913

>>212904
If you want action, why are you reading a roman?

ILLITERATE FAGGOT DETECTED.

>> No.212920

I don't know why, but UBW gave me a headache from reading it.

I think it was the copypasta overdose mixed with the annoying blood-pulsing headache sound effect.

>> No.212921

Clannad = Generic high-school romance shit with the Key "twist".
Fate = PORN WITH PLOT

Both aren't great, but I'd take Fate over the overrated, slow pieces of Key shit everyone keeps slobbering over.

>> No.212923

>>212910
We speak English in here, sir.

>> No.212925

>>212913
How do I read a Roman?

>> No.212936
File: 49 KB, 600x400, 1205542529211.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212936

>>212925
Like this.

>> No.212943

>>212921
DELICIOUS POPULARITY. I MUST HAET IT.

>> No.212947

>>212921
Clannad is better because it has better characters and better writing, not because of the actual plot.

The After Story plot is still much better than anything in F/SN as far as I'm concerned, though.

>> No.212940

this thread needs to be uguu~ bombed.

>> No.212941

>>212925

When in Rome, do as the Romans do.

>> No.212953

>>212921
I think Fate is more overrated than all Key works united, but whatever.

This thread is bound to fail since the start. The OP is just trying to provoke a shitstorm since both VNs have nothing in common.

sage

>> No.212958

>>212940
I agree, uguu~

>> No.212961

>better writing
Yeah, okay.

>> No.212964
File: 42 KB, 704x392, 1205542813169.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212964

I agree uguu~

>> No.212966

>>212953
Both VNs are VNs.

>> No.212967
File: 88 KB, 614x376, 1205542830832.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212967

>> No.212968
File: 79 KB, 480x362, 1205542847359.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212968

>> No.212963

>>212943
It has nothing to do with popularity and everything with Key repeating the same tired spiel for at least 4 games.

And Fate's nice but definitely not as good as Tsukihime.

>> No.212970
File: 360 KB, 828x908, 1205542871991.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212970

>> No.212973
File: 119 KB, 704x821, 1205542889182.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212973

>> No.212978
File: 71 KB, 704x400, 1205542908723.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212978

>> No.212981
File: 53 KB, 704x400, 1205542923663.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212981

>> No.212987

>>212961
>People die if they are killed.

>> No.212995
File: 100 KB, 1024x768, 1205543000788.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212995

If you want an action oriented VN, Phantom of Inferno is better than FSN or Tsukihime and Cal is a much more complex and endearing character than anyone in these games.

>> No.212996

>>212963
>>It has nothing to do with popularity and everything with Key repeating the same tired spiel for at least 4 games.
Hay guises, I talk without knowing shit about the subject!

>>And Fate's nice but definitely not as good as Tsukihime.
And you just redeemed. Why is Fate more popular than Tsukihime? Why the fuck isn't at least TM remaking Tsukihime?

>> No.212998
File: 29 KB, 640x480, 1205543027863.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
212998

>> No.213004
File: 350 KB, 847x1200, 1205543068384.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213004

>> No.213005
File: 37 KB, 704x396, 1205543079317.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213005

>>212963

It may be the the same tired spiel, but damn if it doesn't pull on your heartstrings. Key has BAAWWW down to a science by now.

It's like complaining about getting gold for your last few anniversaries in a row. It's still gold.

>> No.213007

>>212961
Actually he's right, Maeda and Suzumoto are definitely better writers than Nasu. They don't come close to Tanaka Romeo though.

>> No.213012
File: 619 KB, 716x955, 1205543119353.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213012

>> No.213017
File: 297 KB, 600x766, 1205543149795.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213017

>> No.213022
File: 31 KB, 576x432, 1205543171569.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213022

>> No.213026

>>212998
What is the source for that picture? I never got it.

>> No.213027
File: 318 KB, 359x424, 1205543199464.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213027

>> No.213021

>>212995

Didn't PoI have a horrid translation?

>> No.213031
File: 5 KB, 200x350, 1205543214366.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213031

>> No.213034
File: 21 KB, 627x426, 1205543245866.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213034

Gee, it sure is SHITSTORM around here.

>> No.213055

>>213021
Horrid way of playing as well. Someone really needs to do a good translation of Phantom INTEGRATION.

>> No.213060

>>213021
The translation isn't that bad, just mispellings, and the game is fully voiced, even the narration.

>> No.213077

>>213034
I don't know how /jp/ keeps getting pictures of me.

And Clannad is better simply because the writing is better. I got tired of FSN because it the same old crap as Tsukihime with a crappier plot.

Also, I really wish Nasu would cut out that thing he has about repeating the same line over for 5-10 lines for emphasis. Everything he writes already has enough emphasis because he repeats the same idea ten times to begin with.

>> No.213084

TYPE-MOON has a bigger fanbase because it attracts the pedos.

>> No.213085

>>213077

THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR THIS CHAIR

>> No.213086

You all do realize that none of you have factored Heaven's Feel into this comparison shitfest

>> No.213094

>>213086
The hype behind UBW was much bigger than HF, so there's not much to expect at this point.

>> No.213103
File: 57 KB, 640x480, 1205543734295.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213103

>>213085
That was also because he repeated it for an entire page, and it was hilarious.

>> No.213116

>>213103
Yeah, but he mixes it up in the end with an exclamation mark to emphasize his emphasis on how much of an eyesore the chair is.

Even I started to hate the chair at that point.

>> No.213125

>>213116
I fucking hate chairs now. I don't even use one anymore, I just squat on the ground.

>> No.213135
File: 40 KB, 640x480, 1205544022568.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213135

this was the exact moment that i decided CLANNAD was worth watching.

however, UBW was always relevant to my interests.

>> No.213156

Suddenly

Everyone is a Keyfag

>> No.213157
File: 64 KB, 480x293, 1205544221688.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213157

>>213135
indeed. best VN route, too.

>> No.213207
File: 70 KB, 640x480, 1205544798005.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213207

>>213135
I thought everyone started playing because of this.

>> No.213209

HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES

>> No.213214
File: 108 KB, 750x600, 1205544884895.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213214

>>213207
No, it was this.

>> No.213219

>>213209
Apparently somebody didn't finish the After Story.

>> No.213236

You guys like Key's works because it makes you BAAAWWW, is that it? Fuck, I like VNs because they're a form of entertainment, many times more immersive than "normal" games. I don't play them because I wanna cry, how stupid can that be?

>> No.213237

>>213209
...and?

It doesn't spoils any of the "fun".

>> No.213244

>>213236
>>it makes you BAAAWWW, is that it? Fuck
>>I like VNs because (...) more immersive than "normal" games.
...Auto goal! You lost the game

>> No.213251
File: 15 KB, 275x300, 1205545334230.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213251

Okay... everyone is comparing Clannad and F/S N translation, but where's CLANNAD one?!
I had no probs with finding UBW, but i can't find clannad one.
Plz deliver.

>> No.213268

>>213236
Actually I'm far from being a fan of BAWWWWWWWWING games but I really loved Clannad. That's because it not only had some BAWWWWWWWING scenes, it also had lots of really heartwarming scenes and LOTS of really funny scenes. And yes it was really immersive.

>> No.213282

>>213268
exactly. It had a bit of everything. nothing wrong with a little BAWWWW

>> No.213432

>>213268
That's what I meant when I said the writing and characters are better along with the plot.

UBW didn't have anything special to it, the whole story was cliche and boring and the action scenes sucked. I was expecting the actual Unlimited Blade Works to be a lot more grandiose than it actually was.

>> No.213779

Gentlemen, i like both.

>> No.213786
File: 30 KB, 122x142, 1205551062969.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213786

>>213779
I respect your tastes Sir and acknowledge that you only play these for your own enjoyment regardless of other people's biases.

>> No.213803
File: 18 KB, 150x150, 1205551181913.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213803

>>213779
>>213786
You lost me.

Clannad is better

>> No.213819

>>213803

Well, i did enjoy both. Clannad for it's character interaction and FSN for it's plot.

>> No.213833

>>213819
Well, i did enjoy both. Clannad for it's character interaction and FSN for it's porn.

I fixed your typo for you.

>> No.213832

Comparing the two is like comparing apples and oranges. They're both fruit (Visual novels) but they're completely different.

>> No.213837

>>213819
>Well, i did enjoy both. Clannad for it's character interaction and FSN for it's porn.

I fixed your typo for you.

>> No.213848

>>213837
>Well, I did enjoy both. Clannad for its character interaction and Tsukihime for its porn.

Double fix.

>> No.213864

>Well, I did enjoy both. Apples for their crisp sweetness and Oranges for their sour softness.

Fix'd.

>> No.213868
File: 4 KB, 117x126, 1205551791790.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213868

>>213864
LOL NO U DON'T IDORT

>> No.213869

>>213848
>Well, I did enjoy both. Clannad for its Sunohara/Akio and Tsukihime for its porn.

Geez, this thing is ridden with typos.

>> No.213876
File: 116 KB, 646x512, 1205551877752.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213876

For all it's hype, After Story did deliver. While UBW was kinda meh except for a few parts. Maybe HF would fix that, maybe.

>> No.213879

>>213876
HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES HAHA NAGISA DIES

>> No.213890
File: 203 KB, 640x480, 1205552026131.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213890

Comparing Clannad and FSN is like comparing Dangos and Starfishes. Both are good in their own way.

>> No.213899
File: 92 KB, 640x480, 1205552100580.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
213899

>> No.213912

>>213899
Why are you so cute?

>> No.213913

>>213876
Nah, After Story blew away my expectations.

I thought Kotomi's arc was depressing, but After Story made it seem like nothing.

Watching Tomoya's depression was like a train wreck.

>> No.213924

>>213913

I laughed at After Story.
After all the shit I had to read/sit through with
dumbshit Nagisa...it was sooo worth it.

>> No.213925

I liked Clannad because I could relate to Tomoya.

I wanted to punch Shirou every time he had a thought.

>> No.213930

Sorry, but Fate is the superior game.

>> No.213944

>>213930

At least explain why tripfag.

>> No.213946

>>213924
That's because you're a miserable pile of secrets.

Nagisa didn't deserve to die, but I felt worse because Tomoya lost her and any motivation he had to keep living. Her parents also didn't deserve what they got.

>> No.214000

>>213946

Its a troll.

>> No.214006

UBW was pretty much fail. Fate was better. For now Clannad is better, and i don't think that HF could fix that.

>> No.214036

>>213944
It should be obvious. There's nothing in Clannad that can match the action and epic moments in Fate. Forget living up to the hype, UBW surpassed it.

>> No.214040

>>214000
I usually say they are, but these days I'm not sure.

4chan has been infested with underage retards for the last 2 years or so. It wouldn't surprise me if some kid got his hands on Clannad and continued to play it for 90+ hours even though he hated it just for trolling material.

>> No.214048
File: 8 KB, 135x131, 1205553480913.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
214048

>>214036
Now I know you're trolling.

>> No.214058

>>214036
>Forget living up to the hype, UBW surpassed it.

Read the whole thread first before trolling.

>> No.214065

>>214036
ahahah oh wow.

>> No.215786

>>213876
After fails because this loli can't be fucked.
/thread

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action