[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 194 KB, 994x743, a58be9b6ae05a30a5238d3d15bf41d4ba92f9ebcdbbb5b4bd7c1ecbf86b6a60c.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19652550 No.19652550 [Reply] [Original]

DJT is a language learning thread designed by and for those studying the Japanese language.
Japanese speakers learning English are welcome, too..

Read the guide below to get started.
https://djtguide.neocities.org/

Last thread: >>19644741

>> No.19652595

Newer guide website:
https://itazuraneko.neocities.org/

>> No.19652596

>> No.19652611
File: 573 KB, 1327x980, セっクス.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19652611

>> No.19652646

>>19652595
Stop shilling your website already.

>> No.19652666

you gotta drop that hater boner dude

>> No.19652741

>>19652646
The old website stopped being updated several months back.

>> No.19652861

>>19652595
Thank you, I was able to get some nice clean resources from that site.

>> No.19652868
File: 1.69 MB, 2400x2400, 3776é­Æ«é®é╚éóùØùRé¬éáéÚéãéÀéÛé╬(OTOTOYô┴É╗ìïëÏö┼)(24bit_96kHz)jacket_with_autograph.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19652868

sakubi is still the best

>> No.19652869

>starting the day
>250 kanji reviews
>仕方ないね?
>start listening to some classical music
>done in 40 minutes
I'm feeling the gains bros.

>> No.19652882
File: 5 KB, 271x186, 33ds.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19652882

Have you managed to make Japanese a part of your everyday life?

>> No.19652905

>>19652882
I talk to myself in Japanese sometimes and that's about it. I don't have anyone else to talk to, since I'm keeping my studies a secret from my friends and family.

>> No.19652920
File: 21 KB, 680x383, ebb0067bc4e3a0c03ac9f26e3f224eaa966f82c696a743166f3733f88ce02949.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19652920

>>19652905
>not using Japanese as your main party trick

>> No.19652929

>>19652920
>parties
what year is this lol

>> No.19652941

I've started on my Core2k very recently, but how am I supposed to actually learn the kanji themselves?
Writing them down on paper a bunch of times and trying to form some basic sentences is the way to go right? What is the best dictionary to look them up so I dont draw them all wrong?
Should I start using RememberingTheKanji or studying radicals as well?

>> No.19652964
File: 45 KB, 514x222, kklc.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19652964

>> No.19652981

>>19652941
Anki has been almost useless for me when it comes to kanji. I just skim through Remembering the Kanji and use apps like Takoboto and Tsukiji for checking them out. Also, don't write them in your notebook more than once. It's a waste of time.

>> No.19652991

minna genki? lmao

>> No.19652996

>>19652868
yo what the shit i just started listening to this

>> No.19653005

>>19652991
ううん。元気じゃないだ。

>> No.19653012

>>19652868
Cute monkey, which island is she from?

>> No.19653013

>>19652920
Who am I going to impress? The weebs?

>> No.19653022

>>19652941
>how am I supposed to actually learn the kanji themselves?
why do you think you need to or that there's anything important you wont learn through the actual words that use them
>Writing them down on paper a bunch of times
if you want to, buthow often are you going to use writing you think it should be an early priority? it'll be easier to practice when you know japanese but it's not harmful, only distracting
>trying to form some basic sentences
that's called forced production, do not produce japanese while you suck unless you are required to for uni credits, you will build unnatural habits especially with no one to correct you, only read and repeat sentences made by native speakers
>What is the best dictionary to look them up so I dont draw them all wrong?
any dictionary actually made for japanese (like jisho) or the stroke order font (in the cor on the djt site)
>Should I start using RememberingTheKanji or studying radicals as well?
only if you hit a wall in learning vocab that you can't seem to push through
if you do, consider doing 500-1000 kanji in rtk and then quitting it and going back to fulltime vocab
you don't need to learn the kanji, you need to get used to dealing with them
note that you are more likely to hit a wall if you use core for too long without reading, anki is intended for drilling things that you have looked up before, not for being your initial exposure to what you are learning
consider switching to a mining deck somewhere between 1000 and 2000 words, you should definitely not do core6k or core10k

>> No.19653024

>>19652981
>apps

>> No.19653033

>>19653024
>that 20+yo boomer who uses physical

>> No.19653039

>>19653013
everyone who has ever googled what languages are hard has read that japanese is literally the hardest language on the planet and only a genius could learn it
even if they haven't they will still think you're a genius either because those crazy chinese characters look impossible or because they're monolinguals who are easily impressed by anything anyway
most non-weebs don't know what a weeb is and have no reason to think less of you

>> No.19653042

>>19653039
Exactly. People always wonder what their names are written like in "Chinese".

>> No.19653068

>>19653042
Just write it in manyougana and tell them to fuck off.

>> No.19653074

>>19653039
>you're a genius either because those crazy chinese characters
I look back on these past few months and appreciate how far I've come. They looked like scribbles to me, all indistinguishable from the rest. I'll keep pushing forward because I unironically think there's something beautiful in the Japanese language.

>> No.19653107

people who think japanese is like beautiful or whatever are ultra kimoi lol

but there is a good amount of cool things that you can do that you cant in english

>> No.19653130

is it true that the japanese think there's something special about their culture or race and so it's no wonder that white people can't learn kanji or the japanese language?

>> No.19653133

yes

but its not like its a secret

you just have to ask : )

>> No.19653158

take a glance at a list of historical accomplishments and it floors me that the japanese could possibly think this, but i guess that's human nature for you.

>> No.19653166

>>19653039
First of all, Japanese isn't the "hardest language on earth." Chinese is. Second of all, nobody gives a shit that you can do something that 1000000 other people can do, except they're all way better at it.

>> No.19653176

I want to move to Japan and impose my gaijin beliefs and culture, as they are far superior to the japanese which is why they adopted many of our technologies amongst other things!

>> No.19653193

I just want them to stop sexually discriminating women in their media

>> No.19653195
File: 510 KB, 698x768, language learning difficulty foreign service institute.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19653195

>>19653166
>First of all, Japanese isn't the "hardest language on earth." Chinese is.

>nobody gives a shit that you can do something that 1000000 other people can do
normal people do find it impressive. because people think there is a difference between learning a second language as an adult and acquiring it as children.

>> No.19653206

>>19653193
why should they?

theres no such thing as ladies first in japan

>> No.19653216

btw its a better time for women now in general than its ever been and most ladies got more game than most of the guys be it in work or pimpin

>> No.19653225

>>19653195
I'd love to see one of these for my language.
At least i'm not finding Japanese pronounciation hard at all since it's basically the same in my language so at least that's a couple days/weeks less of learning

>> No.19653237

>>19653166
Where did you get that Chinese is harder? Pretty sure it isn't.

>> No.19653247

>>19653195
>by /u/Fummy

>> No.19653261

>>19653225
when i think about whether or not a language is difficult, pronunciation difficulty is perhaps the last thing that crosses my mind. that's not to say that it doesn't matter, but i learn a language primarily to comprehend it.

>> No.19653274

顔に妹がおしっこするよう願っている

>> No.19653281

>>19653274
no ones gonna wanna even piss on you with nihongo that bad

>> No.19653289
File: 191 KB, 1280x720, mpv-shot0101.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19653289

sure you might learn japanese sooner if you have a high iq but it really doesn't take intelligence to learn japanese or any other language. it takes repetition and persistence more than anything.
most people give up after a month because they realize what a great task it is to learn japanese or any other langauge. they don't have the autistic mindset(doing the same thing every day as if it's a ritual) to learn japanese

i have been studying japanese every day for 3 years now. still can't comprehend or speak it. i must be learning it ineffectually and lazily

At first, i was learning grammar from the 2 genki textbooks and then i just started learning vocabulary using anki and memrise. i moved to whole sentences and have learned some kanji along the way. i am gonna perfect kanji last

i have been just watching misa sensei videos over and over again

>> No.19653297

>i have been studying japanese every day for 3 years now. still can't comprehend or speak it.
what the fuck

>> No.19653305

>>19653289
Misa先生は私の顔に座ってほしい

>> No.19653310

daily reminder https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylbmc1hAofg#t=71

>> No.19653317

>>19653305

yeah i would bang misa sensei

being in love her helps with her learning japanese

>> No.19653323

she wouldnt bang u tho

>> No.19653325

>>19653281
But I basically copied the grammar from an example sentence in core

>> No.19653328

>>19653317

with learning *

>> No.19653330

I'd bang her stupid face tho

>> No.19653331

So I just tried reseting my deck. But I'm clearly doing something wrong. I want to start from scratch. With the first intended card. Which was, sore? (don't have jp ime, apologies).

I tried the googles but I'm not getting a working answer. One is to reimport the deck with the one tickbox unticked. Did that, no cigar. The other one, rescheduling all the cards also does not work, I have to manually reschedule each card?

I believe I saw how to do this a few months ago in this thread. Can anyone give a hand?

>> No.19653348

>>19653325
your grammar god has ravaged the fields of your mind and abandoned you

>> No.19653366

>>19653325
The absolute state of toilet poster(s).

>> No.19653371

>>19653325
this is why core sucks

>> No.19653378
File: 142 KB, 1280x720, mpv-shot0130.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19653378

みさせんせいとセックスしたい

>> No.19653379

>>19653325
you need to watch thousands of hours of anime and read hundreds of volumes of manga before you can start to copy grammar correctly

>> No.19653385

>>19653331
>the googles
I'd tell you to donate your brain to science but I'm not sure even the world's top minds can do anything with a cabbage that's been hollowed out and filled with mayonnaise. Even worse if this is reddit.

>> No.19653403

>>19653378
but will you eat her poop?

>> No.19653408

>>19653166
as should have been evident by my wording, i wasn't making a claim about the reality, but about the perspective that people have due to the data literally everyone cites, as can be seen in >>19653195
although beginner-level japanese is harder than beginner-level chinese from my perspective of not knowing chinese
>>19653247
the image cites where the data is from, don't be an idiot

>> No.19653448

みさ先生は3Dピグですわ

>> No.19653520

誰か妬んでる

>> No.19653557

誰を妬むんかよ

>> No.19653589

>>19653379
Manga isn't reading though.

>> No.19653600
File: 79 KB, 1024x768, reading teh manga.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19653600

>> No.19653606

>my face when playing vns

>> No.19653623

vns aren't playing

>> No.19653749

but they make me play with myself

>> No.19653765

no you got bored of that samey shit years ago

>> No.19653783

i didnt get bored of it my biology did

>> No.19653812

>>19653589
manga is eating

>> No.19653920
File: 50 KB, 604x591, Capture.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19653920

If you do RTK, remember to not rush through it and do like 70 new words/day just so you can say "I get through RTK in a month".

>> No.19653945
File: 118 KB, 405x364, 15435453243243.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19653945

>too slow to do rtk in a month

>> No.19653953

>>19653920
Is that your pic?

Also 25 feels shitty enough as it is, yet simultaneously agonizingly slow. Kudos to whoever can get through 70 a day for an entire month and then retain all of it. RTK3 is gonna be a fucking bitch though.

>> No.19653956

>7 months later
>still reviewing rtk
deleting your deck is a required step along the way to enlightenment

>> No.19653967

rtk is meant to be done fast. anyone telling you to go slow doesn't understand how the method works, aka they did it wrong

>> No.19653978

>rtk3
you can reach enlightenment faster than that
delete your deck
anata no yumes hontou ni naru

>> No.19653980

>>19653956
>2 years later
>still reviewing kana
i'll never forget it though

>> No.19653984

After 7 months the reviews will be so few they'll be trivial to get through, so long as your retention isn't ass. Might as well keep them up or RTK will have been an even greater waste than people already think it is.

>> No.19653985

>>19653980
>never reviewed kana
i'll never forget it either

>> No.19653991

>>19653984
>Might as well keep them up or RTK will have been an even greater waste than people already think it is.
you don't even know why you're doing rtk if you unironically think this is

>> No.19653993

Anki question:
Is there any addon that plays an alert if its getting late and you haven't done your reps?

Some nights I just forget to do it

>> No.19653996

>>19653985
eh anki is useful for kana when you don't have time to run into it in the wild. its just personal preference

>> No.19653998

>>19653991
RTK is to write. If you forget how to write then what was the point? You could have just read more.

>> No.19653999

>>19653996
>when you don't have time to run into it in the wild.
what the fuck are you doing
>its just personal preference
i suppose it is, some people prefer to learn japanese

>> No.19654008

>>19653993
is calle d smartphonw

>> No.19654014

>>19653999
>what the fuck are you doing
I keep kana and counters in a separate deck to practice reading them
>some people prefer to learn japanese
feels pretty good too. you should try it

>> No.19654016

>>19654008
yeah, I too put an alarm for every night, at about 10 pm, titled "Anki, you lazy ass"

>> No.19654020

>>19653998
>RTK is to write.
can you write?
i mean real japanese, not isolated kanji or copying what you see on the screen

>> No.19654028
File: 7 KB, 336x268, rawr.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654028

>> No.19654033

>>19654014
>to practice reading them
if you read at all this isn't a problem for kana
>you should try it
says the guy who still uses a kana deck
and not just a kana deck, a kana recognition deck

>> No.19654054
File: 113 KB, 320x320, 1310121.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654054

>> No.19654060

>>19654020
No. I have to learn Japanese first.

>> No.19654064
File: 49 KB, 609x583, Captureq.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654064

>>19653953
Of course it is, what, you think I care about others' experiences?

I had better experiences with my own vocab deck

>> No.19654067

>>19654060
then it seems you don't know how to write after all
what is the purpose of rtk again?

>> No.19654078

>>19654067
I know how to write kanji in isolation, which is a prerequisite for writing Japanese. Now that I've clarified we should be on the same page now.

>> No.19654082

>>19654033
some of us are busy and cant read 2 books a day. leave me alone. also i dont shit on your methods, oh yeah your probably too scared to share them.

>> No.19654095
File: 1.54 MB, 1920x1080, 4321534.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654095

>>19654028

>> No.19654112
File: 47 KB, 523x286, Heisign.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654112

>>19654067
>what is the purpose of rtk again?

>> No.19654114

>>19654078
>I know how to write kanji in isolation
who gives a shit, are you going to do 書道
>a prerequisite for writing Japanese
no it's not
>we should be on the same page now.
the page you're not on is that the only reason any beginner should waste any time with rtk is to stop mixing up kanji

>> No.19654129

>>19654082
>cant read 2 books a day
if you read 30 minutes a day you've got kana covered my dude
>oh yeah your probably too scared to share them.
i waste 20 minutes on anki review of a mining deck and i read 2 hours a day and listen an hour a day
my listening sucks and i need to do more of that
boy i'm tense now that i shared that no bully please

>> No.19654143

>>19654129
>no bully please
I don't believe you'll ever achieve Japanese fluency.

god i hope that was a decent bully, how did i do

>> No.19654144

>>19654114
>are you going to do 書道
No, but it's nice having a really good mental image of every kanji to such an extent that I could write them, which also means it's really unlikely I'd mix them up.
>no it's not
It is if you don't want to write with kana only.

>> No.19654161

>>19654143
shit that got me right here dude
good job

>> No.19654162

You, J*mal, M*att, and J*mes Heisig are all in a room together and you have a gun but only 2 bullets. Who do you kill?

>> No.19654171

If I want to do 書道 but I'm not Japanese (or Chinese), how do I get rid of that execrable feeling of "being a weaboo" out of my heart?

>> No.19654175

>>19654112
>for correlating the writing and the meaning of the Japanese characters
Uh oh. RTK doesn't contain the meanings of the Japanese characters.

>> No.19654177

>>19654144
>which also means it's really unlikely I'd mix them up.
you can get to this point 1/4 through rt1k
>It is if you don't want to write with kana only.
all you have to do is learn the general stroke order patterns and double-check when you're unsure, then start writing, practicing every single kanji in isolation is completely unnecessary and you can get to the point where you can guess the stroke order of 90-95% of them very quickly
all rtk is good for is if you can't stop mixing words up

>> No.19654179

>>19654162
Jamal and myself. No way am I putting down two of the greatest Japanese minds to grace this earth.

>> No.19654184

>>19654054
ur a guy i like

>> No.19654189

>>19654177
>practicing every single kanji in isolation is completely unnecessary
It's not about stroke order. Recognition isn't recall. If you don't practice recall then you won't be able to write them.

>> No.19654193

>>19654162
matt is the only threat to new learners
heisig has already done his damage and jamal is doing god's work
but i'm selfish so i'll double-tap myself

>> No.19654203

>>19654193
Fucking selfish idiot won't even share the bullets, fucking asshole

>> No.19654204

>>19654189
recalling isolated kanji does absolutely nothing for your ability to write japanese
you need to recall words
there is no benefit to practicing isolated kanji before practicing words
you can give me the "oh but you're still learning the kanji" bullshit but it's different because you're focusing on the actual task that matters and not being distracted by a bunch of bullshit kanji you wont actually write

>> No.19654217

>>19654204
>you need to recall words
Which you'll be able to do after you learn Japanese. We already clarified this point earlier when we talked about learning to write isolated kanji.
>there is no benefit to practicing isolated kanji before practicing words
This doesn't make sense. You have to know how to write the kanji to write the words. The "isolated" study is better because you're using mnemonics to recall kanji in bulk.

If you dislike that RTK teaches you how to write a lot of kanji you don't care to write then just skip them. Not hard.

>> No.19654222

Is reading a show's subtitles in subs2srs and adding all i+1 cards to your sentence deck reading?

>> No.19654228

Is there any difference in meaning between ...ならばならない and ...ざるを得ない? They both mean that you must do something or something can't be avoided right?

>> No.19654229

So you're saying for this language, I can spend upwards of six weeks (according to this Heisig guy) learning like 2000 letters and STILL wouldn't be able to read things? My god, what a language.

>> No.19654236

>>19654229
You only learn to recall and recognize those kanji. You don't learn their readings or associated vocab. You pick up on the latter two by actually reading Japanese.

>> No.19654244

>>19654217
>Which you'll be able to do after you learn Japanese.
not if you don't practice recalling words
>You have to know how to write the kanji to write the words.
you can do both at the same time without losing efficiency because you're skipping the step of making unnecessary associations with keywords
>The "isolated" study is better because you're using mnemonics to recall kanji in bulk.
the mnemonics are to recall the kanji given a keyword
you need to recall the kanji given the word you want to write
>If you dislike that RTK teaches you how to write a lot of kanji you don't care to write then just skip them.
you wont know which kanji are worthless before learning japanese
but i actually dislike that it teaches you how to write a bunch of kanji that are used too, you don't need to learn 1500+ kanji before learning japanese

>> No.19654245

>>19654054
What's this?

>> No.19654252

>>19654229
not the language's fault
you can skip isolated kanji and jump straight into learning words and bango bingo bungo bengo bongo you can read some japanese
also most people seem to spend 3 months on rtk

>> No.19654253

>>19654162
ill give you the right answer even though it involves me gettin capped

shoot jamal and heisig and pistol whip matts retarded ass to death

easy win

>> No.19654262

>>19654253
you're not getting out that easily
you have to live and watch djt continue to suffer
this is the life you've earned

>> No.19654265

>>19654245
a game you should play

>> No.19654275
File: 59 KB, 570x300, キャプチャ.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654275

>>19654262
i was hoping that aggro intermediate guy was gonna finish me off the other day so i could finally claim my eternal rest

>> No.19654277
File: 274 KB, 1257x3102, Intermediateざるを得ない.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654277

>>19654228
The Dictionary of Intermediate Japanese Grammar has this to say.

>> No.19654280

>>19654245
Dragon Knight 2.

>> No.19654293

>>19654244
>because you're skipping the step of making unnecessary associations with keywords
Yea you can replace English keywords with Japanese words if you think that's more useful. I don't bother because it would tremendously slow down RTK. I want to get RTK done with. The English keywords are just scaffolding that will be replaced with actual vocab when I learn Japanese.
>you wont know which kanji are worthless before learning japanese
I'm talking about people who are doing RTK after they know Japanese. For those who don't, they could just do some frequency based list.
>you don't need to learn 1500+ kanji before learning japanese
No one is arguing you do. No one argued RTK is required at all.

>> No.19654295
File: 130 KB, 326x52, words words wrods.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654295

One day I'm gonna be able to read and understand Japanese as fast as I can understand pic related.

>> No.19654296

you cant grow up big and strong unless you play your elf classics kids

>> No.19654302

>>19654275
shit i finally learn some japanese and i miss a standoff

>> No.19654304

>>19654296
If you play any games at all you'll permanently cripple yourself

>> No.19654306

Yeah, you gotta play the classics like https://vndb.org/v8731

>> No.19654316

>>19654306
thats not a classic but yet it is

>> No.19654317

i think anyone that unironically wants to learn japanese is already permanently crippled no lol

>> No.19654331

>>19654277
Thank you. So they're extremely similar aside from one single ridiculous exception that differentiates the two that I'll immediately forget.

>> No.19654333

well until someone figures out a way to dispel the gaijin mystique to it all people are gonna keep maiming themselves

>> No.19654337

>>19654293
>Yea you can replace English keywords with Japanese words
and reinvent rtk to be less shitty by hand? why bother doing it at all?
>I want to get RTK done with
you don't need to
if you've done 500 kanji you're good, you're not going to mix up kanji as badly, you've gotten 90% of the value in rtk already, diminishing returns my man
>I'm talking about people who are doing RTK after they know Japanese.
that would be a mistake, if you want to learn to write and you know japanese just make vocab recall cards and write them

>> No.19654339

I want to kill all the people who keep rehashing these cancerous meme arguments.

>> No.19654340

>>19654306
Why do I always have to be curious of how NTR stories end? It ends almost exactly as I dreaded, and now that my dread is confirmed I'm just gonna feel bad for a few minutes throughout my life. NTR never leaves.

>> No.19654369

>>19654337
>why bother doing it at all?
Ask people who already know Japanese but still use RTK to learn how to write. Recognizing a word isn't good enough to help you recall how to write it. Heisig's method works great regardless of fluency.
>if you've done 500 kanji you're good
I'm over 2000. Probably gonna make it to 3000.
>that would be a mistake
That's not what fluent people tell me.

>> No.19654374

>>19654369
>Probably gonna make it to 3000.
How many are you going to learn? The 6000-ish for Kankei 1?

>> No.19654382

>>19654374
No, just to RTK3.

>> No.19654383 [DELETED] 

>>19654265
Whats the name?

>> No.19654397

>>19654280
Thanks. Downloading now.

>> No.19654401

>>19654383
whats your name

>> No.19654405

>>19654369
>Ask people who already know Japanese but still use RTK to learn how to write.
how many people is that? just one?
>Recognizing a word isn't good enough to help you recall how to write it.
it's funny how i never suggested it was, and being able to recall how to write individual kanji doesn't solve this problem either

>> No.19654439

>>19654405
>how many people is that? just one?
Two off the top of my head. But I don't know many people who learn to write Japanese period since it's apparently not very useful in the modern age.
>it's funny how i never suggested it was
Oh then you're suggesting some rote memorization kind of process instead of just using mnemonics? Yeesh.
>and being able to recall how to write individual kanji doesn't solve this problem either
Sure you have to be able to remember the kanji in the word.

>> No.19654456

>>19654439
you're talking in circles and can't remember what i've already posted above so i'm going to drop it and you can feel confident that in the end you were right

>> No.19654518

>>19654456
Well in the beginning it seemed like you were just being a nitpicking asshole troll, and then later it seemed like you were in some contrarian mode responding with short sentences and I had no idea what point you were trying to make and for what reason, so I responded in kind. To summarize my point, Heisig's method involves you associating images with components. You build stories with those images to remember whole kanji. That helps you recall how to write the kanji. This method works great for anyone at any level because it's easier to recall an image than abstract squiggles. I consider this self-evident so we'll have to agree to disagree if you think otherwise. And I know of a couple people who are already fluent who found it to be faster, easier, and more efficient learning to write this way. No, that doesn't mean you'll be able to write words because you still have to remember which kanji are in which words but that's not gonna be very tough if you're already fluent, and you'll learn words later if you're not. So I don't really get what your point was.

>> No.19654550
File: 228 KB, 2400x1800, 7.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654550

Tashiro Daisuke talking about his English study;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BuGVK6ZsIuM

>> No.19654556

who?

>> No.19654599

>>19654518
doubting the value of rtk is not contrarian on djt these days
i did 75% of rtk1 and i wish i had stopped earlier
the only value i see in rtk is get better at distinguishing kanji, i find many things about it to be very misguided, such that it is neither appropriate for people who do not know japanese or for people who do
you get past the "abstract squiggles" phase after a couple hundred
my point was that doing some of rtk does have some value to stop mixing up kanji so you can learn to recognize words more easily, but that rtk is insufficient and in my opinion inefficient towards learning to write japanese
agree to disagree it is

>> No.19654616

>>19654550
is that hiro at 6:05? can't tell, all you guys look the same to me.

>> No.19654625

>>19654599
>you get past the "abstract squiggles" phase after a couple hundred
I was talking about for writing. Just because I'm deep into RTK doesn't mean I can recall how to write any new kanji I come across. But fair enough on the rest.

>> No.19654634
File: 91 KB, 447x597, 1529949669438.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654634

>> No.19654671

>>19654625
RTK doesn't teach writing. It teaches you how to remember the stroke order and composition of kanji. THESE ARE NOT THE SAME THING.

>> No.19654678

>>19654671
Follow the convo. Already agreed on that.

>> No.19654688

dingdingdingding
"Doesn't know anything about Japanese arguing about learning Japanese" detected.

>> No.19654695

isnt that basically everyone in this thread

>> No.19654707

>>19654671
That's not true. It doesn't teach vocabulary. It only teaches how to write some of the characters (there are a lot more than the ones covered in the book). If you want to know how to write Japanese, then I recommend just drilling Kanji with vocabulary.

>> No.19654713

>>19654707
Learn English before responding to me thanks.

>> No.19654724

>>19654713
English isn't really required to learn Japanese. Sure a lot of the resources ARE in English, but you can find plenty of translations of some of the more popular resources in other languages. After the beginner stage, you'll want to read in Japanese only anyways, so it really doesn't matter after that.

>> No.19654725

>>19654724
I'm saying that my post does not say what you assumed it does dude.

>> No.19654729

村 町 俺 川 木 店 天 風 嵐 岩 石 心 力 anyways just some words i could think off the top of my head that you can write after rtk the list goes on and on

>> No.19654733

>>19654725
I'm just saying that there really isn't any way around hard work when it comes to learning a new language.

>> No.19654739

>>19654733
Nothing you're saying has anything to do with what I'm saying at all.

>> No.19654742

>>19654739
Sorry, wrong thread

>> No.19654748

whats yalls issue

>> No.19654756

>>19654748
does it matter? if anyone sticks around they have sufficient issues to belong here

>> No.19654763

>>19654748
>>19653945

>> No.19654778

How much do I have to study to be able to watch anime

>> No.19654785

>>19654778
a lot

>> No.19654788

>>19654778
serious answer or meme answer?

>> No.19654789

>>19654778
It's not very hard
Step 1. Open nyaa
Step 2. Search for the anime you want
Step 3. Make sure it has subtitles and download it
congrats you are now watching anime!

>> No.19654792

>>19654778
you can always watch anime
the question is if you can understand it
you're not going to understand it if you don't watch it
so get to it

>> No.19654794

>>19654778
none. just keep watching anime until you understand it. some people say it takes 10,000 hours of watching anime for that to happen

>> No.19654797

>>19654788
the serious one please

>> No.19654807

>>19654785
This is the serious answer

>> No.19654808

>>19654778
1 hour of reading, 4 hours of ACTIVE listening per day. Minimum. No exceptions.
After 1 year you'll understand 80-90% of what you hear in most shows according to this guy:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JuJW3bWmJ9Q

>> No.19654815

Practicing my hiragana right now and I'm wondering, is there a stroke order for the kana in "gatsu"?

>> No.19654831
File: 2 KB, 250x152, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19654831

>>19654815
yeah

>> No.19654843

>>19652868
old and punished: sakubi
new and 元気: https://boirodaisuki.neocities.org/

>> No.19654848

>>19654808
>listening to cultists
reading for vocab, listening for listening

>> No.19654855

>>19654788

you'll need to at least pass n1 to understand understand without a dictionary. some people say this can be reached in 4 years if you study very hard every day. personally, i don't think n1 alone is good enough, because i've seen way to many words not on that test when watching anime, so in my opinion, 5 or 6 years to watch without a dictionary.

but that assumes you've been watching anime the entire time. so now is the best time to start. you just will be watching anime differently for the next 5 or 6 years in a different way than you are used to.

>> No.19654857

>>19654848
can confirm, I did listening for vocab and reading for listening and now my listening is better than my reading even though I spent like less than 1% as much time on it

not joking btw

>> No.19654870

if i get similar results to these ajatters after a year will you believe my testimony or will i just be another lying cultist

>> No.19654880

>>19654870
both

>> No.19654879

>>19654855
>6 years to understand anime
This is the meme answer right?

>> No.19654882

>>19654855
that's just for sol anime btw it will take at least two times as long to be able to handle a scifi masterpiece such as evangelion or ghost in the shell or akira

>> No.19654883

>>19654808
Too bad the last 10% takes way longer than the first 90%.

>> No.19654891

>>19654880
wtf explain

>> No.19654892

>>19654879
yeah, but since you had to ask, no

>> No.19654895

>>19654870
who said they're lying
if you do what they do you will be evidence that following their method yields their results
that's not the question, the question is can you get better results

>> No.19654904

>>19654895
well obviously not because their method is pure distilled science called i+1

>> No.19654910

>>19654891
i believe learning a language is nothing special
i also believe anon is quite likely a lazy piece of shit
therefore, id believe that you could do it but not that you actually did
hence both

>> No.19654911

>>19654870
You will be believed so long as you can demonstrate your skills and not just vaguely claim in English you understand "most" stuff and also please donate to my patreon.

>> No.19654914

it's funny because they're doing i+1 but not for the reasons they think they're doing it

>> No.19654917

>>19654879
think about it. doraemon requires over 10k words for the first 300 episode. thats 10 words a day for over 3 years. now, those words are used in plenty of ways, so no, thats not "one sentence per word". and if you want to hear it fast as fuck, thats a lot of practice. no dont listen to matt. i know matt. he started way back in high school. he lies out his ass and only counts the time he started ajatting, which is way past when he really started.

>> No.19654922

>>19654883
Also, depending on how you define comprehension, 90% comprehension can mean that you barely understand what is being said.

Here's an example of 90% comprehension on slide 12
https://www.slideshare.net/MarcosBenevides/how-easy-is-easy

>> No.19654927

>>19654904
i+1 is pure distilled science
they've diluted the purity

>> No.19654935

>>19654922
Yea but by the time you hit 90% you know enough to enjoy watching media in that language.

>> No.19654960

>>19654935
>enough to enjoy watching media in that language
i enjoyed it at 10% what are you doing with your life

>> No.19654962

>>19654917
you can learn 100 a day according to kaufmann. according to him you make tiny incremental improvements over a large portion of vocab such that you'll average far over 10 words a day after a couple years.

>> No.19654968

>>19654960
I actually do too because I like the feeling of improving, but I mean that when you're at 90% watching shows isn't a chore in any real sense. You're just enjoying the story. And incidentally you're getting practice. So at that point you're pretty much set.

>> No.19654978

I wish WoW was available in Japanese. The new expansion is going to eat into my study time.

>> No.19654994

>>19654917
>which is way past when he really started.
Yea that lying scum must have learned so much in his genki classes for those couple years.

>> No.19654995

>>19654978
you can make the better decision for your life and resist, it is up to you if you want it

>> No.19654998

>>19654917
>10k for doraemon

>> No.19655019
File: 742 KB, 800x3389, キャプチャ.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655019

>>19652595
Why same not?

>> No.19655022

>>19654978
>playing wow in 2018
You are a lost cause, just give up on life already

>> No.19655028

>>19654978
its called final fantasy 14

>> No.19655038

>>19654917
Jisho shows 70% of those as nouns that don't have a suru usage. You can probably memorize 20 of those a day easy.

>> No.19655048

>>19655038
ok, well divide the time by 2. but my point still stands.

>> No.19655058

>Daisuke
Worst name.
Prove me wrong

>> No.19655061

who?

>> No.19655065

>>19655058
Male Yuukis

>> No.19655067

>>19655028
still not as effective as putting the time into actually learning japanese

>> No.19655077

>>19655058
If anyone has that name I'm just gonna assume they're gonna get cucked. Too many protagonist and what-not has that name are often doomed to suffer.

>> No.19655090

genki is meme textbook don't waste your time with it just use tae kim and minna no nihongo

>> No.19655095

>>19655090
They are no different than Genki.

>> No.19655099

>>19655090
skip minna no nihongo too
>>19655095
genki is bad

>> No.19655104

>>19655090
Text books are meme

>> No.19655109

>>19655095
tae kim wastes far less of your time

>> No.19655116

>>19655090
tae kim is a meme, just use sakubi and boirodaisuki

>> No.19655133

>>19655116
what's a ボイロ
glad that guide is formatted now because it's the best thing we have

>> No.19655143

>>19655133
Boiceroid (B is like B for boneless, representing V)

>> No.19655144
File: 166 KB, 613x428, Capture.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655144

>>19654922
I don't know if it's a particular feature of English or if it's the maker's good skills, but English sure can make it seem like any silly combination of sounds can be words.

Assengle seems like a real word.

>> No.19655145
File: 535 KB, 989x807, 1519676897857.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655145

>I can understand Japanese more than before but can only process it if they are talking in a slower speed than how they usually speak.

How do I fix this?

>> No.19655150

>>19655145
Try faster sounds, of course. Songs are perfect for this. Better if you have a transcript for like, radio programs.

>> No.19655151

>>19655145
>How do I (get better at any facet of Japanese)
Read/listen more

>> No.19655153

飛んでいるファックあげない。もうじょうずいから。

>> No.19655154

>>19655145
Watch ボイロ実況. It's listening practice on lunatic mode, but there's almost always hardsubs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMYytG9uipg

>> No.19655158

>>19655145
Watch more anime and get used to it

>> No.19655161

>>19655158
If manga isn't reading, is anime truly 'watching'?

>> No.19655163

>>19655161
No, it's listening

>> No.19655173

>>19655163
Then what do you do with your eyes

>> No.19655177

>>19655151
So to get better at producing Japanese I have to produce more?

恥ずかしい

>> No.19655180

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k_WNjDS1rpA

>> No.19655181

>>19655173
You blink.

>> No.19655185

>>19655153
>もうじょうずいから

>> No.19655186

>>19655173
Read manga

>> No.19655190

おはようおにいちゃん

アニメみる

なにがいいかな

>> No.19655194

>>19655186
That's not right manga isn't reading.

>> No.19655198

>>19655177
Yes, pretty much. Like, make absolutely no mistake, reading and listening will improve your speaking as you absorb natural speech patterns. However, you need to speak to get used to speaking. You may subconsciously know the proper way to say "Where can I get a chair?", but if you haven't practiced speaking, you'll stammer and pause while thinking over how to properly say it, instead of just naturally saying it thanks to experience.
>>19655185
Awful "pun" on 上手 (jouzu) and 上手い (umai)

>> No.19655199

>>19655194
sure it is

>> No.19655206

>>19655190
俺の妹がこんなに可愛いわけがない!!!

貴方はだれ?? 俺の妹はどこ?

>> No.19655212

>>19655161
anime closer to listening than manga is to reading
podcasts or audiobooks are better

>> No.19655230

>>19655154
normal 実況 can often have natural speaking speed without the tts
subs interfere with listening practice, your progress will be slower

>> No.19655235

>>19655230
you can just ignore the subs

>> No.19655236
File: 22 KB, 856x83, Screenshot 2018-08-13 at 01.33.04.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655236

When did you realize that "method" learning is a meme?

>> No.19655237

>>19655206
あたしだ

そのアニメはみるつもりがない

>> No.19655244

When と is being used in its function as the quotation particle, how restrictive is the list of legal operative verbs?

So for example this sentence

>寺田教授は「正確な分析ができるようになることで、太陽系の起源をより詳しく研究できると期待している」と話していました。
https://www3.nhk.or.jp/news/html/20180808/k10011568411000.html?utm_int=news-culture_contents_list-items_024

makes most sense to me by interpreting 研究できると期待している as と (quotation) + 期待する , as in 寺田教授 is 期待する'ing for the quoted phrase. But 期待する is outside the usual shortlist of 思う・言う・など that you see used with this grammar so I'm not too sure if I'm reading real Japanese or inventing my own.

>> No.19655247

>>19655235
you can, but that post seemed to endorse them so i thought it was worth saying
the fact that tts should be avoided when you are bad at japanese remains

>> No.19655251

>>19655247
voiceroids aren't normal TTS, they're programmed by the people who use them, who are natives

>> No.19655255

>>19655236
unironically from krashen

>> No.19655256

are Japanese subs in Japanese videos aimed at Japanese audience good or not?

>> No.19655257

>>19655256
they're fine

>> No.19655260
File: 435 KB, 1268x713, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655260

>>19655251
ex

>> No.19655266

>>19655236
The person who wrote that post sounds like the kind who do easy textbooks and language learning apps for years with no result because "they're appropriate for my level".

>> No.19655267
File: 339 KB, 1270x714, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655267

>>19655260
continuation
>>19655266
they're also write about what they're actually saying in this case

>> No.19655270

>get the reading correctly but the meaning wrongly
>get the meaning correctly but the reading incorrectly
This sucks. I feel so much worse than if I got both wrong.

>> No.19655274
File: 66 KB, 586x658, てらだ.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655274

>>19655244
いろんなのがいっぱいつく

はっきりいうと

どうくっつけても

だいたいのいみはつうじるんじゃないかなあとおもうよ

>> No.19655275

>>19655267
Is he right about AJATT being the exact opposite of what Krashen recommends? Because it's not.

>> No.19655277

>>19655251
they are both still an imitation of human speech and you don't know how much effort the creator put into corrections
>>19655256
they will not harm your japanese but they will decrease the efficacy of your listening practice in the same way that narrated dialogue will decrease the efficacy of your reading practice
it is up to you if you are okay with that, the most important thing is that you put in time at all
>>19655260
>>19655267
so there's no sentence pitch?

>> No.19655279

>>19655275
everything ajatt recommends except for massive input is the opposite of what krashen recommends

>> No.19655283

>>19655275
krashen doesn't recommend wasting hours on drilling the same input, via flash cards or passive listening

>> No.19655287

>>19655275
krashen doesn't recommend rtk

>> No.19655302

>>19655244
https://djtarchive.neocities.org/bunpou/full_day.html#と(3)
>2. と is used to mark the content of such actions as 思う 'think; feel', 考える 'think (with the intellect)', 書く 'write', 聞く 'hear', and 説明する 'explain'.
https://kotobank.jp/word/%E3%81%A8-579147
>2 (文や句をそのまま受けて)動作・作用・状態の内容を表す。引用の「と」。「正しい―いう結論に達する」

>> No.19655305

>>19655270
Reminder that the prime minister of Japanese read 云々 as "てんでん"

>> No.19655312

>>19655305
>the 々 doesn't represent the same reading
is this legal? isn't someone going to jail for ruining the writing system?

>> No.19655313

>>19655305
>々
What the fuck is that? I've been seeing that a lot lately.

>> No.19655314

Did the translator confuse 貝 with 具?

>> No.19655317

>>19655313
google先生

>> No.19655320
File: 353 KB, 1168x368, b.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655320

>>19655314
Duh, forgot the image

>> No.19655321

>>19655313
云々 = 云云

>> No.19655324

>>19655320
Yes

>> No.19655328

>>19655320
that's good i like that

>> No.19655330

>>19655312
Lad, 時々 is one of the most common words in the fucking language.

>> No.19655332

>>19655274
わかるとおm

>>19655256
Your comprehension will be greater and so your overall progress will be faster, but your eyes will be doing more of the lifting than your ears, so your listening returns won't be as great as if you'd gone without. What do you want to train?

>> No.19655338

>>19655330
and it uses the same reading, i know that rendaku is covered

>> No.19655340

>>19655305
Too busy thinking up ways to boost birth rates, I bet!

>> No.19655341

>>19655324
That's kind of a dumb mistake for a professional translator to make isn't it?

>> No.19655343

>>19655321
So what, the symbol repeats phrases to save time?

>> No.19655344

>>19655338
うんぬん is just a special type of rendaku specifically for ん and subsequent vowel syllables

>> No.19655346

>>19655341
motherfucker didn't do rtk
that's a joke
>>19655343
i told you to google it you fuck

>> No.19655351

>>19655344
interesting, thanks

>> No.19655352

>>19655346
>i told you to google it you fuck
You're not my father.

>> No.19655354

>>19655352
No, I AM your father.

I told you to learn Chinese because it'll be a far more useful language, and what did you do? Disappoint me further.

>> No.19655364

>>19655341
Yeah well. It doesn't take much to become a "professional" translator of Japanese media. A lot of Japanese media, let's say more than 65%, a number I pulled out of my ass, has bad translations. No one checks and no one cares.

Also I don't know if you realize but that's not the only translation mistake in that screenshot.

>> No.19655367

>be me learn few hiragana charatcters
>dont memorize it fuck all but still can remember them but have a terrible photographic memory so i cant imagine them in my head
>open new flan doujin
>see characters that i know i learned
>get flustered as fuck

its like i wanna learn this shit, dont get me wrong but my brain is weird with photographic memory of some shit i learn. It irritates me that i cant learn all of it but i see shit i know.

>> No.19655368



はあたらしいにほんごなのかな

えいごがはじめてはいってきた

300ねんまえくらいに

つくられたとか

うんぬんかんぬん

>> No.19655373

most of manga translations you see online is actually translated from chinese to english by chink themselves btw

>> No.19655374

>>19655368
云々の「ぬん」とは、なぜ「うん」ではないの?連濁とか?

>> No.19655375

>云
>言

What's the difference?

>> No.19655376

>>19655364
>Also I don't know if you realize but that's not the only translation mistake in that screenshot.
That was the only one I caught, what else is wrong with it?

>> No.19655379

>>19655375
tell
say

>> No.19655389
File: 7 KB, 560x315, QB.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655389

にほんごのなりたちは

わけがわからないよ

きゅっぷい

>> No.19655392

>>19655367
if you want to be able to picture them in your head you have to practice recalling and writing them (doesn't have to be on paper, imaging the strokes is fine)
you also don't have to do this to be able to read
but if you are giving up because your life isn't easy you're not gonna make it so don't bother

>> No.19655395
File: 495 KB, 1176x1000, 1401036424102.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655395

>>19655274
ありがとうございます。わかったと思うけど漢字を使わないときに私には読みにくいです。生じるものを間違ったら、生じることが珍しいことだから、許してくれてください

Is that a sentence parser? Thank you for pointing me to that, as well.

>>19655302
The first definition seems to prescribe more restrictions than the second. I'm going to trust the second because it's in Japanese.

>> No.19655400

>>19655374
そういうのは

「うんうんより

はつおんが

かっこいい」

「むかしの

がいこくの

はつおんがのこってる」

とかそういうのじゃないかなあとおもうよ

>> No.19655406

>>19655392
ouch

>> No.19655407

So it only takes like 10 years ofconstant study to reach an acceptable level of proficiency right

>> No.19655415

>>19655407
how much study
what do you consider proficient

>> No.19655416

>>19655407
>10 years of constant study
The moment you think your level of proficiency is acceptable, you'd have already permanently crippled yourself.

>> No.19655421

>>19655407
More like three fiddy to be honest

>> No.19655430

>>19655406
not supposed to be a jab my dude
if you want to do anything hard you're going to need to get a more realistic attitude, stop making excuses, and truly commit or you're wasting your time because with your current attitude you're looking for a reason to quit
if you want to learn japanese then prove me wrong, do it for yourself, personally it's made me better at committing to other things in life as well

>> No.19655438

>>19655376
このままじゃ。。。 is the start of a phrase which continues in the second bubble.
I would translate it like this:
Well, it may be alive, but it poses no danger. In its current state...
It's kinda like a shell.

My translation is slightly more awkward to read but on the other hand it's more true to the original.

>> No.19655441

>>19655367
Hiragana often takes people no longer than a week to learn so maybe there is something wrong with you.

>> No.19655446

>>19655395
おにいちゃんのにほんご

わかりやすい

へんだけど

わかる

>> No.19655447

>>19655441
the majority of people approach kana stupidly so it's not surprising

>> No.19655454

>>19655430
only if i had more in life sure, but right now im at my best choice of shit. Poor as shit going to online community college, such as life not even a pessimist either. Just slowly walking through life.

>> No.19655463

>>19655446
あ、、ありがとう

>へんだけど

やっぱりそうだ
どうしよう
うわ~

>> No.19655465

>>19653195
>I could have learned Spanish or French or pretty much any European language in half a year.
I sometimes think about this, not that I have any interest in it but damn that's such a short time compared to Japanese.

>> No.19655467

>>19655454
Getting dangerously close to blogging there, so let's move on to something else.

What are you trying to read?

>> No.19655469

>>19655438
Forgot to add that putting a period in the middle of a manga bubble in English is super awkward in some situations like this one, so I totally understand if that translator intentionally combined the two phrases into one to avoid having a period. On the other hand I would not be surprised if the translator just went over every word in that bubble with google translate and mashed it into something that made the most sense.

>> No.19655470

talking about your experiences in a group of similars is not blogging

>> No.19655479

>>19655467
Just anything in general, along with just learning this as a 2nd language.

>> No.19655519

learn an easier 2nd language, like ภาษาไทย, íslenska or Cymraeg

>> No.19655522

>>19655463
ぜったいだいじょうぶ

きにしない

草稿だけかいて

にほんごがじょうずなにほんじんに

推敲してもらえばいい

にほんじんもそうしてる

>> No.19655523

>>19655519
Learn English first, then German. This will take 6 months. Then learn Russian, since you already know German this will be easier. After that learn Chinese, which will be easier because you already know Russian. Only after that should you learn Japanese.

>> No.19655527
File: 155 KB, 1280x720, mpv-shot0134.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655527

any more japanese teachers on youtube besides misa sensei?
i have seen all over her videos

>> No.19655528

>>19655523
What's the connection between Russian and Chinese that makes it easier?

>> No.19655530

>>19655523
>6 months
Why do people believe you can be fluent in anything in 6 months? that's bullshit.

>> No.19655533

>>19655528
Experience with another alphabet.

>>19655530
Thats what the vague online resources tell me, they wouldn't lie :^)

>> No.19655539

>>19655527
JapanesePod101 is okay.

>> No.19655551

>>19655530
at only five hours a day that's 900 hours, you absolute can be fluent in 6 months.

>> No.19655557

>>19655533
>Experience with another alphabet.
And ภาษาไทย isn't?

>> No.19655565

>>19655438
What makes you think このままじゃ is referring to it's appearance and not that it's not currently dangerous? To me it reads like typical 倒置法

>> No.19655571

>>19655551
You'll have to define fluent here

>> No.19655580

あたしはフランス語とかロシア語にきょうみがありあります

あとトルコ語

>> No.19655585

>>19655571
The same way Steve Kaufman defines it.

>> No.19655591

>>19655551

fluent like a native speaker? no way

i don't even think you can become fluent in german in that amount of time, and german is an easier language to learn for english speakers

>> No.19655594

>>19655591
>Fluent like a native speaker
The goal just shifted

>> No.19655595

>>19655591
fluent does not mean nativelike

>> No.19655597

>>19655591
French takes about 700 hours to reach C1 so I don't see why not.

>> No.19655598

>>19655594

fluent to me means you can speak like a native speaker. if you can't speak like a native speaker, you're not fluent

>> No.19655599
File: 20 KB, 622x297, Capture.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655599

>>19655585
At least link me to his 9-minute long video that does this.

>>19655595
Fuck, I'm not even fluent in English, then

>> No.19655600

>>19655591
That's quitter talk. If you believe in yourself, you can do anything.

>> No.19655602

>>19655598
Ok well to you you can't become fluent in 6 months. To people with a more reasonable definition of fluent which isn't just "native-level", you can.

>> No.19655601

>>19655599
none of those mean nativelike

>> No.19655605

>>19655599
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BCfUMCwr4dM

>> No.19655607

>>19655601
Yeah, I was agreeing with you

>> No.19655614

>>19655605
>it is actually 9 minutes-long
haha

>> No.19655622

>>19655591
>[x] is an easier language to learn for [y] speakers
I wonder if there's information on what languages are easier to learn if you speak a certain language, with languages outside English.

>> No.19655629

>>19655622
rank 1: languages which are demonstrably related and share a writing system
rank 2: languages which are unrelated, but share a writing system; or which are related, but do not share a writing system
rank 3: languages which are unrelated and do not share a writing system

>> No.19655633

>>19655599

>spoken easily and accurately

that basically means native-like

non-native speakers can't speak a language accurately and easily. they fuck up the grammar and forget words

>> No.19655638

>>19655622
It's nothing but bullshit opinions in the end because every language differs from each other. I've often thought Spanish was easier for English speakers since we use the same text, but if you ignore how their grammar structure work, then it's pointless.

>> No.19655645

>>19655633
to be nativelike you need to have a good grasp on almost all colloquialisms and word usage patterns, and have an impeccable accent

virtually no non-natives have that, no matter how fluent they are

>> No.19655659

あたまがEnglishになってると

みみからきこえるにほんごが

20びょうくらいえいごにきこえる

こういうのってなんていうの?

>> No.19655660

>>19655645
That is rare. I only know maybe one or two people I've follow on YT that mastered that but only because they live in Japan and/or have Japanese family and maybe Japanese blood. Me, on the other hand, i'm willing to accept it'll never happen because trying to talk like a native speaker can get tiring and a bit annoying.

>> No.19655670

>>19655645

when i say "like a native speaker" i am not talking about the accent.
i am talking about the ability to speak the language and comprehend what is being said like a native speaker

i think misa sensei is fluent in english like a native speaker.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_c3V882am0

if you can speak japanese as well as misa sensei speaks english then i would say you're fluent

>> No.19655673

>>19655670
okay then read the rest of the post instead of zoning in on a single part

>a good grasp on almost all colloquialisms and word usage patterns

>> No.19655690

>X is fluent like a native speaker
Well I guess X is fluent, and I think native speakers are fluent too. So I guess they are fluent like a native speaker.

>> No.19655691

>>19655645
That'd mean a person who's a native in American English is not so in British English, and now I wonder how specialized can your 'nativelikeness' be. Would native-level AAVE speakers from, say, New Jersey, also be equally native-level in Noi Joisey?

>> No.19655692

>>19655691
learn english before trying to argue with me please

>> No.19655695

>worrying this much about production

I dont get the fuss when japanese is one of the easiest languages to speak because it's all about context you can minimize a lot and still get your point across.

I visited Japan and was way worse at the time and was really surprised at the level of complexity I could convey with basic grammar and using context. You literally drop like half the words you would need in English with Japanese because Japanese people dont waste time saying things already known in the context of the conversation.

Writing is easy too since all you do is type in kana and get what you want.

>> No.19655700

>>19655692
I understood him perfectly, maybe you need to brush up on your English. He's hard implying dialects are different languages which is stupid, but you're bullshit about native-level fluency is also retarded so really this is just two retards in a slap fight.

>> No.19655701

>>19655692
Alright, see you in 6 months.

Also, I wasn't trying to argue with you, but I guess I don't have enough English to make that distinction clear yet

>> No.19655704

>>19655701
i'm a native speaker dude
>>19655700
if someone can respond to me with something dumb like "native in American English is not so in British English" i can only assume they had no idea what i actually said

>> No.19655706

>>19650848

I didn't look at the numbers of the puzzle properly.
ごめん。俺は恥ずかしい。

>> No.19655710

>>19655704
I can see where he's coming from, it's kind of hard to respond to you with something smart when your entire argument is sub-20 IQ.

>> No.19655717

>>19655710
i'm sorry that you can't tell that he's misinterpreting what i said and turning it into something stupid to spite it

>> No.19655721

this is just another way you'll permanently cripple yourself

>> No.19655751

>>19655717
He didn't misrepresent anything, I read your posts in entirety before I even looked at his.

>> No.19655754

>>19655751
guess you have the reading comprehension of a frog then

>> No.19655756

Is it worth reading something that's above your reading level? Trying to read 新世界より and I'm realizing how difficult this is going to be.

>> No.19655758

>>19655754
There's a saying that if you meet a jerk then you met a jerk, but if you meet 10 jerks then maybe you're the jerk. Apply that to this, there's several people saying that you're wrong.

>> No.19655760

>>19655758
i'll spell it out for you: you didn't understand what impeccable means
all natives have impeccable accents... in their local dialect
non-natives can have impeccable accents too, even when they are obviously non-native
a german who nails all the consonants and vowels and gets all the stress patterns right may very will still sound german, but their accent will be impeccable
impeccable accent does not mean that it "doesn't sound like an accent" or whatever

>> No.19655763

>>19655760
This reply has nothing to do with my post, what the fuck.

>> No.19655765

>>19655763
and your post had nothing to do with mine

>> No.19655773

>>19655765
It's 1 vs how many, throw a tantrum as much as you want it won't change the fact you're the one who's factually wrong here. But I guess I'm also wrong for arguing with a literal autist in a fight that won't end.

>> No.19655774

>>19655773
keep telling yourself that's how it is lmao

>> No.19655777

>>19655022
I think that ship sailed long ago when I started posting on /jp/

>> No.19655782

>>19655695

>easiest language

um no it's not
japanese has informal and formal forms that you have to switch between based on who you talk to. you're basically have to speak a different way when you speak to someone like a boss or a teacher(in english we don't have to do this).
it has a bunch of complicated verb and adjective conjugations
it has a difficult writing system(you have to learn 3 of them to understand every day japanese. kanji is the hardest of the three to learn)
you have to learn like multiple different ways to say I(watashi, boku, ore, etc) and you(kimi, anata, omae,etc) in japanese and you have to know which one to say in a given context.

>> No.19655784

>>19655695
Fucking this

Chatted with my Japanese friend who used to be an exchange student living with my family like 10 years ago, and it's amazing just how much you can convey with very few words, which is really nice because of how clunky Japanese is at times. I think the moment I realized this was when we were talking about what season would be best to visit Japan in, and one of her sentences was just "夏より。。。" leaving out 99% of the sentence, but I knew exactly what was meant, which prompted a surprisingly fast "そうそうそう" from me as I segued into recent 熱波・熱中症・台風・豪雨 shit as well as keeping the 冷房 and 扇風機 on

The only thing I wish I'd done before talking with her was to study more specific sentence patterns/phrases to say certain things, but that'll just come with time. She was genuinely impressed with my progress in just 5 months of learning, and the fact that I could write 鬱 and 薔薇 from memory blew her mind.

Output isn't scary, it's kind of cool how your listening ramps up when the stakes are higher, and cutting your losses on words you don't know.

>> No.19655787

>>19655782
the only part of formality is learning all the different keigo euphemisms
kanji are not hard in the grand scheme of things, they are just deceptive
the pronouns are literally not a problem at all

>> No.19655788

>>19655782

you basically have*

>> No.19655789

>>19655787
the only hard part of formality*
also natives have to consciously learn keigo too so

>> No.19655792

>>19655145
Try listening to faster audio. If you brute force yourself to try to understand blitzing speed nihongo, normal speed will eventually sound slow.
just don't let it affect your speech or any form of output, when you get to the point that you can follow quick speech, return to normal speed.

>> No.19655793

>>19655782
>japanese has informal and formal forms that you have to switch between based on who you talk to
English also has formality.

>it has a bunch of complicated verb and adjective conjugations
English has easier rules but half of its words don't even follow those rules, making them just as complicated.

>it has a difficult writing system(you have to learn 3 of them to understand every day japanese. kanji is the hardest of the three to learn)
English isn't even phonetic so you basically have to brute force the spelling of every word.

>you have to learn like multiple different ways to say I(watashi, boku, ore, etc) and you(kimi, anata, omae,etc) in japanese and you have to know which one to say in a given context.
English also has synonyms.

>> No.19655799
File: 68 KB, 595x695, できた.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655799

>>19655706
あたしはいちおうやったよ

かきとりやってるきぶんだった

>> No.19655801

do you guys keep track of how many internet arguments you win

>> No.19655804

>>19655801
do you count how many pieces of bread you eat

>> No.19655805

>>19655801
Yeah.

0.

>> No.19655808

>>19655804
no because eating bread isnt special
>>19655805
cool me too

>> No.19655809

>>19655792
I've been listening to Japanese music for many years now and watch V YouTubers such as Kizuna AI, and other Japanese content but it never sticks to me. It could be my lack of Vocabulary.

>> No.19655816

>>19655801
It's impossible to win an argument, you're both autistic no matter what so even if you show them undeniable proof they'll just say the source is shit or something. In the end you always lose because you wasted your time, both of you, and now you're angrier than when you came. The issue is that it's sometimes very hard to avoid arguments because they don't start as arguments, they slowly turn into one and you're unaware until it's too late.

>> No.19655820

>>19654843
ps: if any of matt's fans are here go ahead and post this in his discord for me

>> No.19655823

>>19655782

>have to learn pronouns

90% of the problems with learning Japanese can be eliminated by not using pronouns.

If I need to talk about a particular person, I start with their name and only use pronouns as a last resort. 自分 may be the only exception as it is much more powerful and useful than ANY of the "specific" pronouns.

>> No.19655827

>Just saw 気象
>spirit elephant
THANKS HEISIG

>> No.19655835

>>19655827
>see 気象
>learned kanji from vocab
>ambience-phenomenal
Thanks immersion.

>> No.19655836

>>19655835
To be fair that's a lot closer

>> No.19655838

>>19655836
That's the joke. It even covers both senses.

>> No.19655839

>>19655827
>気象庁によりますと。。。

Falling for the heisenberg meme is fucking lol

Next you're gonna mention 99% of the use of 連, hm?

>> No.19655843

>>19655838
Damn I missed the joke dude.

>>19655839
>Next you're gonna mention...
Only if I actually see it in a reading, I'm not pulling these examples out of my ass.

>> No.19655851

>>19655793

formality in english only requires that you speak proper english. no double negatives, no slang, and no ebonics. you don't have to switch between formal and informal if you already speak proper english in the first place

>> No.19655852

>>19655851
>proper english

>> No.19655857

>>19655851
Speaking in proper English is boring.

>> No.19655859
File: 45 KB, 874x541, Screenshot 2018-08-14 at 01.34.05.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655859

>>19655843
>連続... Take along continue
>連敗... Take along failure
>連勝... Take along victory
>連覇... Take along hegemony
>連絡... Take along entwine

I'm really sad I fell for this meme when all I had to do was watch Game Center CX and play Final Fantasy VIII to realize that 連 typically means "consecutive"

>> No.19655860

Are there any good Japanese textbooks in mobi or epub format? I strongly prefer reading on my Kindle, so I tried putting my Genki pdfs on it, but it's pretty much useless for pdf.

>> No.19655865
File: 493 KB, 698x768, 1527382858369.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655865

>>19653247

>> No.19655866

>>19655851
>formality in english only requires that you speak proper english.

>Casual: Want to eat?
>Formal: Would you like to eat?

In the formal way you change the word entirely from "want" to "will", then further change it to past tense.

>Casual: Did you ever eat a Twinkie?
>Formal: Have you ever eaten a Twinkie?

In the formal way you change the word "eat" to its passive form.

>Casual: What day should we go out?
>Formal: Which day should we go out?

In the formal you use an obsolete word.

>Casual: That guy I met was nice.
>Formal: The man whom I met was nice.

In the formal you again change a word completely (guy -> man) but also add "whom".

We're all fluent so none of us have to think about these things so we can ignore them, but they exist. English has "keigo".

>> No.19655882

Reminder that Anki creates an illusion that you cannot remember words without it thus permanently crippling your natural leanguage learning ability.

>> No.19655883

>>19654295
You can only follow that so easily because you already know what it says. It being relatively short also helps. If someone made a gif like that for a chapter of a novel, most likely you would lose track very quickly.

>> No.19655885

>>19655883
This

>> No.19655896

>>19655882
Anki is good for exactly 3 things

>the first 2000-3000 or so words
>remembering rare/obscure shit you don't encounter enough to retain naturally
>learning the locations of the prefectures/their respective Kanji in 3 days*


*got tired of not being able to read prefecture names in the news and said "fuck it" and never have to worry about it ever again. Good bang for buck in terms of learning.

>> No.19655899

>Checked LingQ stats
>27238 words of reading
>Still N3 level at best
I guess one book's worth of reading gets you to N3 though, which is nice to know I guess.

>> No.19655902

>>19655882
I've been using Anki for about a week now and I'm not retaining much from it. I feel like it's slowing me down in a way. Should I give it up?

>> No.19655919

>>19655902
If you think you're gonna pull amazing results in a week or less then you are out if your mind.

>> No.19655925

>>19655902

A week? That's only 140 words in my world, which is actually a decent amount of useful stuff if you were pulling the good words from the news/pokemon and the like.

>> No.19655930

>>19655925
I've definitely learned/retained a lot less than 140 words. I really don't know the best way to build my vocabulary. I can read kana just fine and have a pretty solid grasp of grammar, but memorizing kanji and building my vocabulary has been a struggle.

>> No.19655932
File: 731 KB, 1366x768, Screenshot from 2018-08-13 23-58-40.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655932

i think i am intermediate level(probably between JLPT 4 and 3)

if i can watch all of misa sensei's videos without any difficulty. i think am at least intermediate level. i don't know what to do next.

>> No.19655938

>>19655932
>intermediate level(probably between JLPT 4 and 3)

>> No.19655945

>>19655899
We're not memeing when we say that N5, N4, and N3 are pathetically easy.

>> No.19655950

>>19655938
>N4 is Intermediate now
As someone who can't learn Japanese I am very happy to see that we're on course for N4 being advanced by next year.

>> No.19655956

>>19655950
By the end of Trump's second term being able to read katakana perfectly is native-level.

>> No.19655978
File: 51 KB, 384x384, 9fc80c0e2f0c2b8d1d0398cc29f74570c0fff66dc78ee8eeffc1131a7c7073d4.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19655978

>>19655930

Best way to build vocab is to see certain words often and in context.

You may find this miserable, but Pokemon Red/Green is a good way to get used to things. Don't expect it to be easy (kana-only is a bitch at the beginner level).

"Learn" 20 words a day, and no more. Mine the shit you find that's common at first - mostly verbs since you NEED to know things like たたかう、かう、うる、もどる、にげる、つかう、なる、はしる、あるく、する、たおれる、さがる、あずける、あがる、てにいれる、もらう、ひろう、おす、やめる、まける、かつ、and lots of する verbs like かいふく、きどう、かくとく、and so forth. The kicker? LEARN THE KANJI FORM and drill those even if you aren't seeing them in the damn game. This will help solidify it in your mind since now you will imagine 戦う when you see たたかう, or 使う when you see つかう.

>> No.19655996

>>19655978
>You may find this miserable, but Pokemon Red/Green is a good way to get used to things. Don't expect it to be easy (kana-only is a bitch at the beginner level).
Started playing Green the other day since I bought the cart a few years ago, actually, but decided to stop after choosing my starter until I learned more basic vocabulary. I'll start playing tonight if it'll actually build my vocabulary, though. I also have a few Japanese manga that I tried reading, but I was struggling too much with those, too. Thanks for the advice.

>> No.19656001

>>19655930

i find learning words in groups to be helpful

first day - learn family related words(kazoku, otousan, okaasan, etc).
2nd day - learn japanese names for animes(saru, inu, neko, uma, etc)
3rd day - learn pronounces(kimi,anata, omae, watashi, etc)
4th day - learn body parts(kao, ude, te, ashi, oshiri, etc)

>> No.19656004

>>19655978
I'm chiming in here, DON'T play games at beginner level unless that's the only way you can motivate yourself. You'll be liable to start skipping text (I mean, hey, you already played Pokemon gen 1, right? You know what to do, you don't have to read what people are saying!).
It also lacks repetitiveness since you obviously can't just load to wherever you want to read the same section again like you can with normal reading.
Also, you can't just look up words as easily. kana-only games are possible obviously but once you get into kanji games with no furigana, you're shit outta luck unless you can find some obscure program that will read the kanji in the game window for you without lagging out your computer.

>> No.19656011

>>19656001

animals*

animes lol

pronoun*

fuck!

>> No.19656019

>>19656011
haha

Japanese names for animes, such as "子供だけ" or "きもー"

>> No.19656045
File: 97 KB, 785x713, 効果はバツグンだ.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656045

>>19655996
This is exactly how you're gonna learn basic vocabulary though.

Thinking you have to know a certain "level" of vocab to play Pokemon is foolish when this will LEVEL UP your vocab and grammar just by seeing certain things.

Are you gonna know it all? Even 5% of it at the start? God no. But you're gonna indirectly learn some pretty neat shit like 前歯 (from ひっさつまえば), 光線 (from a shit ton of こうせん attacks), 電気・電磁波・雷 (get a Pikachu, you won't regret it), 火炎放射, 火の粉, 波乗り, and lots of other cool stuff.

How the hell did we learn so many words when we were kids? Pokemon sure as hell contributed to my vocab growing up, as did lots of other vidya.

>> No.19656048
File: 1.55 MB, 1920x1080, [HorribleSubs] Chio-chan no Tsuugakuro - 03 [1080p]_[00:10:58.324].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656048

Where can I get Sono Hanabira (the game)?
There's a SH pack on sukebei, but it seems they're all eng-patched.

>> No.19656056

>>19656045
>How the hell did we learn so many words when we were kids?
Comics and sitcoms, for me. Don't really play vidya until I 'learned better'.

>> No.19656067

what's that one hentai game where you go around school trying to get laid? i learned my first japanese from that game

paizuri

>> No.19656109

こんばんはって何
今晩は??分かりません

>> No.19656115 [DELETED] 

>>19656067
It's はなひらっ! for big boys.

>> No.19656116

>>19655809
Were you trying to parse it? Listening in your native language doesn't really require you to do that, but it's a dangerous pitfall when learning others. You'll have to start by deconstructing what's being said first before you move on to on the fly listening. Voiced VNs are great for this

>> No.19656139

Can't get text hook/auto-clipboard to firefox to work after some years without using it. Can anyone tell me what firefox version I should use for it to work?

>> No.19656150

>>19656109
こんにちはもよくみるとおかしい

さようならはいちばんかっこいい

>> No.19656181
File: 96 KB, 757x673, 両方の目が存在しない.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656181

>>19656056
The simple fact is, even if you can't read/parse this out yet, there's a virtue in learning what a 蝙蝠 is by reading the zukan.

>> No.19656203

>>19656181
I tend to agree with Steve that for reading to do you any good it has to be comprehensible. If you can't read/parse it out then it's above your level and you should come back to it later.

>> No.19656228

>>19656048
https://sukebei.nyaa.si/view/241482

>> No.19656247

>>19656228
Well, is it その花びらにくちづけを, but it's not THE その花びらにくちづけを

>> No.19656294

>ドイツ人に「飛び込むと言う規則になっています」
>フランス人に 「飛び込んじゃダメですよ」
>イギリス人に「飛び込んでこそ紳士です」
>アメリカ人に「飛び込めば英雄になれますよ」
>イタリア人に「飛び込むと女性にもてるでしょうね」
>日本人に「皆さん、飛び込んでいらっしゃいますよ」

Did this guy just tell everyone but the French to jump to safety? What the hell, Japan.

>> No.19656298

>>19656247
my bad I don't really follow yurige, All of the games are on ab if you could find someone to upload them, I would but my ratio has been tanking recently, sorry.

>> No.19656367
File: 118 KB, 888x884, wordpuzzle0814.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656367

challenge

>> No.19656411

>>19656367
wtfチョウむずいんだな。無理とオモいます

>> No.19656421

>>19656367
mawarimiti

>> No.19656448

Guys we gotta make a new thread

>> No.19656455
File: 124 KB, 888x884, わからん.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656455

>>19656367
わからん

>> No.19656468
File: 112 KB, 534x411, img-mondai-201607.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656468

challenge

>> No.19656474

Why the fuck am i having such a hard time with weekdays? Most other kanji and general vocabulary trinkle in just fine but i can't get any day of the week right, does anyone know how to get over this weird problem where something just refuses to seep in?

>> No.19656484

>>19655996
Cool story but manga isn't reading.

>> No.19656495
File: 29 KB, 339x354, 156_20180803_00866279_001.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656495

impossible to solve

>> No.19656499

>>19656367
znznwkrn
>>19656468
一文
生地
上手

>> No.19656501

>>19656474
Dont learn them together.

>> No.19656503

>>19656495

>> No.19656507

>>19656495

>> No.19656508

>>19656474
In weekdays, it is best to just remember the fist Kanji and nothing more since they all translate into 曜日last. it's not difficult when you get the hang of it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JnoZE51WZg4

>> No.19656519

>>19656503
>>19656507
the answer is two characters

>> No.19656577

あいはげんそうですか

>> No.19656590

>>19656474
>日曜日
>にちようび

Just fuck my shit up, I always end up trying to read it like "hiyoubi"

>> No.19656602

>>19656590
Im sorry anon but thats hilarious

>> No.19656603

>>19656590
Stop reading it as a radical/Kun'Yomi dum dum.

>> No.19656606

>>19656508
I did figure the last part out (-youbi), but its exactly the first kanji that's tripping me up for some reason.
Probably slightly less relevant, but why are these kanji used? I noticed that tsuki (moon) and kane (money) are used in the weekdays, is there some connection?

>> No.19656630

>>19656606
Yep. You can read about it here: http://www.cjvlang.com/Dow/dowjpn.html

>> No.19656674
File: 128 KB, 1280x720, mpv-shot0138.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656674

tfw no misa sensei gf to give me private lessons

she's beautiful

>> No.19656686

>>19656606
They're named after the planets and the moon actually (just like our weekdays are). In English it's hard to see the link (although it's there if you look at the Old English) but in languages like French you can see it easily.

Monday - moon -月 - Lundi / Luna
Tuesday - Mars - 火星 - Mardi / Mars
Wednesday - Mercury - 水星 - Mercredi / Mercury
Thursday - Jupiter - 木星 - Jeudi / Zeus - Jupiter
Friday - Venus - 金星 - Vendredi / Venus
Saturday - Saturn - 土星 - Samedi / Saturn
Sunday - The Sun, dummy - 日 - Dimanche / I dunno but look it up I guess

>> No.19656708
File: 2.62 MB, 1280x720, To Wear _ To Put On in Japanese (Differences 着る vs はく vs つける etc)-wLzt2XqwCjI-[06.19.645-06.28.888].webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656708

>>19656674

>> No.19656737

>>19656519
>>19656519
My bad, it's さお then.

>> No.19656748

>>19656686
>Monday - moon -月
>Saturday - Saturn - 土星 - Samedi / Saturn
>Sunday - The Sun, dummy - 日 - Dimanche / I dunno but look it up I guess
these are easy to remember

Water Wednesday -> 水ようび
Fortune Friday -> 金ようび

>> No.19656779

>>19656674
She's so shiny, too.

At first I didn't like how she's always kind of talking down to you in her videos but it's kinda working for me now. Talk down to me more, misa-senpai.

>> No.19656789

>>19656686
Well, in English the names were swapped out for the equivalent Germanic gods.

>> No.19656958
File: 3 KB, 41x131, Untitled.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19656958

Hey, I'm pretty new to Japanese
Can someone tell me what kanji are these?

>> No.19657023

>>19656958
just do rtk, oh wait...

>> No.19657055

>>19656958
Looks like Mumbo Jumbo to me,

>> No.19657069

>>19657023
>>19657055
Oh I'm retarded.
I thought it was 亡心, but it's one fucking kanji.
This language should be nuked.

>> No.19657076

>>19657069
>亡心
You did better than me, anon, I thought it was 亡バ and was thoroughly confused for the entire 10 seconds I cared.

>> No.19657143

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWs-1UU353Y

Learn to write like a beloved OL

>> No.19657166

>>19657143
このビデオ asmrをくれた

>> No.19657185

who is Jamal

>> No.19657199

any hot new resources you've found friends?
mine is:
http://aiki.info/kanji/

>> No.19657218
File: 102 KB, 1000x1000, rco,mens_premium_t_shirt,mens,x1770,fafafa_ca443f4786,front-c,180,40,1000,1000-bg,f8f8f8.lite-3u3u2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19657218

>>19657199
Cool tshirt

>> No.19657254

>>19655236
>>19655275
The crux of AJATT is still the input. It's fine to disagree with sentence cards but it's hyperbolic to say AJATT as a whole is "the exact opposite" of what Krashen recommends. Moreover there's probably a difference between what Krashen thinks would work for the average person and what is actually the most optimal for select autistic individuals who are willing to put in far more effort than most people. Nice job cutting out your username too.

>> No.19657258

>>19657218
w2c?

>> No.19657262

>Krashen doesn't recommend X
what did he write a book about learning Japanese?
his theory is vague at best. You can't really attribute things to him that you think he would advise against

>> No.19657311

>>19657218
Now that's learning through immersion!

>> No.19657338

>>19656958
亡心れるな

>> No.19657339
File: 296 KB, 529x720, 1530226211012.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19657339

why do the japanese like to call each other yellow monkeys at random times?
is it some kind of bizarre racial insecurity?

>> No.19657341

>>19657339
What?

>> No.19657402

>>19656674
俺のタイプじゃないな

>> No.19657405

>>19655859
>all I had to do was watch Game Center CX and play Final Fantasy VIII to realize that 連 typically means "consecutive"
I just had to hover yomichan over all those words.

>> No.19657423

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78WQ26o2YbA

Based Steve

>> No.19657448

>>19655860
djt.netlify.com

Just download the whole site and get what you want. Zero no Tsukaima is a surprisingly easy one to start with. Kino no Tabi is better but imo a little more difficult (although still entry level). You may need to install a dictionary, there are some tutorials you can google.

You may need to convert some to the right format but that's trivial with Calibre. Calibre also converts pdfs iirc but it'll mess up a lot of the formatting.

>> No.19657453

>>19657262
That was my impression too but I played it safe and assumed he was more specific somewhere.

>> No.19657461

>>19657448
Nobody ever mentions this because it's obvious but DJT's guide is an awesome resource. Upvotes to the left.

>> No.19657760

the crux of ajatt is fun

>> No.19657787
File: 152 KB, 497x652, 8292.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19657787

Realtalk, a lot of us READ AND LISTEN a lot, but rarely do any of us elaborate past that. How do you all read, specifically?

Do you just read through stuff once and go to the next thing of interest?
Do you read the same thing several times?
Do you read something once then do flashcards for it?
など

As for me, it depends. If I'm getting mostly vocab from it then I'll read it once then do flash cards for it then read it again after awhile to make sure it stuck. If I'm getting mostly grammar then I'll just read it again once a day for a few days.

>> No.19657824
File: 112 KB, 707x820, mm.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19657824

what's the point of these? to kill you on your way down?

>> No.19657891

>>19657824
Manga sure looks like reading

>> No.19657895

>>19657824
Maybe to slow bikers down so they don't slam into pedestrians at top speed? We don't have that kind of stuff here but we do have it for cars where I live. Big flower pots in the middle of the road forcing you to zig-zag so that you can't drive 70km/h through a residential area.

>> No.19657903

>>19657824
I guess they're there to make you walk your bike instead of riding it down.

>> No.19657905

>>19657787
read something once while making sentence cards of useful words for that particular book

>> No.19657937

>>19657824
weeb in japan here, these things exist to slow bikers down so that they don't collide with other people. In that image, if those didn't exist, Yotsuba (or someone else) would ride down normally, gain a disgusting amount of speed because of the steep slope, and potentially run into a jogger at the bottom who didn't see them.
You see these a lot on city corners where bikers can be on the sidewalk.

>>19657905
Thanks, interesting method. I use LingQ so I just mark every word and if I ever see it a second time I know it's probably an important word, I assume you just do it by intuition?

>> No.19657943

>>19657895
Has your govt heard of speed bumps?

>> No.19657950

>>19657937
Same guy here, sometimes they also exist for just the biker's safety. Maybe there's something at the bottom of the slope that you wouldn't think you'd need to slow down for but actually you really do. Maybe a lake or a bad bump or something.

>> No.19657955

>>19657937
no, i usually wait until i've seen it 2-4 times before i decide i need to know it.

i tried lingq but it was a huge pain in the ass when dealing with word seperation since japanese doesn't have spaces. can you show me a picture of something you read in lingq and how it parses stuff now?

>> No.19657963

>>19657787
Read through somethhing while marking the words I don't know with a pencil. I only look them up immediately if I have no clue what's going on in the sentence. Otherwise I continue reading until I reach the end of a chapter. Then I look up all the marked words and make custom Anki cards for them, usually with a short example sentence (doesn't have to be from the book, I prefer them to be short so I usually use the exmaples from the Japanese-Japanese dictionaries).

>> No.19657970
File: 204 KB, 1024x683, 6605560553_49f9f152e4_b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19657970

>>19657937
>>19657950
Surely something like this would be a much smarter option than murderous poles.

>> No.19657973

>>19657970
But that doesn't prevent you from speeding down there.

>> No.19657983

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bC1oDx9jIFo
barakan sama is the true boss

>> No.19657985
File: 53 KB, 661x268, Capture.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19657985

>>19657955
LingQ is still pretty bad in that respect, you learn to make do with it though.
In the beginning I went in and edited everyone's lessons to fix the spacing but then I stopped because it was more work than it was worth. After awhile I stopped caring.

>食べ られる
This is usually two words in LingQ, you just tag the られる as "potential/passive" and the 食べ as "eat" and move on.

It is annoying though, definitely.

>>19657970
Poles don't kill, people do.

>>19657963
>Marking the book
I should stop being autistic about marking my books and do this.

>> No.19657988
File: 414 KB, 1024x768, 2840514069_d37f2bcb83_b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19657988

>>19657973
Better.
A brave drunken lad will just try to dodge the poles anyway and crack his head open.

>> No.19657997

>>19657943
Yeah. We have those, too. Sometimes we have both in the same place.

I guess the idea is that these also contribute to making the street look nicer. Besides, if you have speed bumps you still see lunatics speeding across them.

>> No.19658000

>>19657988
Most of the killer poles aren't on stairs, they're at corners you can't see past. In fact, they're rarely on stairs at all: City stairs are too busy and the poles would be too much blockage and in the sticks nobody cares, so your best bet to find them are probably in sub-urban areas.

>> No.19658076

>>19657891
I read 10000 pages of manga and became a nihongo pro.

>> No.19658176

any idea where I can find the phenomeno raws

>> No.19658181

>>19657985
>えいごちから
i would read that as えいごりょく what about you?

>> No.19658216

>>19658181
The furigana is wrong a lot of the time. This text is one of the ones that the author also gave audio for so we could check it if we were unsure, and sure enough it is in fact えいごりょく

>> No.19658240
File: 57 KB, 939x532, 言葉より行動.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19658240

>>19658216
thats cool there's audio for it. seems like some useful vocab that you're learning in context. i think lingq is really a good concept to build vocabulary because you can be sure if you mark a word that it will show up.
like when i read i have to rely on the fact that ok i'm pretty sure i've seen this word before so i'll learn it properly.
but with lingq you just click it and let the computer remind you that you've seen it before which is cool.

>> No.19658279

>>19658240
LingQ is an amazing resource for languages with spaces, for languages like Japanese where LingQ has to parse itself it's still ok but not nearly as much. I still use it because it cuts out the anki middleman and is overall still quicker than looking stuff up manually.

>> No.19658288

>>19657985
>I should stop being autistic about marking my books and do this.
I figured I'll most likely not be resell my books anyway (got most of them from book-off already), so I might as well do it. If you use a really soft pencil you can erase most things without much of a trace though.

>> No.19658308

>>19658288
>BOOK-OFF
Hell yeah I got the entire set of Shokugeki from there a month ago.

>> No.19658310

粗野な男達

>> No.19658316

dekinai hour

>> No.19658369

it's crazy how as reading become easier, reviewing cards in anki become faster

>> No.19658387

>>19658369
anki is reading

>> No.19658419

How does Anonymous practice his listening?

I've chosen some fairly easy material (昔話 http://hukumusume.com/douwa/pc/jap/)) and my methodology is basically to go sentence-by-sentence, pausing a thousand times, and referencing the transcript afterward to compare with what I thought I heard.

I've made some progress, but it's painful. Truly worse than Anki. Maybe that's just the way it has to be in the beginning. But maybe I'm studying like an oaf and Anonymous has a better idea.

>> No.19658433

>>19658419
watch anime. rip audio from anime into mp3 after completing a season. put mp3 on phone and listen throughout the day.
after you listen to the same thing like 5+ times you have internalized all the stuff you know and everything you don't know sticks out like a nail for you to hammer down with a quick dictionary search of the unknown part you just heard

>> No.19658434

>>19658419
I watch anime on animelon with Japanese subs. Every now and then I pause so that I can dissect a sentence or something.

Last one I watched was Rozen Maiden Zuruckspulen which was pretty good. I really think it improved my nihongo desu kashira karishimobe.

>> No.19658453

>>19658419
3+ hours of anime per day

>> No.19658492

minna genki? lmao

>> No.19658542

i think rtk3 will be a waste of time. has anyone completed it that feels otherwise? there's a bunch of characters in there that i've never seen before. of course some of them are useful but... yeah

>> No.19658595
File: 553 KB, 678x718, 1435121974839.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19658595

>>19658433
>>19658434
>>19658453
To be honest I do this stuff anyway, which I why I'm surprised by how 下手 my listening is. I need dedicated listening time, because anything with subtitles it seems my brain mutes the audio and does all of the work through reading.

As for listening to anime throughout the day it's charming, but very easy to ignore.

>> No.19658600
File: 56 KB, 1424x516, Screen Shot 2018-08-15 at 01.16.43.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19658600

What mnemonic did you use anon?

>> No.19658643

>>19658595
try listening to something 50+ times then. and don't ignore it... you might as well not listen if you're ignoring it

>> No.19658649

if you watch 10000 hours of anime your listening is gonna be epic and when you go to learn how to read things will basically read themselves ftw

>> No.19658657
File: 24 KB, 323x176, Capture.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19658657

Burnout city here I come. What do you do when you realize you've probably done too much too fast?

>> No.19658675

>>19658643
Indeed, perhaps repetition is key. I'll try listening to the same episode over and over again.

>> No.19658709

A vulture landed on the luggage carrier (porter) at the train station and started doing lewd things to him (I picture the vulture rubbing its dick all over his face). I grab water and throw it on the vulture to shoo it away.

>> No.19658718

>>19658419
I watch ボイロ実況, you should too!

>> No.19658720

>>19658709
response to
>>19658600

>> No.19658724

>>19657185
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4EOC1tqmm4c

>> No.19658729

>>19658709

thx friend, vivid image. Top story on koohii but with dick rubbing

>> No.19658736

How do I get around youtube country blocks easily? Don't feel like using a VPN just for this

>> No.19658741

>>19658736
should prolly google that

>> No.19658747

>>19658736

hooktube

>> No.19658757

>>19658747
Didn't work

>> No.19658830

>>19658718
When are you gonna stop shilling that apex autismal shit.

>> No.19658880

>>19658830
When it stops being good.

>> No.19658905
File: 6 KB, 702x450, 1534262612308.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19658905

Makes sense.

>> No.19658945

it does cuz water is 3 drops

>> No.19658976

What's the longest you've gone learning Japanese while not actually learning Japanese? 3 months here.

>> No.19659005
File: 791 KB, 1808x2042, 10 years.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19659005

>>19658976

>> No.19659040

>>19659005
how he uses sawako for his avatar is really fitting

>> No.19659054

>>19659040
Because they're both potatoes? He'll either be the best NEVER GIVE UP success story /DJT/ will ever have to offer, or the best dekinai story. 10 god damn years.

>> No.19659087
File: 123 KB, 823x412, Capture.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19659087

for the people who obsess about their precious rtk stories and waste so much time trying to associate story with kanji

>> No.19659104

>>19659087
I'm confused. What do you think you're proving here?

>> No.19659199

>>19655638
Whoever said Spanish is easier for English speakers is retarded. In fact, I'd say it is impossible to master unless you natively speak Portuguese, Italian or French already.

>> No.19659223

>>19659199
please don't tell me you're basing this off of some dumb shit that doesn't actually matter like the subjunctive form

>> No.19659224

One day I'll be able to read Muramasa

But that day is not today

>> No.19659226

>>19655048
no your point is retarded because you definitely don't need 10k fucking words to understand doremon

>> No.19659426

>>19659226
You need to feel it.

>> No.19659594

>>19658905
nice font, wicked

>> No.19659610

>>19659087
didnt read lol

>> No.19659639

>>19659087
come on my dude every good mattdrone alive emphasizes that the stories fade away and the kanji remains
you've got to try harder than that to convince them to waste less time
you could also stand to go a step further and tell them not to do rtk3 and maybe even not to do all of rtk1

>> No.19659646
File: 43 KB, 600x469, 1527132623253.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19659646

>> No.19659649

>>19659646
shit im next what do i do

>> No.19659665

>>19659646
next wa....can't read katakana.

>> No.19659674

>>19659665
at least you've got that heisig down my man
next stop remembering the katakana then you'll be a fuckin pro
i hope he writes a remembering the grammar so that we can learn japanese someday

>> No.19659680

>>19658181
I'd read as えいごりき to be ironic

>> No.19659699

Was playing a game and on the character sheets they had the characters sign their names in romanized form cursive, is that something Japanese people actually do sometimes or just something the localizers did? Just seemed weird to me since they also showed the kanji for their name above

>> No.19659705

>>19659639
"if i don't spend hours creating epic personal stories that i never forget based off an english word for 2200+ characters i'll never remember the kanji!"

the faster you can move through rtk the faster you can compartmentalize everything. if you need a long detailed story to walk you through writing 日 you probably won't learn japanese in a reasonable timeframe

>> No.19659710

>>19659699
its a fuckin video game

do the characters look like white people?

good chance its a cool western style choice because japan loves the west!!

>> No.19659719

>>19659665
>wa
Isn't that ha? Or am I missing something?

>> No.19659723

>>19659674
thanks man
>>19659719
i read rtk so i'm pretty sure i know what i'm talking about

>> No.19659725

>>19659705
>the faster you can move through rtk the faster you can compartmentalize everything
i don't believe this but i'd be open to evidence towards it
>if you need a long detailed story to walk you through writing 日 you probably won't learn japanese in a reasonable timeframe
the problem is that a long detailed story is more to remember
short and to the point is ideal

>> No.19659734
File: 34 KB, 927x528, 女は度胸.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19659734

>>19659719
it's actually neither. it's just は

>> No.19659781

>>19659705
>if you need a long detailed story to walk you through writing 日
you don't. that's an example of a character you can just rote memorize. the more complex characters will be harder to recall and stories help with those.

>> No.19659834

>>19659781
agreed. complex stuff like 融 and similar looking characters like 微徴 緑録 are useful to learn with stories. a good number of my rtk cards say just remember it for stuff like 日木水百千火雨 etc

>> No.19659838

>>19659705
as an anti-RTK drone, I realized early on that it's literally easier to just learn vocab and read.

>秘密 learned from pokemon
>"ok cool"
>later encounter 秘匿
>"ひ。。。 something, let's dictionary that shit"
>later encounter 蜂蜜 but hear it as the kanji appears on screen in an educational video
>"ハチ。。。みつ。。。Bee's secret? No way..."
>turns out it's not "bee's secret" but rather "bee's nectar" but it still makes sense either way (maybe more sense in the former)
>quickly realize that 蜜 is literally just the bug version of 密, pronounced like the top half
>encounter stuff like this all the time in other Kanji

While there's not ALWAYS crossover between a kanji's actual meaning and its reading, sometimes you can make some fairly decent educated guesses even if you don't have a whole lot to work with. 99% of せん either comes down to a boat, a battle, or a line, and most other instances of it are parts of such different words there's no way for you to guess them wrong.

>力
>ちから
>from... earth? 地? Blood? 血? Some source of power
>no such meaning, but interesting to think of it that way regardless


The more you make this all your own by making such connections, whether real or inaccurate, the closer you get to truly understanding, as this is the same sort of stuff you did when learning English.

>> No.19659862

>>19659834
wtf are you on about

99% of the time when you see 緑 it's on its own
99% of the time when you see 録 it's in a word like 記録的 or 世界記録

How the fuck could you EVER mix those two things up when actually reading?

Next, are you going to say you can never distinguish 続 from 読 without a mnemonic?

>> No.19659863

>>19659838
i know. i learned to read using your method. but you still can't write without practicing writing. your eyes naturally just skim over words because it recognizes the general shape of things so when you try to recall how to write it it's just a blur unless if it's a very simple shape.

>> No.19659866

>>19659710
Well it's the English release so I was curious if they actually felt the need to "localize" the characters signatures or if westernizing them like that is something Japanese people actually do...

>> No.19659873

>>19659838
Okay, I'll take my time to explain this. Assuming that you are serious, I also did come to realization that Anki for remembering vocab is totally useless about 4 months ago, not even that, the act of trying to "remember" words is dumb IMO, but I still stand for the fact that if I could go back to March 2017 when I started, I'd still do RTK 1 before learning Japanese.

And it's not to "guess" meanings of words, I don't know if anyone does this, I don't do it, never did even after RTK unless it's super obvious and even then I still check to be sure, it's simply for recognition. When I started learning, I quicky learned kana and read through Tae Kim in a week for basics of how langauge words and jumped straight into a visual novel. And I can tell you all kanji for a beginner look the same. Like even seeing the difference between 大-犬-太 is super hard and actual similar looking ones like 網-綱 or 線-綿 etc is virtually impossible. So you have to draw them cause you don't know what they mean every time. Which is also funny, cause if I see new kanji nowadays and can't guess the reading, I quicky memorize what components it has and draw it in google translate in 5 seconds, but when you are new you are gonna alt-tab back and forth between game window and google translate for every stroke and it takes like 2 minutes to even draw kanji and by that time the whole "context" of what the kek are you ever reading is out the window. And if you only had to draw all of them once it would be nice but the reality is that the next day you'll froget the once you've already looked up anyways. So here's a true story and one example. I did just try to power through and persist with reading for a bit over a month! During that month I saw word 確認, which is super common word so no wonder, like 8 times and each time i just saw it it new context, my brain would go "fuck, I should know this, I already looked it up...can't remember....draw it again -> get mad that couldn't remember -> draw it like 10 times by hand -> 2 days later, can't remember it again, repeat cycle!" And to the point where I was about to quit learning the langauge. So if you are not intersted in stuff with furigana, and I'm not, I'd rather shoot myself then read manga or NHK easy, recognition is a crazy issue for a beginner. It's hard to sympathize when you are already literate, cause it seems like you can tell everything just from context, like how do you tell the difference between 湛える and 堪える? literate person will say, it doesn't matter, you'll read the 傷の痛さを湛える even with wrong kanji cause you won't even look at it, you'll just read through but that's not true for anyone who's not literate yet so you need to put yourself in their position.

So yeah, my point, people who recommend "knowing 2000 kanji" ahead, it's not for trying to guess words, I can assure you people still look up every new word they see unless it's pronounced and super obvious to guess what it is.

>> No.19659876

>>19659862
lol no one mixes that up while reading, i'm talking about writing from memory

>> No.19659886

>>19659838
It's almost as if the language wasn't based on the kanji and the kanji are just a patch.

>> No.19659903

>>19659873
Yeah I'm not reading this post, 5 decides what I read next.

>> No.19659908

>>19659903
all exposition in RTK

>> No.19659910

>>19659903
逆転裁判

>> No.19659914

>>19659866
having cursive english in a japanese video game isnt the most uncommon stylistic choice to add some western flair

>> No.19659917

>>19659914
So it's the kind of thing you see in fictional media but not so much in the real world?

>> No.19659927

im pretty sure cursive is all but dead in most of the western world anyway outside of signatures

>> No.19659944

if you could even call the scribbles people call their signatures cursive

>> No.19659960

Can kids even write nowadays?

>> No.19659965

doubtful

gonna need the djt teen squad to field this one

>> No.19659969

>>19659927
Are you retarded?

>> No.19659974

>>19659969
yes but only slightly less than you

>> No.19660005

>>19659863
>>19659873
if you can't read japanese you don't need to learn to write
if you can read japanese rtk is a dumb approach to learning to write

>> No.19660025

おきちゃった

なんかおはなしして

そうしたらねるから

>> No.19660028

>>19660005
>if you can read japanese rtk is a dumb approach to learning to write
rote memorizing the kanji will never be as effective as RTK's story-telling method.

>> No.19660033

>>19660005
so are you going to offer a better method for learning to write kanji for people who can already read or just make useless comments?

rtk might be dumb, but it's an organized method that lets you write kanji from memory without doing rote kanji practice

also that second post you replied to is copypasta

>> No.19660040

>>19660028
mnemonics are rote memorization

>> No.19660053

"Rote memorization" is redundant and any idiot who uses that phrase is quite likely parroting second hand opinions he's seen in this thread

>> No.19660061

accidental memorization is not rote and it can be memorization without being rote as long as it's not truly learned

>> No.19660066

You're almost there, keep thinking about it though

>> No.19660071
File: 17 KB, 804x104, Capture.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660071

very helpful thanks heisig

>> No.19660074

i've been there for longer than learning japanese has been on the table for you

>> No.19660076

>>19660025
起きなかった方がいい

>> No.19660080

If you say so, Mr. Idiot Who Likes To Argue Without Knowing What Rote Means

>> No.19660084

>>19660028
if you can read, you already have something to build on
rtk-style mnemonics are acceptable when you're struggling with some kanji but you don't need to default to using them
english keywords are a distraction and waste of time
most importantly of all, using rtk implies you are reviewing isolated kanji which is unnecessary
>>19660033
my bad

>> No.19660090

>>19660025
あきちゃった

>> No.19660094

>>19660084
>you already have something to build on
it's not enough. the words themselves and the ideas or things they represent will not help you recall the subcomponents. sorry, but your hatred of RTK is retarded.

>> No.19660109

>>19660076
>>19660090
こばなしでいいから

>> No.19660112

>>19660094
having seen the kanji with the subcomponents thousands of times will help you recall the subcomponents
before you respond please note that i said "will help", you still need to practice yes that is true
see also
>rtk-style mnemonics are acceptable when you're struggling with some kanji but you don't need to default to using them

>> No.19660114

>>19660094
actually i find this to be the opposite. where i struggled with rtk in the past without having a decent vocabulary, now that i know words for pretty much every kanji in rtk1 it's a lot easier to tie things down so to speak

>> No.19660127

>>19660080
that would be you

>> No.19660130

>>19653225
are you german?

>> No.19660135

日本人 just うまいですね'd me, doushiyo

>> No.19660136

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k_SLE3IGLP4

I'm surprised at how often speed runners fuck up at basic shit. It proves that it's less about above-average skill and more about knowing bugs and the fastest route.

>> No.19660137

>>19659646

Next stop, Omaeda

>> No.19660142

>>19660130
No
why?

>> No.19660144

>>19660137
tigau

>> No.19660147

ねてたらおこされたの

おきろおきろーって

ねこに

>> No.19660148

>>19660135
私を食べないでくださいって言ってみて

>> No.19660153

>>19660142
>At least i'm not finding Japanese pronounciation hard at all since it's basically the same in my language
because I'm German and feel the same way you described

>> No.19660154

>>19660112
>you still need to practice
yep. faster to just do RTK.
>rtk-style mnemonics are acceptable when you're struggling with some kanji but you don't need to default to using them
right. so do RTK and skip/delete every single kanji you can already recall. also if you already know japanese you can just substitute the english keyword for a japanese keyword.
>>19660114
no shit sherlock. they alone aren't enough. you still either have to write them down a million times or use mnemonics.

>> No.19660171

>>19660109
ごめんね

言葉だけじゃ足りないの

ただ抱きしめたい

>> No.19660173

>>19660154
....which is why i'm doing rtk. but maybe you just haven't read enough to begin with and that's why you can't recall subcomponents

>> No.19660175

>>19660148
たべないでくださーい

>> No.19660176

>>19660135
dont say anything else and go offline

>> No.19660177

>>19660173
>....which is why i'm doing rtk.
then stop responding to me because we don't disagree you retard.

>> No.19660180

>>19660154
you have poor reading comprehension and too much love for rtk
your "faster" claim is unsubstantiated and directly contradicts points i have made
your suggestion only addresses two points
you have zero interest in entertaining any argument that does not align with your existing stance so there is no point in discussing this further

>> No.19660181

>>19660153
Well, some dumb list I found on the internet says German is the 8th easiest language to learn for Spanish-speakers.
Supposedly vowels are very similar and dont change all the time like in English. But words with a lot of consonants together are a bit harder

>> No.19660189

Started RTK a month ago after three years of learning Japanese and it's pretty fucking cool, honestly. I never bothered with writing because I thought it was a waste of time but decided to finally tackle it now. Almost feels like magic when you can easily write down some complex-looking kanji.

>> No.19660202
File: 82 KB, 361x691, 1464704297254.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660202

>>19660171

>> No.19660207

>>19660154
also i just wanna say it really bugs me when dipshit anons like this retard implies that RTK is some rigid thing where you have to make up stories even for kanji you already know how to write, or that you can't substitute english keywords for japanese keywords. god you're so fucking dumb and dishonest.
>"faster" claim is unsubstantiated
what's great is that it doesn't need to be. only mouthbreathers like you would contest that mnemonics make it easier to remember things than not using mnemonics.
>you have zero interest in entertaining any argument that does not align with your existing stance so there is no point in discussing this further
>i didn't change your mind. that must mean you're not interested in having your mind changed. it doesn't reflect anything at all about the quality of my arguments.

>> No.19660227

>>19660189
did you read this post?
>>19660112
you shouldn't be using RTK to learn to write if you already know japanese. just whip out your notebook and write out each kanji you want to write hundreds of times. remember, you can either learn to write 20 new kanji a day in about 30-60 minutes using RTK method, or you can spend hours learning to write 20 new kanji by writing them down hundreds of times.

>> No.19660255

>>19660202
疑問符

>> No.19660270

Do 左利きs have trouble writing kanji?

>> No.19660289

............*sits next to you*......................... *coughs*........................................... いい天気だね............ haha........... *stares at you*..............

>> No.19660293

>>19660207
>RTK is some rigid thing
it's certainly not just anything you want it to be or there's no point in discussing it
>you have to make up stories even for kanji you already know how to write, or that you can't substitute english keywords for japanese keywords
that's half of what rtk means
the other half is the ordering
and most importantly you're missing the center of my argument: learn words, not individual kanji
that is not rtk
>god you're so fucking dumb and dishonest.
you sound underage and lack self-awareness
>what's great is that it doesn't need to be.
solid point, i'm convinced
>contest that mnemonics make it easier to remember things than not using mnemonics.
you should really try reading what you're disagreeing with sometime because i never said or implied this
>see also
>>rtk-style mnemonics are acceptable when you're struggling with some kanji but you don't need to default to using them

>> No.19660298

>>19660227
also no one suggested that, chill boy

>> No.19660305

my interpretation of how to use rtk is the right one

>> No.19660313

>>19660305
As toilet paper?

>> No.19660319

>>19660305
my interpretation of rtk is that if you do anything other than write each kanji hundreds of times in a notebook you are doing rtk thus rtk wins again checkmate fuckin nerd

>> No.19660332

>>19660293
>it's certainly not just anything you want it to be or there's no point in discussing it
it's the ordering and having components represent things. it's important to keep in mind you can tweak aspects of RTK to make it work better for you.
>and most importantly you're missing the center of my argument: learn words, not individual kanji
we're talking about writing right?
>you sound underage and lack self-awareness
>>you have zero interest in entertaining any argument that does not align with your existing stance so there is no point in discussing this further
>solid point, i'm convinced
that's not something you can convince someone of. it's just self-evident to everyone who's used mnemonics to recall things. maybe you're confusing the fact that it took you hours to create your own stories with stories being inefficient even though you can just go and copy someone else's.
>rtk-style mnemonics are acceptable when you're struggling with some kanji but you don't need to default to using them
oh so then you think RTK is great, you just recommend people replace english keywords with japanese keywords and skip/delete kanji you can already write.

>> No.19660333

>>19660227
>you shouldn't be using RTK to learn to write if you already know japanese
Why not? I did it too and went through the jouyou kanji plus about 200 other characters in 45 days.

>write out each kanji you want to write hundreds of times
Hell no. When you already a word that uses the character you already kinda have a vague idea in your head of what the character should look like so there is no need to write it more than once or twice and then its memorized. I have a retention rate of about 97%.

>> No.19660339

>>19660333
i don't know what to say other than you've completely wasted your time with RTK and you're close minded. maybe try remembering how to write those kanji without using RTK and see how you do. your retention will probably rise to 99%.

>> No.19660341

>all those long ass fucking replies
Are those guys bots? Nobody would read that shit.

>> No.19660349

>>19660332
>it's important to keep in mind you can tweak aspects of RTK to make it work better for you.
there's a difference between a tweak and a fundamental change
>we're talking about writing right?
yes
>it's just self-evident
strong argument
>maybe you're confusing the fact that it took you hours to create your own stories with stories being inefficient even though you can just go and copy someone else's.
i used rtk for about 1700 kanji
i made about 50 of my own mnemonics
>oh so then you think RTK is great, you just recommend people replace english keywords with japanese keywords and skip/delete kanji you can already write.
i've explained to you that this is incorrect so many times that i am not going to again
>>19660333
the dude i'm replying to is butthurt and making a parody of his misunderstanding of my advice, pay no mind

>> No.19660354

>>19660341
it's one of those posters who're never explicit in what they believe so you have to dive through a billion potentially irrelevant points before you know what they're trying to argue.

>> No.19660358
File: 90 KB, 835x308, Capture.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660358

heisig sensei... i...

>> No.19660359

>>19660354
write vocab not kanji

>> No.19660365

>>19660339
Writing characters hundreds of times seems like a total waste of time. My reps took me under an hour every day

>> No.19660367

I used to trash RTK but it's great to learn writing specifically
It's obviously shit to learn how to read and understand a text, but that's not what it's for
If I had to learn Japanese from scratch again I'd probably spend about two months on RTK exclusively as "preparation" before I'd start the actual studies

>> No.19660373

>>19655782
I'm the guy you replied to

>japanese has informal and formal forms that you have to switch between based on who you talk to. you're basically have to speak a different way when you speak to someone like a boss or a teacher(in english we don't have to do this).
You kinda do in English but regardless 98% of the time in Japanese you can use informal speech.
Do you have a japanese boss or teacher?
Japanese people find it weird if you even use masu form. Japanese people expect you to make mistakes and their language is a mishmash anyway so most of the time your small mistakes dont matter.

>it has a bunch of complicated verb and adjective conjugations
Conjugations in Japanese are extremely easy compared to learning English, Spanish or most languages especially since you dont have to worry about plural either.
>it has a difficult writing system
We are talking about production ie speaking and writing isnt that difficult since it will show you the kanji you probably want.

>you have to learn like multiple different ways to say I(watashi, boku, ore, etc) and you(kimi, anata, omae,
Wow japanese has like 20 pronouns and you could get away with never uttering any of then if you wanted to. And they're not even hard. If you're a dude use boku or ore unless you're a faggot and use Watashi. Non native should only use Anata but ONLY if you dont know their name, if you know the persons name and are familiar with them call them name-san/chan/kun. So difficult!

>> No.19660375

>>19660365
>the dude i'm replying to is butthurt and making a parody of his misunderstanding of my advice, pay no mind

>> No.19660382

やわらかなふわふわで

つつまれたような

ねむりにおちたい

>> No.19660384

>>19660349
>there's a difference between a tweak and a fundamental change
cool. some people disagree with you on what constitutes a fundamental change so you should be more explicit about that when arguing against RTK's utility. maybe try "RTK is bad but if you change this then it's good and you should do it."
>strong argument
"it's not faster" is an even stronger argument.
>i made about 50 of my own mnemonics
how was your retention, how many kanji did you learn per day, and how long did it take every day?
>i've explained to you that this is incorrect so many times that i am not going to again
you should probably stop posting about this then.
>write vocab not kanji
alright let's try asking someone about that.
>>19660367
why would you do RTK to learn to write you retard? just write vocab. oh wait, what i'm saying is incoherent isn't it? but i'm not going to explain myself at all.

>> No.19660386

I remember when we used to shit on RTK. I can't believe it but /djt/ managed to get worse.

>> No.19660392

>>19660386
DJT still hates RTK but it didn't used to.

>> No.19660407

>>19660384
RTK is bad but if you don't do it before learning japanese, don't use its set of kanji or ordering of them, don't practice isolated kanji, don't use a mnemonic unless necessary, and don't use keywords for kanji, then it's good and you should do it.
I really enjoy using RTK to put a word in kana on the front of a card, with contextual disambiguation in the case of homophones, and the word written in kanji on the back with an optional memory cue for any words that that are particularly difficult. I'm glad that Heisig invented such a flexible method that is always the correct choice.
You are probably going to ask how I deal with needing mnemonics for the components of more than one kanji in the same word. To answer this question in advance, I have not run into this problem before because knowing Japanese before learning to write goes a lot further than you might expect.

>> No.19660454

>>19660392
is there anything about learning japanese that djt has held consistent majority opinions on?

>> No.19660461

>>19660153
I love Germans
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ErdTmzy1Jg8

https://vocaroo.com/i/s1uzB9tzqmrY

>> No.19660466
File: 36 KB, 916x311, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660466

>>19660341
Just fucking set up your filters already.

>> No.19660475

RT___K is great.

>> No.19660476
File: 175 KB, 480x470, 1507684218972.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660476

>>19660135
>the conversation continued after that
>we talked about eroge, he even recommended me some
>またチャットしよう
Why nobody told me talking in Japanese is so damn fun. Looks like taking time off reading to stalk nips was a right decision after all.

>> No.19660479
File: 8 KB, 200x200, depression.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660479

In the middle of a GROVE you find a TIN CAN. There's a CROWN inside! You're excited and you put it on, but then someone appears behind you: "Hey, gimme that kid!" You look and it's WOLVERINE, with a SHOVEL on his back, all covered in 鹵 (#2879). "I found that crown in the rocksalt mines over there, so hand it over!" - You unwillingly hand him the crown and he walks away. Then you SIT ON THE FLOOR, feeling GLOOMY. Suddenly Mystique appears - she watched the whole thing and tries to cheer you up.

>> No.19660492

>>19660466
Why didn't you reply to my post

>> No.19660500

>>19660466
you can hide your eyes but you're still posting in a pool of shit

>> No.19660509

>>19660479
absolutely fucking based beyond belief

>> No.19660527

>>19660479
now this is learning japanese

>> No.19660542

RTK is one of those cases where the subject might not be that bad per se, but the user/fanbase is so obnoxiously cancerous that you can't not hate it.

>> No.19660546

>>19660542
agreed

>> No.19660557

RTK is one of those cases where it has legitimate flaws and it's fine to point them out, but its critics too often hyperbolize and treat it like the worst thing ever.

>> No.19660580

RTK is one of those cases where you'd better be careful how you talk about my waifu or you're getting the smackdown.

>> No.19660583 [SPOILER] 
File: 163 KB, 1282x987, 1534278397053.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660583

that's... an unexpected ending

>> No.19660623
File: 19 KB, 864x90, kha--tzumoto.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660623

>> No.19660638

>>19660623
smartest and realest thing he's ever written

>> No.19660659

>>19660583
You managed to finish reading that boring story?

>> No.19660668

>>19660583
Looks like a boku no pico ripoff.

>> No.19660672

Please never make a new thread

>> No.19660681

>>19660672
we can't stop it from happening but we can stop showing up
let's make a pact

>> No.19660705

次は俺がOPしています

>> No.19660715

>>19660659
it's not other... https://vndb.org/v1913

>> No.19660820
File: 46 KB, 699x709, cover.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19660820

now I know what "yada yada" means in seinfeld. didn't know they spoke japanese in that show, but it all makes sense now

>> No.19660880

theres nothing wrong with worshipping a balding piss bottler

>> No.19660906

particularly when he's been vetted by a native

>> No.19660926

>>19660880
and don't you forget it
>>19660906
you're got dang right

>> No.19660974

So I'm on anki day 4 or 5 and I'm starting to slow down.
I'm struggling tremendously with things that are similar sounding like 一人 - ひとり and 人 - ひと and 大人 - おとな
I can't comprehend based on these kanji (which I haven't learned) when it ends in a ri or na or whatever else.
Should I have learned more kanji first?

>> No.19660987

>>19660974
>kanji isn't a syllabary
You learned something today.

>> No.19660994

>>19660974
Two things: Do you know the difference between On'Yomi and Kun'Yomi? If not, I suggest you look it up. Second, it is natural for you to not pick up the native speak so quickly unless you're a quick learner. It takes a while to get used to.

>> No.19661010
File: 12 KB, 652x391, you're dumb lmao.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19661010

>>19660974
I'm also on day 4 or 5

>> No.19661016

thou shalt have no other gods before わたし

>> No.19661024

>>19660974
"learning" kanji first wouldn't have helped you at all with this problem
the more words you know the easier it will be
二人 and 一つ will be easier after knowing 一人, 人々 will be easier after knowing 人, 大人 is bullshit (the kanji were just stuck onto an existing word because they fit logically) and you will meet more bullshit along the way but you get used to it

>> No.19661025

>>19660994
>If not, I suggest you look it up
Not him but what's the best place to completely clear that up?

>> No.19661033

>>19660987
but the radicals kind of are, no? Like large is ookii, and person is hito, so I kind of understand where oto comes from, but how am I supposed to remember the end? If its just through repititiona and I'm supposed to learn, like >>19660994 says, then fine I'll just keep chuggin

>>19660994
Like the chinese and japanese pronunciation or something? Idk

>> No.19661047

>>19661033
Woah man, I think you're confused.

>> No.19661050

>>19661047
about which part
>>19661024
so what I'm getting from everybody is just keep doing what I'm doing?

>> No.19661055

>>19661050
About life in general.

>> No.19661062

>>19661033
>Like large is ookii, and person is hito, so I kind of understand where oto comes from
yeah don't do that, it really doesn't work like that in this case
just learn these readings through memorization for now, you'll get a feel for how it all works eventually

>> No.19661069

>>19661062
yea thats all I was askin, just wanted to know if I had the wrong approach.

>> No.19661079

>>19661025
Tofugu explains the difference well. https://www.tofugu.com/japanese/onyomi-kunyomi/

>>19661033
>Like the chinese and japanese pronunciation or something?
Yes. Compound Kanji uses different readings. Many people would think 大人 is おひと which is incorrect. Sometimes Meanings changes to Chinese, sometimes it stays as Japanese when there are multiple Kanji in play.

>> No.19661116

>>19661033
大人 is an example of a word you can't guess because it doesn't follow from common readings, the similarity to the readings you know is essentially a coincidence
other words you will be able to guess when you are familiar with the kanji elsewhere, but while there are common patterns there will always be the chance its an exception and your guess is wrong
>so what I'm getting from everybody is just keep doing what I'm doing?
yes, it will overall get easier

>> No.19661244

>>19661116
what do you mean isnt that dai hito?

>> No.19661253

>>19656294
The joke is that the French will do it if you tell him not to.

>> No.19661260

>>19661244
well it can be dainin or daijin if you really want it to be

>> No.19661285

みんなどんなパンツ履いてんの : )

>> No.19661290

>退く
fucking epic

>> No.19661307

what the fuck you can barely hear the r sound in that word using yomichan, that kana is lying.

>> No.19661318

what r

>> No.19661319

pantunanteiranzo

>> No.19661323

commandoっすか

それもいいっすね

>> No.19661325

>>19661318
i mean l my bad

>> No.19661335

>>19661325
what i

>> No.19661368

(You)

>> No.19661407

does jamal like kohh too?
https://twitter.com/mattvsjapan/status/1028382388609400832

>> No.19661421

>>19661407
everybody loves kohh hes like that one autistic friend everyone has

>> No.19661440

Could you use で to make two な adjectives describe the same noun?
元気で寡黙な人
Don't worry, I'm not producing.

>> No.19661441

>>19661407
you musta been born yesterday

anyway yeah kohh owns dude hes very simple and articulate and easy for foreigners to understand thats why i bump him : )

>> No.19661445

>>19661440
お元気で馬鹿な人

>> No.19661505
File: 186 KB, 909x787, SCN_0036.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19661505

I feel a little bit proud.
Is that okay or should I slap myself for having so few points in listening even though I listen to Japanese every day?

>> No.19661518

>>19661505
how much do you listen per day and read per day and how long have you been studying

gj btw

>> No.19661569

>>19661518
Studying on and off for about 5 years I guess. But I didn't study a lot for most of the time, and I've been doing more than ever the last half year.
I watch Japanese youtube daily for like an hour, but mainly entertainment purpose. I don't think I learn much from that. The rest is mainly reading when I feel like it, but often multiple hours at once, if not the whole day. Plus several anki decks that I picked back up half a year ago.

>> No.19661611

how i stop being a brainlet who has trouble reading kana heavy texts?

>> No.19661616

>>19661611
read less

>> No.19661620

>>19661611
shoot your brain with a gun
that will teach him

>> No.19661664

>>19661611
listen to more spoken japanese so you can read it with the proper rhythm

>> No.19661676

>>19661505
Slap yourself.

>> No.19661677

>>19661664
Never thought I'd see a helpful reply.

>> No.19661681

>>19661611
>>19661664
read more might work too, depends on how you fuck up, but the obvious answer is if you are better at japanese you will be better at guessing what natural sentences fit the kana, so get better at japanese

>> No.19661684

>>19661569
You need more anime in your life

>> No.19661708
File: 506 B, 114x75, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19661708

why though

>> No.19661712

>hifumi
why tho?

>> No.19661724

>>19661684
True, I've burned out over the past years. But don't worry, I'm reading LNs and VNs so I'm staying loyal to my roots.

>>19661676
Will do.

>> No.19661733

>>19661708
why didn't you complain about 十日

>> No.19661739

>>19661733
i did but i didn't post about it

>> No.19661747

>>19661739
just say にとおか so that natives will immediately know you're a foreigner and give you an easier time

>> No.19661795

>>19661747
can't they tell that by, you know, looking at my face?

>> No.19661808

>>19661795
i meant over text when typing in all hiragana or misconversions

>> No.19661878

Can anyone hit me up with an epub / aoz for ノルウェーの森?

CoR has a bunch of Murakami but not this one.

>> No.19661906

Anyone know how hard the Japanese version of Lovecraft stories are to read?
Saw them under LNs the other day and almost bought it, but it's 1200 yen used so I'm not sure if I should go for it.

>> No.19661930

Am I the only one that finds take kim's explanations really longwinded?
It's especially a pain in the arse when reviewing, cause the key things are often hidden in huge text blocks.
Are there any more concise resources/references for grammar?
Or has someone done a summary of tk's lessons, I thought I'd do that so might as well check if someone else did it first.

>> No.19661942

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DR0_cOH-d14&t=4881

>> No.19661943

>>19661930
Whatever you read about using tk as a reference is turbo bullshit. Use dojg.

>> No.19661951
File: 694 KB, 905x1072, m.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19661951

>>19661906
Doesn't look too hard

>> No.19661970

>>19661951
Thanks for that, might go for it. Hopefully the book isn't too heavy.

>> No.19661976

>>19655784
You could in English say simply, "Not summer."

You could probably communicate any message in English while being about as terse as the Japanese equivalent. The difference is that while in Japanese this is normal and flowing, in English you may sound like a caveman.

Message end. Bed now.

>> No.19661977

>>19661970
Sorry it was a joke.

>> No.19661985

>>19661977
Well, you got me. What LN is it then?

>> No.19661991

>>19661985
The Lovecraft one

>> No.19662018
File: 69 KB, 350x500, 237[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19662018

>>19661991
?

>> No.19662025

>>19662018
Yeah probably

>> No.19662026

>>19661943
>use a dictionary to learn grammar

>> No.19662045

>>19661943
Oh wau, dojg is great for referencing, thanks anon.

>> No.19662068

Actually you have to know all of DoJG to get anywhere near knowing Japanese. N1 probably covers more than DoJG and DoJG doesn't even touch on classical Japanese that is known by all natives.

>> No.19662079

>>19662026
what of it? better than tae kim's vocab guide

>> No.19662125

>>19661942
that entire broadcast is hilarious, especially the part where nukemarine says he's studied for 8 years and isn't past core2k and tae kim

>> No.19662142
File: 197 KB, 500x520, 1524942028189.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19662142

>>19662068

>> No.19662151

>>19662125
Nuke's tendency to just butt in and talk over people and never concede anything is annoying, particularly considering how fucking inept at Japanese he is after studying it off and on for 10 years.

>> No.19662159

>>19662142
DoJG has 600 entries. また is in the advanced section. You are fooling yourself if you think every single point isn't expected to be known, it's practically made to be turned into an Anki deck in terms of things you should memorize.

>> No.19662167

>>19662151
i know. his pronunciation is so fucking weird because he's been imitating text to speech programs and core recordings for 12 years. it's probably beyond repair at this point. you can see matt trying to not laugh when he tries to speak japanese

>> No.19662183

>>19662159
Are you playing a part right now or are you serious?

>> No.19662191

>>19662183
I'm dead serious and I dare you bring one valid counter argument fool.

>> No.19662201

>>19662183
he's a beginner who doesn't know anything trying to bait people into explaining shit for him because he's a lazy, stupid, and sad person

>> No.19662205

>>19662159
The reason it's in the advanced section is that they never originally planned out the three volumes and just kind of stuck it in there as something that got left out from the others. Anyway of course you need to know everything in DoJG to be good at Japanese, I don't think anyone is arguing with you.

>> No.19662210

>>19662191
SRSing japanese -> english grammar points will permanently cripple your intuitive understanding of japanese. you should do mass immersion and then go back to a grammar guide like minna no nihongo and look in the back section at the patterns and ask yourself if you understand what the pattern means instead of translating it into english

>> No.19662224

>>19662210
>will permanently cripple your intuitive understanding

It might not be worthwhile but, no. Time to add "permanently cripple" to the filter list.

>> No.19662233

filtering people will permanently cripple your ability to comprehend shitposting and thus your shitposting output.

>> No.19662272

>>19662224
it was time for that a while ago, he's been quite active
if you like to pretend the thread isn't trash, that is
don't shield your eyes from reality, recognize that djt is beyond recovery

>> No.19662326

doesn't nukemarine recommend you srs dojg? nice advice.... if you want to stay at the beginner stage for 8 years i guess

>> No.19662327

I'm pretty sure studying grammar terms causes damage. Like the guy above said it fucks your intuitive understanding of Japanese. Just watch 10000 hours of anime and you'll intuitively know everything in dojg.

>> No.19662380

>>19662326
you are right on the substance but wrong on the reasoning and hence i respectfully beg to disagreeably agree

>> No.19662392

Just read https://boirodaisuki.neocities.org/ and then consume content with a grammar handbook on the side for things you keep seeing but can't seem to pick up.

>> No.19662438

Wanting to take JLPT N3 test this year as a personal challenge, from trial questions online I think I could pass N4 minus the spoken sections. My problem is I don't know where to start. Is grammar most important thing to actually study? Flashcards are helping me a lot with vocab, and I get a lot from trying to play games or read stories, but I'm not sure where to start with grammar.

>> No.19662448

How many words should I have to look up when reading? Is 500+ per game too much? Should I find easier reading material?

>> No.19662450

>>19662327
Just watch 1500 hours of raw anime and you're good. No need for 10k hours with subs.

>> No.19662462

>>19662205
The three volumes are an attempt to match the three general levels of popular textbooks for learners and the concepts as they are covered. This is why また is in the advanced volume and has contextual examples which have a much higher complexity/assumed knowledge in contrast to something like まだ, in the basic volume.
For anyone who wants to know what in sweet fuck I'm referring to, here are the entries for each of the above.
また
https://itazuraneko.neocities.org/pages/dojg.html#advancedまた
まだ
https://itazuraneko.neocities.org/pages/dojg.html#basicまだ

The publisher, The Japan Times, generally expects the audience to follow your typical classroom Genki textbooks type progression.

>>19662448
>How many words should I have to look up when reading?
As many words as you feel the need to.
>Should I find easier reading material?
Only if it feels too difficult and isn't enjoyable.

>> No.19662506
File: 90 KB, 620x541, 1524015940796.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19662506

Anyone else who just can't motivate themselves to do listening? I find it so boring compared to reading so I always just do that instead. I'm probably doing 99 parts reading to 1 part listening at this point, even though I know that it's likely bad for me.

>> No.19662515

>>19662450
You'd learn much more from 1500 hours of english subbed anime than 1500 hours of raw. On top of subbed being enjoyable and raw being completely unenjoyable. Definitely don't recommend watching raw without being able to understand the meaning of what you're hearing.

>> No.19662521

Best way to learn is comprehensible input. Best way to find comprehensible input is wading through the mess of incomprehensible input. Same with reading. Raw is definitely a better way to learn. You won't learn shit with subs.

>> No.19662528

>>19662521
>best way to learn is comprehensible input
Ok, then why do you say than incomprehensible input is better than input+something that helps you comprehend it?

>> No.19662537

Best way to learn listening is by speaking with a native. Both subs and dubs are disastrous to your ability because they won't correct you.

>> No.19662539

>>19662528
retards think consulting subs for a clue when youre stuck will p*rmanently d*mage your intuition forever and ever

>> No.19662544

>>19662528
The answer to your question is the same reason relates to why it 10k hours of subtitles to learn Japanese.

>> No.19662546

>>19662544
what?

>> No.19662555

>>19662539
they just haven't been learning long enough to understand the first thought that pops into your head isn't permanently ingrained there forever

>> No.19662556

>>19662544
Basically, it takes 10k hours of subtitles to get anywhere because reading subtitles isn't learning Japanese.

>> No.19662561

>>19662556
that's not a reason. that's just using a meme incorrectly as proof

>> No.19662567

>>19662561
I'm using that person's own assertion against him.

>> No.19662578

>>19662567
If you only did 10k hours of raw anime you'd make less progress than if you only did 10k hours of subbed anime.

>> No.19662608

>>19662578
If you only did about 2k hours of raw anime you'd make as much progress as doing 10k hours of subbed anime.

>> No.19662611

if you actually think that 2k or 10k or whatever or however many hours of a particular task is going to bring you to success due to near numbers you're seriously delusional

you need to apply yourself for 2k or 10k or however many hours worth of time, not sit there lifeless for hours at a time

>> No.19662623

>>19662611
When listening to raws you definitely have to pay attention. With subtitles people will naturally get lazy and just use them as a crutch, ignoring a lot of what they hear, hence why it requires 10k hours. There's reality and then there's your idealized fantasy world.

>> No.19662634

>>19662578
the absolute state of djt

>> No.19662640

>>19662623
>With subtitles people will naturally get lazy and just use them as a crutch
You're assuming everyone is as lazy as you, yes I know where we are.
If you're that lazy you can just keep them off until you need them

>> No.19662659

You should first read the subtitle file quickly through to pick up new words and then watch the raw without subtitles

>> No.19662668

>>19662640
>i'll make maximum gains out of lazy methods by maximizing my effort without changing them
keep doing what makes you comfortable instead of focusing on progress

>> No.19662670

That doesn't make sense because all text subtitles are made by illiterate Chinese basement dwellers and consequently filled to the brim with mistakes to the point the subtitles are illegible without the video.

>> No.19662678

>>19662668
Raw: Watch, try to understand, some parts are too hard so you just skip them
Subs: Watch, try to understand, have reference material for the meaning of the hard parts so now you don't have to skip them

>> No.19662694

>>19662668
Precisely because I am focused on progress I recommend using comprehensible input over incomprehensible input.

>> No.19662696

>>19662678
>have reference material for the meaning of the hard parts so now you don't have to skip them
your misconception is that this is valuable input even if the parts you can understand without subs are unaffected

>> No.19662703

>>19662694
you don't know what comprehensible input is

>> No.19662705

>>19662696
How is it not I wasn't talking about JP subs by the way

>> No.19662719

>>19662705
if you need assistance to understand it it is not comprehensible input by krashen's definition
i know and that makes it worse, at least jp subs would only be diminishing your listening practice and not your overall japanese gains

>> No.19662731

1825 hours of raw audio gets you to this point in a year
https://youtu.be/JuJW3bWmJ9Q
can't say the same for subbed unfortunately

>> No.19662742

how do i learn german

>> No.19662752

>>19662731
>yeah so ive been learning japanese for a year and i now when i watch animes i understand everything
Seems legit

>> No.19662759

why does DJT understimate the power of listening

>> No.19662764

>>19662752
he didn't say that though
he might be an ajatt cultist but he's somehow more honest than you

>> No.19662791

i've never studied any japanese and i can roughly understand anime

>> No.19662800

did you remember to log your daily progress so you can give future djters inspiration?

>> No.19662825

>>19662731
So did he record himself taking JCAT? Does he have videos of him extensively reading Japanese beyond something you can prepare and rehearse in 20 minutes? Are there videos of him interacting effortlessly with Japanese people?

All these AJATT cultist are getting on my nerves. They upload videos of them talking about the progress they made, willingly overstating what they can do and at most have a video of themselves reading a fucking script not even well. Not to mention that we have no evidence for him or any other AJATTER actually starting at the time they say they did. The last time I listened to BritVsJapan talking about his progress I was amazed, but when I saw the video of him talking Japanese and his actual method of reviewing and making flashcards I cringed. These people are full of shit and do not understand everything they are reading/watching. I wager you can reach general fluency with 4 years of consistent work. People should stop shilling these losers and giving learners false impressions of what it takes to learn Japanese.

>> No.19662850

>>19662825
don't forget all of them lie or hide that they started learning japanese before they started ajatt, they act like it's some kind of rebirth and all of their time spent before isn't worth mentioning
maybe because it makes how bad they are at japanese more acceptable if they can say they've been doing it for a shorter time

>> No.19662855

>>19662759
its hard to convince someone that hasnt watched 10000 hours of anime that 10000 hours of anime is needed but its not hard to convince someone whos watched 10000 hours of anime that 10000 hours of anime is needed so if youre not watchin 10000 hours of anime you need to be watchin 10000 hours of anime because thats the only way youre gonna get better its the only way youre gonna be #1 is to watch 10000 hours of anime so keep watchin 10000 hours of anime

>> No.19662870

>>19662825
I think he might be exaggerating about how much he can understand but I don't doubt that this guy made huge progress in that one year and he is well on his way to knowing Japanese. Most people should just do AJATT because it's very effective and brainlet-proof.

>> No.19662878

>>19662825
the victims deserve what they get imo its natural selection

>> No.19662882

>>19662800
why, so conspiracy theorists can just claim you're lying?
>>19662825
>>19662850

>> No.19662886

>>19662870
except for everything about ajatt that isn't what krashen says you're spot-on

>> No.19662897

>>19662825
>I was amazed at BritvsJapan's purported ability to comprehend input, but then I found his output unimpressive.
Try harder man.

>> No.19662899

yea matts a bona fide intermediate

hes basically as good at nihongo as the people who fan tl hentai games

>> No.19662907

>>19662882
who said conspiracy
they are independently of their own will being dishonest to make themselves look better
it helps them feel better about themselves in their own eyes too
i don't think brit and matt get together and say heh we're gonna fool some nerds and make some dolla
i think they genuinely think that their time spent before ajatt doesn't make a difference because they are delusional
similar to how they think they're actually good now when they are intermediates
that's not a conspiracy

>> No.19662913

wait i dont actua;lly have any proof matts an intermediate either lol

see how well the kool aid works when u start drinking it

>> No.19662926

>>19662897
Make him record himself taking the JCAT.
Have him stream himself actually reading something difficult.
You people are a big fucking a joke.

>> No.19662928

>>19662913
to be fair when you hang around djt for so long a scripted reading of muramasa looks pretty impressive by comparison

>> No.19662937

>>19662907
>they are independently of their own will being dishonest to make themselves look better
there are more ajatters than just matt and brit. also how long did brit study genki in his japanese class before doing ajatt?

>>19662926
ajatt is turning the frogs gay!!

>> No.19662961

>>19662937
i used them as examples because they seem to have known each other for a while and both be into the patreon shit so that seemed like a pair you would use as conspiracy
claiming that the followers are in on the conspiracy is even more ridiculous
if you're more up to date on this shit you can help me out i just call it like i see it
i think brit studied for at least a year, might have been 18 months, but you can look into it for me if you're interested

>> No.19662972

>>19662961
i'm going to assume he studied for 6 months and say that if his 6 months of study consisted of genki in a classroom then that time is trivial both in absolute terms and relative to the 18 months he spent doing AJATT in his 18 month AJATT update video.

>> No.19662974

brit is shit matt makes sheep noises and the rest of the sheep follow

>> No.19662985

luckily my djt boys arent sheep right??

>> No.19662992

You kids need to stop obsessing over this pointless topic. Also I still don't know Japanese, yet still haven't lost a debate on /djt/.

>> No.19662995

no youve definitely lost

the game

now bring in the next victim

>> No.19663015

>>19662972
>i'm going to assume he studied for 6 months
i am certain it was longer but it doesn't really matter
>if his 6 months of study consisted of genki in a classroom then that time is trivial both in absolute terms and relative to the 18 months he spent doing AJATT
that's rather naive
the problem isn't even how far he's come, but if his methods are suitable for a complete beginner
classroom genki might be a shitty method but any experience at all prior to following ajatt makes a huge difference in how feasible it is for a beginner

>> No.19663019 [DELETED] 

Hahaha I'm going to snipe the victory at the last second!

>> No.19663038

the only method suitable for a beginner is to let your sense of wonder lead you into cool japanese things like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9aGOpjqAW3M

if you dont have that its fuckin pointless start going to church and find jesus

>> No.19663042

Do these AJATT ecelebs atleast have N1?

>> No.19663049

reminder to put the itazuraneko site back in the OP because the djtguide site is dead and contains outdated/incorrect information

>> No.19663059

>>19663038
>start going to church and find jesus
this makes me uncomfortable

>> No.19663064

Starting from a complete beginner I watched like 6-7 thousand hours of anime and ended up learning enough to watch most anime raw

>> No.19663070

how do i know how many hours of anime i've watched

>> No.19663072

>>19663042
if any of them did i would take up the good fight of defending ajatt for at least 24 hours
ironically of course but i'm a man of my word

>> No.19663079

>>19663070
if you havent been keeping track then its effectively 0

>> No.19663088

>>19663079
shit is that why i don't know japanese yet shit shit shit why didn't anyone tell me fuck

>> No.19663092

>>19663070
whats your fave anime

ill be able to guess from that

>> No.19663106

>>19663092
I like boku no hero academia. I cosplay as All Might every day

>> No.19663110

>>19663092
uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
dont really know what my favourite is but i guess its either Girls und Panzer, Evangelion, or if we count movies Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu
Haruhi's movie is definitively my favourite if we only count one seaon/movie and not the whole franchise

>> No.19663119

>>19663092
do me
my favorite anime is shingetsutan tsukihime

>> No.19663130

>>19663106
300 hours

>>19663110
1500 hours

>>19663119
your post gave me aids *hangs out of order sign around neck*

>> No.19663135

>>19663092
New Game

>> No.19663143

>>19663130
that was a joke don't stop yet
my favorite anime is エア・ギア

>> No.19663144

>>19663130
I haven't watched any shounen anime btw
So no 500000 episode bullshit like Naruto, One Piece, Bleach and so on
t. >>19663110

>> No.19663149
File: 92 KB, 316x219, i said gday.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19663149

>> No.19663156

to be h matt tricking people into pretending they're learning jap is pretty epic. i learned this shit in 3 months with the deej method yall wasting ya time

>> No.19663157

shit i memed too hard
i did like shingetsutan tsukihime when it was like the 5th anime i watched ever

>> No.19663164

im sure you liked the first fsn anime too lmao

tukihime owns but that anime was so fuckin trash

i deem this djt closed https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3p8nxO_XiE

>> No.19663169

btw actually whats worse mini skirt arc of the modern era of aids or that anime from before most of you were even born

>> No.19663179

>>19663164
>im sure you liked the first fsn anime too lmao
shit you got me figured out it was just a phase
i liked tsukihime when i played it after the anime in like 2004 or some shit, someday i'll play it properly and see how i feel about it now
>>19663169
what if i said neither

>> No.19663183

>>19663164
wow this is a really good spoof

>> No.19663188

>>19663179
i think thats reasonable as they are both quite offensive

i personally give the slight edge to mini skirt arc tho what a disaster

>> No.19663197
File: 29 KB, 720x403, dedede laugh.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19663197

>>19663156
>3 months

>> No.19663202

>learn Japanese so I can read the Tsukihime remake
>mini skirt Arc happens

>> No.19663207

>>19663188
i gotta ask have you thrown down some act cadenza ver. b

>> No.19663211

>learn japanese
>by the time im done japanese people have already dissappeared from the world

>> No.19663212

>>19663202
>learn japanese to read mahoyo
>FGO happens so typemoon is never going to finish the series

>> No.19663215

>>19663202
New Arc is an improvement. The Tsukihime remake was one of the many reasons I wanted to learn Japanese. Too bad it is never getting released ever.

>> No.19663216

>>19663202
The logical progression is skirtless Arc right?

>> No.19663226

>>19663212
I want to read Mahoyo, but the autist in me says I need to re-read all of the Tsukihime and F/SN VNs in Japanese and probably KnK as well.

>> No.19663229

>>19663207
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKJmi1D4Obw

>>19663216
itd be less offensive if she did just roll bare ass and vagine illuminated by the moon glow

>> No.19663236

>>19663226
reread fsn, watch the knk movies unsubtitled, and skip tsukihime and mahoyo. proceed to never give typemoon the time of day again, because they ruined eroge.

>> No.19663244
File: 384 KB, 640x480, 1408309627055.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19663244

>>19663236
>skip tsukihime and mahoyo

>> No.19663247

>>19663244
tsukihime really doesn't hold up to modern standards imo

you could, like, pick a couple routes and read them i guess, if you really really want

and mahoyo is essentially an extended prologue to a series that never actually got made

>> No.19663256

idk depends on how new you are just generally imo

but yea thats the problem with a lot of shit from that time period not just t-m

>> No.19663258

>>19663247
But I love Tsukihime's early 00s edgy, gritty atmosphere.

>mahoyo is essentially an extended prologue to a series that never actually got made
Yeah but I want to suffer like everyone else.

>> No.19663263

If the games you play have voice acting or a backlog or don't need to be emulated, you can't learn Japanese.

>> No.19663272

if you post you cant learn japanese

>> No.19663283

Who updates the DJT library around here?

>> No.19663286

Not me

>> No.19663289

>>19663283
watakushi-sama

>> No.19663291

me

>> No.19663296
File: 1.62 MB, 288x204, tenor.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19663296

← this guy

>> No.19663297

>>19663229
i haven't played since netplay was a hack, maybe i'll find out how i feel about these extra fighting styles and shit

>> No.19663299

>>19663297
yah i remember playing ac on hamachi or some shit ftw

>> No.19663300

What's this miniskirt thing about? I played Tsukihime but I'm out of the loop.

>> No.19663301

reading is hard
so's being alive

>> No.19663303

they gave arc a mini skirt in the new remake thing or w/e and it sux hard how could they do this

>> No.19663305

>>19663258
if you want to suffer like everyone else you know what you have to do, you can't half-ass that

>> No.19663309
File: 2.73 MB, 2100x1500, 1529046198175.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19663309

>>19663300
>he doesn't know
These are canon (although they are very very old now).

>> No.19663320

if theres one thing we can say has never changed its that ciel still fuckin blows

>> No.19663322

>>19663309
damn though check out that gothkiha
ciel is literally worse though what did i do to deserve this

>> No.19663325

yeah she blows my DICK hahaha
(how do you say this in japanese btw?)

>> No.19663327

>>19663303
I see. I like the new design a lot but I like the old one more. That's only comparing the visuals. The old design fits her character much better.

>> No.19663330

>>19663327
see also her face

>> No.19663332

Are those 1 yen books on Amazon really that cheap? Or is there a catch?

>> No.19663334

>>19663309
I think it's weird that they would want to redesign these characters even though at this point their most iconic looks are from Melty Blood. That's what everyone recognizes now, so why change it?

>> No.19663344

>>19663330
Yeah my post was about everything including the face. The new design is qt as heck but it doesn't fit her character at all.

>> No.19663345

>>19663334
gotta make shiki look like a autismo to fit the times

same with mini skirts same with whatever you call what they did to satuki

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action