/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Didn't play it, did you?

more like chieftain arthur

>>1325407

Even if she was disguised as a man so people would follow her, she should still be Queen when referred in this time period as we now know her sex.

How could Ciel be Roa if he was a man? Wouldn't he be Roako? Or does Nasu suck that bad at English?

...

Possible /a/ troll or the occassional newfag

can somebody explain the eternal world from One~ to the radiant season?

How can archer be Shiro from the future? Wouldn't that create a time paradox thus causing the universe to fold inwards and collapse ? Or does Nasu suck that bad at Theoretical Physics?

After you read UBW it makes sense, as you figure out Saber is Shirou with a sex-change, from the future

>>1325517
Heh.

>>1325401
I'm also interested in this question. Shouldn't Saber be referred to as Queen Arthur? I don't understand. Could you dumb it down for me?

How can archer be Shiro from the future? If time travel was possible then why wouldn't a wizard use it to win every Holy Grail war with the power of hindsight ? Or does Nasu suck that bad at Human Nature?

>>1325553
Shut the fuck up you cockmongler.

>>1325517

>>1325553
impossible

>>1325563
SHIROU WOULD NEVER INSULT SOMEONE WHO ARE YOU?!?!

p.s. sage for shitty thread

This thread is an eyesore

>>1325401
Saber is King Arthur's daughter

How can sakura cast magic if she has no magic crest? Wouldn't she need penis worms to infest her vagina? Or does nasu suck that bad at casting magics?

>>1325600
>Saber is King Arthur's daughter

Saber is actually Joan of Arc, can you read? or did you just look at the pretty pictures while playing F/S N?

King Arthur is a faggot.

Its not supposed to make sense, honestly if we were to point out every plothole in Touhou + every VN + every manga we will be here for years.

>>1325620
Why can't we have WIliam Wallace as a Saber Servant? It would be nice to see him crying "FREEEEEEEDOOOOOOOOOOOOM!!!"

>>1325615
!, my Joan, WHERE

>>1325693
Enjoy your purple haired Scottish shota..

>>1325615
Wait what?
When was this said?

You are crowned King when you pull out Excalibur, not Queen.

>>1325731
it wasnt

>>1325401
Hot damn needs some more Saber in that white armor.

>>1325742
have great fap, anon.

>>1325401
Merlin betrayed King Arthur and casted a spell on him to turn him into a girl.

>>1325752
FFFFFFFFFFFFF where is this Saber from?

Sheesh. Merlin turned Saber into a man so that s/he can be crowned as King. That's why Saber had an heir (who, in fact, looked exactly like herself).

Oh god white saber is hot.

>>1325752
Thanks bro.

Tag is saber_lily on danbooru for those who wanted more like I did.

ITT people who never passed the abstract phase of psychological development

Obviously Arthur was always a girl and history got their facts wrong.

Either that or Arthur was a boy in life and when summoned came to the modern world as a girl.

Either way who cares?

>>1325828
King Arthur is Artorious, a Roman officer who became ruler of the Romano Britons after the Western Roman Empire withdrawn from Britain due to the relentless barbarian invasions.

He leads a company of 'knights' who are in fact Sarmatian auxiliary heavy cavalry, who were noted for using the dragon as their faction symbol hence his name "Arthur Pendragon".

>>1325916
you must have failed history.

>>1326000
I am Asian so I don't give a fuck about your Roman history.

No seriously, why did she have to hide her gender instead of being a queen? A nation following a female ruler really wasn't out of the question at the time.

And why the hell didn't they just use Joan of Arc instead of "lol Arthur was a girl" I mean seriously Japan.

>>1326013
I am a World citizen I give a fuck about Asian and Roman histories.

So why wasn't Lu Bu or Zhuge Liang reincarnated for the holy grail war? Or even Wong motherfucking Fei Hong or Masamune. FUCK....Nasu is so fucking white washed that he ignores Asian history.

What's so legendary about Joan of Arc? What magical stuff she does?

Zhuge Liang would shoot motherfucking lazers out of his fan, but too bad that idea is taken already.

Besides Zhuge is a comtempt man at the time of his death. There was nothing that triggers him to return to the Holy Grail war.

>>1326020
Liberate a fortified city captured by the English army (12,000 +) soldiers, having only 2000 herself.
Claims she was guided by visions from God.

>>1326014
Britain, pre-Dark Ages. Male rule. None of you fuckers ever studied history, right? Also, Britannia =! Japan.

>>1326020
She had "holy visions" and/or heard voices from virgin Mary and stuff. Its why people followed her.

Now how would they tweak that into something that could be used in combat. Hrmhmmmm.

>>1326041

King Arthur didn't really fight either. He was a strategist who sometimes rode out on the field to boost morale.

>>1326054
King Arthur was mostly myth, Joan is a historical character.

Why wasn't I reincarnated? I would've won by having everyone fight amongst themselves while I will position my final strike to knock out all players. Then I will call upon the south east winds to scatter the ashes.

>>1326062
weren't some of the assassins historical characters too?

>>1326078
Its because your Chinese, and nobody likes Chinese people.

>>1326054
King Arthur single handedly decimated armies, fought giants, dragons and witches. Fuck you and your shitty french version of king Arthur. Lancelot is a faggot.

>>1326083
The Hashshashin were a historical militant faction, who gave birth to the term assassin, but of course they nothing to do with the supernatural.

King Artur's legend is so vague and unspecified on the other hand (since his reign was nowhere near close the age of knights) and there are no clear historical records.

>>1326083
Some were historical, some were just myths, some were a mix of both.

They just have to be "legends".

>>1326107
but archer wasn't a legend

>>1326121
He did become one.
'The legendary sucker, saved a 100 peoples lives and died for it, and had his eternal soul tormented'.

Shirou was originally supposed to be girl, and Saber was supposed to be guy, but artist thought that female Arthur looked cute so Nasu changed the script.

>>1326148
No, artist wanted an eroge.

>>1326157
Something like that.

How come they have all these people with magical powers but nobody knows about them and nobody ever happens to cross the street and see the weird people fighting with magical powers?

>>1326219
Did you not read at all?

>>1326219
Becuz diapers Oo

>>1326219
Boundary fields, eliminated witnesses.

>>1326121
How come in Tsukihime they have all these people with magical powers but nobody knows about them and nobody ever happens to cross the street and see the weird people fighting with magical powers?

>>1326242
Tell that to the girl Nero ate.

>>1326254
That was only 1 person, when the characters in Tsukihime fight they destroy entire buildings and nobody bothers to investigate and there are never any people around.

>>1326288
You mean the entire hotel where everyone inside it was massacred? You mean the constant serial killings that had the entire city in fear?

>>1326288
Remember X/1999? KEKKAIS, BITCA

>>1326303
I don't read CLAMP they produce nothing but trash.