[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 315 KB, 792x976, 40076871_p7.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784108 No.11784108 [Reply] [Original]

Has Marisa ever shown (or even just implied) disinterest at becoming a Youkai Magician in canon or is it all just fanon wanting to keep her human for whatever reasons?

I can't for the life of me remember that there was ever a line implying it in the games, but I might just have missed something.

>> No.11784123 [DELETED] 

I like that picture, especially her eyes and hair.

>> No.11784158
File: 651 KB, 827x1181, 1389105705731.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784158

>>11784123
Have the artist's pixiv. Good shit.
http://www.pixiv.net/member_illust.php?id=5626224

>> No.11784174

>>11784108

I don't give a fuck what anyone says, Marisa will become a youkai magician like Alice and Patche and Reimu will become a god through faith and crazy awesome adventures will continue in Touhou forever.
It's ok if Sanae dies though. I'd only be moderately sad.

>> No.11784182
File: 1.42 MB, 1154x1452, 1386787471493.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784182

>>11784108
It's pretty much canon that marisa is searching for an immortality potion

>> No.11784187

She's just an ordinary human magician.
Don't think she'll go full youkai.

>> No.11784190

>>11784158
allmost thought it was by wampire hunter.thanks!

>> No.11784192

>>11784187
Except there is like nothing actually ordinary about her:I would say patchouli is more ordinary.

>> No.11784197
File: 349 KB, 590x590, 35423509_p9.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784197

>>11784174
I'm with you on that. Except I like Sanae a bit more than Reimu so I wouldn't be okay with her dying at all. I wouldn't be okay with either of them dying.

>> No.11784211

>>11784192
is patche human? I honestly can't remember.

>> No.11784214

>>11784211
She'd be dead if she was.

>> No.11784218
File: 141 KB, 850x850, 1389106655979.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784218

>>11784211
She was born as a magician type youkai therefore she is not human.

>> No.11784222

She won't become a full magician because she's static like almost all the cast. No changes here.

>> No.11784233
File: 256 KB, 604x600, 1388957972818.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784233

>>11784222
The question wasn't if she will become one or not, the question was if she's canonically opposed to the idea of becoming one.

Fanon works often uses her humanity as a base for romance drama, which I always found really odd because I can't remember her showing any opposition to the idea of becoming a youkai.

>> No.11784228

>>11784214
>>11784218
Okay, thanks. I just kinda assumed she was a youkai, but I didn't remember where I got that from.
She is like 100 years old though, so I guess that makes sense.

>> No.11784235

>>11784218
It never been stated.
It's possible that she also went through process from human just like Alice.

>> No.11784242

>>11784235
I read it in some side material not sure which one though.

>> No.11784247
File: 382 KB, 500x708, 1381491826264.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784247

>>11784174
If Sanae has any faith left, she might be able to skip the whole dying part and just stick around as a god.

Or maybe there's paperwork she has to do with Shikieiki, it's probably complicated. Like where does the karma go if she has enough faith to directly become a god?

>> No.11784249

>>11784235
I thought it was confirmed in side material.

>> No.11784252

>>11784235
Found it

悪魔の棲む館、紅魔館の頭脳と言えば、この魔法使いパチュリー・ノーレッジである。

Patchouli Knowledge is a magician known as the brain of the Scarlet Devil Mansion, the manor where devils live.

紅魔館で起こる問題を解決する役目を負っている(*1)。

It is her role to resolve problems that occur in the Scarlet Devil Mansion (*1).

長い髪を持つが、姿は人間と区別付かない。

She has long hair, but otherwise her appearance is indistinguishable from a human's.

彼女は、生粋の魔法使いであり、既に百年以上生きているという。

>She is a born magician, and it is said she has lived for over a hundred years.

>> No.11784255
File: 629 KB, 1024x1080, 1336275443250.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784255

>>11784192
I think she's pretty ordinary, but in a good way. ZUN chose her title well.
Sure, she is eccentric and sometimes weird, but she is ordinary in the sense that there is nothing inherently special about her and her origins, kinda like you and me. She was born an ordinary human and worked hard to get where she is today, meanwhile Reimu was born with her abilities.

She shows that even ordinary people can become heroes.

>> No.11784258

>>11784252
Oh I forgot about this.
I only remember that she's a witch and witch is type of youkai, forgetting that she's born that way.

Maybe I'm thinking about Alice too much.

>> No.11784260

>>11784255
That's not something I feel would keep her from becoming a youkai though.
In fact, it feels like the next logical step. With just hard work she managed to not only become a skilled magician, but even a youkai.

>> No.11784264

>>11784258
Isn't witch just another word used for born magicians?
To make them easier to distinguish from normal magician youkai who were former humans.

>> No.11784265
File: 442 KB, 966x746, Marisa confirmed for taoist.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784265

Why become youkai when you can be TAO?!

>> No.11784268

>>11784264
There is no easier-to-use term, all Akyuu really refers to is Magician/Sorceror as a species or as an occupation.

>> No.11784273
File: 60 KB, 700x700, 1379212811327.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784273

>>11784265


I"m pretty sure its illegal to post the endings og touhou games like that. Please delete your file

>> No.11784271

>>11784265
>Posting endings
BURN HIM.

>> No.11784276

>>11784265
ZUUUUUUUUUUUUUN

>> No.11784278

>>11784260
I guess that makes sense, but I like to think that Marisa will keep her humanity intact and not take shortcuts.
Sure, she could become a Youkai and use magic a lot easier, but Marisa would rather get there through hard work and guts and become a powerful magic user in spite of her normal human side.

>> No.11784281

>>11784278
Was becoming a youkai ever stated to be a "shortcut" though?
Isn't it just a result of hard work?

>> No.11784285

>>11784278

Becoming a youkai would be the ultimate fruits of hardwork. It's not easy to just become a youkai. There's no magic potion or spell.

>> No.11784295
File: 428 KB, 980x1040, 1316459753445.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784295

>>11784281
No. But changing who you are just for power doesn't seem very Marisa-y to me.

>> No.11784296
File: 222 KB, 800x600, 1351491624679.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784296

Guys, why do you have to abandon humanity and become youkai, when you can embrace the power of the TAO, and extend your lifespan without tainting yourself with the horrors that are youkai?

>> No.11784299
File: 464 KB, 800x600, 21549476.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784299

Rather than a magician, I hope she becomes a mushroom youkai

>> No.11784302

>>11784264
Speaking about heritage Tenshi is also born celestial. I thought she was ascended from earth at some point as a reward for guarding sacred keystone.

In fact, there's her father who is a lord at Heaven.

>>11784278
Is there really a side effect of becoming a youkai? I mean, Alice is just fine and she doesn't eat human.
Maybe the whole "relying on human beliefs" thingy she's worried about?

>> No.11784303

>>11784296
I don't wanna be a plate. I'd still hug Futo though.

>> No.11784307

>>11784108
Any ever wonder if youkai magician is just Gensokyoian for becoming a Lich?

>> No.11784304
File: 205 KB, 713x557, 1366087451893.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784304

>what fanon wants Marisa to be

>> No.11784311

>>11784295
But that's not what becoming a youkai magician means.
Look at Alice, she still acts like a human.

And as has been said before, becoming a youkai magician is the end result of all her hard work.
She would still have worked hard to earn her power.

I always saw it as her hard work resulting in her becoming so powerful she cannot be considered human anymore.

>> No.11784315 [DELETED] 

>>11784182

How can something be 'pretty much canon'?

>> No.11784316
File: 357 KB, 1600x1241, 1327435527975.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784316

>>11784307

>> No.11784322
File: 160 KB, 850x680, 1389108694883.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784322

>>11784304
Maybe I should show you Mima to proof if you really have "bones"

>> No.11784325

>>11784304
Where's my normal human character who has no magic or science, can't fly at all and just beats up youkai scum with his/her fists and anger?

>> No.11784347

>>11784315
Well it was mentioned that she was trying to create an immortality elixir in several games ,but failed in the end.

>Protagonist Marisa Kirisame has been known to perk her ears up at mention of easy routes to immortality but so far hasn't had the patience or the nerve to follow through (one of her options would have been to eat Mokounote Or Kaguya. But Marisa didn't know this yet when she fought Kaguya.). She's also rejected several forms of immortality: she's specifically trying to keep her humanity while also being immortal, so any method that turns her into a youkai is out.

>> No.11784348

There's really no downsides to her becoming a youkai. Marisa knows this, she hangs out with youkai all the time and can tell that, the same as people, there are youkai that are bad and youkai that are good. There is no reason why she wouldn't become a youkai. I don't think it would necessarily be a conscious ritual or decision of whatever. As she continues to accumulate power, at some point she is no longer human and is considered a youkai.
And I don't think Marisa would ever stop studying and strengthening her magic so it's pretty much inevitable that she will become a youkai

>> No.11784356

>>11784347

What's the source on that quote

>> No.11784357

>>11784311
I don't entirely trust Alice because of her PC-98 relationships and her non-game official literature. That could just be me though, many don't consider those pieces canon. She seems pretty nice otherwise and in more recent pieces.

And I don't think being incredibly powerful would make you not human, but I can see what you mean. Kinda like liches.
Reimu is incredibly powerful but I don't see her becoming anything non-human anytime soon though.

>> No.11784358
File: 64 KB, 266x398, 1382320091511.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784358

>>11784348
Except becoming a youkai would mean you would also have the same weaknesses as a youkai.

>> No.11784360

>>11784325
What she can do if every youkai can fly above her head?

>> No.11784367

>>11784357
PC-98 is only considered canon whenever it doesn't contradict the Windows games though, if I remember correctly.

So if they contradict the Windows depiction of Alice, those contradictions are considered non-canon.

At least that's what I remember hearing.

>> No.11784368
File: 402 KB, 1013x700, 1379895878685.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784368

>>11784356
Tvtropes
But you can find the same info in side materials and games if you don't like tvtropes this one was just easier and faster to find for me.

>> No.11784370
File: 695 KB, 1100x1488, 39213110.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784370

>> No.11784373

>>11784325
She's not actually canon but isn't that pretty much what Hakurei Miko is?

>> No.11784375

>>11784358

What weaknesses do youkai have?

>> No.11784377

>>11784367
You are correct.
I'm still wary of Alice, and nearly every Touhou at that.

>> No.11784379

>>11784368
>side materials and games
Please post the quotes themselves' or something.

>> No.11784380

>>11784360

Sneak, wait until they're on the ground, pounce, rip and tear

>> No.11784385
File: 1.19 MB, 1160x1160, 1379482206440.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784385

>>11784375
Like the fact that their power and entire existence depends on how much humankind believes in them.

>>11784379
Perfect cherry blossom manual
>Magic is her weapon. For the time being, her aim is to create the elixir of immortality.

>On another topic, the elixir of immortality she had been developing during the winter ended up being too large for consumption. More improvement required.

>> No.11784406

>>11784385
I never understood what makes 丹 an "elixir of immortality".

>> No.11784443

>>11784406
I never understood that particular quirk about my dick either.

>> No.11784509

>>11784406
From dictionary.goo.ne.jp:
>たん【丹】

>3 薬。特に、道家における長寿・不老不死の薬。

I didn't know this before I posted either, it's probably some Chinese thing.

>> No.11784790

>>11784296
Why is Futo so cute?

>> No.11784849

>>11784360
Step 1: Is the target flying? Y/N
Step 2: [Y] Grab rock
Step 3: Trow rock
Step 4: Return to step 1
Step 5: [N] Switch to melee combat

>> No.11784852

>>11784849
Mad tactics right there son

>> No.11784874
File: 82 KB, 400x550, 1389124130158.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784874

>>11784790
Why do people like her?

>> No.11784877
File: 130 KB, 620x614, futocape.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784877

>>11784874
Because she's the cutest and most loyal. She also fights the youkai scum.

>> No.11784906
File: 228 KB, 517x794, 5ed9f92b.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11784906

>>11784874
It's the ponytail

>> No.11785006

>>11784108
*Has Marisa ever shown (or even just implied) interest at becoming a Youkai Magician in canon or is it all just fanon wanting to make her youkai for whatever reasons?

^ actually it's more like this Then again, thread is obvious bait. Silly me?

>> No.11785015

>>11785006
No anon, you are the bait.

>> No.11785022

>>11785015
And then anon was.. who?

>> No.11785026

>>11785022
An earthworm.

>> No.11785034

In PCBs manual, it was mentioned that she does make attempts to become immortal. Also, in DDC, she's the only one of the protagonists to be mistaken for a youkai by Seija; the other two are recognized immediately as "just" human.

>> No.11785112

http://danbooru.donmai.us/pools/3659

>> No.11785134

>>11785034
> she does make attempts to become immortal
Okay, and? Nothing about youkai wannabe.

> Also, in DDC, she's the only one of the protagonists to be mistaken for a youkai by Seija; the other two are recognized immediately as "just" human.
So? What are you trying to imply?

>>11785112
Yeah, that stuff was dark as hell. Jiroo is very sad guy.

>> No.11785174

>>11785134
>Nothing about youkai wannabe.
The question was never if she wants to or not, but if she's actually opposed to the idea.
She can still be indifferent to it. What happens happens, you know?

>> No.11785237

>>11785174
This is a weird way to put it. Baically, you're trying to define something like a russel's teapot?
You should look for existence of her desire/indifference, not looking for absence of the opposite desire.. Lack/absence of something is impossible to find.
Damn, I hope what I wrote is comprehendable.

>> No.11785261

>>11785237
I know what you're trying to say, as the OP pointed out, the fanworks often shows her with some kind of aversion to the idea of becoming a youkai.
At least from my experience, though I will admit I'm not the most knowledgeable when it comes to fanon.

>> No.11785547

Is the only difference between youkai magicians and human magicians that the former don't have to eat?

I mean, are they born like humans or does some wizard just magically mutate his sperm into a baby?

>> No.11785609

>>11785547
I remember reading that Alice technically doesn't have to sleep or eat either, she just does it out of habit or because she likes it.

>> No.11785665

>>11785609
Are all youkai like that or is it just magician youkai?

>> No.11785683

>>11785665
I think it varies.

>> No.11788139

>>11785547
There's two stages to it. Stage 1 makes you a youkai who doesn't need to eat. Stage 2 is optional and stops the aging process. Patchy was born at stage 1, but any human could reach it if they figured out the right spells/potions.

>> No.11788147
File: 211 KB, 800x549, a_face_you_can_trust.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11788147

>>11788139
Oh, and Stage 2 is possibly a permanent version of the Four Wise Monkeys statue that Miko was selling in SoPM. As in, it involves removing your "sin worms".

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action