/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Can Emrakul kill Servants?

Clearly.

Don't really know what the other abilities should be

>mtg
Nerd

>>10026628
the -8 ability could be something in style with "convert every +1+1 token into -1-1 tokens and replace them on target creatures"

>>10026641
I don't think that's strong enough

rin
0 mana cost
tap: any player may tap rin. at the beginning of every turn, for all creatures in play, tap rin that many times. observing players who are not participating in the game may tap rin at any time.

>>10026652
This is a blue ability, not white.

Why not design the main mechanics first? That ways you can just fill slots and make a few esoteric cards.

>>10026663
Too abusable.

the set seems like it would be very legend and artifact dependent. You might need to come up for a term for token equipment so Emiya and Gilgamesh abilities don't have to be so abstracted.

Make sure to pad out the set with additional copies of each character; it makes sure that multiple design ideas for the cards don't go unnoticed, and allows people to actually see and play their favorite cards in the event the set gets drafted.

>>10026663

>>10026690
i'll take 60 of these

>first strike

Red

>Hexproof

Green

>big creature for low mana

Green


Her abilities as shown are not white in any manner.

Saber should be ridiculously expensive for a white super card.
>4WWWW
>4/8 Vigilance
>Tap, WWWWW, deal 5 damage to each creature target opponent controls

>>10026722
You could also have different (weaker) versions of saber representing her having a different master, I guess.

>>10026722
>>first strike
>Red
Last time I played M:tG I had an all-white very first strike-heavy deck. Tundra Wolves and Longbow Archers and Pikemen and whatnot. (It wasn't very good at all, but that's beside the point.)

>>10026722
White is second for first strike after red, and is second in big creature for low mana against green. Seeing both of these things on a white card would be fairly normal tbh. The only thing out of place is the hexproof, where white will get protection from instead.

>>10026722
>deal 5 damage to each creature target opponent controls.
Because this is such a white ability.

CMC 4 for a 5/5 with First Strike and Hexproof is REALLY good.

But the idea is cool, i'm working on a 2hu set myself.

>>10026722
>>10026797
true about it not being white. Isn't white second for destroy after black? You could use that. Like Tap, WWWWWW destroy up to 3 target creatures?

>>10026722
also white

also white

also... blue...

>>10026810
In the latest sets white's removal has been trending toward oblivion ring type removal.

Go back a bit and you see that white has exile+opponent gets a benefit (though they have said recently they are not happy with white being able to remove things that cheaply and have been moving away from this) and can deal direct damage to attacking or blocking creatures.

>>10026810
>>10026830
White still does get wrath effects(destroy all creatues) though.

i love how every fanmade card is way too fucking OP

>5/5 First Strike Hexproof
>People were arguing whether Saber could beat Emrakul in an earlier thread.
There's your answer.

>>10027556
The real question I'd like to argue about is
Who are you quoting

I don't care how little sense it makes, I like it.

>>10026645
>I don't think that's strong enough
Then have it deal creature damage by the end of the turn.

>>10027589
Huh?

>>10027647
Each creature takes 1 damage for each counter on them by the end of the turn.
Combined with how the counters themselves lower their defense it would deal quite a bit of damage.

>First Strike
Definitely can be White.

>Hexproof
Change to protection from spells. Or make her White and Blue. She does use wind, air, and protects herself from magic.

>Knight
All servants should be Legendary creatures. For that cost and strength, you shouldn't have more than one of her out. Also have multiple Sabers with different effects and abilities so that you can only have one out. Finally, find a way that you can have both FSN Rider and FZ Rider in play.

>>10027582
Pretty cool, although with those abilities, she almost seems black/red

>>10027541
>i love how every fanmade card is way too fucking OP

What about re-themes?
http://imgur.com/unHeo,DN79D,dGiZg,vPfxe,Cgn30,zKtpA,lEUnH,7TsFJ#0

>>10027956
Blue: flash, flying, hand peek
Bed: first strike, haste

The only problem with the card is that it should be gold instead of hybrid.

>>10027975
I thought hand peek was pretty black, I'm sorry.

>>10027956
Blue: flash, flying, hand peek
Red: first strike, haste

The only problem with the card is that it should be gold instead of hybrid.

>>10027582
This is honestly way too good to only cast 4.

Maybe make it exile itself at the end of any turn that it's in play, and allow the player to pay 4 to return it from exile to their hand. Aya is all over the place, after all.

>>10026628
Could have something like:

-2: Search your library for any equipment and put it aside, then shuffle your library and put that equipment on top.

>>10028039
That would go from quite good to extremely bad.

>>10028039
or something simple like a cost of 3UR.

>>10028073
You're right, every card should be format-breaking.

>>10028223
I don't demand that it be format breaking, I just want it to not fucking suck. 2UR for three to the face plus reveal hand is fucking awful, even if you can pay 4UURR to recur it. Same with 2UR to destroy target attacking creature with three toughness or less.