/jp/ - Otaku Culture

General Umineko closed rooms and speculations thread.
Umineko haters, please bear with me.

I'll start with the first episode, first twillight. Not much of a closed room, huh? But it actually gives us something to think about - basically, somebody opened the shutter with the key and then returned it back to the servant's room so the others could open it later. What I'm going about is that it proves that somebody other than a possible death faker out of the six corpses has to be included as an accomplice. That person would lock the door with the culprit faking his death inside and then put the key back where it came from. With Battler and Kinzo excluded, our possibilities are:

- Eva
- Hideyoshi
- Kanon
- Genji
- Kumasawa
- Nanjo
- Jessica
- George
- Natsuhi
- Maria

I doubt it would be Hideyoshi, Eva or George. It most likely would be Kanon, OR possibly Maria - she was the one to wake up first out of the kids after all. Perhaps she wasn't asleep at all? Though you could say it would be impossible for her to stay up for so long without being tired.

Well, what do you think?