/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>5781595
I don't "believe" anything, in the sense that I'm trying to start from an objective (for example, denying Shkanontrice) and justify it.

I'm just trying to find the truth of the situation.

>If you have something more solid than 'Knox's 8th', let me know.

Doesn't get more solid than that.

>It's not like my theory is even a stretch of the imagination or physical possibility

But it's impossible to confirm or verify, which makes it effectively worthless as a solution.

>you're just trying to assume it isn't possible because there wasn't a 10 page passage dedicated to the sealing

Far from there being ten pages, it got a sentence.

One.

>You are no different than the person claiming Erika might've sealed the windows first in that you're both arguing an assumption.

Your solution assumes that Erika has no way of being able to seal both the doors and the windows without Kanon escaping from the other, when there's no evidence that would either confirm or deny this fact.

For example, just as you can say "Kanon left by the door while she was sealing the window" in response to "They sealed the windows first," I can say "Erika has enough fucking common sense to make sure that look in the room and make sure that no one ran out while she was sealing the door/window," to which Ryuukishi would say "you're all retarded for not remembering Knox's 8th."

>The difference is that you're assuming the author's intentions for the scene and the Decalogue's interpretation, trying to say your view is fact when it's not even close.

I'm not assuming anything. I'm stating that your solution has no clues either to confirm or deny it and that if you bothered to read the white text, you would know that Ryuukishi - through Dlanor - says outright how you're supposed to apply Knox's 8th.