/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>6132986
I'm gonna kill you and rape the body.

>>5726869
'I shall say more with the red! When the five other than Kinzo were murdered, the murderer was definitely in the same room!'

If that's the case, why does Beatrice specifically exclude Kinzo in this red truth, which comes after the gunshot truth?

>>5680681
Okay, by that logic, the only explanation for all the crimes is that a witch did them. After all, the story shows that Beatrice kills a bunch of people, and that Kinzo is actually alive and summoned a bunch of demons to kill his family, even though he wasn't really alive.

That would make about as much sense as personalities being counted as people and being able to kill off those personalities counting as a death or that person not existing.

This is a mystery. A game where the entire point of the witch side is to force a false truth on you. As the GM, Battler is putting forth this illusion that Kanon and Shannon are the same person.

The story is the one entity in Umineko which is a bold-faced liar 90% of the time, especially about things it forces down your throat in no small quantity.

If you buy into that lie while denying all other possibilities, you are not looking at the story properly. You are not even thinking about it, much less looking at it.

>>5657348
Sure, at the time it was repeated, they were all there. But this was 'before Erika sealed the rooms'. And no matter in what order she sealed them, there is a chance for someone from either room to escape.

If she sealed the door to the cousin's room first, someone could escape from the window.
If she sealed the windows to the cousin's room first, someone could leave through the door.

Magic does not exist. There does not exist any way for Erika to seal both simultaneously, as she did not have anyone working with her, so it's not possible for both rooms to become sealed instantly without that chance to exist.