/jp/ - Otaku Culture

To answer OPs question.

Tsukihime.
FSN.
Clannad.
KLANG KLANG aka Planetarian
Yume Miru Kusuri

Are the ones on the top of my head

alright /jp/, VN thoughts and ratings
keep in mind the timeframe in which it was released mind you.

Yume Miru Kusuri: 10/10
pros? loved the characters, plot, music, art, ect not even movies got me as fired up or ;_; as this game
problems? saving one girl means death for the other two, or atleast pain for the other two, but then again, its something to be expected, and i guess adds some dimensions to the plot.

Tsukihime: 9/10
pros? so many twists and turns in the plot, kept me interested, music was definately one of the best factors. art wasnt so flashy, but still pretty pleasing
cons? game overs are more common than the word "oyster" in that game, and thats saying something

fate/stay night: 9/10
pros? music is awsome, art is definately some of the best ive seen for a VN, GARness aswell
cons? some pretty stupid plot holes, like "hey im gilgamesh, i could kill you but i got the fatal-character-flaw attribute, and you got plot-immunity"

ever17: 8.5/10
pros? story was pretty epic, music was on the decent side, art was pretty good aswell
cons? voice acting was irritating at times, especially when they laughed. the plot seemed to be kinda rushed in coco's route, even if the "story from the first 4 routes were supposed to make up for that"

planetarian 8.5/10
pros? art was pretty good, plot was pretty good, music was pleasant
cons? to short, much to short, also made the plot progress a little too quick imo

just played this game (Yume Miru Kusuri), and compared to all the other VN's ive played (in b4 tsukihime, f/sn, ever17, planetarian) this is probably the most compelling and absorbing
music, art, plot. all 10/10
Aeka's route i cried bricks, couldnt bring myself to get her bad end (good end was awsome though, although shoulda castrated that Jinka/gaito guy)

anyway, just a thought

if you choose one girl over the other two, your basically condeming the other two to a life of pain?

choose Aeka, and Mizuki will probably do something rash, and die.
Nekoko will probably try to go to fairyland extra early (and die)
choose either Mizuki or Nekoko, and Aeka will spend her life alone and in torment.

tl;dr: story writer is a bastard.