/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>35990277
Man, you really are thick as a brick...

>No, you retard, his dream is stupid, period. You CANNOT save everyone, no matter how hard you try.
He knows. He doesn't care. He still helped people, and that's objectively good. Seethe all you want about it.
>That's how real humans work anon.
And you failed to comprehend the question and give me an answer.
If Shirou loves Sakura and lets Taiga die for it, is it stupid?
If not, why is it stupid for him to do what he likes, which is helping people?
>Again, you're missing the whole point, retard. Shirou CANNOT make everyone happy. No one can. His dream is stupid because it's impossible.
And you're thick as a rock. It doesn't matter if he can save everyone or not. As long as he makes even one person happy, that dream is worth it.
How did you go through both Fate and UBW but still don't understand that?

The narrative isn't that the world tells him his path is wrong and he does it anyway. The narrative is that Shirou will be true to himself and will refuse to buckle down, whether it's the world telling him to stop or it's his alternative future self telling him to stop. He will not give in, he will persist on this path no matter what. If someone tells him his way is wrong, he'll simply surpass them and keep moving forward. Ultimately, Shirou's will is too strong, and no one has the strength of will to defeat his mentality. In Unlimited Blade Works, Shirou is the strongest, so the fact that he persists on his path means that everyone else is weaker than him, at least in terms of willpower. Nasu makes it clear that despite how much the narrative might call that ideal a "fake" it doesn't matter as long as it's meaningful to Shirou himself. Hence why UBW beats you over the head so much with "fake vs original". Shirou surpassed Kiritsugu. He surpassed Archer. That's all there is to it.

>A random familiar is just an obstacle for Shirou to overcome with power. Saber though? She's much, much more than just a random fight. She was his biggest supporter, and now he has to kill her to save the woman he loves.
Anon, he barely knew Saber in HF. Maybe Alter would've been a good emotional enemy, if she had any semblance of Saber, or any personality whatsoever.
But she doesn't, so she's just a mindless puppet tacked on for a boss fight.
>How are any of those remotely similar?
One is a choice between his own wishes and saving a bunch of innocent children that have been tortured for almost a decade.
He doesn't know that Kirei is a lying shit, so that's irrelevant. What matters is his choice.
He chooses to save Taiga despite the fact that it means trampling over Saber's wishes and possibly dooming her.
In both of these, he chooses the ones closer to him. Saber and Taiga.
>>He sees no difference between spending a magic item and letting people die.
By using the pendant, Rin goes against Tokiomi's teachings. Directly ignoring the Tohsaka's reputation and such.
When Sakura is a threat, she doesn't even bother looking for a different way, doesn't even bother questioning the situation, doesn't even bother analyzing the level of the threat. She just wants to kill her at the first chance she gets.
That's entirely out of character, as much as you try to say otherwise.
>and you don't understand Heaven's Feel because it's the route where the characters act most like real humans would in their place.
Heaven's Feel is just as autistic as the other routes, wormfag.