/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>45793031
Okay, here it is. It's basically a slightly cleaned-up draft. You'll be able to see some things I considered and dropped. I'll copy the text of my final theory here if you want to read it on here instead. I thought it over and could not find an error in it, only some logical stretches. But I don't really believe I got it, because the last 3 are all explained with the same "gimmick". Oh well. Time to go check the answer, my head hurts.

1st twilight:
Someone (George? can only be one person according to red text) kills all six and hides in the room. Evidence: liar George lies about no one hiding, breaks the locked room. If that is wrong, it can also be explained by Gohda, who becomes a key suspect later, simply using his master key to lock the door after the deed is done.

2nd twilight:
Someone (Jessica and Nanjo?), but not a servant kills Natsuhi and Krauss then leaves the room unlocked. The servant's alibi is preserved, they really were together the entire time. Gohda arrives first (he is the first to make a statement). He claims the door is/was locked but is lying. He either locks it quickly before anyone notices, or takes a gamble that the next person, Shannon, will simply take his word for it and unlock it without confirming if it was actually locked. This allows Shannon to say she unlocked the door without lying, maintaining her innocence.

4th twilight:
Since anyone but George could have done the crime here, Maria kills Shannon and Kanon. Also, here Gohda dooms himself with an unnecessary statement about no one having an alibi, which is disproved not long after by the innocent Battler and the culprit Jessica, though we already suspected Gohda because of the second killing.

5th and 6th twilights:
Gohda kills Kumasawa then pretends to be dead. His death is confirmed by liars Nanjo and Jessica but he is quite alive.

7th twilight:
Nanjo is not killed. He is faking like Gohda. Confirmed by trio of liars Jessica, George and Maria.

8th twilight:
Jessica is not killed. "death" is confirmed by liars George and Maria. Battler is the only one who doesn't lie here, which makes him the only innocent to survive until the end of the game.

Culprits and who they killed (it is not important to know who killed who, all that is important is to have at least one kill per culprit as it is required to kill to be a culprit. We have 2 restrictions. George can't kill Shannon because of innocent Battler's claim, and the first six must all be killed by the same person, confirmed by Bern's red)
George - Kill the first six people
Jessica - Kills Krauss or Natsuhi
Nanjo - Kills Krauss or Natsuhi
Maria - Kills Kanon and Shannon
Gohda - Kills Kumasawa